Car vibrating when breaking at speeds over 100km
I am neither an engineer nor a sport or motorcycle driver/rider so maybe asking a really silly question but does 4matic have any influence on the situation. My 205 is 4matic.
Also I had the shock of replacing rear pads recently whereas it had always been fronts first so I discovered about the ebd system resulting in heavier rear brake pad wear...is it possible the 4matic system evens braking more than on the rear wheel drive or does the 4matic system make it worse by favouring the rear over the front?
is the solution a change to the programme controlling the brakes or just better quality rotors (discs to me) and if the latter mb should offer all distronic owners the upgrade sooner rather than later. This is a stain on their reputation for me.
- Use more engine braking / drag braking
We know taking your foot of the gas will usually result in the car slowing down so this should be used as an alternative to braking when possible.
- Use both or alternate use of front/rear brake
- Increase tolerance of cruise control speed
If you could instruct the cruise control to maintain a speed within some range, say between 97 to 103 km/h instead of 100 exactly, this would reduce the frequency at which the control system would need to apply acceleration/braking. Over a given period of time, the reduction in braking acceleration would be considerable.
- Reduce speed attainment target time
This is the time you expect the cruise control system to get your car to the target speed. The lower the time, the more aggressive the control system needs to be. Allowing this timing to be more relaxed would also reduce the magnitude of the acceleration/braking.
All the above would need to be programmed together and would likely address some of the vibration issues reported if the issues are due to the overheating discs.
Would MB ever do this?, maybe but the downside of allowing drivers to change these parameters means MB will need to add a extra layer of controls in their control system to ensure all other automation is unaffected and remains safe.
In the case of adaptive cruise control, exposing these parameters up would require significant changes to their algorithms possibly reducing the usability of the feature in order to maintain safety so I'd not expect it to ever be applied here, certain not soon. Upgrading the non-AMG brakes would probably be the easier option for the company.
In my new W213, I tried the basic cruise control briefly (5 mins) and found it quite aggressive but as I prefer to control the speed of the car, I have not used it since.
Nb: Even though I used be be an engineer with some experience designing and programming robots/actuators in closed loop systems, what I wrote above is just a guess what MB might be able to do but given the complexity of all the control systems and their emphasis on safety, my ideas might all be unfeasible but worth sharing nonetheless




You can test this while letting go of the steering wheel, braking and watching the steering wheel vibrate left to right/up down. Mine does it at around 40mph. I will try to film it to prove my dealer wrong.




You can test this while letting go of the steering wheel, braking and watching the steering wheel vibrate left to right/up down. Mine does it at around 40mph. I will try to film it to prove my dealer wrong.
1. Is your car AMG equipped
2. Do you have the P3 self driving option
Robert




last week did ONE trip from Marseille to Barcelona (500km) and immediately the problem came back.
so is it the speed at which i drive/brake… or the trip time…. or maybe a combination of the 2..????
have an appointement for the 8th of November even though no official fix exists,.. will see...
other issues they have to address:
1) radar: screen might light up red but no warning sound goes off (this only happens right after starting the car)
2) command:
- slow as sh*t
- I play music from a usb stick which often freezes at startup. I then must choose another source & go back to the usb for it to work again
- gives messages over and over again saying I need to get an internet subscription for certain features to work (which I have!)
- internet radio crashes sometimes & won't come back on till next start up
dealer said several months ago there' no update for my car, yet it seems there is, so will insist
3) speakers still vibrate/rattle when playing music or during phone calls - (makes a sound the tweeters have ruptured)
4) rear bumper stick out a bit on left & right. - not sure if somebody hit me during parking....
5) a sound is at front left wheel, like something is loose. problem with shock breaker?
6) pao roof squeaking
7) and the warped brakes issue
I love the way the car drives, but all these "small " problems do not make me very happy...
Last edited by Egonvdv; Oct 25, 2018 at 04:07 AM.




i suspect the command issues will be resolved by some sort of reboot. So far mine has worked ok though the navi element is slow to locate place names. The audio 20 in my c clas destroyed 2 usb sticks with odd file formats corrupting them beyond saving though i have read other car manufacturers systems do the same...
The brake issue should surely be a good old mechanical solution but previous research indicated some people with different manufacturers cars were plagued and others not(as i possted further back) But the research indicated it was a material build up on the discs not discs warping. So far i tend to use the limiter and not drive pilot that much in part from your experience but the car at 2100km is fine(🤞
. I also try a bit of heavy braking occasionally. Out of interest do you live close to the med ie could saltwater be a factor?not had trouble with the burmester in my c or e so far and indeed am very impressed. I have some iconic quad esl63 at home which the burmester compares well with. Is the tweeter noise on all sound sources or just some? Wondering if there is some sort of audio distortion arising from the source material. That is a whole different ball game but the clarity on the burmester system is not very forgiving ie its clarity lets you hear more and clipping and compression artefacts are more audible. Other half is a sound expert and is totally happy with the burmester set up considering it an excellent uncoloured system especially given its in a car. Or alternatively the crossovers on the speakers are not properly designed and they have bottomed out on too much bass getting through. We mainly listen to classical not rap or bass heavy music which might protect the system. Be interested in mb response.
wonder if the suspension noise is related to brake judder?
re bumper bet you it was a fellow citoyen. Love them but they are terrible for believing bumpers are just that to be bumped off😂 i am trying to shed my brit reserve (indeed these days i am ashamed to be english sorry eu but remember over 16 million voted to stay in the club!) and be more comfortable with people parking 2inches away or following me at a distance of 5inches from my back bumper😉
you are not being unreasonable in expecting better and in being disappointed and i hope things are resolved. Keep us updated.




