2016 S550 suspension feel
#26
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,111
Received 3,319 Likes
on
2,055 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
I can't reconcile how you compare 20" rims with conventional tires with 19"s and RFTs to then say 20's don't ride harsher than 19's. You changed 2 variables. It's apples and oranges.
RFTs generally are stiffer, especially those made a few years ago. Most people don't have a choice though if they still want peace of mind without having to drop a damn tire in the trunk full time. If you lived in NY/NE you may feel different after going through 5+ rims/tires a year. There's a reason people don't often get 20's in these parts...
RFTs generally are stiffer, especially those made a few years ago. Most people don't have a choice though if they still want peace of mind without having to drop a damn tire in the trunk full time. If you lived in NY/NE you may feel different after going through 5+ rims/tires a year. There's a reason people don't often get 20's in these parts...
Not sure why you can't reconcile that. This whole conversation started with my comment early in the thread: "Some people have an affinity for 18” or 19” wheels but 20” work and look great as long as you have good tires" and devolved from there...
I also discussed tire options from the get-go to go to conventional tires for the OP. As for blown tires, our MN streets are pretty crappy as well. Our first blown Pirelli RFT on the W222 happened during the first 2 weeks. Zero afterwards on conventional tires.
#27
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,111
Received 3,319 Likes
on
2,055 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
I think my AMG 19s are good looking, not as good looking as the 20s.
And a 19" S Class on non RFTs will ride less harshly than a 20" S Class on non RFTs. Whats your point? The same variable and impact of wheel sizes exists.
I feel very confident speaking for most people here. "Harsher" = worse.
Zero logic lol
And a 19" S Class on non RFTs will ride less harshly than a 20" S Class on non RFTs. Whats your point? The same variable and impact of wheel sizes exists.
I feel very confident speaking for most people here. "Harsher" = worse.
Zero logic lol
As for a 19" RFT tire riding better than a 20" conventional is obviously a joke unless you can share your wealth of experience on that subject...
#28
MBWorld Fanatic!
Where did I say a 19" RFT rides better than a 20" with conventional tires? I said 19s with conventional tires ride better than 20s with conventional tires, and they do.
#29
MBWorld Fanatic!
Not sure why you can't reconcile that. This whole conversation started with my comment early in the thread: "Some people have an affinity for 18” or 19” wheels but 20” work and look great as long as you have good tires" and devolved from there...
I also discussed tire options from the get-go to go to conventional tires for the OP. As for blown tires, our MN streets are pretty crappy as well. Our first blown Pirelli RFT on the W222 happened during the first 2 weeks. Zero afterwards on conventional tires.
I also discussed tire options from the get-go to go to conventional tires for the OP. As for blown tires, our MN streets are pretty crappy as well. Our first blown Pirelli RFT on the W222 happened during the first 2 weeks. Zero afterwards on conventional tires.
Its the same as people being satisfied with the ride of run flats. Most people are, that doesnt mean that conventional tires dont ride better.
Last edited by SW20S; 02-01-2022 at 06:31 PM.
#31
MBWorld Fanatic!
I actually run mine at 32 non run flats, the ride difference is huge.
#33
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,111
Received 3,319 Likes
on
2,055 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
You are correct. I actually misread your comment as the opposite...
#34
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,111
Received 3,319 Likes
on
2,055 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
What devolved the thread is when you told me that my comment about 20s riding worse wasn't accurate. It is accurate. You may be completely happy with the ride quality on 20s, but that doesn't mean that they don't transmit more road imperfections to the cabin, they absolutely do, and most people consider that a reduction in ride quality. Telling people there is no reduction in ride quality isn't giving accurate information.
Its the same as people being satisfied with the ride of run flats. Most people are, that doesnt mean that conventional tires dont ride better.
Its the same as people being satisfied with the ride of run flats. Most people are, that doesnt mean that conventional tires dont ride better.
Conventional tires over RFT's have a bigger impact on ride quality than wheel size. It does come with a risk factor in case of a flat tire one maybe stranded. To offset that, tire fix kits or a spare in the trunk maybe needed. Opposite, run flats only work with minor tire damage and one can be stranded as well.
Last but not least, I reiterate my prior statement (now with more details). To me, the ride quality on 20" is not worse than with 19" (both non-RFT) because firmer does not equal worse. It is a similar conversation that others have driving in comfort, curve or sport(+) mode. We all have our preferences.
#35
MBWorld Fanatic!
Like I said before, if you can find me a review that says people prefer harder, sharper crashes through the cabin over expansion joints and road imperfections, then I will reevaluate my comment that the ride is "worse" on larger wheels. Until then, I am 100% comfortable calling it worse.
The difference as I said is not positive. If you drive a sporty sedan, that firmness can be positive, but in this car its still a big soft car, just with wheels that make impacts sharper and harsher, more jolting with no improvement in handling or driving feel. The big wheels are not well suited to the car's suspension. I can provide many professional reviews that say the same thing.
I am also 100% confident in saying that most drivers of this specific type of car prefer a softer ride vs a harder ride. There are many reasons to believe that...for one every carmaker in the segment has made their cars softer, not firmer. Lexus tried to make the LS firmer, and their sales collapsed and they turned right around and made it softer at the mid cycle refresh. If you want a firm riding sporty car, you should buy a different kind of car than this.
The decision to go to 20s is all about looks. But, people should understand the car does not ride as well on 20s as it does on 19s or 18s, but it does look better.
The difference as I said is not positive. If you drive a sporty sedan, that firmness can be positive, but in this car its still a big soft car, just with wheels that make impacts sharper and harsher, more jolting with no improvement in handling or driving feel. The big wheels are not well suited to the car's suspension. I can provide many professional reviews that say the same thing.
I am also 100% confident in saying that most drivers of this specific type of car prefer a softer ride vs a harder ride. There are many reasons to believe that...for one every carmaker in the segment has made their cars softer, not firmer. Lexus tried to make the LS firmer, and their sales collapsed and they turned right around and made it softer at the mid cycle refresh. If you want a firm riding sporty car, you should buy a different kind of car than this.
The decision to go to 20s is all about looks. But, people should understand the car does not ride as well on 20s as it does on 19s or 18s, but it does look better.
#36
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,111
Received 3,319 Likes
on
2,055 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
Like I said before, if you can find me a review that says people prefer harder, sharper crashes through the cabin over expansion joints and road imperfections, then I will reevaluate my comment that the ride is "worse" on larger wheels. Until then, I am 100% comfortable calling it worse.
The difference as I said is not positive. If you drive a sporty sedan, that firmness can be positive, but in this car its still a big soft car, just with wheels that make impacts sharper and harsher, more jolting with no improvement in handling or driving feel. The big wheels are not well suited to the car's suspension. I can provide many professional reviews that say the same thing.
I am also 100% confident in saying that most drivers of this specific type of car prefer a softer ride vs a harder ride. There are many reasons to believe that...for one every carmaker in the segment has made their cars softer, not firmer. Lexus tried to make the LS firmer, and their sales collapsed and they turned right around and made it softer at the mid cycle refresh. If you want a firm riding sporty car, you should buy a different kind of car than this.
The decision to go to 20s is all about looks. But, people should understand the car does not ride as well on 20s as it does on 19s or 18s, but it does look better.
The difference as I said is not positive. If you drive a sporty sedan, that firmness can be positive, but in this car its still a big soft car, just with wheels that make impacts sharper and harsher, more jolting with no improvement in handling or driving feel. The big wheels are not well suited to the car's suspension. I can provide many professional reviews that say the same thing.
I am also 100% confident in saying that most drivers of this specific type of car prefer a softer ride vs a harder ride. There are many reasons to believe that...for one every carmaker in the segment has made their cars softer, not firmer. Lexus tried to make the LS firmer, and their sales collapsed and they turned right around and made it softer at the mid cycle refresh. If you want a firm riding sporty car, you should buy a different kind of car than this.
The decision to go to 20s is all about looks. But, people should understand the car does not ride as well on 20s as it does on 19s or 18s, but it does look better.
Just more verbiage to justify your preference.
You must feel bad for the tens of thousands of S-class owners that have 20” wheels. After all, I expect over 30% of all W222’s in the US have that option…
#37
The tires are 20" Goodyear Eagle F1 run flats
Front 245/40R 20
Rear 275 35ZR 20
The fronts have a lot of tread but I did find that the rears are just above the tread wear indicators. I'm sorry to hear the 20" wheels are an issue because they are beautiful!
