Catch can opinions
Has anyone used one of these guys from ECS? 1/3rd the price of weistec.
https://www.ecstuning.com/Mercedes_B...Can/Catch_Can/ |
Nothing magical about a catch can in principle. They’ll all work to keep PCV oil out of your intake and that’s a good thing. You just have to remember to empty them ;) |
That was my thinking too but I see a lot of people spending $600+ for the Weistec one which through me for a loop. Also, do I want reverse or standard flow?
|
Originally Posted by Doc Oc
(Post 7386368)
Has anyone used one of these guys from ECS? 1/3rd the price of weistec.
https://www.ecstuning.com/Mercedes_B...Can/Catch_Can/
Originally Posted by Doc Oc
(Post 7386427)
That was my thinking too but I see a lot of people spending $600+ for the Weistec one which through me for a loop. Also, do I want reverse or standard flow?
|
Interesting. If you purchase, please let us know how the install goes |
Reverse flow is simply a way to deal with mounting or hose routing challenges per this manual: http://bd8ba3c866c8cbc330ab-7b26c6f3...tch_Can_R1.pdf (check page 16 if this link doesn’t take you there directly). |
This is a generic universal catch can. You need specific fittings for the C63. Only one I know of currently is weistec for $$
|
Weistec unfortunately is the only one so far to take the time to get that fitting where the PCV valve goes and because of that we pay crazy money. Shardul if you’re reading get it done. |
You have the fittings in the PCV.
Just yank the existing hose off and route new hose to a generic can. From: https://mbworld.org/forums/c63-amg-w...ml#post6753683 https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...48375dded.jpeg |
Jasonoff’s nickname is “mr catch can” so he knows what he’s talking about, listen to that man :y |
Originally Posted by Jasonoff
(Post 7387586)
You have the fittings in the PCV.
Just yank the existing hose off and route new hose to a generic can. From: https://mbworld.org/forums/c63-amg-w...ml#post6753683 https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...48375dded.jpeg |
It looks like the Weistec can is downstream from the PCV valve where this setup with the generic can is on the upstream side of the PCV valve. Is that correct? Would it make any difference?
|
The difference is that the Weistec catch can setup comes with fitting which connect inline with the PCV. Specifically made for the M156.
The set up from ECS (Turner) doesn't have that. |
This looks like it’s hust a universal kit that you need to make work. No difference on actual funtiality between it and Weistec it any other catch can really just that you have to make the pcv and crank vent hook up to the catch can |
ADD has a baffled catch can for $99 (ADD W1 Baffled Oil Catch Can V3)
Further discussed in thread: https://mbworld.org/forums/c63-amg-w...catch-can.html |
I am looking to install and catch can, so I read up all the threads and I don't think there is any one unanimus Catch can recommendation, based on built qulity, fitment , mounting points etc. Is there one that stands out? (apart from the $600 weistec one)
so far in the running: 1.ADD W1 Baffled Oil Catch Can V3 Looks like very good quality product, 3 different separator plates (Someone mentioned putting steel wool? Woundering Why this and not the others?) 2.Mishimoto MMBCC-MSTWO-BK Black Compact Baffled 2-Port Oil Catch Can Looks like this only has 1 separator plate vs the ADD W1 3. ECS Turner Baffled Oil Catch Can Kit - 6/8/10oz Hard to tell but Looks a little more generic plastic, no real info. says it's a 4 compartment unit VS what in the others? |
|
I have the mishinoto very good quality. Catches a fair amount of fluid every oil change (3000 miles roughly) and I took my intake off a year after installing it and cleaning the intake and no oil/carbon build up at all. |
I found space for my not $600 oil catch can.
With a card board I was able to develop the basic form for my bracket to attach firmly my catch can. https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...b1654091af.jpg Bracket for oil catch can behind right headlight https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...13a11fb403.jpg powder coated https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...715d0d8e77.jpg Ready to Install https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...9504d9a111.jpg https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...80bbdaaf3f.jpg Finally in Place |
I installed an ECS catch can when I installed my ESS supercharger. If you look at my post for the ESS supercharger DIY installation, I put in several pictures of the catch can installation. It is easy to take the hose off between the original PCV valve pieces and just run the hoses to and from the catch can. The ECS can I got has an excellent baffle set-up and also a dip stick so you can easily tell how full it is without removing the can.
|
Originally Posted by Big Jimbo
(Post 7689376)
I installed an ECS catch can when I installed my ESS supercharger. If you look at my post for the ESS supercharger DIY installation, I put in several pictures of the catch can installation. It is easy to take the hose off between the original PCV valve pieces and just run the hoses to and from the catch can. The ECS can I got has an excellent baffle set-up and also a dip stick so you can easily tell how full it is without removing the can.
So far I already upgraded the pulleys to billet, changed the tensioner, got one step colder plugs and got the plugs for the injectors. |
So do we have an ultimate decision and step by step guide on which can and how to install from A-Z?
I looked at your install @Big Jimbo but I'm still pretty lost as the guide is half pics/half words/half supercharger stuff. I think I'm going to be creating a thread that will list every single Catch Can for sale for the M156 and then try to compile an actual photo by photo, step by step, for dummies guide somehow. (I know there's a bunch of threads but none of them are truly "for dummies" style). |
Originally Posted by AnthonyiLLMaTiC
(Post 7690611)
So do we have an ultimate decision and step by step guide on which can and how to install from A-Z?
I looked at your install @Big Jimbo but I'm still pretty lost as the guide is half pics/half words/half supercharger stuff. I think I'm going to be creating a thread that will list every single Catch Can for sale for the M156 and then try to compile an actual photo by photo, step by step, for dummies guide somehow. (I know there's a bunch of threads but none of them are truly "for dummies" style). https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...0125742dcb.jpg |
ADD catch can. If it all works out with the hose/fittings and pcv I'll post more pics and details
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...44894600a4.jpg |
Like most mentioned these catch cans aren't rocket science. Its a fairly straight forward setup. That ECS Unit looks the business! For a fraction of the Weistec Can its a no brainer (if install / parts are as easy as the Weistec units)
Owning the Weistec Catch Can, you can tell they didn't cut any corners on it. The thing is build like a tank. Pretty over kill for a catch can, but i love the build of it none-the-less. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:31 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands