trade in versus independent sale?
Thread Starter
Super Member
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 728
Likes: 6
From: Chicago, IL
2018 AMG E63s
There is no leveraging a dealer. They used 54k retail and 50k on trade as an example.
That would be truth if you were being drastically over charged on your purchase vehicle. I would assume if your car was worth 54k private party you would be offered 42k, and then after its "reconditioned" you would see it on their lot for $58,999.
You will take a HUGE loss trading in to a dealer.
It seem like some people have they money where if they get $9,000 less then the car is worth they can eat it, but I can not. I have more time then money, so I can show the car to a few people on craigslist. It can be a pain, but most the time people that are going to spend 40-50k on a car are there to buy it. Selling cheap cars is where you run in to problems.
I've work for several car dealerships. I have seen some cases with higher end cars where the dealership will take it on trade and flip it literally the next day at a 40k profit. It is rare, but it gives you an idea of how they work. You will lose thousands and thousands of dollars trading a vehicle in.
That would be truth if you were being drastically over charged on your purchase vehicle. I would assume if your car was worth 54k private party you would be offered 42k, and then after its "reconditioned" you would see it on their lot for $58,999.
You will take a HUGE loss trading in to a dealer.
It seem like some people have they money where if they get $9,000 less then the car is worth they can eat it, but I can not. I have more time then money, so I can show the car to a few people on craigslist. It can be a pain, but most the time people that are going to spend 40-50k on a car are there to buy it. Selling cheap cars is where you run in to problems.
I've work for several car dealerships. I have seen some cases with higher end cars where the dealership will take it on trade and flip it literally the next day at a 40k profit. It is rare, but it gives you an idea of how they work. You will lose thousands and thousands of dollars trading a vehicle in.
Super Member
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 650
Likes: 20
From: Alabama
09 Carrera S, , 03 F250 CC FX4
thanks for the input. I guess what I'm figuring is that if a dealer is getting a trade and also selling a new car they've got two opportunities for margin. To your point they're going to make money somewhere or they ain't doing business, but I wonder if the offset in NY tax, combined with them making a bit on the trade and new vehicles, might not make this a bad deal overall. Versus the hassle and uncertainty that comes with selling the car direct to consumer. After all, if you walk in with $$$ from an outside sale, they're still going to need to make their margin to keep the lights on. So you may end up paying regardless on the new vehicle. Make sense? I guess I'm trying to figure out how best to negotiate this exchange...
Yes folks, dealers make a percentage off helping you with the financing.
You need to talk to a dealer about trade in value on your car. I think you are going to be surprised at how little they offer you.
Also remember that tax is based on the out the door sale. More money you bring to the table the more you save.
Thread Starter
Super Member
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 728
Likes: 6
From: Chicago, IL
2018 AMG E63s
can you tell me a little more about this? What sort of deals are to be had, versus going with MB financing? Are they making money on the interest rates, or on other additional charges? thx again
Super Member
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 650
Likes: 20
From: Alabama
09 Carrera S, , 03 F250 CC FX4
90% of the time I finance a car, I have my own financing secured through my local bank. That way I can make a 'cash' deal and just bring them a check after negotiations.
I always end up with a better interest rate bringing my own financing
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 1,274
Likes: 38
From: Seattle
2008 Mercedes Benz E63
I'd get on craigslist and take a look at similar cars and price it a couple grand less.
You can always go talk to a dealer so you have an idea of trade in value before you waste your time, unless you don't mind taking the hit.
You can always go talk to a dealer so you have an idea of trade in value before you waste your time, unless you don't mind taking the hit.
Member
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 82
Likes: 1
11 C63
There are some cars that aren't worth trading into a dealer because the tax savings isn't going to yield a decent value. List your car locally to find a serious local buyer but you have to deal with tire kickers. When you find someone who is seriously interested discount it to a good price point (higher than trade and lower than retail) and ask the buyer to work with you and the buyer on an in and out. Ask your dealer for their fee to do the paperwork and negotiate that fee. The buyer buys your car through the dealer at a lower than retail price and you still get the tax savings.
It's a little bit more work but worth the extra effort IMO. I'm not a fan of giving the car away on trade.
It's a little bit more work but worth the extra effort IMO. I'm not a fan of giving the car away on trade.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 2,286
Likes: 62
From: eNyCe
Steel Grey Metallic C63!!
There are some cars that aren't worth trading into a dealer because the tax savings isn't going to yield a decent value. List your car locally to find a serious local buyer but you have to deal with tire kickers. When you find someone who is seriously interested discount it to a good price point (higher than trade and lower than retail) and ask the buyer to work with you and the buyer on an in and out. Ask your dealer for their fee to do the paperwork and negotiate that fee. The buyer buys your car through the dealer at a lower than retail price and you still get the tax savings.
It's a little bit more work but worth the extra effort IMO. I'm not a fan of giving the car away on trade.
It's a little bit more work but worth the extra effort IMO. I'm not a fan of giving the car away on trade.
1) Is interested in the OP's vehicle
2) Has the funds to purchase the OP's vehicle
3) The OP has to find a dealership that would be willing to do the In and Out for him.
4) The OP has to factor the cost of doing the In and Out at the dealership because the buyer sure isn't going to pay for that process.
5) Find a buyer that is willing to go through the process of doing an In and Out at the local dealership.
6) Now the price has to be higher than trade in + the tax savings + fees for in and out.
Good luck with finding that perfect buyer. Most likely, the OP will find many tire kickers before that ever happens... The price for the OP's vehicle isn't 20 or 30k. The 50k price point is different from the 10-30k used car market. Most buyers will seek the vehicle that has everything they want or will buy based on price.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 1,274
Likes: 38
From: Seattle
2008 Mercedes Benz E63
Hoops? A person with good credit can call their bank and be approved over the phone without as much as showing pay check stubs. At least with BECU that is how it works, and I don't have any where near my car's value in assets or cash. Even if you owe on the vehicle it is still very easy to sell a car that the bank has the title too. 99 percent of the time they are electronic and transferred with no issue.
Getting a car loan is not very difficult as long as your not trying to buy a 20k car with 50k of the banks money. Its actually as straight forward as a loan procedure could be.
Getting a car loan is not very difficult as long as your not trying to buy a 20k car with 50k of the banks money. Its actually as straight forward as a loan procedure could be.
MB World Stories
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Manual Mercedes? 6 Times Sindelfingen Let Drivers Have All The Fun
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes SLR McLaren 722 S Is Extremely Rare Example Modified by McLaren
Verdad Gallardo
8 Classic Boxy Mercedes Designs That Have Aged Like Fine Wine
Verdad Gallardo
Flawlessly Restored Mercedes 190E Evo II Heads to Auction
Verdad Gallardo
Electric Mercedes C-Class Unveiled: 11 Things You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes EQS Gets A Major Update: Everything You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
5 Underrated Mercedes-Benz Models That Don't Get the Love They Deserve
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes 300D Has Pushed Well Past 1 Million Miles and It Ain't Stopping
Verdad Gallardo
10 Most Reliable Mercedes-Benz Models You Can Buy Used
Verdad Gallardo
Junior Member
Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 66
Likes: 2
2013 Audi RS5
For a car like this you can make close to $10k more on a private sale than you would get on trade if you put together a polished internet ad on the big sites.
I found a way to have the best of all worlds by forming a relationship with a broker. I basically handle the sale and purchase of my cars with other private buyers/sellers, but run the transactions through the broker's dealership so that the sale looks like a trade on the new purchase. My broker charges $600 x 2 for the paperwork, etc, but also handles registration of the new car.
Last time I did this I made $9k more on the sale than a true trade in would have netted, saved close to $10k off what a dealer would have charged on the purchase side, saved $4k in ad valorem sales tax because of the "trade in" effect, all of which cost $1200 paid to the broker. PM me if you want the broker's info. He is awesome and works nationwide and has great relationships with shippers to boot.
I found a way to have the best of all worlds by forming a relationship with a broker. I basically handle the sale and purchase of my cars with other private buyers/sellers, but run the transactions through the broker's dealership so that the sale looks like a trade on the new purchase. My broker charges $600 x 2 for the paperwork, etc, but also handles registration of the new car.
Last time I did this I made $9k more on the sale than a true trade in would have netted, saved close to $10k off what a dealer would have charged on the purchase side, saved $4k in ad valorem sales tax because of the "trade in" effect, all of which cost $1200 paid to the broker. PM me if you want the broker's info. He is awesome and works nationwide and has great relationships with shippers to boot.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 1,185
Likes: 42
'15 T&C & '14 SL63
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 1,142
Likes: 3
2010 C63 P30
the catch is you may have to wait a few days to take possession of the car if the CU cant wire funds and you wait for a check
Thread Starter
Super Member
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 728
Likes: 6
From: Chicago, IL
2018 AMG E63s
They have one in stock? Sweet. I haven't even been there yet... It looks like on their web site that they don't have 1 in stock at all? http://www.mercedesbenzgreenwich.com/amg-vehicles.aspx It's odd. Then if I search for vehicles through MBUSA, it shows 2 vehicles are "available on request". http://www.mbusa.com/mercedes/invent...iorColor-2:040 What's up with that? Is there any way to tell what they actually have in stock besides calling? Does "available on request" mean that it's somewhere within 100 miles or something and they can truck it over or something?
