MBWorld.org Forums

MBWorld.org Forums (https://mbworld.org/forums/)
-   E-Class (W213) (https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w213-208/)
-   -   Audi's A6 is better right now (https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w213/723890-audis-a6-better-right-now.html)

rbrylaw 10-25-2018 08:02 PM


Originally Posted by teksurv (Post 7586372)
That's fair. I suspect both of us will have all kinds of fun learning MBUX in the future :)

I'm sure we will next time around. The 2019 CLS won't be coming with MBUX and neither will my 2019 E450.

superangrypenguin 10-25-2018 08:46 PM


Originally Posted by wdimagineer (Post 7586234)
I'm extremely biased having previously led the teams that built all of the current and next-gen Audi MMI technologies. Despite my allegiance, I have an E63S Wagon on order, solely as a **** you to my colleagues at AoA who won't bring over the RS6 Avant. If it were sold here, I wouldn't be buying the E63S. The technologies in the new A6/A7/A8/Q8 are leaps and bounds better than anything Mercedes has an offer currently. VAG still edges out MBUX by a fair bit. The gap will grow once Audi finally ships Audi AI for semi-autonomous driving.

I left VAG due to the diesel emissions issue and have protected whistleblower status. Woo. Take it from an insider, VAG isn't the only bad actor. The things I've seen will make many want to dust off their bicycles.

Thanks for joining MBWorld. Great to have you with us. I agree with you re: MMI! I actually really like the Comand system too, even the current iteration, but when I look at the MMI interface in the 2019 A6 or the A8, hell, having used the new Comand system in the S class and now the A8 (haven't driven the A8 yet but had fun with it at the dealership floor today), the new MMI system is FAR superior.

Germancar1 10-25-2018 10:21 PM


Originally Posted by wdimagineer (Post 7586234)
I'm extremely biased having previously led the teams that built all of the current and next-gen Audi MMI technologies. Despite my allegiance, I have an E63S Wagon on order, solely as a **** you to my colleagues at AoA who won't bring over the RS6 Avant. If it were sold here, I wouldn't be buying the E63S. The technologies in the new A6/A7/A8/Q8 are leaps and bounds better than anything Mercedes has an offer currently. VAG still edges out MBUX by a fair bit. The gap will grow once Audi finally ships Audi AI for semi-autonomous driving.

I left VAG due to the diesel emissions issue and have protected whistleblower status. Woo. Take it from an insider, VAG isn't the only bad actor. The things I've seen will make many want to dust off their bicycles.

What exactly in the A6/A7/A8/Q8 is more advanced than MB's MBUX?

M

rbrylaw 10-25-2018 10:24 PM

I'm interesting in that as well, especially since virtually none of us have had an opportunity to try MBUX in any car in the US. The 2020 GLE isn't out and the A class isn't either. Those are the only two cars that will offer MBUX in this model year.

parkwood 10-26-2018 05:05 AM

Is the only difference in mbux that there is some touchscreen facility? Have to say i am not keen on touchscreens in cars but at least in the air suspension mb's you might hit the right icon more times than not. In an astra (opel an old gm brand now french owned) i had on loan this year it was hard to hit it right when travelling along as your body was bouncing around too much😂😂
i love tech but frankly all operating systems from ibm mainframes ( shows my age) crappy windows to ios and android have glitches.....i do think mb maybe a little slow in development compared to others which might reflect their company ethos of trying to get it right before launch and their conservative approach. But actually they are all a variation on a theme and i suspect our preference for one over another is just down to what we get used to. I am with others in that despite enjoying tech i would be loathe to have to get used to another system given i amnot fully conversent with command yet!
just to comment on a previous poster re vag not being worse than others re emission tests i accept all have worked to make the best of the test system but only vag so far have been found to have taken a deliberate corporate decision to try to cheat ie go beyond just meeting the letter of the law. I will be happy to alter my view re vag if any other manufacturer is prosecuted. I also accept it is a very complex area and that control software used to deal with varying climatic conditions has in some cases been referred to as cheat software when that was not its intention. I understand the vag went beyond that. Complex but i still think audi are very well constructed cars that look good but for me the mechanics still feel less high quality....

