Winch
I looked into replacing the eye bolt for the front hold-down, so I could put in an anchor shackle. Thus far I'm just using the factory eye bolt. I'm toying with putting in a second one; I could then just put a portable winch on a bridge cable between the two.
But, it seems like the front eye bolt is pretty simple way to do it? Maybe there's no reason to reinvent the wheel?
Eric, just out of curiosity... what's the benefit to having a shackle permanently attached to a bolt, as opposed to just attaching the shackle to the eye bolt?
I'm no off roading expert, but I believe you want the shackle to lend directional freedom to the hook or whatever.
You'll definitely want to allow the winch attach point to be centered or to distribute the force between two points if off centered; that's why I said put it on a bridge cable between the two. To get a second hold-down, you have to drill into the bumper; I was hoping the bumper was made symmetrical, with a second hold-down welded nut on the other side, but pictures of bumpers being sold as salvage showed me there's only one. Bummer.
Trending Topics
With the right welding skills and reinforcing (small triagular gusseting, for example) where the shackle welds to a grade 8 bolt, you could do it. But I think the tow eye is plenty strong? I mean, that's what it's meant for, right? Once you put a shackle into the tow eye, you get that freedom of direction you're referring to. BUT... the same thing is accomplished by the hook when it's attached to the tow eye.
I don't see any reason you couldn't try and figure out a hidden hitch setup. I'm not looking under my vehicle right now, but "assuming" there is enough structure under there, the only downside I can think of is that you would likely be inserting the winch's draw bar (the piece that inserts into the hitch) in a somewhat vertical fashion, which can create a lot of leverage onto the structure the hitch is attached to. Unless the hitch's square opening can be far enough rearward to allow the draw bar (roughly a "U" shape) to be inserted and the "U" wraps around the bumper cover.
Another thought... what if you created a hole for the hitch into the bumper cover where a front license plate would normally be? Then just put a vanity plate over it. Or, if your state require front license plates, you can eithe remove the plate when you go 4-wheelin' or use a flip down plate holder (hinged). If you go that route, what could you attach to... possibly cutting a hole in the "actual" bumper, as well?
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
You'd put it on top of the bumper, right? It could either pinch the cover down or you just cut out a rectangular opening.
Just what capacity were you thinking of for the winch? Reason I ask is the aluminum is probably quite strong, especially if you were to run the winch mounting bolts all the way through. (It's a box section of aluminum, right?) You could also reinforce how the aluminum fastens to the steel bumper. Run long bolts through on either side of where the winch mounts.
What's more, you could simply test it. Hook up the winch to the base of a big tree and let it stall out. If it tears apart the aluminum, well, you were going to replace it anyway.
If you were thinking the hidden winch would be inside where the box aluminum is now, I doubt there's enough room, but I don't know much about winches.
Take off the bumper cover and check out what you've got to work with. It's not that hard to remove.
Extruded aluminum is really tough. You'd be surprised.
Also, you can't just get rid of the aluminum; it is actually functional. I think.
The hook in the tow eye gives freedom, you're right. People use anchor shackles because they're big, so you can hook all kinds of stuff to them, and they drop out of the way when you don't need them.
There appears to be a mounting point right in the center of the bumper... maybe a square hole through the middle of that area would allow the square hitch tubing to mount to something structural behind the bumper?
I have worked with aluminum before, I think it would buckle under the load of the gl.
yes the eyelet does not attach to the aluminum bumper but to more sturdy part of the car.
I am getting a technical drawing of the front, so I can study it and design my new bumper before I tear my car apart. If it shows that there is not enough room for the winch. Then its back to thinking outside the box, or in this case outside the bumper.
There appears to be a mounting point right in the center of the bumper... maybe a square hole through the middle of that area would allow the square hitch tubing to mount to something structural behind the bumper?
The tow eye screws into a nut welded onto the bumper.
"Bumper reinforcement" is a misnomer. The aluminum is there as a crumple zone; it deforms before the steel bumper - which deforms before the unibody. Etc. Aluminum is a curious choice of material. They weren't concerned about weight. Maybe it's not elastic? Hot rolled steel isn't elastic either.
