My '13 is acting sketchy as hell
02-08-2017, 10:15 AM
#26
MBWorld Fanatic!
02-08-2017, 10:44 AM
#27
There are many stations selling non-Top Tier/"expensive" fuels that are every bit or nearly as beneficial to performance and engine longevity.
02-08-2017, 10:56 AM
#29
MBWorld Fanatic!
In total agreement on all counts. That's my combo, and I also believe it's good to switch between a couple of brands to mix up the additives. I've had some issues with just running Chevron 94 at all times, even tho that's my preferred flavour. Mixing that up has avoided any further issues.
02-08-2017, 04:45 PM
#33
No, no argument necessary. *Top Tier gasoline is best. That does not mean all others are "subpar" or bad. All gasolines start off the same, with different suppliers often getting their fuel from the same source. The difference between brands is in type/quantity of additives/detergents added. Numerous tests have been conducted by respected organizations, validating the benefits of using Top Tier gas and acknowledging that "lesser" fuels won't harm engines or reduce performance. Bottom line Top Tier is best but, not all other gases are junk.
*The Top Tier program, managed by GM, reviews fuel sample tests submitted by companies seeking certification as Top Tier gas distributors. Upon successful screening, submitting companies pay a licensing fee (renewed each year) and then may advertise theirs as Top Tier.
*The Top Tier program, managed by GM, reviews fuel sample tests submitted by companies seeking certification as Top Tier gas distributors. Upon successful screening, submitting companies pay a licensing fee (renewed each year) and then may advertise theirs as Top Tier.
02-08-2017, 04:58 PM
#34
MBWorld Fanatic!
http://www.motortrend.com/news/all-f...l-technologue/
You don't think your ECU will pull timing using epa minimum deposit fuel?
Make up your mind man...
You don't think your ECU will pull timing using epa minimum deposit fuel?
Octane level and engine cleanliness do not go hand in hand. That is the job of the detergent additives.
I didn't say anything about subpar gas. Of course using subpar gas may result in reduced engine performance and longevity. By definition, subpar means inferior.
I didn't say anything about subpar gas. Of course using subpar gas may result in reduced engine performance and longevity. By definition, subpar means inferior.
02-08-2017, 05:42 PM
#35
MBWorld Fanatic!
It was a rhetorical question pointing out the obvious that gas can have an effect on the car.
Never said hand in hand, but it is certainly part of the equation.
Your first post said it wasn't necessary to run good gas in order to achieve "best performance" and to "keep your engine cleanest" and essentially was a blanket statement that any gas will be fine. At least that's how I took it which is why I said something.
Now, I'm not going to hold you down and waterboard you until you fess up and pick a side, but for those who read these threads I just make sure that info stays as clear and accurate as possible. Sometimes I say the same thing, just a different way, so as many people can understand. Perhaps your initial intent wasn't a blanket statement about gas, but your first post basically said "You should use good gas but you don't have to to achieve best performance." That is what I disagree with.
There is no wiggle room for confusion here -- Using bad gas will result in decreased performance and can lead to CEL worthy issues as the OP has experienced.
Luckily, these issues usually go away with a fresh tank of premium fuel.
Not looking to cause a fuss, just ironing out some wrinkles.
Never said hand in hand, but it is certainly part of the equation.
I didn't say anything about subpar gas. Of course using subpar gas may result in reduced engine performance and longevity. By definition, subpar means inferior.
There are many stations selling non-Top Tier/"expensive" fuels that are every bit or nearly as beneficial to performance and engine longevity.
There are many stations selling non-Top Tier/"expensive" fuels that are every bit or nearly as beneficial to performance and engine longevity.
Now, I'm not going to hold you down and waterboard you until you fess up and pick a side, but for those who read these threads I just make sure that info stays as clear and accurate as possible. Sometimes I say the same thing, just a different way, so as many people can understand. Perhaps your initial intent wasn't a blanket statement about gas, but your first post basically said "You should use good gas but you don't have to to achieve best performance." That is what I disagree with.
There is no wiggle room for confusion here -- Using bad gas will result in decreased performance and can lead to CEL worthy issues as the OP has experienced.
Luckily, these issues usually go away with a fresh tank of premium fuel.
Not looking to cause a fuss, just ironing out some wrinkles.