I bought the car 3,000 miles ago so I don't know how the ride compares with new or even with new tires. Now 38,000 miles.
Does the fact that there is an air suspension test indicate that there can be issues that don't trip a warning light or alter the ride height appearance?
Front 245/40R 20
Rear 275 35ZR 20
The fronts have a lot of tread but I did find that the rears are just above the tread wear indicators. I'm sorry to hear the 20" wheels are an issue because they are beautiful!
I bought the car 3,000 miles ago so I don't know how the ride compares with new or even with new tires. Now 38,000 miles.
Does the fact that there is an air suspension test indicate that there can be issues that don't trip a warning light or alter the ride height appearance?
b) run flat tires have very stiff sidewalls
a+b = non-compliant ride
c) I keep my tires at 39 PSI F+R so as to trade off a bit of comfort while gaining feel at the steering wheel--this also improves tire life.
d) as to the problem with AirMatic--unlikely
and finally:
e) M P4s have a lot more traction than the suspension was designed to handle, so while the car will respond faster and grip more, the car will lean more in the turns--thus taking longer to go from steering input to car taking a "set" in the turn; probably not something you will like long term.
#38
MBWorld Fanatic!
I don't feel bad for people who have 20s at all, unless they are unhappy with their choice because they didn't realize the negative impact on the ride before they bought. And we see many of those posts and threads. The difference is not that dramatic, but it is a real difference and its there and people should understand that before they decide. Thats all.
If someone came on here and said "RFTs don't ride worse, they just ride different" you would argue with them, and they would be wrong..
Last edited by SW20S; 02-02-2022 at 08:39 PM.
#39
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,111
Received 3,319 Likes
on
2,055 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
I'm not justifying my preference at all, I'm just trying to give people accurate information when they are deciding what size wheels they want on their S Class. The bottom line is, 20s ride harsher than 19s which ride harsher than 18s. Thats a fact, "harsh" is a negative descriptor. My car has 19s, and I chose it over a car with 18s that would have ridden better because I wanted the AMG package. So...I too chose style over ride comfort, but I'm not pretending my car on 19s rides better than one on 18s, or that somehow I prefer a harsher ride...
I don't feel bad for people who have 20s at all, unless they are unhappy with their choice because they didn't realize the negative impact on the ride before they bought. And we see many of those posts and threads. The difference is not that dramatic, but it is a real difference and its there and people should understand that before they decide. Thats all.
If someone came on here and said "RFTs don't ride worse, they just ride different" you would argue with them, and they would be wrong..
I don't feel bad for people who have 20s at all, unless they are unhappy with their choice because they didn't realize the negative impact on the ride before they bought. And we see many of those posts and threads. The difference is not that dramatic, but it is a real difference and its there and people should understand that before they decide. Thats all.
If someone came on here and said "RFTs don't ride worse, they just ride different" you would argue with them, and they would be wrong..
This thread was to provide the OP with feedback on his suspension feel and this thread has been sufficiently derailed with this back and forth.
Sorry that my responses contributed to that and appreciate Mitch for taking it back on topic.
Further off topic posts will be deleted. Thanks
#40
Junior Member
Just out of interest have you had all the suspension components checked. I have been advised that these cars are susceptible to wear in the upper arms of the front suspension causing deterioration in ride. If that’s all ok how are your alignment settings ? Might not just be the tyres .
#41
MBWorld Fanatic!
I am wondering the same thing, have heard the weight of the car wears out suspension bushings and ball joints, and there are a lot of them in an S-class ... three arms each side in front and what, five in the back?
The following users liked this post:
Wolfman (02-09-2022)
#42
Junior Member
I believe it’s the front in particular , I only know this as the Mercedes Specialist I’m bringing mine too next week said that’s one of the first things he checks. Will find out exactly but he said it was a complete arm that wears usually around 40k miles , some before that. Any wear on these would likely be the cause of the Ops symptoms . Even with an alignment the car still wouldn’t ride correctly.
Last edited by Googsy; 02-03-2022 at 06:02 PM.
#43
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2016
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
2016 Mercedes AMG GTs 2015 Corvette Z06 2022 Lamborghini Huracan STO
There is a happy ending to this story thanks to all the great advice here. I now have Michelin Pilot Sport AS4 (all season) non-run flats and the car rides beautifully. I don't know the difference vs the PS4s someone recommended here but this is what my tire guy recommended.
