Can i buy an extra ECU for a tune?
#26
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 12,040
Received 2,162 Likes
on
1,520 Posts
2014 E63S; AMS 100 octane ecu tune; edok tcu tune; BB intakes; dyno tuned
Obviously this is a 2015 thread and I finally tuned my ride in 2018 by AMS in West Chicago IL and it was flawless. No issues for them to close on oem ecu then to tune the eBay ecu
#27
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 12,040
Received 2,162 Likes
on
1,520 Posts
2014 E63S; AMS 100 octane ecu tune; edok tcu tune; BB intakes; dyno tuned
The following users liked this post:
amgboy916 (02-13-2019)
#29
MBWorld Fanatic!
Nope. ECU is considered an emissions component. All Emission components are covered up to 80k miles. At least in the US I believe. Perhaps elsewhere too.
#32
MBWorld Fanatic!
OK, so these last 2 posts don't make sense because I requested the one before them to be pulled as I missed the digital barcodes on my OEM ECU. On to what should have been posted:
Here is what you look for if you are going to get a used ECU. Notice the character string underlined in red. This should match for a suitable ECU. For my string, I found about 6 options on Ebay averaging ~$600 for my string.
Blacked out ECU label is my OEM. Label below is my 2nd ECU (if I were to have one. ).
Here is what you look for if you are going to get a used ECU. Notice the character string underlined in red. This should match for a suitable ECU. For my string, I found about 6 options on Ebay averaging ~$600 for my string.
Blacked out ECU label is my OEM. Label below is my 2nd ECU (if I were to have one. ).
The following 2 users liked this post by Vrodman:
BiturboSF (01-08-2021),
Jaybird123 (09-25-2024)
#33
Super Member
I hope one of the tuners will chime in, but from what i know, in order to clone the 2nd ECU for your VIN, the tuner has to physically open the stock ECU and extract data from it.
I am afraid this action alone will be a dead giveaway. Besides seeing that it was physically opened, i am certain that MB can see that data was extracted at some point.
If there is a way around this i am not aware of, i am getting a tune today!
I am afraid this action alone will be a dead giveaway. Besides seeing that it was physically opened, i am certain that MB can see that data was extracted at some point.
If there is a way around this i am not aware of, i am getting a tune today!
#34
MBWorld Fanatic!
I hope one of the tuners will chime in, but from what i know, in order to clone the 2nd ECU for your VIN, the tuner has to physically open the stock ECU and extract data from it.
I am afraid this action alone will be a dead giveaway. Besides seeing that it was physically opened, i am certain that MB can see that data was extracted at some point.
If there is a way around this i am not aware of, i am getting a tune today!
I am afraid this action alone will be a dead giveaway. Besides seeing that it was physically opened, i am certain that MB can see that data was extracted at some point.
If there is a way around this i am not aware of, i am getting a tune today!
Lastly, I have yet to hear from a single person on this site how they were denied warranty work as a result of suspected ECU tampering or the like.
So to you Sir I say:
GET THAT TUNE TODAY!!!!
The following users liked this post:
I.T. Guy (07-17-2019)
#35
Banned
^ +1 Most techs are really not that bright, and wont ever go that in detail to check for tampering. Most reputable companies who do open the ECU's, you cant even tell it was touched.
#36
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 12,040
Received 2,162 Likes
on
1,520 Posts
2014 E63S; AMS 100 octane ecu tune; edok tcu tune; BB intakes; dyno tuned
Last edited by PeterUbers; 02-13-2019 at 08:05 PM.
#37
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 12,040
Received 2,162 Likes
on
1,520 Posts
2014 E63S; AMS 100 octane ecu tune; edok tcu tune; BB intakes; dyno tuned
Btw kudos to vrod for helping me navigate the second ecu concept and setting me up with the right tuner!! Before he guided me I thought this was all theory
but it's quite possible and quite easy!
but it's quite possible and quite easy!
