Farewell: Making the Jump: MB to Lexus
#176
Super Member
Originally Posted by ricky.agrawal
No, the GX isn't the Sequoia. I was right, the GX is the Landcrusier Prado.
You are correct. It is still quite confusing. Fortunately the GX doesn't ride like the 4Runner. I guess that is why there is a premium over the Toyota conterpart.
John
#177
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: FL410
Posts: 4,968
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
'05 E320 CDI, '08 BMW X5 4.8i, '11 Duramax 2500HD
Originally Posted by PCH_4.2
ouch.... that's a harsh comment.
I guess I shouldn't mention the ES300 that I use as a partial driver... been relatively troublefree except for a recent exhaust (EGR) related bleeder valve problem.
-=PCH=-
I guess I shouldn't mention the ES300 that I use as a partial driver... been relatively troublefree except for a recent exhaust (EGR) related bleeder valve problem.
-=PCH=-
no prob man, to each his own, I'm just not a big fan of Rice, never have been... I just don't like the whole branding philosophy behind the upscale Japanese cars either. I mean these "brands" were just suddenly invented from thin air when the Japanese decided they wanted to copy the Germans/other Europeans and sell "fine cars", but up until then their cars were crappy little econoboxes. I agree, in many ways they've outdone the Germans (reliability, and efficiency being two) but they lack soul and curb appeal (for a lack of a better description), and they're not priced so much less, as to make a case for them being a bargain.
I mean, It's absurd for me when I see the obvious similarities of some Toyota's and Lexus... as well as Honda / Acura's.. but yet I have to call it a "Lexus".. When MB starts to use Chrysler platforms, I'll call those Chryslers too!
Just call it a Toyota... it's like the whole Lincoln/Ford thing... its a FORD! Lincoln hasn't made their own cars since the 1930's!
#178
Originally Posted by JohnAMG
You are correct. It is still quite confusing. Fortunately the GX doesn't ride like the 4Runner. I guess that is why there is a premium over the Toyota conterpart.
John
John
#179
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Queen Creek, AZ
Posts: 309
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by CE750
your quite a bit shy of 369ft/lbs of torque @ 1800RPM..
Lexus is impressive sure.. but not as impressive.
Lexus is impressive sure.. but not as impressive.
That's it? 369 ft/lbs of torque?
My wife drives a truck with over 750 dynoe'd rear wheel ft/lbs of torque! That's a girl truck too.
#180
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: FL410
Posts: 4,968
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
'05 E320 CDI, '08 BMW X5 4.8i, '11 Duramax 2500HD
Originally Posted by PHXATC
That's it? 369 ft/lbs of torque?
My wife drives a truck with over 750 dynoe'd rear wheel ft/lbs of torque! That's a girl truck too.
My wife drives a truck with over 750 dynoe'd rear wheel ft/lbs of torque! That's a girl truck too.
750's rear wheel = about 1000 ft/lbs... that's quite a bit.
#181
Super Member
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Ramsey, NJ
Posts: 575
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
2007 M5, 2004 X3 3.0i
My previous car having been a 98 GS400..I can maybe be a bit more objective.
At the time, the GS400 was the fastest automatic sedan in the world. Have they updated the engine much since? No. HAve they offered a more powerful version? nope. Thats why I bought my E55. Lexus, while now charging 12 grand more for the same exact car up to this year, had not offered more. I had interior squeaks, I had "oh-sh*t" handles popping, but that was about it.
The car, while having 300 hp, handled OK..but not that great. The lexus was mostly trouble free except for the stuff I mentioned above, but have you any idea what I spent on maintenance? Most services were over $800, with the cheapest being around $450. That was with a "trouble-free" car. My E55 services are cheaper than that and are less frequent.
In the end, I wanted a car that had a bit more soul, a bunch more *****. The LS, being 27 years old, would never be an option for me, and in any case, I find the styling very uninspiring. I also find the interior of my E more luxurious than Lexus, which many tout as being better.
If lexus had offered a 500 hp version of the E55, at 10 grand cheaper, I mightve thought about it, but I prob still wouldve gone with the E55. Now if it also had AWD for that price..then maybe we're talking. Overrall, there is nothing wrong with the lex..but when you want that little bit extra something, Lexus isn't the one offering it.
At the time, the GS400 was the fastest automatic sedan in the world. Have they updated the engine much since? No. HAve they offered a more powerful version? nope. Thats why I bought my E55. Lexus, while now charging 12 grand more for the same exact car up to this year, had not offered more. I had interior squeaks, I had "oh-sh*t" handles popping, but that was about it.
The car, while having 300 hp, handled OK..but not that great. The lexus was mostly trouble free except for the stuff I mentioned above, but have you any idea what I spent on maintenance? Most services were over $800, with the cheapest being around $450. That was with a "trouble-free" car. My E55 services are cheaper than that and are less frequent.
In the end, I wanted a car that had a bit more soul, a bunch more *****. The LS, being 27 years old, would never be an option for me, and in any case, I find the styling very uninspiring. I also find the interior of my E more luxurious than Lexus, which many tout as being better.
If lexus had offered a 500 hp version of the E55, at 10 grand cheaper, I mightve thought about it, but I prob still wouldve gone with the E55. Now if it also had AWD for that price..then maybe we're talking. Overrall, there is nothing wrong with the lex..but when you want that little bit extra something, Lexus isn't the one offering it.
#182
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: SoCal OC
Posts: 1,464
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
S, GL, Escalade ESV, my shoes
Same here, my GS300 was the most reliable car I've ever owned (Nissan, Toyota, Lexus, BMW, and Benz). But among the car I've got since got out of college 9 years ago, it's also the most boring car. Needless to say, I gave it to my dad, and he's happy with it. No problem whatsoever.
I don't think anyone question Lexus reliability. Any car/brand could have problem, but generally speaking, Lexus have less problem than German rivals. Lexus maintenence, however, is often more costly than BMW and Mercedes. You still have to change timing belt !!!, These things don't even exist in Benz. And anyone know what happen when the belt broke.
Have anyone read the latest Car & Drivers ? The new IS350, with newly design V6 engine, smoke every car in its class with 0-60 in 5.1 seconds, on the track. However, on lane change acceleration & handling (more like what we're doing every day), it ranks bottom. This probably enough to tell about why people & magazine complain that Lexus lack soul.
The look & feel, both interior and exterior, is subjective & personal preference, so I can't comment here.
Btw, not only the GS not adding anything while price is raising year after year, they took out the steering wheel sequential ship (like F1 shifting on the steering wheel, really cool). Talking about less car for more money.
At least the 2004 E320 that I bought new cost LESS than the new 1995 E320, my first Benz. And that's even before adjust for inflation.
I don't think anyone question Lexus reliability. Any car/brand could have problem, but generally speaking, Lexus have less problem than German rivals. Lexus maintenence, however, is often more costly than BMW and Mercedes. You still have to change timing belt !!!, These things don't even exist in Benz. And anyone know what happen when the belt broke.
Have anyone read the latest Car & Drivers ? The new IS350, with newly design V6 engine, smoke every car in its class with 0-60 in 5.1 seconds, on the track. However, on lane change acceleration & handling (more like what we're doing every day), it ranks bottom. This probably enough to tell about why people & magazine complain that Lexus lack soul.
The look & feel, both interior and exterior, is subjective & personal preference, so I can't comment here.
Btw, not only the GS not adding anything while price is raising year after year, they took out the steering wheel sequential ship (like F1 shifting on the steering wheel, really cool). Talking about less car for more money.
At least the 2004 E320 that I bought new cost LESS than the new 1995 E320, my first Benz. And that's even before adjust for inflation.
Originally Posted by ThemisN
My previous car having been a 98 GS400..I can maybe be a bit more objective.
At the time, the GS400 was the fastest automatic sedan in the world. Have they updated the engine much since? No. HAve they offered a more powerful version? nope. Thats why I bought my E55. Lexus, while now charging 12 grand more for the same exact car up to this year, had not offered more. I had interior squeaks, I had "oh-sh*t" handles popping, but that was about it.
At the time, the GS400 was the fastest automatic sedan in the world. Have they updated the engine much since? No. HAve they offered a more powerful version? nope. Thats why I bought my E55. Lexus, while now charging 12 grand more for the same exact car up to this year, had not offered more. I had interior squeaks, I had "oh-sh*t" handles popping, but that was about it.