they definitely vibrate within the door, and are not ripped. depends on what sort of music i play,
but especially during phone call it gets bad..
yes i live right on the med, but no seawater gets directly on my car.
and i doubt it's the salty air…?
I was on a french board and there they basically laughed at the idea that it might have something to do with the adaptive cruise…
Let's see in 2 weeks...
The Best of Mercedes & AMG




they definitely vibrate within the door, and are not ripped. depends on what sort of music i play,
but especially during phone call it gets bad..
yes i live right on the med, but no seawater gets directly on my car.
and i doubt it's the salty air…?
I was on a french board and there they basically laughed at the idea that it might have something to do with the adaptive cruise…
Let's see in 2 weeks...




last week did ONE trip from Marseille to Barcelona (500km) and immediately the problem came back.
so is it the speed at which i drive/brake… or the trip time…. or maybe a combination of the 2..????
have an appointement for the 8th of November even though no official fix exists,.. will see...
other issues they have to address:
1) radar: screen might light up red but no warning sound goes off (this only happens right after starting the car)
2) command:
- slow as sh*t
- I play music from a usb stick which often freezes at startup. I then must choose another source & go back to the usb for it to work again
- gives messages over and over again saying I need to get an internet subscription for certain features to work (which I have!)
- internet radio crashes sometimes & won't come back on till next start up
dealer said several months ago there' no update for my car, yet it seems there is, so will insist
3) speakers still vibrate/rattle when playing music or during phone calls - (makes a sound the tweeters have ruptured)
4) rear bumper stick out a bit on left & right. - not sure if somebody hit me during parking....
5) a sound is at front left wheel, like something is loose. problem with shock breaker?
6) pao roof squeaking
7) and the warped brakes issue
I love the way the car drives, but all these "small " problems do not make me very happy...
No braking rotor problems on my 2018 non AMG yet but we are trying to keep the mileage down for once and we are at only 8,000 miles or for you about 13,000km.
Aah I have a suggestion for the warped tweeters. Listening to "Let it Bleed" on your recent trip at max volume might be the cause!
Robert
been having a search around the net. Does not seem to be just an mb issue. I wonder if dtv maybe the culprit but is its cause be linked to distronic.....would like an mb view.
interested in the french forum view it is not why do they think that should explain for our north american friends our neighbours use their brakes a lot as they have a penchant for travelling very close to other cars and often very fast😉




been having a search around the net. Does not seem to be just an mb issue. I wonder if dtv maybe the culprit but is its cause be linked to distronic.....would like an mb view.
interested in the french forum view it is not why do they think that should explain for our north american friends our neighbours use their brakes a lot as they have a penchant for travelling very close to other cars and often very fast😉
No not an exclusive issue with MB. I have been with this issue since disc brakes started being installed on USA cars. True that it affects all vehicles but seems to me some vehicles more than others. I concur with the article you found and have noted that last paragraph. When I was actively doing brake refinishing I would always put a non directional finish on the disc followed by a good washing. Yes, I believe the P3 option non AMG MB equipped cars will exhibit this item more frequently. That last paragraph sums the issue but it isn't a big deal to refinish front rotors in my opinion.
My Lexus has 268,000 miles/432,000km and the rotors I have refinished probably 3 times and are still above minimum recommended thickness. Not by much now though.
Robert




as mention before i never had warped discs on ANY of mpy previous MBs (see signature), so intriguing why now on the w213...
car at dealer today (and tomorrow), let's see…...




1) radar: screen might light up red but no warning sound goes off (this only happens right after starting the car)
2) command:
- slow as sh*t
- I play music from a usb stick which often freezes at startup. I then must choose another source & go back to the usb for it to work again
- gives messages over and over again saying I need to get an internet subscription for certain features to work (which I have!)
- internet radio crashes sometimes & won't come back on till next start up
dealer said several months ago there' no update for my car, yet it seems there is, so will insist
3) speakers still vibrate/rattle when playing music or during phone calls - (makes a sound the tweeters have ruptured)
4) rear bumper stick out a bit on left & right. - not sure if somebody hit me during parking....
5) a sound is at front left wheel, like something is loose. problem with shock breaker?
6) pao roof squeaking
7) and the warped brakes issue
(radar, speaker, pano roof)
only the warped discs remains a "mystery". dealer has now sent a "case report" to Mercedes
they have 1 other client with the same issue (also a w213) - to be continued...
The command update however is AMZAZING. it is so much faster now.
And a few things have improved, it's a bit more user friendly.
Out of curiosity, any idea how long it took to do the Comand update? Could I just pop by for it and wait around for a coffee?




Robert




with this latest pair of discs (mounted in april) i only feel vibration when i brake at speeds over 120km, and it's rather subtle
Much better that the previous pair, but .. not perfect...
When going downhill at highway speeds and braking, I get a judder. This did not happen in my previous Mercedes (C-class)
I'm going to take it to the dealer soon to have it inspected. I don't know if I should mention "Topic number LI42.10-P-066910"




When going downhill at highway speeds and braking, I get a judder. This did not happen in my previous Mercedes (C-class)
I'm going to take it to the dealer soon to have it inspected. I don't know if I should mention "Topic number LI42.10-P-066910"
I’ll ask them to resurface the rotor. Hopefully they don’t give me a hard time. I really love this car.