#38
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2016
Location: Toronto, ON
Posts: 1,527
Received 284 Likes
on
194 Posts
2021 Mercedes C63s AMG Coupe
Just resurrecting this thread to share what I know about this. Mercedes dealerships consider ECUs to be a TRP. Meaning Theft Related Part. Dealerships are not allowed to sell TRPs without having the currently installed component back at hand. As far as I know Mercedes can only code a blank ECU back to the car, meaning the ECU has to be brand new (not previously coded to another car) for Mercedes to code/ marry it to your car. There is no official way of coding a used ECU through the star system. And as for these new ECUs, there is no blank file you can install on a used ECU to turn them bootable through the Star system, you have to buy a new one in order to have a second ECU for your car.
For the older generation ECUs, you could take one and blank it out to code it again to the car using Star.
But here is the thing, for the new cars even though Mercedes won’t sell you a brand new ECU, they will however sell a brand new ECU to a registered Indy Shop, so you can go to one and buy one through them. Then have it coded to your car through star by going to a MB coder who has a star system. This way you can technically have two ECUs married to your car.
The only way to copy your original ECU file to a used ECU is though breaking the seal for the original ECU and copying that file to the used ECU you acquired. Which makes the whole point moot as Mercedes techs these days check the sealing bead on the ECU to see if it has been cracked open and if they notice any irregularities in the seam, the flag the car right away, I know cause this happened to me.
The reason why I am writing all this is to know if you guys can clarify something for me, say you have successfully managed to code two ECUs for your car, is there any way Mercedes can find out if you swap them out by tracing the data logs? I mean the ECU keeps track of your car’s odo count, so say I one day swap the original ECU and put a tuned second ECU in there, run the car for a few months. Say I want warranty support now, so I put the original ECU back in, so the original ECU now suddenly sees a different ODO reading (ODO reading is stored in another module in the car, not the ECU, ECU can just read it), if that is the Case, does the ECU keep track of these sudden jumps and changes? And can Mercedes technically find this out? Or there would be no way of Mercedes knowing this?
For the older generation ECUs, you could take one and blank it out to code it again to the car using Star.
But here is the thing, for the new cars even though Mercedes won’t sell you a brand new ECU, they will however sell a brand new ECU to a registered Indy Shop, so you can go to one and buy one through them. Then have it coded to your car through star by going to a MB coder who has a star system. This way you can technically have two ECUs married to your car.
The only way to copy your original ECU file to a used ECU is though breaking the seal for the original ECU and copying that file to the used ECU you acquired. Which makes the whole point moot as Mercedes techs these days check the sealing bead on the ECU to see if it has been cracked open and if they notice any irregularities in the seam, the flag the car right away, I know cause this happened to me.
The reason why I am writing all this is to know if you guys can clarify something for me, say you have successfully managed to code two ECUs for your car, is there any way Mercedes can find out if you swap them out by tracing the data logs? I mean the ECU keeps track of your car’s odo count, so say I one day swap the original ECU and put a tuned second ECU in there, run the car for a few months. Say I want warranty support now, so I put the original ECU back in, so the original ECU now suddenly sees a different ODO reading (ODO reading is stored in another module in the car, not the ECU, ECU can just read it), if that is the Case, does the ECU keep track of these sudden jumps and changes? And can Mercedes technically find this out? Or there would be no way of Mercedes knowing this?
Last edited by munis; 07-17-2019 at 11:46 AM.
#39
Super Member
Just resurrecting this thread to share what I know about this. Mercedes dealerships consider ECUs to be a TRP. Meaning Theft Related Part. Dealerships are not allowed to sell TRPs without having the currently installed component back at hand. As far as I know Mercedes can only code a blank ECU back to the car, meaning the ECU has to be brand new (not previously coded to another car) for Mercedes to code/ marry it to your car. There is no official way of coding a used ECU through the star system. And as for these new ECUs, there is no blank file you can install on a used ECU to turn them bootable through the Star system, you have to buy a new one in order to have a second ECU for your car.
For the older ECUs, you could take one and blank it out to code it again to the car using Star.