Last edited by jcfay; Oct 20, 2015 at 07:41 PM.
Super Member
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 650
Likes: 20
From: Alabama
09 Carrera S, , 03 F250 CC FX4
For a car like this you can make close to $10k more on a private sale than you would get on trade if you put together a polished internet ad on the big sites.
I found a way to have the best of all worlds by forming a relationship with a broker. I basically handle the sale and purchase of my cars with other private buyers/sellers, but run the transactions through the broker's dealership so that the sale looks like a trade on the new purchase. My broker charges $600 x 2 for the paperwork, etc, but also handles registration of the new car.
Last time I did this I made $9k more on the sale than a true trade in would have netted, saved close to $10k off what a dealer would have charged on the purchase side, saved $4k in ad valorem sales tax because of the "trade in" effect, all of which cost $1200 paid to the broker. PM me if you want the broker's info. He is awesome and works nationwide and has great relationships with shippers to boot.
I found a way to have the best of all worlds by forming a relationship with a broker. I basically handle the sale and purchase of my cars with other private buyers/sellers, but run the transactions through the broker's dealership so that the sale looks like a trade on the new purchase. My broker charges $600 x 2 for the paperwork, etc, but also handles registration of the new car.
Last time I did this I made $9k more on the sale than a true trade in would have netted, saved close to $10k off what a dealer would have charged on the purchase side, saved $4k in ad valorem sales tax because of the "trade in" effect, all of which cost $1200 paid to the broker. PM me if you want the broker's info. He is awesome and works nationwide and has great relationships with shippers to boot.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 1,185
Likes: 42
'15 T&C & '14 SL63
They have one in stock? Sweet. I haven't even been there yet... It looks like on their web site that they don't have 1 in stock at all? http://www.mercedesbenzgreenwich.com/amg-vehicles.aspx It's odd. Then if I search for vehicles through MBUSA, it shows 2 vehicles are "available on request". http://www.mbusa.com/mercedes/invent...iorColor-2:040 What's up with that? Is there any way to tell what they actually have in stock besides calling? Does "available on request" mean that it's somewhere within 100 miles or something and they can truck it over or something?
I usually just use Autotrader to find who has what. According to Autotrader there's a blue one in Greenwich... and a YELLOW one in Rockville Centre with more options.
If I go to the MB of Greenwich site directly, click NEW CARS, it shows one AMG GT. The Blue one.
It appears the MB dealers all use MBUSA software to back their web sites... I say this because they all seem to work exactly the same.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Aug 2013
Posts: 1,365
Likes: 61
2006 E320 CDI 2014 C63 507 Coupe 2012 E550 4M 2016 E63s Wagon
Both of those GTS are beautiful cars. I like the yellow, but can't see paying $9,900 just for that paint color option.
I'm also looking to trade/sell my 14 C63 coupe in on a new AMG wagon. Selling big ticket items is a pain the rear, but trade in offers feel like I'm getting rear-ended.
I'm also looking to trade/sell my 14 C63 coupe in on a new AMG wagon. Selling big ticket items is a pain the rear, but trade in offers feel like I'm getting rear-ended.
Member
Joined: Aug 2015
Posts: 195
Likes: 7
From: Houston
C63 507
Adding to the tax savings issue, really need to watch out in private sales for fraudulent cashier's checks and related car-buy fraud. As a bank lawyer, I've seen a lot of these, and my neighbor got hit a year ago. The cashier's checks look legit. If you do the private sale and take a cashier's check, make sure you contact the issuing bank and try to confirm the authenticity of the instrument before parting with your car. Even that is not fail safe -- don't use the telephone information from the check, contact the issuing bank directly by its local contact info. And DO NOT take a cashier's check issued out of state or foreign.
Former Vendor of MBWorld
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 1,629
Likes: 6
AMG
Doesn't Hurt to try both avenues but in all honesty you will be surprised the number they give you in trade ins which will always be alot less then expected. Once you know that number is you will most likely make your choice based on that. I have also said sell private because you will always collect more than trade in even if you get tax savings. Most dealers will sell you the car and you pay local taxes where the car will be registered. If you know anyone close even consignment can be an option I have cosigned exotics and high end cars before (previous dealership). The amount loss on trade in is not equivalent to the time earned money for convenience.
