GLK250 Blutec vs BMW 328d x-drive Wagon?
07-05-2014, 11:47 PM
#1
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2014
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ford Focus ST
GLK250 Blutec vs BMW 328d x-drive Wagon?
That Bimmer claims 43mpg on the highway...WTF?
In terms of quality car ownership experience, would anyone here consider the 328d against a GLK250?
In terms of quality car ownership experience, would anyone here consider the 328d against a GLK250?
07-06-2014, 03:26 AM
#2
Junior Member
why wtf? look at the shape: one is a car the other is a brick. At highway speeds that is a win.
Considering 328 vs GLK is like considering e class to M class or a dog to a cat or an elephant to a giraffe. Completely two different cars.
In my experience, owning both a bmw and a mercedes is prety much the same. I would speculate that where the BMW was in 2006ish is where MB is right now. After e60 BMW started using completely different materials on the same vehicles. It feels like they ran out of money. Thus, MB, in the same class of vehicles, would be a clear winner for me.
Still e34 is in my heart
Considering 328 vs GLK is like considering e class to M class or a dog to a cat or an elephant to a giraffe. Completely two different cars.
In my experience, owning both a bmw and a mercedes is prety much the same. I would speculate that where the BMW was in 2006ish is where MB is right now. After e60 BMW started using completely different materials on the same vehicles. It feels like they ran out of money. Thus, MB, in the same class of vehicles, would be a clear winner for me.
Still e34 is in my heart
07-06-2014, 10:13 AM
#3
Junior Member
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Red Feather Lakes, CO
Posts: 44
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
2014 GLK 250, 2016 Volvo XC70, 2013 Jeep JK Sport
We have a 2014 GLK 250 BT. My wife was considering the BMW Diesel wagon and test drove one. Her comparison was that the BMW felt under-powered compared to the GLK.
She ended up going with the X3. As far as build quality/finish, I'd give the MB the nod. As far as ownership experience however, BMW has had no issues while the BT, not so much.
She ended up going with the X3. As far as build quality/finish, I'd give the MB the nod. As far as ownership experience however, BMW has had no issues while the BT, not so much.
07-06-2014, 12:23 PM
#4
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2014
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ford Focus ST
We have a 2014 GLK 250 BT. My wife was considering the BMW Diesel wagon and test drove one. Her comparison was that the BMW felt under-powered compared to the GLK.
She ended up going with the X3. As far as build quality/finish, I'd give the MB the nod. As far as ownership experience however, BMW has had no issues while the BT, not so much.
She ended up going with the X3. As far as build quality/finish, I'd give the MB the nod. As far as ownership experience however, BMW has had no issues while the BT, not so much.
07-06-2014, 05:28 PM
#5
Newbie
Join Date: Jun 2013
Posts: 9
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
04 330i ZHP, 13 GLK250 Bluetec
The 328d in US and Canada is in fact, called 320d in Europe as the engine output is exactly the same for these 2 "different models". only. BMW can tell you why the renamed it when they introduced the car here in NA.
I would not be surprised if anyone feels the bimmer underpowered.... On paper the GLK250 at least has 1 more turbo.
I would not be surprised if anyone feels the bimmer underpowered.... On paper the GLK250 at least has 1 more turbo.
06-17-2017, 04:00 PM
#6
Newbie
Join Date: Jul 2016
Posts: 3
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2015 GLK250 BlueTec
GLK250 Owner - 328d Wagon Admirer
These were the two models I considered in my purchase process. Everything I read about the 328d wagon (Car & Driver esp.) was HIGH praise. The mileage is a bit better and it is supposed to handle like a true sport sedan. Surprised to hear everyone saying the 328d X-drive wagon feels underpowered.
That being said, I have never test-driven one. I checked out a 2015 GLK250 (CPO) as my first option...loved the test drive. Wheeled, dealed and got a screamer of a deal.
Now, I have a bit of buyers remorse (don't read into this...self admitted perfectionist here) a year later because it feels a tiny bit "bricky" on the highway sometimes. 99% of the time I am happy with it and it meets all the requirements I had. Great mileage, can drive it in snow...can fit snowboards and surfboards in it and the kids...great all around car. I find it sexy too...as the bold lines harken a bit to the G wagon.
GLK250 is going to average 32-33 mpg. I am currently averaging 31.7 - but my commute is on very congested highway in SoCal.
328d is going to average 33-35. So, a tad better. I had an Audi TDI with same mileage specs (had to give it back in recall) and averaged 34.
But, damn, that 328d wagon is sexy and sporty. Guess I am a wagon nerd. Anyone have one that thinks it is peppy and handles sporty?
That being said, I have never test-driven one. I checked out a 2015 GLK250 (CPO) as my first option...loved the test drive. Wheeled, dealed and got a screamer of a deal.
Now, I have a bit of buyers remorse (don't read into this...self admitted perfectionist here) a year later because it feels a tiny bit "bricky" on the highway sometimes. 99% of the time I am happy with it and it meets all the requirements I had. Great mileage, can drive it in snow...can fit snowboards and surfboards in it and the kids...great all around car. I find it sexy too...as the bold lines harken a bit to the G wagon.
GLK250 is going to average 32-33 mpg. I am currently averaging 31.7 - but my commute is on very congested highway in SoCal.
328d is going to average 33-35. So, a tad better. I had an Audi TDI with same mileage specs (had to give it back in recall) and averaged 34.
But, damn, that 328d wagon is sexy and sporty. Guess I am a wagon nerd. Anyone have one that thinks it is peppy and handles sporty?