rbrylaw 10-26-2018 08:49 AM


Originally Posted by parkwood (Post 7586659)
Is the only difference in mbux that there is some touchscreen facility? Have to say i am not keen on touchscreens in cars but at least in the air suspension mb's you might hit the right icon more times than not. In an astra (opel an old gm brand now french owned) i had on loan this year it was hard to hit it right when travelling along as your body was bouncing around too much😂😂
i love tech but frankly all operating systems from ibm mainframes ( shows my age) crappy windows to ios and android have glitches.....i do think mb maybe a little slow in development compared to others which might reflect their company ethos of trying to get it right before launch and their conservative approach. But actually they are all a variation on a theme and i suspect our preference for one over another is just down to what we get used to. I am with others in that despite enjoying tech i would be loathe to have to get used to another system given i amnot fully conversent with command yet!
just to comment on a previous poster re vag not being worse than others re emission tests i accept all have worked to make the best of the test system but only vag so far have been found to have taken a deliberate corporate decision to try to cheat ie go beyond just meeting the letter of the law. I will be happy to alter my view re vag if any other manufacturer is prosecuted. I also accept it is a very complex area and that control software used to deal with varying climatic conditions has in some cases been referred to as cheat software when that was not its intention. I understand the vag went beyond that. Complex but i still think audi are very well constructed cars that look good but for me the mechanics still feel less high quality....

MBUX isn't just a touchscreen system. It's a personal assistant, ala Elexa, Hey Google, etc. Here's a video about MBUX which is worth watching. I too don't care for touch screens in a car, but with MBUX one wouldn't really need to touch the screen much at all and as is typical in MB cars, redundancy is built in so you can control things with the new trackpad (think laptop trackpad).


superangrypenguin 10-26-2018 08:54 AM


Originally Posted by Germancar1 (Post 7586492)
What exactly in the A6/A7/A8/Q8 is more advanced than MB's MBUX?

M

Fancy things (UI etc) aside, address entry for the nav is blipping amazing.

rbrylaw 10-26-2018 08:58 AM


Originally Posted by superangrypenguin (Post 7586751)
Fancy things (UI etc) aside, address entry for the nav is blipping amazing.

Again, that's nice, but what is your point of comparison with MBUX? Have you actually had the two systems side by side? I'm betting you haven't touched a MBUX system yet.

superangrypenguin 10-26-2018 09:17 AM


Originally Posted by rbrylaw (Post 7586753)
Again, that's nice, but what is your point of comparison with MBUX? Have you actually had the two systems side by side? I'm betting you haven't touched a MBUX system yet.

I think we need to bring perspective back in here. I have made no such statements about comparing anything with MBUX. In fact,

the thread title is "Audi A6 is better right now" (bolded is mine)

And the former VAG engineer's comment that I was replying to is " The technologies in the new A6/A7/A8/Q8 are leaps and bounds better than anything Mercedes has an offer currently " (also, bolded is mine)

MBUX is not on offer on any E classes in N. America.

rbrylaw 10-26-2018 09:19 AM

Fair enough and you are correct, no E class vehicle has MBUX.

Germancar1 10-26-2018 01:34 PM


Originally Posted by superangrypenguin (Post 7586751)
Fancy things (UI etc) aside, address entry for the nav is blipping amazing.

So in other words you can't answer the initial question.

M

Wolfman 10-28-2018 01:11 AM


Originally Posted by wdimagineer (Post 7586234)
I'm extremely biased having previously led the teams that built all of the current and next-gen Audi MMI technologies. Despite my allegiance, I have an E63S Wagon on order, solely as a **** you to my colleagues at AoA who won't bring over the RS6 Avant. If it were sold here, I wouldn't be buying the E63S. The technologies in the new A6/A7/A8/Q8 are leaps and bounds better than anything Mercedes has an offer currently. VAG still edges out MBUX by a fair bit. The gap will grow once Audi finally ships Audi AI for semi-autonomous driving.

I left VAG due to the diesel emissions issue and have protected whistleblower status. Woo. Take it from an insider, VAG isn't the only bad actor. The things I've seen will make many want to dust off their bicycles.