#184
Newbie
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Simi Valley
Posts: 23
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2000 CLK 320
although benz electirc quality has plummeted, there is no subsititude in the feeling u get when you riding 80 + on the freeway blowing by lexos smooothlyyyy
#185
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: USA
Posts: 326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Multiple
Originally Posted by 2000 CLK 320
although benz electirc quality has plummeted, there is no subsititude in the feeling u get when you riding 80 + on the freeway blowing by lexos smooothlyyyy
#186
Super Member
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Ramsey, NJ
Posts: 575
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
2007 M5, 2004 X3 3.0i
Originally Posted by rjm
You are so dreaming!
#187
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: San Diego Californ-i-a
Posts: 1,467
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
89 300TE, and 68 280sel
The Benz's will always hold a place in my heart for saftey, hands down over any other car, these things weigh more and it is for a damn good reason, that metal will save your life, unlike those cheap jap cars not matter how smooth or not. My doors still shut like a benz when my car flipped then slid down the highway, I walked away with not a scratch. A lexus feels like a toyota, but more expensive.
Last edited by myfirstbenz; 12-01-2005 at 09:26 PM.
#188
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: CT and FL
Posts: 462
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SL500 E320 ML350
Mercedes are for those who like to DRIVE. Lexus are for those who like to RIDE...RIDE ON...
#189
MBWorld Fanatic!
#190
MBWorld Fanatic!
umm.. i beg to differ. yes MBs are great cars to own but driving dynamics/razor-sharp handling is not their forte. Our family owns many MBs including my 97 E420, 96 E320, 03 E500 Sport, and 2 03 SLK320s. Going at 155 on the autobahn yes, but carving up mountain roads i don't think so. Go drive a BMW with the sport or ///M-tuned suspension and let's talk about driving dynamics.
#191
MBWorld Fanatic!
I think he meant something different under driving. I own Z4 sport, so I think it's quilified to be compared. Benz is a compromise between cushy ride and crazy driving.
#192
Super Member
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: North Bay Area, California
Posts: 669
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
2001 E320
rjm:
"By the way, so far I have ZERO defects or problems with this car."
I can't agree with that: isn't the 'exterior' a defect? I know it's reliable and quick but come on; could the exterior be anymore plain vanilla?
Glad you’re happy with your choice, as anyone who just bought any new car would be. It's not like people spend tens of the thousands of dollars and then admit they made a mistake. (And I’m not saying that you made a mistake, just stating simple human behavior.) In fact, for some reason they usually make numerous posts in other manufacturers forums, telling us how great their new car is. Okay, I'm convinced, but a Lexus just doesn't do it for me, and that's okay, we'll both live...
"By the way, so far I have ZERO defects or problems with this car."
I can't agree with that: isn't the 'exterior' a defect? I know it's reliable and quick but come on; could the exterior be anymore plain vanilla?
Glad you’re happy with your choice, as anyone who just bought any new car would be. It's not like people spend tens of the thousands of dollars and then admit they made a mistake. (And I’m not saying that you made a mistake, just stating simple human behavior.) In fact, for some reason they usually make numerous posts in other manufacturers forums, telling us how great their new car is. Okay, I'm convinced, but a Lexus just doesn't do it for me, and that's okay, we'll both live...
#193
Newbie
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Little Rock, AR
Posts: 3
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2001 E320-Classic Alabaster White
Lexus owners want MB
Man, get ready for not having to go back to the dealership. Get ready for having your car not have problems. Get ready for not worring about something going wrong during a date.
Make sure you check out www.clublexus.com .
I'm vraa over there, drop us a line in the Clubhouse!
Make sure you check out www.clublexus.com .
I'm vraa over there, drop us a line in the Clubhouse!
#194
Check my threads started on this site, you'll see I just had a thread that was criticising the LS460l pretty heavily.
One thing you'll find on this site (especially on this site) is that there are plenty of folks that are brand loyal. They don't see beyond Mercedes. That's not as true on other sites (but it does correlate to how much money you have interestingly, a case example being the LS460 forums on Clublexus).
#195
Super Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: California
Posts: 563
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1998 E320
Honestly, lexus cars are way better than mercedes. Mercedes are by far overated. Lexus cars are like #1 in reliability. You are making no mistake switching to lexus no matter what anyone here thinks. You are making a smart move and a practical move.
The only difference I see between a lexus and a mercedes is that Lexus' all look like toyotas. I can never even tell the difference. I'm more into looks then reliability but as I get older, I'm sure I will make the move to lexus.
The only difference I see between a lexus and a mercedes is that Lexus' all look like toyotas. I can never even tell the difference. I'm more into looks then reliability but as I get older, I'm sure I will make the move to lexus.
#197
Super Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: California
Posts: 563
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1998 E320
Mercedes are not the only cars that have that. They aren't really performance cars either, I still wonder why people try to race them. They may have big engines, and a lot of power. In reality, they are a tank. You don't race tanks.
#198
MBWorld Fanatic!
i just bought a lexus for my daily driver and gotta say a lexus and mercedes are far apart....
the lexus is confortable but then again the benz is moded and not in stock form....so telling the different between the 2 would be harder but nothing wrong with lexus
the lexus is confortable but then again the benz is moded and not in stock form....so telling the different between the 2 would be harder but nothing wrong with lexus
#199
Senior Member
The reason more features came standard on the LS430 is that it's more akin to the S-class than the E-class. Sorry if that thought has already been shared; I'm being lazy in not reading all 4 pages of this thread. Comparing an E to an LS isn't really fair in terms of standard features. I haven't driven the LS yet, so I can't agree or disagree w/ your decision, but my mother has a W211...I think the analog clock adds some class, the seats are not "rock hard" - they are simply firm and better suited for real driving than that of a Lincoln Town Car (couch on wheels, etc.). I also kind of like the center armrest, and how it's split in two...great flow, in my opinion, from the navi screen all the way back to the back of the armrest.
Again, just my opinions, and I haven't been in an LS430. Of course our W210's aren't perfect rides. When my E430 was totaled, I was on the fence between an E320 4matic and an Audi S4. The only reason I didn't go with the S4 is that there are probably going to be kids on the way within a couple of years and i needed a long-term investment with a bigger back seat, not "just" a fun sports car (yet). I kind of wish there were more A6 4.2's or S6's available, but regardless...I also drove an A8 that was incredible, but really loved the E-class and couldn't say no to it in the end.
Also, the E-class W210 came out in 1996. It's likely the LS430 that's currently out there (if you bought or leased new) is the brand new one or wasn't around nearly that long if it's the generation prior...that kind of leapfrogging happens often in the industry (new camry & altima are out now, for example, and when the new accord comes out, people will say the camry looks dated, etc.)
Again, just my opinions, and I haven't been in an LS430. Of course our W210's aren't perfect rides. When my E430 was totaled, I was on the fence between an E320 4matic and an Audi S4. The only reason I didn't go with the S4 is that there are probably going to be kids on the way within a couple of years and i needed a long-term investment with a bigger back seat, not "just" a fun sports car (yet). I kind of wish there were more A6 4.2's or S6's available, but regardless...I also drove an A8 that was incredible, but really loved the E-class and couldn't say no to it in the end.
Also, the E-class W210 came out in 1996. It's likely the LS430 that's currently out there (if you bought or leased new) is the brand new one or wasn't around nearly that long if it's the generation prior...that kind of leapfrogging happens often in the industry (new camry & altima are out now, for example, and when the new accord comes out, people will say the camry looks dated, etc.)
#200
Senior Member
umm.. i beg to differ. yes MBs are great cars to own but driving dynamics/razor-sharp handling is not their forte. Our family owns many MBs including my 97 E420, 96 E320, 03 E500 Sport, and 2 03 SLK320s. Going at 155 on the autobahn yes, but carving up mountain roads i don't think so. Go drive a BMW with the sport or ///M-tuned suspension and let's talk about driving dynamics.
Plus, I'll point out again that we all have to remember this car (w210) came out in 1996...it's a design that's nearly 12 years old.
Last edited by fju2112; 03-14-2007 at 10:09 AM.