When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I thought the W205 looks soft, but after seeing that pic it looks downright mean and sexy!
Makes the 2 PFL W204 next to it look super outdated.
Originally Posted by Amg63-
I agree, but at the same time an FL w204 also makes a PFL look pretty outdated as well.
My issue is more the side and rear profiles/angles of the w205. Just too damn rounded for such an aggressive type of car.
Everyone has different tastes. That's all. In fact, I disagree with both of your statements.
From that picture, while the W205 looks great, it still looks super soft.
AMG63 - I'd actually have to disagree with you regarding a FL making a PFL look outdated (outside of tail lights -- yes this does give it away), but from the front end of the car, I'd be hardpressed if anyone who's not an AMG fan could point out the newer car.
I do, however, completely agree on the bolded statement. The lines are just too curvy for such muscle under the hood. Don't even get me started on the coupe or should the I say, the miniwagon looking thing
Given the build quality issues on my w205 what put me over the top was the build loc of usa ... And alabama...., Every time i had a squeaky bit i thought of my bama built benz.. And that just killed it for me.
The exhaust was cool at first but then seemed a bit contrived, or simulated w all the extra popping and whoomph. Sounds.
i also thought the w205 did not look distinct enough from the non amg version.
Subjective i know.
The motor trans was the best part though---- very gts like, oh the loads of tq!
I wouldnt say better, beacause such a different car. Ill be curious to see how the smaller tt motor and the softer looks hold up over time.
Given the build quality issues on my w205 what put me over the top was the build loc of usa ... And alabama...., Every time i had a squeaky bit i thought of my bama built benz.. And that just killed it for me.
The exhaust was cool at first but then seemed a bit contrived, or simulated w all the extra popping and whoomph. Sounds.
i also thought the w205 did not look distinct enough from the non amg version.
Subjective i know.
The motor trans was the best part though---- very gts like, oh the loads of tq!
I wouldnt say better, beacause such a different car. Ill be curious to see how the smaller tt motor and the softer looks hold up over time.
Nice review.
The new motor is no doubt more powerful than the older one.
Can you give some details on how the older motor drives/sounds compared to your experience with the w205?
Everyone has different tastes. That's all. In fact, I disagree with both of your statements.
From that picture, while the W205 looks great, it still looks super soft.
AMG63 - I'd actually have to disagree with you regarding a FL making a PFL look outdated (outside of tail lights -- yes this does give it away), but from the front end of the car, I'd be hardpressed if anyone who's not an AMG fan could point out the newer car.
I do, however, completely agree on the bolded statement. The lines are just too curvy for such muscle under the hood. Don't even get me started on the coupe or should the I say, the miniwagon looking thing
I also think it's those led fog lights that give away the FL. That always catches my eye.
I'll say is, either model of w204 fl/pfl has a better exterior and more fitting to the cars character than the w205 IMHO.
Yea this car looks so lame I think I'll take it back today for a refund...WHAT?? The pic with the three C63's is my black 2009 W204, my friend Levitics 2010 W204 and my just purchased W205.
I hereby promise to un*****ify the W205's apprearance. Lots of CF already ordered. Performance wise the previous owner is my freakin hero, Eurocharged Turbos & Tune, suspension (not sure of brand and haven't torn into it yet) but adjustable coil overs I'm told, no idea yet? Eurocharged intercooler upgrade installed, looking at their downpipes as well and then adding a racing exhaust...a trip to Houston is in order haha!! The car has 2,600 miles on it and check out the wrap and ADV.1 wheels!! I stole it so I am going to drive it that way!!
Now some fun for the W204 / W205 discussion. My buddy is buying my 09 C63, that car is already a flipping fast, loud beast. As I said I plan to continue to add performance enhancing drugs to my W205. So last night as we finished working on a 72 Cutlass convertible top my buddy tells me he is putting the Weistec supercharger on, he's already looked into complete engine overhaul + Weistec SC. We pop a beer and he basically tells me he's going to kick my azz with the 09 W204 vs 16 W205. So two dumbasses with some extra cash and no sense will be going at it to the bitter end. Also I was talking pure trash when said I wanted 1000hp for $100K in original post LOL...thanks to my D-head buddy I'll need more!
Last edited by JRSJR65; 08-11-2016 at 12:26 PM.
Reason: Pic size
Yea this car looks so lame I think I'll take it back today for a refund...WHAT?? The pic with the three C63's is my black 2009 W204, my friend Levitics 2010 W204 and my just purchased W205.
I hereby promise to un*****ify the W205's apprearance. Lots of CF already ordered. Performance wise the previous owner is my freakin hero, Eurocharged Turbos & Tune, suspension (not sure of brand and haven't torn into it yet) but adjustable coil overs I'm told, no idea yet? Eurocharged intercooler upgrade installed, looking at their downpipes as well and then adding a racing exhaust...a trip to Houston is in order haha!! The car has 2,600 miles on it and check out the wrap and ADV.1 wheels!! I stole it so I am going to drive it that way!!
Now some fun for the W204 / W205 discussion. My buddy is buying my 09 C63, that car is already a flipping fast, loud beast. As I said I plan to continue to add performance enhancing drugs to my W205. So last night as we finished working on a 72 Cutlass convertible top my buddy tells me he is putting the Weistec supercharger on, he's already looked into complete engine overhaul + Weistec SC. We pop a beer and he basically tells me he's going to kick my azz with the 09 W204 vs 16 W205. So two dumbasses with some extra cash and no sense will be going at it to the bitter end. Also I was talking pure trash when said I wanted 1000hp for $100K in original post LOL...thanks to my D-head buddy I'll need more!
Amazing wrap color! EC employee Phil has a C32 wrapped in almost same color:
If you're wanting to do downpipes. Call and deposit ahead of time so I can get a set built for you. I would keep the rest of the exhaust stock, don't want any valve restrictions from an aftermarket exhaust. Our shop w205 car only has Downpipes on it and sounds amazing and ran great 1/4mile times. You can hear our car when you're here in person and see how you like it! But looks great! Congrats
"Can you give some details on how the older motor drives/sounds compared to your experience with the w205?"
Launch From a Stand-still: The W205 moves out effortlessly...... the first area the TQ shines is right off the line...... almost NO pedal movement needed to get out of the hole! BEAST. Where the W204 being N/A requires more pedal input (not a big deal),,, but you really have to hammer it off the line for the same experience. (pardon the lack of scientific data.... this is drivers impressions).
20-60MPH roll: W205 TQ again just wallops you....with little pedal input. I tend to rely on kick-down in the n/a W204 for the same effect.
top end:... the tq seemed to fall off on the W205 up top.... but when I say fall off.. it is soo great down low... it seems to drop up top (per my experience).. ... the W204 just pulls and pulls more linear. Again drivers impression.
Braking - I have a lot of seat time in the 507, and some of it at track days.... so I'm biased towards this car in braking. It works very well with no fade @ COTA. The W205 brakes seemed as capable... but I have not had any track time to compare.
Steering - I like the heavier feel of the steering on the 507 vs the newer W205. I've read the W205 is faster on the ring.... but I like the steering feel of the 507 perhaps it's just familiar to me.
Engine Noise/Vibrations - SOO different. Don't expect the 6.2 liter sounds from the 4.0LTT...... they try to enhance the tt sounds with some results.... but I'm not a fan of the woomph sounds.. that part got old.. they seemed disconnected with what I was having the motor/car do... if that makes sense.
Ride Quality - The adj susp on the W205 was nice... but mine started to ride rough in all settings.... could have been a bad day in Alabama..... The 507 rides worse than my wifes reg W204.. but better than out P30 pkg 09 W204.......
Buttons/controls/switches.... never got used to the new stuff...... very different from the w204... not saying better or worse.
Feel / fit finish - The W205 had several fit/finish problems..... side valence fell off (double sided tape went bad), the side cover on the drivers seat fell off (weak snapped plastic), the doors are so much lighter and felt cheap to me.... compared to the w204... I'm sure this was for wgt reduction..... and the creaks in the dash were unbearable on the W205.... coming from deep in the dash... a long period creaking that changed tone/volume w/ the weather.
Don't flame... this is from my sensory experience.
Very elegant car, OP. The W205 really is a wolf in sheeps clothing.
However, the W204 is a wolf in wolfs clothing.
Flame suit on. Here we go.
If you look at the 205 from the rear 3/4, it looks like a rounded Asian import. It does not have the masculine german shoulders and rear. AMG has rounded the shoulders and the rear too much in an effort to be "sleek" and "modern". I hate the squinty jelly bean front headlights! Maybe that's what kills it for me from the front! When I look at a car, the front should like the the front and the rar like the rear...not this unisex crap. I feel like they abandoned there chiseled looks that gave their cars a distinctive look from a distance...
I want to like it, but each time I look at it it just looks too feminine....The rear looks slouched and it looks too much like a Hyundai from the early 2000's
The motor is an amazing feat...
The W205 looks much more softer and less dynamic since we are already desensitized by other car companies with similar looking designs. Mercedes has been hiring many designers from S. Korea on their latest models.
As you can see that aesthetic has been crossing over to the new C63S Coupe, GLE AMG and S65 Coupe models.
MB/MB AMG mainly focuses on the engine, technology, etc without trying to re-invent a exterior design from scratch. They get inspired and borrow, steal ideas. They improve off that design to make it their own. It has always happened in the history of car design from every car manufacturer. For example the MB (W204) chassis/design is worked off a Lexus IS300 (SXE10/JCE10). Facelift 2012+ W204 models basically have the R230 SL headlights to further stray away from the original inspiration.
08-10-2016, 08:03 PM
.
. I look forward to seeing the mods you do to it!