Well, according to German car mags, MBUX is the best system out there, beating the iDrive system which in turn is consdered better than the old or new MMI.
I will give kudos to Audi‘s semi-autonomous driving efforts. Pretty exiting...
That said, biggest complaints in Germany is the touch surface environment on the new Audis. Nothing worst than a mirror surface with a milion fingerprints on it ;)

In regards to the Diesel scandal I don’t care for your insinuations; so far VAG has been the main culprit by a long shot and will have to deal with this for some time to come.
The resulting test methods at least help in developing cleaner running engines...



bellavance 10-28-2018 08:23 AM

Audi A6 might be better, but I don't like its angular shape in and out.

Slugsy 10-28-2018 10:08 AM

We have a new Q7 etron and I do not think the infotainment system is better. It’s actually not that intuitive. It’s workflow as I call it isn’t great and back buttons don’t go to the right screens, side swipes could be connected to better functions etc.

We have software developers at work and left alone, they would create the most technically brilliant stuff that wouldn’t be used by anyone! Just because it’s technically good doesn’t mean it’s good!

BMW’s idrive is the most user friendly system out there in my opinion.

I also think the Audi looks dull inside and outside and don’t really care for touchscreens other than maybe zooming in and out on sat nav.

bellavance 10-28-2018 10:52 AM

Touch Screen would be nice on the E-Class ... such as when using Waze and Google Maps in CarPlay.

rbrylaw 10-28-2018 11:00 AM


Originally Posted by bellavance (Post 7588372)
Touch Screen would be nice on the E-Class ... such as when using Waze and Google Maps in CarPlay.

You'll likely get your wish in the 2020 E Class. I can't say I'm looking forward to touch screens in my car.

Slugsy 10-28-2018 11:17 AM


Originally Posted by bellavance (Post 7588372)
Touch Screen would be nice on the E-Class ... such as when using Waze and Google Maps in CarPlay.

Yep, agreed, that’s where it would be good

riamga 10-28-2018 03:23 PM

MB, the choirboys of the auto industry
 

Originally Posted by rbrylaw (Post 7575273)
I'm with you on this. VW/Audi/Porsche will not get a dime of my money. I'm sure the Audi A6 does some things better than Mercedes E. And I'm equally sure Mercedes E does some things better than the A6. If someone thinks the A6 is better for them, they should buy one. My money stays with Mercedes. I've never been let down and while they are of course profit driven, as they should be, they've never done anything like what VW did in the name of corporate greed. It was shameful.

The only difference between Audi (VW) and
MB is that all the oily things MB has done over the years, haven’t been found out yet.
But if you do some homework you’ll find out that MB did the same thing to their Diesel engines that Audi did. Check out the NHSTA
website and you’l Find it’s true.
Doc

ua549 10-28-2018 04:10 PM

The NHTSA (not the NHSTA) has no engine complaints for 2018 Mercedes W213 models. The NHTSA does not deal with diesel engine emissions issues for any brand of vehicle.

Germancar1 10-28-2018 05:35 PM


Originally Posted by riamga (Post 7588569)

The only difference between Audi (VW) and
MB is that all the oily things MB has done over the years, haven’t been found out yet.
But if you do some homework you’ll find out that MB did the same thing to their Diesel engines that Audi did. Check out the NHSTA
website and you’l Find it’s true.
Doc

Wrong.

M

rbrylaw 10-28-2018 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by Germancar1 (Post 7588674)
Wrong.

M

Don't pay this guy any attention. Clearly a troll. Check out his thread on the Worst MB he's ever owned. Musings of the disgruntled.

AnnaSmit 02-18-2019 12:40 PM

In my case, Audi quad 2009 showed that this is a very naughty car. A lot of effort goes into maintenance. In 2019, now there are even more options that will cause difficulties. Although a decent car and the cross did not know better. Super!!!

rustybear3 02-18-2019 02:31 PM

Audi has never gotten away from those big, ugly, front grills. It's styling over the years mimics the Edsel. If a car doesn't look good to me, there's no incentive to even consider it.

EMEIVI 02-28-2019 01:34 AM

Very impressive with 21" wheel pkg just not feeling the media graphic design and black scratch prone dash media area no panoramic ava.
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...abe21ed973.jpg
https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...caa7e86d2c.jpg
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...76c2b1914e.jpg
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbw...840b984d12.jpg

guhvies 02-28-2019 03:28 AM

Wow, $110 just for cables...


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:23 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands