W222 vs W223: And the winner is........




I managed to string out the buy back, until I could get a 2022 S580, thinking & hoping that most of the bugs would have been exorcised from the 223’s by then, but my loaded S580 has been an absolute nightmare since I took delivery. Look at “My S580 STRANDED ME” thread for details. If you don’t happen to know, they are now buying my S580 back, which thrills me to no end.
As for what car next, right now, I am really leaning towards the Genesis G90. When the 2025 W223 receives the face lift, I will consider going back to MB. Or, if MB comes along with some substantial incentive dollars this time around, I may chance another one.
At this point, I'm going to consider and test drive some SUV's. If my ride has to suffer, why not go with an SUV? in particular, the X5 M60i and the Cayenne. I like the Range Rover but the quality reviews are consistently not good. BMW and Porsche seem to score highest with the Cayenne being more of a drivers' car. But, I'm not crazy about the looks.
The door handles are really troublesome. My wife and I went out for dinner the other night…our car was parked on a fairly dark street. No imminent threat but a little uncomfortable. I unlocked the car with the key fob from about 20 yards, in anticipation of the door handles not working properly. We get to the car and the door handles jam. My wife keeps pulling (she got to the car first, a few feet ahead of me,the handles retreat. I had to pull the keys out and reopen. We get into the car she reaches for the door which has now extended fully out. Hurts her back because the door openings are so bad. She has to step out of the car pull the door back in then sit down.
I lock the doors from the inside, she says “what the f**k is going, what a stupid car. What if we needed to get in quickly?”
Otherwise, I’m pretty happy with the S580. But the way these door handles are designed and the door openings are driving me to distraction!
I’m considering the new Cayenne and some of the super suvs, Urus, AM, Bentayga. My knees aren’t what they used and something high up, with better ingress/egress visibility is what I’m looking for. Comfort is the number one priority and a little sportiness, and maybe a hybrid this time. Would love peoples opinions on these suvs??
Glad you were safe though.
no offense at all, I respect your opinion just that I think ss for running over a curb, I mean I don't know about you but what about not running over a curb?
I will add a supporting argument to why SUV might be better for the sake of this discussion... People also said oh you go over a pothole and don't have to worry after damage or hitting the underbody but then from what I seen, cities have less incentives to fix these roads, which sticks for us sedan drivers.
last but not least not like this matters thaaat much but SUVs wear tires quicker, gets worse fuel economy and possibly aerodynamics.
Ride comfort wise, GLS doesn't ride as nice as an S-Class, I guess it is physics after all.
At this point, I'm going to consider and test drive some SUV's. If my ride has to suffer, why not go with an SUV? in particular, the X5 M60i and the Cayenne. I like the Range Rover but the quality reviews are consistently not good. BMW and Porsche seem to score highest with the Cayenne being more of a drivers' car. But, I'm not crazy about the looks.
I managed to string out the buy back, until I could get a 2022 S580, thinking & hoping that most of the bugs would have been exorcised from the 223’s by then, but my loaded S580 has been an absolute nightmare since I took delivery. Look at “My S580 STRANDED ME” thread for details. If you don’t happen to know, they are now buying my S580 back, which thrills me to no end.
As for what car next, right now, I am really leaning towards the Genesis G90. When the 2025 W223 receives the face lift, I will consider going back to MB. Or, if MB comes along with some substantial incentive dollars this time around, I may chance another one.
For the transmission of your old W222, do you happen to still have the invoice, I am curious if it was a reman or actually new.
If there is one car I wish they can produce with modern tech but with same exact design and main components, it would be the LS430. Give me better cooled seats, massage functions along with lane keep assist and carplay and I’d keep it forever. Same exact engine please!!! 250-260K of oil changes only besides only one lower gasket that needed to be replaced at 240K miles. I didn’t even replace the timing belt!
Both gens took miles like nothing else though you are right. With 200k miles on it if it was well maintained it was like new with new with not a squeak or creak. The engine was also so smooth, my S560’s engine reminds me a lot of it.
My LS460s were great too, especially my loaded 17 LS460L. Not as well built though, and the UR engine is not as refined as the UZ. If it hadn’t been hit in the back I might have bought that 17 out of the lease and kept it.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Both gens took miles like nothing else though you are right. With 200k miles on it if it was well maintained it was like new with new with not a squeak or creak. The engine was also so smooth, my S560’s engine reminds me a lot of it.
My LS460s were great too, especially my loaded 17 LS460L. Not as well built though, and the UR engine is not as refined as the UZ. If it hadn’t been hit in the back I might have bought that 17 out of the lease and kept it.
For the transmission of your old W222, do you happen to still have the invoice, I am curious if it was a reman or actually new.
MBUSA has still not agreed to buy back the 2022, so I have time and will search until I cannot wait any longer.

Or you lower your expectations, whatever comes first, still believe it is the former as you want the perfect car not the compromised car.




Lol… JK!, but it’s true too.
I don't LOVE the diamond white mine is, I wish it was crisper and less cream-ish. If I buy my S560 out of the lease and keep it I would consider a matte silver or matte light grey wrap to make it feel different...