But here is the thing, for the new cars even though Mercedes won’t sell you a brand new ECU, they will however sell a brand new ECU to a registered Indy Shop, so you can go to one and buy one through them. Then have it coded to your car through star by going to a MB coder who has a star system. This way you can technically have two ECUs married to your car.
The only way to copy your original ECU file to a used ECU is though breaking the seal for the original ECU and copying that file to the used ECU you acquired. Which makes the whole point moot as Mercedes techs these days check the sealing bead on the ECU to see if it has been cracked open and if they notice any irregularities in the seam, the flag the car right away, I know cause this happened to me.
The reason why I am writing all this is to know if you guys can clarify something for me, say you have successfully managed to code two ECUs for your car, is there any way Mercedes can find out if you swap them out by tracing the data logs? I mean the ECU keeps track of your car’s odo count, so say I one day swap the original ECU and put a tuned second ECU in there, run the car for a few months. Say I want warranty support now, so I put the original ECU back in, so the original ECU now suddenly sees a different ODO reading (ODO reading is stored in another module in the car, not the ECU, ECU can just read it), if that is the Case, does the ECU keep track of these sudden jumps and changes? And can Mercedes technically find this out? Or there would be no way of Mercedes knowing this?
For the older ECUs, you could take one and blank it out to code it again to the car using Star.
But here is the thing, for the new cars even though Mercedes won’t sell you a brand new ECU, they will however sell a brand new ECU to a registered Indy Shop, so you can go to one and buy one through them. Then have it coded to your car through star by going to a MB coder who has a star system. This way you can technically have two ECUs married to your car.
The only way to copy your original ECU file to a used ECU is though breaking the seal for the original ECU and copying that file to the used ECU you acquired. Which makes the whole point moot as Mercedes techs these days check the sealing bead on the ECU to see if it has been cracked open and if they notice any irregularities in the seam, the flag the car right away, I know cause this happened to me.
The reason why I am writing all this is to know if you guys can clarify something for me, say you have successfully managed to code two ECUs for your car, is there any way Mercedes can find out if you swap them out by tracing the data logs? I mean the ECU keeps track of your car’s odo count, so say I one day swap the original ECU and put a tuned second ECU in there, run the car for a few months. Say I want warranty support now, so I put the original ECU back in, so the original ECU now suddenly sees a different ODO reading (ODO reading is stored in another module in the car, not the ECU, ECU can just read it), if that is the Case, does the ECU keep track of these sudden jumps and changes? And can Mercedes technically find this out? Or there would be no way of Mercedes knowing this?
#40
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 12,040
Received 2,162 Likes
on
1,520 Posts
2014 E63S; AMS 100 octane ecu tune; edok tcu tune; BB intakes; dyno tuned
Just resurrecting this thread to share what I know about this. Mercedes dealerships consider ECUs to be a TRP. Meaning Theft Related Part. Dealerships are not allowed to sell TRPs without having the currently installed component back at hand. As far as I know Mercedes can only code a blank ECU back to the car, meaning the ECU has to be brand new (not previously coded to another car) for Mercedes to code/ marry it to your car. There is no official way of coding a used ECU through the star system. And as for these new ECUs, there is no blank file you can install on a used ECU to turn them bootable through the Star system, you have to buy a new one in order to have a second ECU for your car.
For the older generation ECUs, you could take one and blank it out to code it again to the car using Star.
But here is the thing, for the new cars even though Mercedes won’t sell you a brand new ECU, they will however sell a brand new ECU to a registered Indy Shop, so you can go to one and buy one through them. Then have it coded to your car through star by going to a MB coder who has a star system. This way you can technically have two ECUs married to your car.
The only way to copy your original ECU file to a used ECU is though breaking the seal for the original ECU and copying that file to the used ECU you acquired. Which makes the whole point moot as Mercedes techs these days check the sealing bead on the ECU to see if it has been cracked open and if they notice any irregularities in the seam, the flag the car right away, I know cause this happened to me.
The reason why I am writing all this is to know if you guys can clarify something for me, say you have successfully managed to code two ECUs for your car, is there any way Mercedes can find out if you swap them out by tracing the data logs? I mean the ECU keeps track of your car’s odo count, so say I one day swap the original ECU and put a tuned second ECU in there, run the car for a few months. Say I want warranty support now, so I put the original ECU back in, so the original ECU now suddenly sees a different ODO reading (ODO reading is stored in another module in the car, not the ECU, ECU can just read it), if that is the Case, does the ECU keep track of these sudden jumps and changes? And can Mercedes technically find this out? Or there would be no way of Mercedes knowing this?
For the older generation ECUs, you could take one and blank it out to code it again to the car using Star.
But here is the thing, for the new cars even though Mercedes won’t sell you a brand new ECU, they will however sell a brand new ECU to a registered Indy Shop, so you can go to one and buy one through them. Then have it coded to your car through star by going to a MB coder who has a star system. This way you can technically have two ECUs married to your car.
The only way to copy your original ECU file to a used ECU is though breaking the seal for the original ECU and copying that file to the used ECU you acquired. Which makes the whole point moot as Mercedes techs these days check the sealing bead on the ECU to see if it has been cracked open and if they notice any irregularities in the seam, the flag the car right away, I know cause this happened to me.
The reason why I am writing all this is to know if you guys can clarify something for me, say you have successfully managed to code two ECUs for your car, is there any way Mercedes can find out if you swap them out by tracing the data logs? I mean the ECU keeps track of your car’s odo count, so say I one day swap the original ECU and put a tuned second ECU in there, run the car for a few months. Say I want warranty support now, so I put the original ECU back in, so the original ECU now suddenly sees a different ODO reading (ODO reading is stored in another module in the car, not the ECU, ECU can just read it), if that is the Case, does the ECU keep track of these sudden jumps and changes? And can Mercedes technically find this out? Or there would be no way of Mercedes knowing this?
The following users liked this post:
I.T. Guy (07-17-2019)
#41
MBWorld Fanatic!
They can find out anything really easy without even checking the ECU. For example they can just look at the TCU and see max trq that it has seen. So easy, BAM, you burned.
You guys are over thinking this. It's pretty simple! If you go in for warranty work and dealer is happy to do the work, and knows MB is going pay them, they wont even look for reasons. They just do the work. They like money. If they are unhappy and want to find a reason to deny, or think MB won't reimburse them, then you might be sunk if it's engine related and you have tuned. You think you will be able to fight their techs on their own systems in court because you did an ECU swap or fancy OBD flash? LOL.
So, if you want warranty with no lost sleep at night, and no attempted fraud if they want to deny and you want to lie, then don't tune. If you tune you take the risk, and if warranty is denied, it's on you. I think it's very unlikely, and you probably won't have claims denied. But there is that risk.
If you are so concerned about flipping between tunes yourself, get a MyGenius and have at it. No extra ECU required, faster and easier then swapping.
You guys are over thinking this. It's pretty simple! If you go in for warranty work and dealer is happy to do the work, and knows MB is going pay them, they wont even look for reasons. They just do the work. They like money. If they are unhappy and want to find a reason to deny, or think MB won't reimburse them, then you might be sunk if it's engine related and you have tuned. You think you will be able to fight their techs on their own systems in court because you did an ECU swap or fancy OBD flash? LOL.
So, if you want warranty with no lost sleep at night, and no attempted fraud if they want to deny and you want to lie, then don't tune. If you tune you take the risk, and if warranty is denied, it's on you. I think it's very unlikely, and you probably won't have claims denied. But there is that risk.
If you are so concerned about flipping between tunes yourself, get a MyGenius and have at it. No extra ECU required, faster and easier then swapping.
Last edited by I.T. Guy; 07-17-2019 at 03:51 PM.
#42
Senior Member
They can find out anything really easy without even checking the ECU. For example they can just look at the TCU and see max trq that it has seen. So easy, BAM, you burned.
You guys are over thinking this. It's pretty simple! If you go in for warranty work and dealer is happy to do the work, and knows MB is going pay them, they wont even look for reasons. They just do the work. They like money. If they are unhappy and want to find a reason to deny, or think MB won't reimburse them, then you might be sunk if it's engine related and you have tuned. You think you will be able to fight their techs on their own systems in court because you did an ECU swap or fancy OBD flash? LOL.
So, if you want warranty with no lost sleep at night, and no attempted fraud if they want to deny and you want to lie, then don't tune. If you tune you take the risk, and if warranty is denied, it's on you. I think it's very unlikely, and you probably won't have claims denied. But there is that risk.
If you are so concerned about flipping between tunes yourself, get a MyGenius and have at it. No extra ECU required, faster and easier then swapping.
You guys are over thinking this. It's pretty simple! If you go in for warranty work and dealer is happy to do the work, and knows MB is going pay them, they wont even look for reasons. They just do the work. They like money. If they are unhappy and want to find a reason to deny, or think MB won't reimburse them, then you might be sunk if it's engine related and you have tuned. You think you will be able to fight their techs on their own systems in court because you did an ECU swap or fancy OBD flash? LOL.
So, if you want warranty with no lost sleep at night, and no attempted fraud if they want to deny and you want to lie, then don't tune. If you tune you take the risk, and if warranty is denied, it's on you. I think it's very unlikely, and you probably won't have claims denied. But there is that risk.
If you are so concerned about flipping between tunes yourself, get a MyGenius and have at it. No extra ECU required, faster and easier then swapping.
The following users liked this post:
I.T. Guy (07-27-2019)
#44
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Chicago
Posts: 1,188
Received 171 Likes
on
119 Posts
E63 SL55 996TT C5Z06
They can find out anything really easy without even checking the ECU. For example they can just look at the TCU and see max trq that it has seen. So easy, BAM, you burned.
You guys are over thinking this. It's pretty simple! If you go in for warranty work and dealer is happy to do the work, and knows MB is going pay them, they wont even look for reasons. They just do the work. They like money. If they are unhappy and want to find a reason to deny, or think MB won't reimburse them, then you might be sunk if it's engine related and you have tuned. You think you will be able to fight their techs on their own systems in court because you did an ECU swap or fancy OBD flash? LOL.
So, if you want warranty with no lost sleep at night, and no attempted fraud if they want to deny and you want to lie, then don't tune. If you tune you take the risk, and if warranty is denied, it's on you. I think it's very unlikely, and you probably won't have claims denied. But there is that risk.
If you are so concerned about flipping between tunes yourself, get a MyGenius and have at it. No extra ECU required, faster and easier then swapping.
You guys are over thinking this. It's pretty simple! If you go in for warranty work and dealer is happy to do the work, and knows MB is going pay them, they wont even look for reasons. They just do the work. They like money. If they are unhappy and want to find a reason to deny, or think MB won't reimburse them, then you might be sunk if it's engine related and you have tuned. You think you will be able to fight their techs on their own systems in court because you did an ECU swap or fancy OBD flash? LOL.
So, if you want warranty with no lost sleep at night, and no attempted fraud if they want to deny and you want to lie, then don't tune. If you tune you take the risk, and if warranty is denied, it's on you. I think it's very unlikely, and you probably won't have claims denied. But there is that risk.
If you are so concerned about flipping between tunes yourself, get a MyGenius and have at it. No extra ECU required, faster and easier then swapping.
I had a horrid experience going to a chicago dealer for a flat tire and was threatened to status my car because they saw my after market air filter set up from UPD and told me to remove it, despite coming in for only a flat tire which is ridiculous.
Find a a good dealer and treat your service advisor and. MB tech really well and that will help
#45
There is a Youtube video out of a chap, who bought a second-hand ECU with matching model number. He then unsolders the ePROM of his "dead" ECU as it contains the security info so your key works again and solders it into the second hand unit and smiles. Merc dealers can read the security info via their Star diagnostic and can reprogram that security info into a NEW unit worth a king's ransom.