I am a little concerned hearing that suspension bushing wear can start causing issues by 40,000 miles which is where I am. If so, that is pathetic! You just don't hear of things wearing out so quickly on any brand of car. Being gradual, I'm sure it is something most people never notice.
I am a little concerned hearing that suspension bushing wear can start causing issues by 40,000 miles which is where I am. If so, that is pathetic! You just don't hear of things wearing out so quickly on any brand of car. Being gradual, I'm sure it is something most people never notice.
#44
MBWorld Fanatic!
Woo hoo! Thats great news.
This is a really complex car, with a very sophisticated suspension that emphasises performance over longevity. You WILL have things to repair sooner than you would on something with say, a cheap macpherson strut suspension but that wouldn't drive or ride so well. Just be prepared for that, you gotta pay to play. Even Lexus LS sedans with a similar suspension with all their legendary reliability have the same potential issues at similar age.
This is a really complex car, with a very sophisticated suspension that emphasises performance over longevity. You WILL have things to repair sooner than you would on something with say, a cheap macpherson strut suspension but that wouldn't drive or ride so well. Just be prepared for that, you gotta pay to play. Even Lexus LS sedans with a similar suspension with all their legendary reliability have the same potential issues at similar age.
#46
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2014
Location: Land of Political Criminals and Urban Shootings
Posts: 4,034
Received 482 Likes
on
368 Posts
2015 S550
I love my 20" wheels and the ride and quietness I get with my General G-Max AS05 tires, which are every bit as good as the Michelin Pilot Sport AS4's, but quieter and significantly less expensive. The ride quality after switching out of the GY RFT's was like night and day. These tires ride every bit as smooth and actually suck up road imperfections a little better than my Nokian WRG4's that I run in the winters on my 19" wheels.
FWIW, it really doesn't make any sense to waste trunk space with a spare tire when swapping out to regular tires. A can of goo and air pump easily takes care of a flat where the tire isn't completely blown out. This is what MB offers on the S-class AMG models, but you don't need to buck up for the MB brand when you can get a better and less expensive alternative through Slime.
FWIW, it really doesn't make any sense to waste trunk space with a spare tire when swapping out to regular tires. A can of goo and air pump easily takes care of a flat where the tire isn't completely blown out. This is what MB offers on the S-class AMG models, but you don't need to buck up for the MB brand when you can get a better and less expensive alternative through Slime.
#47
MBWorld Fanatic!
FWIW, it really doesn't make any sense to waste trunk space with a spare tire when swapping out to regular tires. A can of goo and air pump easily takes care of a flat where the tire isn't completely blown out. This is what MB offers on the S-class AMG models, but you don't need to buck up for the MB brand when you can get a better and less expensive alternative through Slime.
That is the exact kit the AMGs and many other German cars come with (though unbranded). Pretty reasonable and you can buy refills if needed.
#48
MBWorld Fanatic!
https://www.griotsgarage.com/12v-tir...hoCr4gQAvD_BwE
That is the exact kit the AMGs and many other German cars come with (though unbranded). Pretty reasonable and you can buy refills if needed.
That is the exact kit the AMGs and many other German cars come with (though unbranded). Pretty reasonable and you can buy refills if needed.
#50
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2019
Location: Palm Beach, Fl
Posts: 495
Received 194 Likes
on
136 Posts
2016 S550 sport, 2018 GLC300, M3, Zo7, 2021 Sierra Denali
There is a happy ending to this story thanks to all the great advice here. I now have Michelin Pilot Sport AS4 (all season) non-run flats and the car rides beautifully. I don't know the difference vs the PS4s someone recommended here but this is what my tire guy recommended.
I am a little concerned hearing that suspension bushing wear can start causing issues by 40,000 miles which is where I am. If so, that is pathetic! You just don't hear of things wearing out so quickly on any brand of car. Being gradual, I'm sure it is something most people never notice.
I am a little concerned hearing that suspension bushing wear can start causing issues by 40,000 miles which is where I am. If so, that is pathetic! You just don't hear of things wearing out so quickly on any brand of car. Being gradual, I'm sure it is something most people never notice.
Last edited by seamus2154; 02-11-2022 at 08:55 PM.
The following users liked this post:
BIGBEAR_1 (02-11-2022)