02-08-2017, 06:01 PM
#36
http://www.motortrend.com/news/all-f...l-technologue/
https://youtu.be/bm14Cw1pt24
You don't think your ECU will pull timing using epa minimum deposit fuel?
https://youtu.be/bm14Cw1pt24
You don't think your ECU will pull timing using epa minimum deposit fuel?
Taking two quotes from different statements and parsing them to prove a point only proves a dishonest intent.
Other than Top Tier fuels and subpar fuels aren't synonymous.
02-08-2017, 06:34 PM
#37
https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/article...ctane-gasoline
Now, I'm not going to hold you down and waterboard you until you fess up and pick a side, but for those who read these threads I just make sure that info stays as clear and accurate as possible. Sometimes I say the same thing, just a different way, so as many people can understand. Perhaps your initial intent wasn't a blanket statement about gas, but your first post basically said "You should use good gas but you don't have to to achieve best performance." That is what I disagree with.
02-08-2017, 06:38 PM
#38
MBWorld Fanatic!
Statement 1: "is it necessary to keep your engine it's cleanest and provide the best performance? No, not really." (referring to top tier fuel)
Statement 2: "Of course using subpar gas may result in reduced engine performance"
They contradict each other. One statement says you don't need top tier fuel for the best performance while the other says using non top tier fuel can reduce performance.
My dishonest intent want's to know which one is true?
You better email the American Automobile Association and tell them they're wrong...
http://newsroom.aaa.com/wp-content/u...rt-FINAL-1.pdf
02-08-2017, 06:49 PM
#39
So since they were different statements they don't relate?
Statement 1: "is it necessary to keep your engine it's cleanest and provide the best performance? No, not really." (referring to top tier fuel)
Statement 2: "Of course using subpar gas may result in reduced engine performance"
They contradict each other. One statement says you don't need top tier fuel for the best performance while the other says using non top tier fuel can reduce performance.
My dishonest intent want's to know which one is true?
You better email the American Automobile Association and tell them they're wrong...
http://newsroom.aaa.com/wp-content/u...rt-FINAL-1.pdf
Statement 1: "is it necessary to keep your engine it's cleanest and provide the best performance? No, not really." (referring to top tier fuel)
Statement 2: "Of course using subpar gas may result in reduced engine performance"
They contradict each other. One statement says you don't need top tier fuel for the best performance while the other says using non top tier fuel can reduce performance.
My dishonest intent want's to know which one is true?
You better email the American Automobile Association and tell them they're wrong...
http://newsroom.aaa.com/wp-content/u...rt-FINAL-1.pdf
Your equating non-Top Tier with subpar is your own belief. If you had read and understood what I said, you would have understood that I (clearly) indicated differences between Top Tier, other than Top Tier, and subpar.
02-08-2017, 07:08 PM
#40
MBWorld Fanatic!
Okay, maybe you weren't being dishonest. Maybe you just weren't paying attention.
Your equating non-Top Tier with subpar is your own belief. If you had read and understood what I said, you would have understood that I (clearly) indicated differences between Top Tier, other than Top Tier, and subpar.
Your equating non-Top Tier with subpar is your own belief. If you had read and understood what I said, you would have understood that I (clearly) indicated differences between Top Tier, other than Top Tier, and subpar.
I didn't say anything about subpar gas. Of course using subpar gas may result in reduced engine performance and longevity. By definition, subpar means inferior.
There are many stations selling non-Top Tier/"expensive" fuels that are every bit or nearly as beneficial to performance and engine longevity.
There are many stations selling non-Top Tier/"expensive" fuels that are every bit or nearly as beneficial to performance and engine longevity.
What's an inferior fuel? A fuel that has the absolute minimum requirement? Why is a less expensive non top tier fuel better than this subpar inferior fuel you speak of? It's still the same octane, so it can't be that as you have already explained to us peasants...
02-08-2017, 07:36 PM
#41
What's the different between top tier, non top tier and subpar? All fuel must follow the minimum standard.
How else can the above two quotes be interrupted?
What's an inferior fuel? A fuel that has the absolute minimum requirement? Why is a less expensive non top tier fuel better than this subpar inferior fuel you speak of? It's still the same octane, so it can't be that as you have already explained to us peasants...
How else can the above two quotes be interrupted?
What's an inferior fuel? A fuel that has the absolute minimum requirement? Why is a less expensive non top tier fuel better than this subpar inferior fuel you speak of? It's still the same octane, so it can't be that as you have already explained to us peasants...
