on my third differential
My old car (different manufacturer) blew it's rear end twice. The first was a legit failure, but the second was due to the incompetence of my mechanic, he didn't set the clearance correctly and it failed 6 weeks later. Setting up a rearend takes a lot of skill, so you may want to ask for a 'differential guru'. I don't want to imply that your mechanic isn't good, it's just that rearends are super sensitive, and most mechanics don't have the time to be experts at everything. Good luck.
I thought I had a messed up DIFF a couple weeks ago and ended up finding out that it was a loose bolt. I even called the dealership and they stated that they didn't get many blown diffs.
An even better route would be to get a DIFF off of EBAY and install it yourself. They are extremely easy to bolt on. I would also check the flex plates to make sure that they are still good.
Good luck!!







