A Sad Day
Also I must be doing something wrong, I can't insert in pictures in this trend.... all the accident photos go to my album.
Trending Topics
The Best of Mercedes & AMG



Problem is that getting diminished value claim is like getting water out of a stone. And unfortunately you are looking at 1/3 reduction of value.
Crashing sucks
Right at the welcome to Manassas...I was just there over the weekend.
Theoretically a car can be repaired if the damages are 100% of the value. Most carriers don't do that, but there is no "80%" rule in most states.
The formula for repair vs replace is:
Initial estimate.
Add 10% for likely supplements.
Determine based on labor hours how many shop days the car needs, based on a 4 hour shop day,
Multiply shop days by per day rental car expense.
Total everything up.
Determine Nada dealer retail for the car in clean condition. Deduct for pre existing damage or excessive reconditioning.
Deduct the value of the salvage. If you have a flat rate deal with a national salvage company, apply that percentage and reduce the value of the car to total it accordingly. (This does not affect what you pay the owner for the car, it's just an offset in the claim expense.)
Compare the cost to repair against the cost to total. If the total loss net expense is within 20% of the projected repair cost, the car is considered a constructive total loss.
Sometimes the owner is upside down in the financing, so totaling the car leaves him without as much in funds to replace it, and their preference is a repair. As long as the repair cost does not exceed the cost to total, you can do a contract repair for the initial estimate ( no supplement contingency and a flat amount of rental or loss of use compensation). Both the owner and the shop have to contractually agree to the repair amount, and if they go over its not the carriers problem.
For the OP, the 3rd party diminution of value claim depends on the state in which he lives. Some don't allow for it.
The one great thing that I did have when I purchased the car was value. I purchased for under the value price and felt I was ahead of the game. I also planned to keep the car for at least 5 plus years. It only has 33K for 2011....
The one great thing that I did have when I purchased the car was value. I purchased for under the value price and felt I was ahead of the game. I also planned to keep the car for at least 5 plus years. It only has 33K for 2011....
My car is still in the shop for some mechanical work and this makes a total of 60 days without it. Bill is at about $20k to date on mine and at fault woman's insurance is paying. Body work looks good so far, but have some remaining mechanical issues, even though dealer gave OK after supposedly doing "complete scan and check over". Back it went and I am still waiting.
Got a trade in quote from dealer while I was there and they said due to accident, it is now worth only about 65% of normal NADA dealer trade in.
I purchased 2 additional CPO years on this car, so I would be taking about a $16K hit for 6 weeks of ownership if I dumped it now. I started a Inherent Diminished Value claim with her insurance company yesterday. I cannot afford to not fight for reasonable DV compensation.
I was in outside sales for years and have decided to treat the DV recovery process like trying to secure a new $16k contract from a difficult account. I will fight till the end and hope for the best. I have been stressed to illness over this and taking that approach makes me feel a bit better about moving on from my loss regardless what happens.
I wish you luck in the rebuild and feel free to contact me if you would like any details on my repair. I got hit in right rear and had bumper, quarter panel, muffler replaced. They had to take out rear glass to replace quarter panel. Muffler was on back order from MB and I had to call MB corporate because dealer said no available mufflers in the world and they were months out on backorder. WTF! I called MB and one showed up at shop next day. Some shops I initially contacted for the body work were not set up to work with the aluminum beneath rear bumper.
As I stated, body now looks good. Remaining issues are loss of radio reception, I think when glass was removed, trunk would not work (now fixed) and rear headrests are stuck in up position and will not retract. My keyless entry seems messed up too, as it is not as sensitive as before. Not sure if that may tie into antenna reception problems as well.
Hope it goes well!
Last edited by Dog Lover; Dec 23, 2015 at 06:16 PM.
My car is still in the shop for some mechanical work and this makes a total of 60 days without it. Bill is at about $20k to date on mine and at fault woman's insurance is paying. Body work looks good so far, but have some remaining mechanical issues, even though dealer gave OK after supposedly doing "complete scan and check over". Back it went and I am still waiting.
Got a trade in quote from dealer while I was there and they said due to accident, it is now worth only about 65% of normal NADA dealer trade in.
I purchased 2 additional CPO years on this car, so I would be taking about a $16K hit for 6 weeks of ownership if I dumped it now. I started a Inherent Diminished Value claim with her insurance company yesterday. I cannot afford to not fight for reasonable DV compensation.
I was in outside sales for years and have decided to treat the DV recovery process like trying to secure a new $16k contract from a difficult account. I will fight till the end and hope for the best. I have been stressed to illness over this and taking that approach makes me feel a bit better about moving on from my loss regardless what happens.
I wish you luck in the rebuild and feel free to contact me if you would like any details on my repair. I got hit in right rear and had bumper, quarter panel, muffler replaced. They had to take out rear glass to replace quarter panel. Muffler was on back order from MB and I had to call MB corporate because dealer said no available mufflers in the world and they were months out on backorder. WTF! I called MB and one showed up at shop next day. Some shops I initially contacted for the body work were not set up to work with the aluminum beneath rear bumper.
As I stated, body now looks good. Remaining issues are loss of radio reception, I think when glass was removed, trunk would not work (now fixed) and rear headrests are stuck in up position and will not retract. My keyless entry seems messed up too, as it is not as sensitive as before. Not sure if that may tie into antenna reception problems as well.
Hope it goes well!
Theoretically a car can be repaired if the damages are 100% of the value. Most carriers don't do that, but there is no "80%" rule in most states.
The formula for repair vs replace is:
Initial estimate.
Add 10% for likely supplements.
Determine based on labor hours how many shop days the car needs, based on a 4 hour shop day,
Multiply shop days by per day rental car expense.
Total everything up.
Determine Nada dealer retail for the car in clean condition. Deduct for pre existing damage or excessive reconditioning.
Deduct the value of the salvage. If you have a flat rate deal with a national salvage company, apply that percentage and reduce the value of the car to total it accordingly. (This does not affect what you pay the owner for the car, it's just an offset in the claim expense.)
Compare the cost to repair against the cost to total. If the total loss net expense is within 20% of the projected repair cost, the car is considered a constructive total loss.
Sometimes the owner is upside down in the financing, so totaling the car leaves him without as much in funds to replace it, and their preference is a repair. As long as the repair cost does not exceed the cost to total, you can do a contract repair for the initial estimate ( no supplement contingency and a flat amount of rental or loss of use compensation). Both the owner and the shop have to contractually agree to the repair amount, and if they go over its not the carriers problem.
For the OP, the 3rd party diminution of value claim depends on the state in which he lives. Some don't allow for it.
I have a question, it there a way to make a claim against the person who hit my car for the inconvenience of me being out the car and I'm still making payments?





