*** Does your car "fall on its face" during part-throttle acceleration? ***
#51
MBWorld Fanatic!
My 2004 C32 has this problem and I have the following installed (below) and it
happens exactly like you explained.
happens exactly like you explained.
#52
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Ventura County USA
Posts: 1,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'06 E55, '05 SLK55, a few others
Victor,
While I don't doubt for a minute that you've identified a real problem, is it possible that some who think they have this issue are really just getting a rather harsh clutch engagement? Mine was pretty bad when stock and has only gotten worse since modifiying the car.
While I don't doubt for a minute that you've identified a real problem, is it possible that some who think they have this issue are really just getting a rather harsh clutch engagement? Mine was pretty bad when stock and has only gotten worse since modifiying the car.
#53
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 1,414
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2005 E55
Victor,
While I don't doubt for a minute that you've identified a real problem, is it possible that some who think they have this issue are really just getting a rather harsh clutch engagement? Mine was pretty bad when stock and has only gotten worse since modifiying the car.
While I don't doubt for a minute that you've identified a real problem, is it possible that some who think they have this issue are really just getting a rather harsh clutch engagement? Mine was pretty bad when stock and has only gotten worse since modifiying the car.
#54
I will get the HW# and SW# tomorrow. For some reason I could not get the car into dyno mode (was following Juice's youtube video).
3 codes I found --
p0410 - secondary air injection system malfunction (I asked that this NEVER be fixed by Benz)
p0730 - gear ratio incorrect - WTF is this?? Related to slipping trans?
p0128 coolant temp below thermostat regular temp. Could it be because its 10 degrees out and I have a the t-stat mod?
#55
I have the harsh supercharger clutch engagement with the biggest pulley around and its nothing like this issue. It can happen at any speed and it seems worse from higher speeds like 60-75 mph. Some times it happens so much I dread giving the car gas knowing its going to happen. It can feel like someone just did a neutral drop in the car with engagement, disengagement and harsh reengagement of the transmission.
#56
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 2,123
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Real Cars
Victor,
While I don't doubt for a minute that you've identified a real problem, is it possible that some who think they have this issue are really just getting a rather harsh clutch engagement? Mine was pretty bad when stock and has only gotten worse since modifiying the car.
While I don't doubt for a minute that you've identified a real problem, is it possible that some who think they have this issue are really just getting a rather harsh clutch engagement? Mine was pretty bad when stock and has only gotten worse since modifiying the car.
-m
#57
MBWorld Fanatic!
this is very funny to me b/c i have the same problem in my car. and i dopnt even have a 55. i have a c63. but my car only does this in 5th gear at about 90mph. (only in that gear and that speed)
edit: how can this be possible in my car. i dont have a supercharger or turbos and currently runing stock ecu. and stock everything?
edit: how can this be possible in my car. i dont have a supercharger or turbos and currently runing stock ecu. and stock everything?
Last edited by mthis; 01-21-2009 at 03:26 AM.
#58
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Ventura County USA
Posts: 1,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'06 E55, '05 SLK55, a few others
Fast I've had 2 E55s now, and without being disrespectful, it is not possible for it to be harsh supercharger engagement. I could go into detail why, but rather than take up a bunch of space on this thead - take my word for it. It's NOT harsh supercharger engagement.
-m
-m
#59
Please everyone lets do this to figure out what the heck is wrong with our cars
The Revision returned from the dyno mode was :
Instr SW: 4102 ver 0073
Instr hw 4502 inst # A211 540 80 11
car is 2003 W211 E55. victor I will send you the VIN #
Also i tested my car in C, S, and M mode and only between 1-2k rpms. The car did this CONSTANTLY. However it would not trigger this behavior in M mode in gears 1-3, only 4-5.
The Revision returned from the dyno mode was :
Instr SW: 4102 ver 0073
Instr hw 4502 inst # A211 540 80 11
car is 2003 W211 E55. victor I will send you the VIN #
Also i tested my car in C, S, and M mode and only between 1-2k rpms. The car did this CONSTANTLY. However it would not trigger this behavior in M mode in gears 1-3, only 4-5.
