Car cranks a bit before it starts
#1
Super Member
Thread Starter
Car cranks a bit before it starts
When my wife was leaving today, I noticed the engine cranking a bit without starting. It started fine the second try. My wife said it did this yesterday as well. This never happened before. It's a 2008 E350 with around 53k miles.
Any ideas?
Any ideas?
#2
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: V E G A S
Posts: 9,067
Received 1,729 Likes
on
1,379 Posts
1922 Ford Model T / no OBD
Was it hot start, or cold start?
I would start with hooking up fuel pressure gauge.
I would start with hooking up fuel pressure gauge.
#4
MBWorld Fanatic!
as for long crank, inspect starting and charging system as well. Battery could be weak and or starter may be starting to fail.
A amp clamp around the starter wire would tell you how many amps it's drawing just to start. If it's excessive may be a good idea to replace starter.
#5
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: V E G A S
Posts: 9,067
Received 1,729 Likes
on
1,379 Posts
1922 Ford Model T / no OBD
No residual fuel pressure on hot engine means leaky injector.
Leaky injector floods the engine.
All you need is $19 gauge to narrow the troubleshooting.
Leaky injector floods the engine.
All you need is $19 gauge to narrow the troubleshooting.
#6
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: MA
Posts: 6,074
Received 1,466 Likes
on
1,147 Posts
2008 E350 4Matic, 2011 E350 4matic
What's the voltage of the battery? Is it OEM? You can go to an auto parts store and they will usually load test it for free. You can also get the voltage on the display. Put the key in the ignition, turn it to run, but don't start the car, hit the reset button 3 times when it's displaying the temperature and it will give you the voltage.
Trending Topics
#8
Super Member
Thread Starter
The Epilogue
Well, I didn't want my wife to get stranded, and the long cranking was happening every time -- hot or cold -- so I told her not to drive the car (she used my Jaguar instead). I made an appt with the MB dealer and took it there after the car sat idle in the garage for 4 days. Sure enough, when I started it to go to the dealer, it cranked long again, but rapidly. Dealer did a diagnostic test and found nothing wrong. Car stayed there for a day and a half and the mechanic said it started quickly every time. I picked it up and it's been starting normally and quickly ever since. I paid $155 + tax for a diagnostic testing. Maybe I should have just waited for it to go away on its own.
I want to run down the gas tank as much as possible and then fill again. I'm also going to buy some fuel injector cleaner additive just in case.
The service advisor said my 4-year old (Mercedes AGM) battery could be the culprit, but I highly doubt that given the rapid cranking and normal voltage after sitting overnight. I don't see any reason to waste nearly $200 for a new (non-MB) battery until it starts to crank slowly.
Thanks to everyone for their responses.
I want to run down the gas tank as much as possible and then fill again. I'm also going to buy some fuel injector cleaner additive just in case.
The service advisor said my 4-year old (Mercedes AGM) battery could be the culprit, but I highly doubt that given the rapid cranking and normal voltage after sitting overnight. I don't see any reason to waste nearly $200 for a new (non-MB) battery until it starts to crank slowly.
Thanks to everyone for their responses.
#9
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Long Islander
Well, I didn't want my wife to get stranded, and the long cranking was happening every time -- hot or cold -- so I told her not to drive the car (she used my Jaguar instead). I made an appt with the MB dealer and took it there after the car sat idle in the garage for 4 days. Sure enough, when I started it to go to the dealer, it cranked long again, but rapidly. Dealer did a diagnostic test and found nothing wrong. Car stayed there for a day and a half and the mechanic said it started quickly every time. I picked it up and it's been starting normally and quickly ever since. I paid $155 + tax for a diagnostic testing. Maybe I should have just waited for it to go away on its own.
I want to run down the gas tank as much as possible and then fill again. I'm also going to buy some fuel injector cleaner additive just in case.
The service advisor said my 4-year old (Mercedes AGM) battery could be the culprit, but I highly doubt that given the rapid cranking and normal voltage after sitting overnight. I don't see any reason to waste nearly $200 for a new (non-MB) battery until it starts to crank slowly.
Thanks to everyone for their responses.
I want to run down the gas tank as much as possible and then fill again. I'm also going to buy some fuel injector cleaner additive just in case.
The service advisor said my 4-year old (Mercedes AGM) battery could be the culprit, but I highly doubt that given the rapid cranking and normal voltage after sitting overnight. I don't see any reason to waste nearly $200 for a new (non-MB) battery until it starts to crank slowly.
Thanks to everyone for their responses.
#10
Super Member
Thread Starter
#11
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Long Islander
Have you tried fuel injector cleaner in the gas tank?
