MBWorld.org Forums

MBWorld.org Forums (https://mbworld.org/forums/)
-   W211 AMG (https://mbworld.org/forums/w211-amg-81/)
-   -   Manual transmission (https://mbworld.org/forums/w211-amg/428433-manual-transmission.html)

Ajackfish 12-25-2011 09:48 PM

Manual transmission
 
Has anyone installed a manual six speed in a W211 E63?

RedBullJnky 12-25-2011 10:10 PM

I would stick with the paddle shifters myself. just my .02 keep your M5.

emoving 12-25-2011 10:15 PM

:crazy: Stick with your M5!

moosejaw 12-25-2011 10:57 PM

Mercedes cant make a decent stick to save it's life
There hasn't been a stick shift AMG since the 1985 W124 Hammers

Im with Marcus on this one

Ali_E55 12-26-2011 12:50 AM

you can always Renntech for these stuff.

e500slr 12-26-2011 04:38 AM

I'm sorry but I had to log in to respond to this. The character of the AMGs and Mercedes in general does not suit a manual. I loved my E39 M5 and my E46 M3 in manual, I wouldn't have them any other way but at the same time I would never have bought a 55 if it weren't for the auto. Think if a Veyron was manual or a GT-R, it just doesn't suit the car, the engine and the whole dynamic. In the 55 you just mash your foot into the right pedal and hold on for dear life :D I also think one of the reasons the car gets such fast quarter mile times is the 5 spd. If you're looking for manual keep your M5 or try another car. Nobody from what I know has done a manual in the 55 and THANK GOD. It would be SO TACKY :puke:Imagine a manual SLR :puke:

Shifter 12-26-2011 08:50 PM

come on, tacky??? Granted its nice having a auto, but a manual would have its rewards.

Ajackfish 12-26-2011 09:22 PM

A manual transmission is offered in Europe. Mercedes attempts to have only what it perceives as luxurious vehicles in the US, but world wide it provides a variety of vehicles. Many of the high end vehicles are available with a stick. It is difficult to check out a car in Europe and then have it imported. It would be easier to convert one over here. My questions are if anyone has attempted it.

Yacht Master 12-26-2011 11:07 PM

Who would go from a 7 speed electronic transmission (that can be up graded with "AMG Speed Shift") and has 3 shift modes, to a 6 speed manual?

e500slr 12-27-2011 01:18 AM


Originally Posted by Ajackfish (Post 4977964)
A manual transmission is offered in Europe. Mercedes attempts to have only what it perceives as luxurious vehicles in the US, but world wide it provides a variety of vehicles. Many of the high end vehicles are available with a stick. It is difficult to check out a car in Europe and then have it imported. It would be easier to convert one over here. My questions are if anyone has attempted it.

I think you're missing the point, it's not that stick shifts are bad it's this car not being suitable for one. By the way when did the E55 ever get offered in manual even Europe, I doubt there's such a model. Maybe for the E60 M5 but not the E55/E63.

Ajackfish 12-27-2011 01:25 AM

Mercedes in their GB brochure was listing a E63 as late as 2011 with a manual 6 speed. I have heard of e63's in Greece and Spain offering a 6 speed option.

e500slr 12-27-2011 09:19 AM


Originally Posted by Ajackfish (Post 4978204)
Mercedes in their GB brochure was listing a E63 as late as 2011 with a manual 6 speed. I have heard of e63's in Greece and Spain offering a 6 speed option.

Proof or it didn't happen which I'm sure it didn't. There will never be a manual AMG......EVER! :X:violent::puke:

moosejaw 12-27-2011 09:39 AM

There's no manual that Mercedes makes that can handle the torque of our engines. If there was as stated by Mr Whopping 4 posts, it would be made by a outfit like Getrag as it did for the 6 speed Supra, Skyline, and the 7 speed found in the M5.

Here's a shot of the E Class 4 cylinder with a 6 speed.
http://www2.mercedes-benz.co.uk/cont...ansmission.jpg

found on this webpage

http://www2.mercedes-benz.co.uk/cont...ines.0003.html

Jakpro1 12-27-2011 06:02 PM

Ferrari said it best, "The manual is dead"

If you can shift a manual in 60ms which is what Ferrari shifts are down to, more power to ya.