Those of you that have this problem, please go through the procedure that you normally follow when you want to put the car into DYNO MODE.
Once you enter that engineering menu the main screen you land on will have some information like your VIN#, the HW # and SW #.
Please write down your HW (Hardware #) and SW (Software #) and post it up here. This will tell us which revision # you are currently using.
I am pretty sure we can isolate this with enough samples.
I was able to obtain a stock BIN of the 55's EEPROM code which I know does not have the load limiting software.
The Revision returned from the Bosche ME2.8 was :
HW: 026 120 8106
SW: 103 736 5088
This is from an 03-04 car which never had any updates performed. We know load limiting was introduced in 2005 and then applied to all previous cars through the recall.
These revision # will be different than what the instrument cluster will display but there is a correlation between the 2.
I am expecting my EGS this week so I'll check and see if that removes the issue for me.
Once you enter that engineering menu the main screen you land on will have some information like your VIN#, the HW # and SW #.
Please write down your HW (Hardware #) and SW (Software #) and post it up here. This will tell us which revision # you are currently using.
I am pretty sure we can isolate this with enough samples.
I was able to obtain a stock BIN of the 55's EEPROM code which I know does not have the load limiting software.
The Revision returned from the Bosche ME2.8 was :
HW: 026 120 8106
SW: 103 736 5088
This is from an 03-04 car which never had any updates performed. We know load limiting was introduced in 2005 and then applied to all previous cars through the recall.
These revision # will be different than what the instrument cluster will display but there is a correlation between the 2.
I am expecting my EGS this week so I'll check and see if that removes the issue for me.
Last edited by e55 baller; 01-22-2009 at 05:31 PM.
#60
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 1,990
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'10 Porsche Turbo PDK, 500e, GL450
Honestly just to give more feedback on the problem was that it really felt like the tranny was going to downshift and then didn't. A few times it would downshift but it would go down 2 gears.
#61
interesting. can you pull your h/w and s/w versions from the dyno mode? Mine is beginning to feel more and more like its a transmission issue despite my transmission woes. I hear a loud "thunk" noise which seems to come from the transmission or rear end. The entire car feels like it is "shocked". Its really bad and the car is now only really drivable at 5% Throttle or 100% WOT.
#62
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Westchester, NY
Posts: 429
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
E55, C32, ML320
Mine also felt like it was just about to downshift, but I was intentionally trying to stay under that threshold (since the car was warming up). The car jerked violently but never changed gears. It sounds more like the problem noted here, but maybe it could be transmission related.
#63
Newbie
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Northern NJ
Posts: 22
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2006 SL55 AMG 030
Mine is:
2006 SL55 030
SW Ver. HW
25 05 0038 28 05
My car is away for the winter so I can't test it now, but I get a significant hesitation any time the SC is about to engage.
Can't you just datalog the throttle position to see if the ECU is closing it?
2006 SL55 030
SW Ver. HW
25 05 0038 28 05
My car is away for the winter so I can't test it now, but I get a significant hesitation any time the SC is about to engage.
Can't you just datalog the throttle position to see if the ECU is closing it?
Last edited by Jax8308; 01-23-2009 at 08:10 AM.
#64
I have a scanner but not sure how to hook it up to a PC and record all the data elements over time. I will look into that this weekend.
#65
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 1,990
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'10 Porsche Turbo PDK, 500e, GL450
+1
Mine also felt like it was just about to downshift, but I was intentionally trying to stay under that threshold (since the car was warming up). The car jerked violently but never changed gears. It sounds more like the problem noted here, but maybe it could be transmission related.
But just to clarify I believe that the problem shows it self thru the tranny but is caused by something in the ECU or TCU.
I remember long time ago I pulled some error code that had to do with OL.
#66
This problem was fixed by setting the torque-limit in the EGS higher. Don't know exactly how it is stored there, you have to change some values.The ECU has to interact correctly with the EGS. This was not the case before it was reprogrammed! At the same time the shifting-times were programmed a little quicker. I am satisfied now, the jerk and P20D4 never came back and the car has great power again without any problems.
#67
could this be the issue?
https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w...my-tranny.html
bad radiator screwing up the entire transmission? Looks like there is a TSB.
https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w...my-tranny.html
bad radiator screwing up the entire transmission? Looks like there is a TSB.
#69
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 2,123
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Real Cars
Just wanted to post an update... been working with Victor/Vadim/Powerchips on the issue. Have an updated tune in the car with around 300 miles, issue has not presented itself once. Unfortunately, (or fortunately?) the weather is not as cold as it was when the issue was very prevalent (coldest it's getting now is 30-35) but inspite of my best efforts to get throttle cut, I have not been able to with the revised tune. I will continue to monitor this and let you know if the problem returns.
-m
-m
#70
Senior Member
Just wanted to post an update... been working with Victor/Vadim/Powerchips on the issue. Have an updated tune in the car with around 300 miles, issue has not presented itself once. Unfortunately, (or fortunately?) the weather is not as cold as it was when the issue was very prevalent (coldest it's getting now is 30-35) but inspite of my best efforts to get throttle cut, I have not been able to with the revised tune. I will continue to monitor this and let you know if the problem returns.
-m
-m
"Highest boost I have ever seen was 20,6 PSI, when it was very cold outside (5 degrees Celsius). On a very hot summer day (33 degrees Celsius) I saw 17,5 PSI.
My tune is from the German "Tuning-Pope" O.Neumann / from Evotech Germany who did my ECU and TCU."
"Woody, the shifting-times are a little bit faster now, and the factory-programmed Load-Limits were set higher. Before the TCU-Tuning I had jerks under full-load from time to time. The jerks are gone now.
By the way, I have a special Option from AMG which is called the M-Mode. When I shift manually, the tranny holds the gear and does not shift at redline. For example when I'm in M-Mode I can give WOT in 5th gear, and the tranny does not shift back. Its fun from time to time to use the full torque without shifting back. But normally I drive in Automatic-Mode.
The M-Mode was a option which you could buy from AMG, but they don't offer it anymore. They now are more focused on the newer cars like the C63..."
Post 40 and on..
http://www.crossfireforum.org/forum/...ad.php?t=30690
Going to dyno tune for 185 soon and hopefully do tcu at the same time and get these limits removed.
#71
Just wanted to post an update... been working with Victor/Vadim/Powerchips on the issue. Have an updated tune in the car with around 300 miles, issue has not presented itself once. Unfortunately, (or fortunately?) the weather is not as cold as it was when the issue was very prevalent (coldest it's getting now is 30-35) but inspite of my best efforts to get throttle cut, I have not been able to with the revised tune. I will continue to monitor this and let you know if the problem returns.
-m
-m
did they work on ecu or tcu?
i dont think the weather has any thing to do with what we have,i think its a boost related because mine does it in 2 celsius in winter and 50 celsius summer where i live.
#73
MBWorld Fanatic!
I think this is a problem with all M113 and S/C M112's MB's.
When I am using part throttle while cruising and I decide to smash the throttle ,the car does have a delay then a herky jerky reaction where it would then downshift and then take off. It happens more so now that I have the 5.5L motor in my car. It seems to happen more so when it's pretty cold outside.
If I shift my car manually from 2nd on up and go WOT it will seldom happen,but try it from 3rd while cruising part throttle then go WOT,it is almost as if the car gets slghtly confused,delays,jerks,will downshift to 2nd gear and then will take off.
Is this bascically the same problem? It's annoying!
When I am using part throttle while cruising and I decide to smash the throttle ,the car does have a delay then a herky jerky reaction where it would then downshift and then take off. It happens more so now that I have the 5.5L motor in my car. It seems to happen more so when it's pretty cold outside.
If I shift my car manually from 2nd on up and go WOT it will seldom happen,but try it from 3rd while cruising part throttle then go WOT,it is almost as if the car gets slghtly confused,delays,jerks,will downshift to 2nd gear and then will take off.
Is this bascically the same problem? It's annoying!
Last edited by ProjectC55; 02-17-2009 at 07:40 AM.