If the aluminum is cast or hot rolled, it could be very soft. If you hang that aluminum by a hook and tap it, you'll hear whether it's annealed. If it rings with a high pitch, it's cold drawn, which effectively tempers it. If you hear a dull thud, it's soft and is useless for mounting a hitch.
I have worked with aluminum before, I think it would buckle under the load of the gl.
yes the eyelet does not attach to the aluminum bumper but to more sturdy part of the car.
I am getting a technical drawing of the front, so I can study it and design my new bumper before I tear my car apart. If it shows that there is not enough room for the winch. Then its back to thinking outside the box, or in this case outside the bumper.
While you have it off, paint the junk underneath body color and sell the cover on Ebay. Your GL will suddenly look like something out of Mad Max.
That size winch - I don't think you'll be able to mount it much of anywhere. There's a possibility you could put it behind the grille, but the hardware to accomplish that makes my bowels clench.
I don't know where you're planning on pulling your truck, but a 6,000 lb winch will pull it straight up the side of a building. If you're just hoping to do minor recovery, then a much smaller winch will do.
I'd start with figuring out what you are working with. A parts diagram is great but nothing beats sitting there and staring at the actual piece.
I'm real curious what you come up with. Keep us posted.
Jake - ah, now I unerstand. You're trying to hide the WINCH, not the hitch. I missed that. Boy, I'm not gonna say it's not possible, but from the times I've been underneath, I'm not sure you're going to accomplish that. BUT, whenever I was underneath, I also didn't have the mindset of looking for a place to mount a winch.
Build a mock-up of the winch out of cardboard. Get underneath the car and see if it's a possibity.
The GL isn't all that heavy - I think it's about 5,500lbs... but Google can help you with that.
The general rule for winch capacity is about 1.5x the vehicle weight. I'm not sure I understand the need for that, but that's what the "experts" recommend... who are also, of course, trying to sell you a product. That said, it can't hurt to go bigger if space will allow. You can always use a pulley/****** block to easily double the winch's pulling power.
GVW of gl is around 6400lbs, this would mean I need a winch that can pull 9600lbs. Or a 10000lbs. But also noted in research that if I am not always loaded down I could size smaller. I am thinking that the smallest I would go is 8000lbs, if the bigger to ones won't fit.
GVW of gl is around 6400lbs, this would mean I need a winch that can pull 9600lbs. Or a 10000lbs. But also noted in research that if I am not always loaded down I could size smaller. I am thinking that the smallest I would go is 8000lbs, if the bigger to ones won't fit.
You'd also get a lot out of having recovery points like I mentioned earlier.
If it were me (and I'm seriously tempted to do this!) I'd put the biggest winch I could comfortably fit on the aluminum, reinforce the aluminum with steel, possibly a plate that spans from the aluminum to the steel bumper, hook it onto a tree, and see if it rips the aluminum apart.
Like I said, a lot depends on whether the aluminum is cold rolled or hot.
Here's a crazy thought, too: If you're really in a pinch, you can double the winch's force by putting a big pulley on the stationary anchor. Run the winch cable through the pulley and then back to your recovery shackle.
Edit: Damn, Dennis beat me to it:
Bottom line is I wouldn't go to all this work for the extreme case. I'd install something for the 80%, not the last 20%. Just my take.
Last edited by eric_in_sd; Jan 27, 2019 at 03:45 PM.
one thing I am a little leery about is trusting the aluminum at all. That is why I am really looking into custom fabricating a piece outof steel to replace the aluminum one.
I agree with Eric - most of the time, if not all the time, you're just gonna need a little extra push to get you out. For those times (which will be rare, if at all) when the winch isn't strong enough, you can figure out other ways to do it. The pulley being an easy one.
Understood about the aluminum. Remember what I said about the "ring test" for the aluminum. When aluminum is cold formed, it becomes extremely tough. The cold forming basically tempers it. Aluminum beverage cans "crinkle" because of this tempering. If you have machined aluminum, there is a decent chance you have worked with annealed stock, which is soft. You and I might be pleasantly surprised.
Dang, now I really want to pull off that bumper cover and start on yet another project my kids will hate me for never finishing.







