So I need a new passegenr side strut.......options?
#1
Super Member
Thread Starter
So I need a new passegenr side strut.......options?
My mechanic says the strut is indeed bad (leaking air and fluid) and can replace it for $1400. He gave me the option to find the part on my own if I could to lower the price. I was considereding going the rebuilt strut route as I don't think I will have this car much longer.
Any suggestions on where to go for a more affordable part?
Any suggestions on where to go for a more affordable part?
#3
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 420
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
2002 Mercedes S 430(GONE), 2001 E320(GONE), 2007 S550(GONE), 2009 BMW X6(GONE), 2014 S550
Is it just leaking or ur car is sitting low and u have warning message, if u not i dont think u should replace it now, because everytime i go to do diagnostic on my car mechanics say that i have leak but it still drives on normal level and dont get any warning messages.
#5
Super Member
Thread Starter
thanks for the reply guys. It definitely needs replacing. I saw it on the lift and its' tore apart and leaking fluid. I'm going to go with the rebuilt one. I know others wouldn't go that route, but like i said I won't have the car that long and it allowed me to fix other things like replacing the ball joints, tranny flush, catalytic converter and this annoying valve cover leak. Being a procrastanator definitely is not a good thing
Trending Topics
#8
Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Prov RI
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
S500 , 04R6 ,62 Impala
#10
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Clifton, NJ
Posts: 4,949
Likes: 0
Received 37 Likes
on
32 Posts
96 and 08 911 turbos
Is it just leaking or ur car is sitting low and u have warning message, if u not i dont think u should replace it now, because everytime i go to do diagnostic on my car mechanics say that i have leak but it still drives on normal level and dont get any warning messages.
#12
Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: San Jose, California USA
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
S500 Silver, Range Rover HSE Black
Air Strut/Bag
You can also pick one up here:
http://www.rover-renovations.com/
Dennis has a section for MB owners too. His service and support is 10x that of Arnott and he does have "sales" once in awhile. I have used him exclusively for my RR air suspension which I totally replaced with his expertise. He was about to buy at 220 (may have by now) when I asked him to look into struts for our cars.
I have replaced them myself several times and on friends cars. If you have a couple of hours, it is easy sweat equity especially given you are selling and wouldn't wan to sink in more cashola.
Thanks,
Art
http://www.rover-renovations.com/
Dennis has a section for MB owners too. His service and support is 10x that of Arnott and he does have "sales" once in awhile. I have used him exclusively for my RR air suspension which I totally replaced with his expertise. He was about to buy at 220 (may have by now) when I asked him to look into struts for our cars.
I have replaced them myself several times and on friends cars. If you have a couple of hours, it is easy sweat equity especially given you are selling and wouldn't wan to sink in more cashola.
Thanks,
Art
#15
Super Member
Thread Starter
You can also pick one up here:
http://www.rover-renovations.com/
Dennis has a section for MB owners too. His service and support is 10x that of Arnott and he does have "sales" once in awhile. I have used him exclusively for my RR air suspension which I totally replaced with his expertise. He was about to buy at 220 (may have by now) when I asked him to look into struts for our cars.
I have replaced them myself several times and on friends cars. If you have a couple of hours, it is easy sweat equity especially given you are selling and wouldn't wan to sink in more cashola.
Thanks,
Art
http://www.rover-renovations.com/
Dennis has a section for MB owners too. His service and support is 10x that of Arnott and he does have "sales" once in awhile. I have used him exclusively for my RR air suspension which I totally replaced with his expertise. He was about to buy at 220 (may have by now) when I asked him to look into struts for our cars.
I have replaced them myself several times and on friends cars. If you have a couple of hours, it is easy sweat equity especially given you are selling and wouldn't wan to sink in more cashola.
Thanks,
Art
![thumbs](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/thumbsup.gif)
.....and my mechanic is charging 100 for the install. I'm sure it's pretty DIY-able but living in a condo have nowhere to work on my cars. This is my last year living the downtown city life and I'm moving into a house. I really miss working on my own vehicles
#16
Super Member
Thread Starter
#17
Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: San Jose, California USA
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
S500 Silver, Range Rover HSE Black
Arnott
FYI, Dennis is an Arnott dealer which is why it is the same price. They are both Arnott. One gives excellent customer service (for free) and the other is the mfg.
Glad it worked out.
Glad it worked out.
#18
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: North Georgia, USA
Posts: 32
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
S430,300D X2,190E X2,280
I went with Arnott's and I'm very happy.
I was surprised to see that not only are they rebuilt; the basic design of the airbag is totally different. Rather than having the relatively thin bladder more or less contained and protected by a metal shroud; a much beefier airbag is installed without a cover of any kind. At first look; I was a bit put off by the lack of apparent protection. Then, I compared the actual airbags to eachother. No contest. The Arnott/Continental bags seem like they could serve as bullet proof material. The original Bilstein bags could probably be torn with bare hands. This plus the lifetime warranty has me sold.
Because they are so different; I can't recommend just replacing one. At least do both fronts or both rears. Maybe there would be no problem but I wouldn't want to upset the balance of things. The way the rear absorbs bumps with the Arnott shocks is subtlely different.
It is a DIY if you have the tools and time. The fronts are very, very simple compared to the rear shocks. Budget two hours for the front and at least four for the back. Having to get into and out of the car a number of times changing the rears makes it a lot more tedious. A stray spot of grease or dust on your elbow or a wrench will find its place somewhere on the nice, nearly uncleanable surfaces in the back of your car. Cover everything you can back there with sheets or towels. I even took a shower before climbing in and deposited a nice rust spot on the parcel shelf when I pushed the sheet aside with the handle of a wrench. I'll do more than simply wipe down my tools next time.
For videos of the job, go to bilsteinus.com and look for "Downloads." Follow the sequence shown and you can't go wrong. Don't get too excited when you see that nice German mechanic complete the job in less than ten minutes. A decent amount of wrenching and heaving went on between those super clean video clips. It's easy....but not THAT easy.
Best of luck.
Sam
Because they are so different; I can't recommend just replacing one. At least do both fronts or both rears. Maybe there would be no problem but I wouldn't want to upset the balance of things. The way the rear absorbs bumps with the Arnott shocks is subtlely different.
It is a DIY if you have the tools and time. The fronts are very, very simple compared to the rear shocks. Budget two hours for the front and at least four for the back. Having to get into and out of the car a number of times changing the rears makes it a lot more tedious. A stray spot of grease or dust on your elbow or a wrench will find its place somewhere on the nice, nearly uncleanable surfaces in the back of your car. Cover everything you can back there with sheets or towels. I even took a shower before climbing in and deposited a nice rust spot on the parcel shelf when I pushed the sheet aside with the handle of a wrench. I'll do more than simply wipe down my tools next time.
For videos of the job, go to bilsteinus.com and look for "Downloads." Follow the sequence shown and you can't go wrong. Don't get too excited when you see that nice German mechanic complete the job in less than ten minutes. A decent amount of wrenching and heaving went on between those super clean video clips. It's easy....but not THAT easy.
Best of luck.
Sam