To answer your question; Top Tier gas is gas that meets minimum government standards and is then fortified with additional detergents/additives. Other than Top Tier gas is the gas that other suppliers offer that meets minimum government requirements. Subpar gas is the gas you read about that often causes problems in cars because of impurities or other contaminants. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee that a consumer won't get subpar gas even at a Top Tier station.
02-08-2017, 08:14 PM
#42
MBWorld Fanatic!
And that's based on painful personal experience. My prior car was a C55 and I was putting a lot of miles on it every day, always running premium but picking gas stations based on price. None of it was Top Tier. Over time it got noticeably sluggish. I went to the dealer with my slug car and a stopwatch and said 'look - something's wrong'. After much eye-rolling and foot dragging, they finally agreed to look at it and eventually agreed there was a problem. Eventually the regional AMG team got involved. Their final diagnosis, after poking a boroscope into the engines internals, was that there was more sludge in the intake than they had ever seen before - a direct consequence of running fuel without a Top Tier detergent package. The cleaned it up and left me with a healthy car and a firm reprimand about my gas buying habits. And I've been good ever since.
02-08-2017, 08:17 PM
#43
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 8,053
Received 2,827 Likes
on
1,670 Posts
2012 P31 C63 Coupe Trackrat, 2019 GLE63S Coupe Beast
I just throw in a bottle of Boostane and it instantly makes any quality of gas 110 octane.
Duuuuuuh
Duuuuuuh
02-08-2017, 08:28 PM
#44
While it's possible that this statement is true, we don't have any better way to tell 'good' from 'not so good' except for the Top Tier labeling, so I won't use anything that's not TT.
And that's based on painful personal experience. My prior car was a C55 and I was putting a lot of miles on it every day, always running premium but picking gas stations based on price. None of it was Top Tier. Over time it got noticeably sluggish. I went to the dealer with my slug car and a stopwatch and said 'look - something's wrong'. After much eye-rolling and foot dragging, they finally agreed to look at it and eventually agreed there was a problem. Eventually the regional AMG team got involved. Their final diagnosis, after poking a boroscope into the engines internals, was that there was more sludge in the intake than they had ever seen before - a direct consequence of running fuel without a Top Tier detergent package. The cleaned it up and left me with a healthy car and a firm reprimand about my gas buying habits. And I've been good ever since.
And that's based on painful personal experience. My prior car was a C55 and I was putting a lot of miles on it every day, always running premium but picking gas stations based on price. None of it was Top Tier. Over time it got noticeably sluggish. I went to the dealer with my slug car and a stopwatch and said 'look - something's wrong'. After much eye-rolling and foot dragging, they finally agreed to look at it and eventually agreed there was a problem. Eventually the regional AMG team got involved. Their final diagnosis, after poking a boroscope into the engines internals, was that there was more sludge in the intake than they had ever seen before - a direct consequence of running fuel without a Top Tier detergent package. The cleaned it up and left me with a healthy car and a firm reprimand about my gas buying habits. And I've been good ever since.
02-08-2017, 08:41 PM
#45
MBWorld Fanatic!
First off, had you paid attention to what I said in my previous posts and in relation to the ones preceding them, you wouldn't have made a fool of yourself and then felt the need to post snarky comments. Your bad.
To answer your question; Top Tier gas is gas that meets minimum government standards and is then fortified with additional detergents/additives. Other than Top Tier gas is the gas that other suppliers offer that meets minimum government requirements. Subpar gas is the gas you read about that often causes problems in cars because of impurities or other contaminants. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee that a consumer won't get subpar gas even at a Top Tier station.
To answer your question; Top Tier gas is gas that meets minimum government standards and is then fortified with additional detergents/additives. Other than Top Tier gas is the gas that other suppliers offer that meets minimum government requirements. Subpar gas is the gas you read about that often causes problems in cars because of impurities or other contaminants. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee that a consumer won't get subpar gas even at a Top Tier station.
Let me repost the article you probably didn't read or didn't pay attention to. It compares 93 octane top tier vs other non top tier fuels. Or, maybe it's a conspiracy and they were all that magic sub par "you read about" fuels.
Click here for article --> AAA Fuel Quality Research <-- Click here for article
Here's the summary since you probably won't read it. I have and others like it which is why I disagree with you.