Quadcammer 12-28-2011 12:21 PM


Originally Posted by moosejaw (Post 4978435)
There's no manual that Mercedes makes that can handle the torque of our engines. If there was as stated by Mr Whopping 4 posts, it would be made by a outfit like Getrag as it did for the 6 speed Supra, Skyline, and the 7 speed found in the M5.

Here's a shot of the E Class 4 cylinder with a 6 speed.
http://www2.mercedes-benz.co.uk/cont...ansmission.jpg

found on this webpage

http://www2.mercedes-benz.co.uk/cont...ines.0003.html

As far as I know, Mercedes does not produce the manual transmissions it uses, nor does BMW, Porsche, or others.

The Tremec Tr6060 would easily handle the power and should fit without a problem.

Its just a matter of mounts/crossmembers, bellhousing bolt pattern, and driveshaft.

I think an E55 with a manual would be cool.


Originally Posted by Jakpro1 (Post 4979062)
Ferrari said it best, "The manual is dead"

If you can shift a manual in 60ms which is what Ferrari shifts are down to, more power to ya.

Ferrari buyers tend to want to be F1 wannabes more than other brands. Some people derive enjoyment from shifting. I know I couldn't care less if my shifts are 60ms or not.

Ajackfish 12-28-2011 03:34 PM

You are right. An e63 with a stick is also a neat car. Mercedes uses the same six speed as BMW. I have ordered the bell housing through Mercedes in another country. It is a listed item. It is a tried and true part. I have driven a stick vehicle since the mid sixties and I am very comfortable with it. I can only assume that those who don't like a stick either haven't driven one much or don't know how to handle it.

Yacht Master 12-28-2011 05:13 PM


Originally Posted by Oliverk (Post 4980104)
Its just a matter of mounts/crossmembers, bellhousing bolt pattern, and driveshaft.

Much more to it than the parts you listed, the M113 has no thrust bearing, so the flywheel (oh there is not one that comes off the shelf) would transmit the forces from the throw out bearing to the crankshaft and it would no longer be held centered by the rods.
Then once you over come that then you can start on the ECU and all the inputs and outputs that no longer exist because the TCU is gone, think that would be easy? Just ask any member that has changed the final drive ratio how easy that was, a 6 speed = 6X harder to do.

Yacht Master 12-28-2011 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by Ajackfish (Post 4980323)
I can only assume that those who don't like a stick either haven't driven one much or don't know how to handle it.

No, these are every day cars, and we have been caught in traffic and that alone is enough to put anyone off, pushing in a clutch.

Why is my left foot numb.

Automatic & SBC in traffic, sweet, oh and I can still put my 722 in manual and pretend I am shifting, with no fear of missing a gear.

moosejaw 12-28-2011 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by Ajackfish (Post 4980323)
You are right. An e63 with a stick is also a neat car. Mercedes uses the same six speed as BMW. I have ordered the bell housing through Mercedes in another country. It is a listed item. It is a tried and true part. I have driven a stick vehicle since the mid sixties and I am very comfortable with it. I can only assume that those who don't like a stick either haven't driven one much or don't know how to handle it.


Are you still subscribing to this pipe dream that's there a E63 6 speed?
Do you believe in Unicorns?

RedBullJnky 12-28-2011 07:53 PM


Originally Posted by moosejaw (Post 4980507)
Are you still subscribing to this pipe dream that's there a E63 6 speed?
Do you believe in Unicorns?

:rolf::rolf::rolf:

_AMG_ 12-28-2011 08:13 PM


Originally Posted by e500slr (Post 4977178)
I'm sorry but I had to log in to respond to this. The character of the AMGs and Mercedes in general does not suit a manual. I loved my E39 M5 and my E46 M3 in manual, I wouldn't have them any other way but at the same time I would never have bought a 55 if it weren't for the auto. Think if a Veyron was manual or a GT-R, it just doesn't suit the car, the engine and the whole dynamic. In the 55 you just mash your foot into the right pedal and hold on for dear life :D I also think one of the reasons the car gets such fast quarter mile times is the 5 spd. If you're looking for manual keep your M5 or try another car. Nobody from what I know has done a manual in the 55 and THANK GOD. It would be SO TACKY :puke:Imagine a manual SLR :puke:

+1

outrun 12-28-2011 08:48 PM


Originally Posted by e500slr (Post 4977178)
I'm sorry but I had to log in to respond to this. The character of the AMGs and Mercedes in general does not suit a manual. I loved my E39 M5 and my E46 M3 in manual, I wouldn't have them any other way but at the same time I would never have bought a 55 if it weren't for the auto. Think if a Veyron was manual or a GT-R, it just doesn't suit the car, the engine and the whole dynamic. In the 55 you just mash your foot into the right pedal and hold on for dear life :D I also think one of the reasons the car gets such fast quarter mile times is the 5 spd. If you're looking for manual keep your M5 or try another car. Nobody from what I know has done a manual in the 55 and THANK GOD. It would be SO TACKY :puke:Imagine a manual SLR :puke:

I for one would like to drive a 6 speed E55...if it were real.

Manual transmissions are meant for sports cars.

Automatics are for car companies that do not want their customers to smoke clutches and rev to 8000 and dump the clutch to save on warranty work. Automatics are for bracket racers that want to run consistent times, car companies that want to save money on warranty work and people that find drivng a manual to be too difficult/annoying etc.

BUT YOU CAN SHIFT AS FAST AS AN AUTO IN A FERRARI.

Big deal. I want a car to have fun in. And I for one think that rowing the gears manually in an E55 would be awesome.

RedBullJnky 12-28-2011 09:31 PM


Originally Posted by outrun (Post 4980730)
I for one would like to drive a 6 speed E55...if it were real.

Manual transmissions are meant for sports cars.

Automatics are for car companies that do not want their customers to smoke clutches and rev to 8000 and dump the clutch to save on warranty work. Automatics are for bracket racers that want to run consistent times, car companies that want to save money on warranty work and people that find drivng a manual to be too difficult/annoying etc.

BUT YOU CAN SHIFT AS FAST AS AN AUTO IN A FERRARI.

Big deal. I want a car to have fun in. And I for one think that rowing the gears manually in an E55 would be awesome.

Get a TCU tune from EC and have full manual with the shift bottons.:D

e500slr 12-28-2011 11:12 PM


Originally Posted by Ajackfish (Post 4980323)
You are right. An e63 with a stick is also a neat car. Mercedes uses the same six speed as BMW. I have ordered the bell housing through Mercedes in another country. It is a listed item. It is a tried and true part. I have driven a stick vehicle since the mid sixties and I am very comfortable with it. I can only assume that those who don't like a stick either haven't driven one much or don't know how to handle it.

You sir are a bloody idiot, did you not see me mention I loved the 6 spds when I had my E39 M5 and E46 M3, I explained to you that the E55/E63 is an everyday missile, high torque, high horsepower and an auto. What next, do you want a 6 spd Veyron :X How about a GT-R, you want a 6 spd so you can turn it into a 370z or like I said do you want a 6 spd SLR :puke::puke::puke: Why don't you go do this stupid 6 spd conversion instead of asking about **** no one wants to do. :rant: :thread:

e500slr 12-28-2011 11:18 PM

If the E55 was a 6 spd those 10 sec runs with cars under 600whp wouldn't be there just like the Nissan GT-R wouldn't be NEARLY what it is now without it's DCT. Have you seen how the UGR Gallardo struggles in those races in Russia because of it's manual or it's stupid e-gear? Manual is fun but if you want a car that's insanely fast and consistent manual is not the way to go. Neither is a torque converter auto but for THIS CAR, THIS CAR, THIS CAR (so you can read what I'm referring to) it's PERFECT. Go try to run 10s in an E39 M5 :rolf:


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:51 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands