Considering going from 4matic to rwd manual
Thread Starter
Super Member
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 816
Likes: 21
2008 W204
Considering going from 4matic to rwd manual
I've got an iridium silver 08 C300 4MATIC loaded (p2, panorama, nav) with 57,000 miles. I'm thinking about trading it for a black on black rwd C300 with a 6 speed with at least nav and P1. The time has come where I am starting college and will probably be buying another car to beat on while my C will be covered in a garage and used on occasion. I wish I thought of this when I bought the car, I just figured it would be my dd until I realized how much wear and tear that is on the car.
I would love to do an even trade with a dealer, or if they are the same year/mileage get some money for my car because mine has auto, awd and all the options, probably more valuable than a 6 speed with less options. Do you think thats crazy?
Does anyone think this would be a stupid move? Should I stick with the auto? To the ones with the 6 speed, how do you like it? I have read it's a bit clunky in comparison to BMWs, but I'm sure I wouldn't mind. I just have a desire to drive a manual now. It's definitely a shame Merc stopped the manual in the facelift w204 instead of improving it.
I would love to do an even trade with a dealer, or if they are the same year/mileage get some money for my car because mine has auto, awd and all the options, probably more valuable than a 6 speed with less options. Do you think thats crazy?
Does anyone think this would be a stupid move? Should I stick with the auto? To the ones with the 6 speed, how do you like it? I have read it's a bit clunky in comparison to BMWs, but I'm sure I wouldn't mind. I just have a desire to drive a manual now. It's definitely a shame Merc stopped the manual in the facelift w204 instead of improving it.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 1,370
Likes: 3
From: Calgary
C63 AMG
I've got an iridium silver 08 C300 4MATIC loaded (p2, panorama, nav) with 57,000 miles. I'm thinking about trading it for a black on black rwd C300 with a 6 speed with at least nav and P1. The time has come where I am starting college and will probably be buying another car to beat on while my C will be covered in a garage and used on occasion. I wish I thought of this when I bought the car, I just figured it would be my dd until I realized how much wear and tear that is on the car.
I would love to do an even trade with a dealer, or if they are the same year/mileage get some money for my car because mine has auto, awd and all the options, probably more valuable than a 6 speed with less options. Do you think thats crazy?
Does anyone think this would be a stupid move? Should I stick with the auto? To the ones with the 6 speed, how do you like it? I have read it's a bit clunky in comparison to BMWs, but I'm sure I wouldn't mind. I just have a desire to drive a manual now. It's definitely a shame Merc stopped the manual in the facelift w204 instead of improving it.
I would love to do an even trade with a dealer, or if they are the same year/mileage get some money for my car because mine has auto, awd and all the options, probably more valuable than a 6 speed with less options. Do you think thats crazy?
Does anyone think this would be a stupid move? Should I stick with the auto? To the ones with the 6 speed, how do you like it? I have read it's a bit clunky in comparison to BMWs, but I'm sure I wouldn't mind. I just have a desire to drive a manual now. It's definitely a shame Merc stopped the manual in the facelift w204 instead of improving it.
is it a coupe or sedan? if its a sedan then forget it.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 5,113
Likes: 57
From: Southwest USA
Another round of ICE
That's quite a puzzling answer! Decades of European sport sedan owners with manual transmissions would be scratching their heads trying to understand.
In any event, to LandSeaAir, your hypothetical equation of trading an automatic for a manual makes sense. If you can find a dealer with such a car, he will probably be motivated to sell the stick. The manual is not as slick as the BMW's (longish throw, not surgically precise), but it works well enough to change the personality of the car quite a bit. I've driven automatic C300 loaners and have to remind myself it's the same basic car as my C300 manual, as the former feels quite more sedate and (sorry) boring than the latter.
If you are doing this for driving engagement, enjoyment, etc., go for it! That is really the only reason for considering the change, but if you find a car, you will enjoy the difference!
In any event, to LandSeaAir, your hypothetical equation of trading an automatic for a manual makes sense. If you can find a dealer with such a car, he will probably be motivated to sell the stick. The manual is not as slick as the BMW's (longish throw, not surgically precise), but it works well enough to change the personality of the car quite a bit. I've driven automatic C300 loaners and have to remind myself it's the same basic car as my C300 manual, as the former feels quite more sedate and (sorry) boring than the latter.
If you are doing this for driving engagement, enjoyment, etc., go for it! That is really the only reason for considering the change, but if you find a car, you will enjoy the difference!
Super Member
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 555
Likes: 0
From: Columbia, SC
W204 2010 C300 Sport/6M
Agree totally. I hate having to have a loaner from the stealership. It's just not the same. Yo have the same fun in the auto I feel like I'm driving st 8/10ths. Good luck in your search.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,714
Likes: 56
From: 1 hours drive north of Sydney Australia
2007 W204 220CDI Classic Sedan
Every young man should drive a manual as it teaches him to become more tuned to the mechanicals of the car & indeed a better driver. Autos in my view are for old farts whose knees & hips are on the way out.
Regards from an Old Fart.
Regards from an Old Fart.
