Question...If have you driven the Tesla model S vs S550, why did you choose the S550?
Soon those Tesla's Super Charger Stations will become Tesla parking lots. Waiting hours in line for a charge. Sort of like the gas lines during the oil shortage in the '70's.
You two Tesla Fan boys are like those crotch rocket teenagers telling me how much faster their bikes are compared to my top of the line Harley. If I can afford a $40K plus Harley I can easily afford a $12K crotch rocket many times over.
Same with your $40K Tesla selling for $120K plus. All I hear is how fast your over priced golf car can get you from 0-60 mph. A used $5K crotch rocket will blow your doors off in a 0-60 mph match up. Why are you two clowns even here? Is Tesla paying fan boys now? Do you pi$$ in the BMW, Porsche, Jaguar, Rolls & Bentley forums as well?
We get it, you like your low rent interior, heavily subsidized Teslas.
My former 2009 E320 Bluetec would kill your Teslas in a race from Florida to NYC (1,300 miles) by hours up I-95, where to make it fair, you have all those Super Chargers. That's if no one is taking all the super charger spots when you arrive.
The E320 Bluetec has over a 700 mile range, I can push it over 800 miles).
Disclaimer: I actually ride my motorcycle far more than my S550. I've had my S550 for a yr now and have just under 7K miles on the clock. My Harley is 3 months old and I have 6K miles on it already. So actually a Tesla would make me a better grocery shopping car than my S550.
Too bad though, luxury was on top of my short list.
Also, I don't suppose an Admin can end this thread? Literally the same thing is being repeated. The two tesla owners, Web and drsaab, and us s class owners bought our vehicles for different reasons.
S Class - Luxury Sedan
Model S - Performance sedan
You are welcome to stop taking part in the discussion any time you want to.If I were to be chauffeured someplace I'd certainly prefer to be chauffeured in an S Class than a Model S, as I won't be doing the driving in that case
No one said S Class sales are tanking. I just said in the US, Model S sales are exceeding S Class sales in the category of a premium 4 door sedan that can seat 5 adults and costing around $100K. It's important to note as these people could have presumably bought an S Class instead. Just pointing this out to make the point that obviously a large segment of customers in this segment see something of value in the Model S that is not met by any other competing product. They are both find vehicles and no choice is a wrong choice as I've said many times.
You two Tesla Fan boys are like those crotch rocket teenagers telling me how much faster their bikes are compared to my top of the line Harley. If I can afford a $40K plus Harley I can easily afford a $12K crotch rocket many times over.
Same with your $40K Tesla selling for $120K plus. All I hear is how fast your over priced golf car can get you from 0-60 mph. A used $5K crotch rocket will blow your doors off in a 0-60 mph match up. Why are you two clowns even here? Is Tesla paying fan boys now? Do you pi$$ in the BMW, Porsche, Jaguar, Rolls & Bentley forums as well?
We get it, you like your low rent interior, heavily subsidized Teslas.
My former 2009 E320 Bluetec would kill your Teslas in a race from Florida to NYC (1,300 miles) by hours up I-95, where to make it fair, you have all those Super Chargers. That's if no one is taking all the super charger spots when you arrive.
The E320 Bluetec has over a 700 mile range, I can push it over 800 miles).
Disclaimer: I actually ride my motorcycle far more than my S550. I've had my S550 for a yr now and have just under 7K miles on the clock. My Harley is 3 months old and I have 6K miles on it already. So actually a Tesla would make me a better grocery shopping car than my S550.
Too bad though, luxury was on top of my short list.

We had just discussed a number of other factors besides the edge in performance so you might want to go back and read what was discussed.
Enjoy your E320. Must be incredible with that 800 mile range as you can drive all that distance nonstop...

We had just discussed a number of other factors besides the edge in performance so you might want to go back and read what was discussed.
Enjoy your E320. Must be incredible with that 800 mile range as you can drive all that distance nonstop...