Originally Posted by AAA Fuel Quality Research
10 Summary Recommendations
1. If concerned with engine performance, fuel economy and emissions, motorists should select
a gasoline that meets TOP TIER standards.
2. Motorists whose cars have a rough idle, cold starting issues or running problems such as
hesitation during acceleration may be experiencing the side effects of engine carbon
deposits. If these drivers routinely purchase a gasoline that does not meet TOP TIER
standards, switching to a TOP TIER gasoline for several tank fill-ups may help remove the
deposits and potentially resolve the drivability problems.
3. It is possible to purchase TOP TIER gasoline for only pennies more per gallon than non-TOP
TIER gasoline. The practice of driving to a specific TOP TIER gasoline retailer may be less
convenient in some situations, but long-term it will often save money through better fuel
economy and reduced need for repairs.
4. Some consumers may associate gasoline quality with fuel grade (premium vs. regular) or
octane number, which is a mistaken assumption. Motorists should use the fuel grade
recommended by the vehicle manufacturer in the owner’s manual.
1. If concerned with engine performance, fuel economy and emissions, motorists should select
a gasoline that meets TOP TIER standards.
2. Motorists whose cars have a rough idle, cold starting issues or running problems such as
hesitation during acceleration may be experiencing the side effects of engine carbon
deposits. If these drivers routinely purchase a gasoline that does not meet TOP TIER
standards, switching to a TOP TIER gasoline for several tank fill-ups may help remove the
deposits and potentially resolve the drivability problems.
3. It is possible to purchase TOP TIER gasoline for only pennies more per gallon than non-TOP
TIER gasoline. The practice of driving to a specific TOP TIER gasoline retailer may be less
convenient in some situations, but long-term it will often save money through better fuel
economy and reduced need for repairs.
4. Some consumers may associate gasoline quality with fuel grade (premium vs. regular) or
octane number, which is a mistaken assumption. Motorists should use the fuel grade
recommended by the vehicle manufacturer in the owner’s manual.
02-08-2017, 09:11 PM
#46
Your posts are filled with verbal diarrhea and contradictions.
Let me repost the article you probably didn't read or didn't pay attention to. It compares 93 octane top tier vs other non top tier fuels. Or, maybe it's a conspiracy and they were all that magic sub par "you read about" fuels.
Click here for article --> AAA Fuel Quality Research <-- Click here for article
Here's the summary since you probably won't read it. I have and others like it which is why I disagree with you.
Let me repost the article you probably didn't read or didn't pay attention to. It compares 93 octane top tier vs other non top tier fuels. Or, maybe it's a conspiracy and they were all that magic sub par "you read about" fuels.
Click here for article --> AAA Fuel Quality Research <-- Click here for article
Here's the summary since you probably won't read it. I have and others like it which is why I disagree with you.
To help you along, I'll provide the clifs notes version. I have acknowledged that Top Tier gas is best. I have noted that other than Top Tier gas can absolutely provide equal performance and engine cleaning abilities. And lastly, I've said subpar gas can lead to reduced performance and engine longevity.
See any contradictions there? I don't.
02-09-2017, 07:39 AM
#47
MBWorld Fanatic!
You have yet to show anywhere I've contradicted myself. The only thing you've successfully demonstrated is an inability to follow a simple discussion.
To help you along, I'll provide the clifs notes version. I have acknowledged that Top Tier gas is best. I have noted that other than Top Tier gas can absolutely provide equal performance and engine cleaning abilities. And lastly, I've said subpar gas can lead to reduced performance and engine longevity.
See any contradictions there? I don't.
To help you along, I'll provide the clifs notes version. I have acknowledged that Top Tier gas is best. I have noted that other than Top Tier gas can absolutely provide equal performance and engine cleaning abilities. And lastly, I've said subpar gas can lead to reduced performance and engine longevity.
See any contradictions there? I don't.
Did you read that article from AAA yet? It's one of the reasons why I laughed at your first useless post in this thread.
Where are you gathering your information from btw? Any credible sources you care to share? So far you've just been repeating gibberish...
02-09-2017, 09:37 AM
#50
https://youtu.be/IwnwO3mFSYg
https://www.edmunds.com/car-care/is-cheap-gas-bad-for-your-car.html
https://www.cars.com/articles/2009/07/10-tips-gas-stations-dont-want-you-to-know/
These are just a few examples. There are many more, all you have to do is "use the googles".