#12
Senior Member
https://www.amazon.com/Chevron-65740...ncentrate+plus
#13
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Honcho
Techron is pretty much the same thing as what the oil companies add to their gasoline to make it "Top Tier"... you do always use a Top Tier fuel brand right?
https://www.amazon.com/Chevron-65740...ncentrate+plus
https://www.amazon.com/Chevron-65740...ncentrate+plus
#14
Senior Member
High octane doesn't make it a top tier retailer. "Top Tier" has to do with the additives (Detergents) added to the gasoline:
http://www.toptiergas.com/retailers/
If a retailer has gone to the trouble to be certified, you will usually see this sticker on their pumps:
http://www.toptiergas.com/retailers/
If a retailer has gone to the trouble to be certified, you will usually see this sticker on their pumps:
#15
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Honcho
High octane doesn't make it a top tier retailer. "Top Tier" has to do with the additives (Detergents) added to the gasoline:
http://www.toptiergas.com/retailers/
If a retailer has gone to the trouble to be certified, you will usually see this sticker on their pumps:
http://www.toptiergas.com/retailers/
If a retailer has gone to the trouble to be certified, you will usually see this sticker on their pumps:
#16
Senior Member
No, don't use injector cleaner. You manual is pretty specific about not using that. If you are using Premium, no need for cleaner. It really does sound like a fuel pump/sending unit failure. Filter may be getting clogged (especially if you run the fuel low a lot). I replaced my filter and sending unit at the same time, but I had about 144k on both. Try just the sending unit as it has the filter built in. But first check pressure, it's easy and quick.
#17
Senior Member
Since you haven't been using a top tier gasoline, you may want to add a specific injector cleaner:
https://www.amazon.com/Chevron-10055...R7RB6X5834435Y
...and always stick to the top tier retailers. After two or three tanks of a top tier gasoline, there's no point to using any additives.
https://www.amazon.com/Chevron-10055...R7RB6X5834435Y
...and always stick to the top tier retailers. After two or three tanks of a top tier gasoline, there's no point to using any additives.
#18
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Gersh320
No, don't use injector cleaner. You manual is pretty specific about not using that. If you are using Premium, no need for cleaner. It really does sound like a fuel pump/sending unit failure. Filter may be getting clogged (especially if you run the fuel low a lot). I replaced my filter and sending unit at the same time, but I had about 144k on both. Try just the sending unit as it has the filter built in. But first check pressure, it's easy and quick.
#19
Senior Member
That very well may be. These cars don't really like short trips; ESPECIALLY in cold weather. Come winter, take some longer trips every few weeks.
#20
Super Member
Thread Starter
Follow up
Well, the Techron did nothing to help with the long cranking problem. In fact, it got to where it cranks very long every single time, so we took the car back to the same dealer who couldn't find anything wrong three weeks ago.
Now they're saying they are certain it is the fuel senders (not fuel pump) that need replacing. I pointed out the 15 year warranty on fuel-related components (which includes the fuel senders), but they said that it doesn't apply because there is no evidence of a fuel leak or fuel smell (they have a fuel odor detector apparently). The language of the letter I got from MBUSA leaves some room for debate, but since I pushed the issue, the dealership said they'd pay for the parts (around $800) and I "only" have to pay for labor ($510). Their labor rate is $155/hr (a bit lower than what Porsche and Jaguar dealers in the area charge), so that comes to about 3.25 hours of labor.
Does anyone know if 3.25 hours is about right for changing 2 fuel senders?
Thanks.
Now they're saying they are certain it is the fuel senders (not fuel pump) that need replacing. I pointed out the 15 year warranty on fuel-related components (which includes the fuel senders), but they said that it doesn't apply because there is no evidence of a fuel leak or fuel smell (they have a fuel odor detector apparently). The language of the letter I got from MBUSA leaves some room for debate, but since I pushed the issue, the dealership said they'd pay for the parts (around $800) and I "only" have to pay for labor ($510). Their labor rate is $155/hr (a bit lower than what Porsche and Jaguar dealers in the area charge), so that comes to about 3.25 hours of labor.
Does anyone know if 3.25 hours is about right for changing 2 fuel senders?
Thanks.
#21
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: V E G A S
Posts: 9,067
Received 1,729 Likes
on
1,379 Posts
1922 Ford Model T / no OBD
The senders take only few minutes to replace and my friend bought new pump at dealer for $560.
I would hope the $800 part would be whole tank, but dealer can come with outrageous mark ups, so everything is possible.
In NY you should have several dealers in small radius.
Why don't you drive to another dealer and complain about gasoline odor after filling up?
I would hope the $800 part would be whole tank, but dealer can come with outrageous mark ups, so everything is possible.
In NY you should have several dealers in small radius.
Why don't you drive to another dealer and complain about gasoline odor after filling up?
#22
Senior Member
New update - car stalled last week and wouldn't start. Had to tow it to dealer. Turns out it was the starter and had to be replaced. $1150 bucks at the generous dealer...
#23
Have you fixed your problem by any chance? I’m also having the same issue
#24
Super Member
Thread Starter
This was quite a while ago and we traded that car to the dealer where we bought it from (for another E-class wagon). We took it to the MB dealer, and it was something like (I believe) $1300 but they charged us about half as a goodwill repair. The car spent several days there before it was all fixed.
#25
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Apr 2019
Location: Silicon Valley
Posts: 4,822
Received 3,028 Likes
on
2,010 Posts
MY'14 W212 M276 3.5NA @55kMi
The following users liked this post:
juanmor40 (11-18-2023)