Tip to traveling over 600 miles non stop, salted peanuts.
As your reading comprehension has failed you in your haste to appear you're taking the higher road here, you missed it was my "former" E320 Bluetec.
My personality is one of someone that's fed up with Bull *****ting fan boys.
Why don't you two clowns go start a Tesla Fan Boy page elsewhere, maybe you can impress some pimple face teen waiting on his learners permit.
Tip to traveling over 600 miles non stop, salted peanuts.
As your reading comprehension has failed you in your haste to appear you're taking the higher road here, you missed it was my "former" E320 Bluetec.
My personality is one of someone that's fed up with Bull *****ting fan boys.
Why don't you two clowns go start a Tesla Fan Boy page elsewhere, maybe you can impress some pimple face teen waiting on his learners permit.

It's rich for you to talk about fanboys as you seem so much of a Mercedes fanboy that you are emotionally unable to handle some other forum members discuss Tesla and Mercedes on a forum thread specifically devoted to that topic. Not everything in the world is about you so get over yourself. If a forum topic does not interest you, don't read it.
Harley is having a really hard time financially according to a recent WSJ article and that means there are fewer obnoxious people like you around and that's a good thing. The recent South Park Episode of Harley reminds me of you. You should watch it.
Since you are incapable of engaging in intelligent discourse without getting all emotional with a tirade of insults, you are going on my ignore list so I will not be responding to any more of your nonsense. Since intelligent discourse is beyond your grasp, go ride your little Harley someplace and make some obnoxious noise so you feel better about yourself.




You are welcome to stop taking part in the discussion any time you want to.If I were to be chauffeured someplace I'd certainly prefer to be chauffeured in an S Class than a Model S, as I won't be doing the driving in that case
No one said S Class sales are tanking. I just said in the US, Model S sales are exceeding S Class sales in the category of a premium 4 door sedan that can seat 5 adults and costing around $100K. It's important to note as these people could have presumably bought an S Class instead. Just pointing this out to make the point that obviously a large segment of customers in this segment see something of value in the Model S that is not met by any other competing product. They are both find vehicles and no choice is a wrong choice as I've said many times.
I was a little disappointed in that I wrote about 10 different points and was told I would get a point by point refute.
In the end that point by point refute was "An iPad charging is negligible in affecting the range of a Tesla."
Yes that makes the other 10 points moot.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Those who are getting "agitated" I assume are not children. They should perhaps not take part in an open forum if they can't handle opinions and views that might be different to theirs. I am still a Mercedes enthusiast and also a Tesla enthusiast and I'm happy to engage in discussion with those who like to engage in civilized discourse about both cars and the future of car technology. I just don't have time for crass dimwits.
For all those who are complaining about this discussion, have they considered not taking part in the discussion if the discussion does not interest them? It's seems quite strange to complain about the topic being discussed and still actively take part in the discussion...
Last edited by WEBSRFR; Jul 21, 2015 at 11:54 AM. Reason: Tidy up grammar.




Those who are getting "agitated" I assume are not children. They should perhaps not take part in an open forum if they can't handle opinions and views that might be different to theirs. I am still a Mercedes enthusiast and also a Tesla enthusiast and I'm happy to engage in discussion with those who like to engage in civilized discourse about both cars and the future of car technology. I just don't have time for crass dimwits.
For all those who are complaining about this discussion, have they considered not taking part in the discussion if the discussion does not interest them? It's seems quite strange to complain about the topic being discussed and still actively take part in the discussion...

I have always struggled to see the value in posts like these as people's requirements for a car are so different. That's why there is 1000's of models.
For example my wife loves the tesla. She says she feels vulnerable filling up at gas stations and loves to come home and just "plug it in". For me, I can't stand the thought of not being able to go to a gas station. I don't want to think about how miles I have left. Each of us could go on for hours why our car is better but the reality is it's only better to us.
If you choose to buy an S or a tesla feel great knowing you are more then likely in the top 10% of household income and enjoy your car that makes up less than 1% of all vehicles.
Last edited by icebeam; Jul 22, 2015 at 03:03 AM.

