W212 M271 EVO voltage readings
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
W212 M271 EVO voltage readings
Hello all, i need some help from my w212 companions, I'm having a hard time diagnosing as it seems an electrical issue, if someone is also driving a w212 E200 blue efficiency i want some voltage data to compare with, at idle with no load my voltage is 12.6v, at idle with only headlights on its 13.5v , but when idling with full load (MAX AC fan, window defogger, fog lights) the voltage is between 12.8 - 13.1 which i think is low for full load mode, please note that with full load the car lights starts to flicker and all car electronics are affected i could even hear the AC blower lowering and rising, and sometimes its not even capable of supplying sufficient electricity to run full MAX, i am suspecting either the alternator or the voltage regulator, if anyone could suggest ideas i would be grateful, i hooked up a scan tool no fault codes but the car surges badly with full load. The idling is smooth without load but with load its crappy
#2
MBWorld Fanatic!
if you're only seeing 12.8-13.1 at idle with full load, it sounds like your alternator/regulator isn't up to snuff. does the voltage recover to 13.5 or so when you rev the engine above idle at full load?
fwiw, the USA never saw the E200 or the M271 in any form in a W212, maybe that engine was used in W203 C class or something.
fwiw, the USA never saw the E200 or the M271 in any form in a W212, maybe that engine was used in W203 C class or something.
The following users liked this post:
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
The following users liked this post:
Sunnyslope48 (03-06-2021)
#4
Junior Member
Thread Starter
if you're only seeing 12.8-13.1 at idle with full load, it sounds like your alternator/regulator isn't up to snuff. does the voltage recover to 13.5 or so when you rev the engine above idle at full load?
fwiw, the USA never saw the E200 or the M271 in any form in a W212, maybe that engine was used in W203 C class or something.
fwiw, the USA never saw the E200 or the M271 in any form in a W212, maybe that engine was used in W203 C class or something.
#5
Junior Member
Thread Starter
if you're only seeing 12.8-13.1 at idle with full load, it sounds like your alternator/regulator isn't up to snuff. does the voltage recover to 13.5 or so when you rev the engine above idle at full load?
fwiw, the USA never saw the E200 or the M271 in any form in a W212, maybe that engine was used in W203 C class or something.
fwiw, the USA never saw the E200 or the M271 in any form in a W212, maybe that engine was used in W203 C class or something.
The following users liked this post:
pierrejoliat (03-07-2021)
#6
MBWorld Fanatic!
Oil is not good for electrics that depend on brushes.... I concur with the above, replace the alternator
The following users liked this post:
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
#7
MBWorld Fanatic!
I would not jump in changing the alternator based on the information posted so far. At no point says it that battery voltage is below 12 V.
If the alternator is bad the voltage should drop below 12.5 V and as long as it does not all equipment designed to run with 12 V should work just fine. I would look into place that supply power to all “gizmos” that show “flickering” or other symptoms.
One way to easily troubleshoot this is to put a battery charger on the main battery and charge it all the way full. Then with fully charged battery you know that everything should work fine for awhile regardless of the condition of the alternator. If problems persist it is not an alternator issue.
I don’t know if this trick works the same in your car but I can pull the full charging voltage from my alternator by turning the fog light ON. My car is a 2010 E550 and fog light control is by rotating the light switch to head lights position and then pulling the knob out. This makes battery voltage to about 14.5 V regardless of driving or on idle.
If you can get your voltage to above 14 V you definitely have no alternator problem. Based on it giving 13.5 V for me already says there is no alternator problem. Voltage at the battery must be going below rated value before you can say alternator is bad. If it stays above 12.5 with all load ON the issue is somewhere else.
If the alternator is bad the voltage should drop below 12.5 V and as long as it does not all equipment designed to run with 12 V should work just fine. I would look into place that supply power to all “gizmos” that show “flickering” or other symptoms.
One way to easily troubleshoot this is to put a battery charger on the main battery and charge it all the way full. Then with fully charged battery you know that everything should work fine for awhile regardless of the condition of the alternator. If problems persist it is not an alternator issue.
I don’t know if this trick works the same in your car but I can pull the full charging voltage from my alternator by turning the fog light ON. My car is a 2010 E550 and fog light control is by rotating the light switch to head lights position and then pulling the knob out. This makes battery voltage to about 14.5 V regardless of driving or on idle.
