Seems a bit high to me, especially with the curb rash. But then again, I believe that these wheels are fairly rare. I considered these same wheels but I couldn't locate a set in a reasonable time (5 months). I liked the fact that they are factory 19s, and the rear wheels are 9.5 inch wide (vs 9 inch for the double spokes). I ended up getting the 18 inch double spoke AMG wheels with Bridgestone 050s (with a little less tread left than the ones you're looking at) and I paid $1500 total including shipping. If you like these, don't hesitate as it may be a while before another set becomes available.