I have always struggled to see the value in posts like these as people's requirements for a car are so different. That's why there is 1000's of models.
For example my wife loves the tesla. She says she feels vulnerable filling up at gas stations and loves to come home and just "plug it in". For me, I can't stand the thought of not being able to go to a gas station. I don't want to think about how miles I have left. Each of us could go on for hours why our car is better but the reality is it's only better to us.
If you choose to buy an S or a tesla feel great knowing you are more then likely in the top 10% of household income and enjoy your car that makes up less than 1% of all vehicles.
You are correct that neither of those things are arguable, but what is arguable are other things. To put it better is to discuss the reality of things regarding the car. The Tesla supporters come on and say you get supercar performance and 300 miles of range. The reality is you get supercar 0-60 performance with around 150-180 miles of real world driving range. Another thing you read is you get a modern luxury interior. The reality is when you compare it you get the interior of what you see in $50,000 cars. That is not to say it is horrible, but not what one expects in a $100,000 car. There are cars that are $50,000 whose interior I like, but if I spend $100K I expect a $100K package in all aspects.
I have yet to see one instance where someone told another what the better car for the other party was. I have seen however people come and correct erroneous information and point out factual data so that if one reads the thread they have an educated decision they can make.
I have yet to see one instance where someone told another what the better car for the other party was. I have seen however people come and correct erroneous information and point out factual data so that if one reads the thread they have an educated decision they can make.
As for the interior, even I readily agree that the S Class interior is better. Having said that I know of no other car at $50,000 or any other price for that matter that has a modern all glass cockpit and instrumentation that is ridiculously easy and intuitive to use in the Model S. No one has yet to duplicate the Model S interface to a point where they can change every aspect of the car with just a software update.
The technology in the user interface is part of the Model S interior that makes it preferable to someone like me who enjoys technology. That combined with the "Premium Interior" option Tesla offers provides me a reasonable balance of modern luxury and comfort with the Next Gen Seats to a point where the "less nice" interior of the Model S is not an impediment to ownership.
As has been said so many times, there is no wrong choice between these two cars and it is a choice based on individual preferences and priorities. The ideal car for me remains an S Class interior with a Tesla drivetrain and technology/software
As for the interior, even I readily agree that the S Class interior is better. Having said that I know of no other car at $50,000 or any other price for that matter that has a modern all glass cockpit and instrumentation that is ridiculously easy and intuitive to use in the Model S. No one has yet to duplicate the Model S interface to a point where they can change every aspect of the car with just a software update.
The technology in the user interface is part of the Model S interior that makes it preferable to someone like me who enjoys technology. That combined with the "Premium Interior" option Tesla offers provides me a reasonable balance of modern luxury and comfort with the Next Gen Seats to a point where the "less nice" interior of the Model S is not an impediment to ownership.
As has been said so many times, there is no wrong choice between these two cars and it is a choice based on individual preferences and priorities. The ideal car for me remains an S Class interior with a Tesla drivetrain and technology/software

Last edited by Landers; Jul 22, 2015 at 11:35 AM.
The glass cockpit makes the Model S interior. There are glass screens, for the instrument cluster and the center console and they are both what defines the Model S interior and user interface. After getting used to ho intuitive and effortless it is to use I find it awkward to switch to Mercedes' Command, especially the navigation interface, whenever I drive my girlfriend's car.
Not sure what you are talking about with fit and finish. Some of the their earlier cars had some issues but our car is rock solid. About the only thing we are going to take the car in for service is going to be to upgrade the car to Ludicrous Mode in about a month.
BTW Model S has been shipping with 4G for a while now and they actually cover the cost of 4G for the first 4 years so the car actually has a pretty decent Internet connection that works well for streaming media at a high bitrate.
Of course I still think the S class interior is so much more refined and luxurious but I'm curious to hear thoughts about it. The one thing to note here is that Fisker as a company tended to be design heavy and was all about the look of things and they ultimately collapsed under their own weight as they didn't have the engineering to back up the design.
Tesla has been careful to grow from it's strength in engineering, safety, and performance first and then get into focusing on the interior niceties. It's only recently that they began offering even a heated steering wheel. When the Model X comes out in a few months it will be interesting to see how better it is to the Model S as Tesla now has far more resources than when they designed the Model S...
Last edited by WEBSRFR; Jul 22, 2015 at 03:34 PM. Reason: Tidy up grammar.
I don't believe there is a conspiracy to buy up amazing battery technology. Nothing else on earth with the abundance and cost effectiveness as petroleum products contains as much energy per pound. I only see electric cars reducing the rate of growth of consumption of gasoline and diesel, not reducing consumption. Its a big world out there, with many billions of people just starting to discover the benefits of modern life, such as the automobile and air conditioning. They won't be lining up to buy Teslas or Mercedes for that matter any time soon.



