COMAND vs MBux....thoughts?
BTW I have the Ottocast wireless adapter in the Mercedes which also gives me a full screen experience with Android Auto. I also love having the volume control on the left side instead of on the right side like the newer W213s do.
You have to search the hardware and not software.
Harman/Becker published all that via FCC filings....

but the Bluetooth itself, allowing Bluetooth LE is usually a minimum of Bluetooth 4.0 and above.




I agree with Kasendorf that it is silly not to use the whole screen for car play. It seems like Mercedes is including car play just to placate people without really caring how it works. I find the interface between car play and the regular Mercedes screen to be difficult so if I want to listen to the radio it takes me two or three steps to get there.
I agree with Mickey that touchpad is easy to use and saves you the trouble of reaching.
Hey Mercedes never works for me or it never works right let's put it that way. If I'm going to make a phone call I use Siri if I want to navigate using Waze I also use Siri.
I agree with JS who clearly drives the CLS or did at one point, that MB UX is faster and that is a plus.
I get the impression that Mercedes engineers do things in a vacuum without looking at the competition or reaching out to drivers to ask their opinion. I can't imagine that the improvements that MB UX needs would be that difficult to include if Mercedes cared to do it.




For the most part, I don't really use the Infotainment system much for anything. As said, I'm driving, not playing games or what not. When I did the AMG factory tour in Affalterbach back in 2019 the tour guide had similar words. He said AMG doesn't really emphasis the Infotainment system etc. in their cars, because that's not what their cars are about. That stuff comes over from the regular MB models and just happens to be there. AMGs are about the driving experience, but as said the driving experience in many cars gets water down further and further in this move to so-called software defined cars. Things are bad, because that's not the core competency of car manufacturers. If you want a smartphone then go to Apple etc., but if you want a proper car not even Tesla offers that.
Last edited by superswiss; May 28, 2025 at 04:49 PM.
Every time I drive a new MB I really miss the rotary wheel/knob. I wish they never got rid of it. The slightly older ones also had a trackpad at least that replaced the scroll wheel, I really don't like the idea of touchscreens in cars but I understand that is what people want. Otherwise, manufacturers wouldn't be putting these things in.
One thing for sure, no one wanted capacitive touch, manufacturers still put those in, frustrating. I don't think anyone signed up for piano gloss either?
Had a mini discussion on the touchscreens in cars earlier today, didn't went in length of discussing it.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
For the most part, I don't really use the Infotainment system much for anything. As said, I'm driving, not playing games or what not. When I did the AMG factory tour in Affalterbach back in 2019 the tour guide had similar words. He said AMG doesn't really emphasis the Infotainment system etc. in their cars, because that's not what their cars are about. That stuff comes over from the regular MB models and just happens to be there. AMGs are about the driving experience, but as said the driving experience in many cars gets water down further and further in this move to so-called software defined cars. Things are bad, because that's not the core competency of car manufacturers. If you want a smartphone then go to Apple etc., but if you want a proper car not even Tesla offers that.
I owned a W212 (2014 E350) which got totaled and (stupidly) replaced it with a newer W213 (2021 E350), The W212 was better. The W213 tech often requires me to look away from the road, the voice command system is less usable (gets it wrong often and doesn't support the same words that the touch screen menus use), the miniscule steering wheel swipe pads misfire quite often and the touch buttons usually require multiple button pushes, the console based touch pad often either misses or doubles the swipes and often misses the push-downs and requires 2-3 pushes, the screen based menu trees are far too complex and the important stuff is buried in deep menu choices which I will never use, the NAV system doesn't understand zip codes but requires cities, all of the buttons require a perfectly centered push and don't respond if you press them even a little off center (even though they give haptice feedback.
Last edited by Holtgraver; Jun 2, 2025 at 06:09 PM. Reason: improve clarity
I owned a W212 (2014 E350) which got totaled and (stupidly) replaced it with a newer W213 (2021 E350), The W212 was better. The W213 tech often requires me to look away from the road, the voice command system is less usable (gets it wrong often and doesn't support the same words that the touch screen menus use), the miniscule steering wheel swipe pads misfire quite often and the touch buttons usually require multiple button pushes, the console based touch pad often either misses or doubles the swipes and often misses the push-downs and requires 2-3 pushes, the screen based menu trees are far too complex and the important stuff is buried in deep menu choices which I will never use, the NAV system doesn't understand zip codes but requires cities, all of the buttons require a perfectly centered push and don't respond if you press them even a little off center (even though they give haptice feedback.

) and have a bit more connectivity support.
) and have a bit more connectivity support.Every time I drive a new MB I really miss the rotary wheel/knob. I wish they never got rid of it. The slightly older ones also had a trackpad at least that replaced the scroll wheel, I really don't like the idea of touchscreens in cars but I understand that is what people want. Otherwise, manufacturers wouldn't be putting these things in.
One thing for sure, no one wanted capacitive touch, manufacturers still put those in, frustrating. I don't think anyone signed up for piano gloss either?
Had a mini discussion on the touchscreens in cars earlier today, didn't went in length of discussing it.

The one gripe I had with my 211 (other than the fact that it exploded ...
) was the radio controls that were on the dash. I disliked reaching for them. It was the 2009 interface (that had a dial in the later versions...) but had 5 buttons on the face of the radio instead. I don't get how so few people are complaining about the touchscreens mounted six to ten inches above that in modern cars... that's an absolute dealbreaker for me. It's funny how car brands seem to be doing the exact opposite of what their fan bases want. Anybody who spends more than twenty minutes in a Mazda (except Doug Demuro...) loves the dial interface.
Indeed I think the new CX-5 looks like a carbon copy of the new Lexus ES. All in all I kind of like it though. If only they integrated the screen better.
The one gripe I had with my 211 (other than the fact that it exploded ...
) was the radio controls that were on the dash. I disliked reaching for them. It was the 2009 interface (that had a dial in the later versions...) but had 5 buttons on the face of the radio instead. I don't get how so few people are complaining about the touchscreens mounted six to ten inches above that in modern cars... that's an absolute dealbreaker for me.It's funny how car brands seem to be doing the exact opposite of what their fan bases want. Anybody who spends more than twenty minutes in a Mazda (except Doug Demuro...) loves the dial interface.
Indeed I think the new CX-5 looks like a carbon copy of the new Lexus ES. All in all I kind of like it though. If only they integrated the screen better.
That said,, in the defense of MB and other manufacturers I guess, is that, a vehicle design and planning is like a 10 year job, for example, forgot what brand but they actually responded to an inquiry and said during the day of their new model (new generation) reveal, they already have the design of the facelift ready and is already blueprinting the next generation after this one (of which isn't even sold at all yet).
So that is something to think about, it was probably too late for certain brands that jumped to the screen only, no climate control trend (fad?) because the vehicle was designed a decade ago.