If you can get your voltage to above 14 V you definitely have no alternator problem. Based on it giving 13.5 V for me already says there is no alternator problem. Voltage at the battery must be going below rated value before you can say alternator is bad. If it stays above 12.5 with all load ON the issue is somewhere else.
The following 2 users liked this post by Arrie:
pierrejoliat (03-07-2021),
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
Trending Topics
#8
Junior Member
Thread Starter
I would not jump in changing the alternator based on the information posted so far. At no point says it that battery voltage is below 12 V.
If the alternator is bad the voltage should drop below 12.5 V and as long as it does not all equipment designed to run with 12 V should work just fine. I would look into place that supply power to all “gizmos” that show “flickering” or other symptoms.
One way to easily troubleshoot this is to put a battery charger on the main battery and charge it all the way full. Then with fully charged battery you know that everything should work fine for awhile regardless of the condition of the alternator. If problems persist it is not an alternator issue.
I don’t know if this trick works the same in your car but I can pull the full charging voltage from my alternator by turning the fog light ON. My car is a 2010 E550 and fog light control is by rotating the light switch to head lights position and then pulling the knob out. This makes battery voltage to about 14.5 V regardless of driving or on idle.
If you can get your voltage to above 14 V you definitely have no alternator problem. Based on it giving 13.5 V for me already says there is no alternator problem. Voltage at the battery must be going below rated value before you can say alternator is bad. If it stays above 12.5 with all load ON the issue is somewhere else.
If the alternator is bad the voltage should drop below 12.5 V and as long as it does not all equipment designed to run with 12 V should work just fine. I would look into place that supply power to all “gizmos” that show “flickering” or other symptoms.
One way to easily troubleshoot this is to put a battery charger on the main battery and charge it all the way full. Then with fully charged battery you know that everything should work fine for awhile regardless of the condition of the alternator. If problems persist it is not an alternator issue.
I don’t know if this trick works the same in your car but I can pull the full charging voltage from my alternator by turning the fog light ON. My car is a 2010 E550 and fog light control is by rotating the light switch to head lights position and then pulling the knob out. This makes battery voltage to about 14.5 V regardless of driving or on idle.
If you can get your voltage to above 14 V you definitely have no alternator problem. Based on it giving 13.5 V for me already says there is no alternator problem. Voltage at the battery must be going below rated value before you can say alternator is bad. If it stays above 12.5 with all load ON the issue is somewhere else.
#9
Junior Member
Thread Starter
I would not jump in changing the alternator based on the information posted so far. At no point says it that battery voltage is below 12 V.
If the alternator is bad the voltage should drop below 12.5 V and as long as it does not all equipment designed to run with 12 V should work just fine. I would look into place that supply power to all “gizmos” that show “flickering” or other symptoms.
One way to easily troubleshoot this is to put a battery charger on the main battery and charge it all the way full. Then with fully charged battery you know that everything should work fine for awhile regardless of the condition of the alternator. If problems persist it is not an alternator issue.
I don’t know if this trick works the same in your car but I can pull the full charging voltage from my alternator by turning the fog light ON. My car is a 2010 E550 and fog light control is by rotating the light switch to head lights position and then pulling the knob out. This makes battery voltage to about 14.5 V regardless of driving or on idle.
If you can get your voltage to above 14 V you definitely have no alternator problem. Based on it giving 13.5 V for me already says there is no alternator problem. Voltage at the battery must be going below rated value before you can say alternator is bad. If it stays above 12.5 with all load ON the issue is somewhere else.
If the alternator is bad the voltage should drop below 12.5 V and as long as it does not all equipment designed to run with 12 V should work just fine. I would look into place that supply power to all “gizmos” that show “flickering” or other symptoms.
One way to easily troubleshoot this is to put a battery charger on the main battery and charge it all the way full. Then with fully charged battery you know that everything should work fine for awhile regardless of the condition of the alternator. If problems persist it is not an alternator issue.
I don’t know if this trick works the same in your car but I can pull the full charging voltage from my alternator by turning the fog light ON. My car is a 2010 E550 and fog light control is by rotating the light switch to head lights position and then pulling the knob out. This makes battery voltage to about 14.5 V regardless of driving or on idle.
If you can get your voltage to above 14 V you definitely have no alternator problem. Based on it giving 13.5 V for me already says there is no alternator problem. Voltage at the battery must be going below rated value before you can say alternator is bad. If it stays above 12.5 with all load ON the issue is somewhere else.
The following users liked this post:
CaliBenzDriver (03-30-2021)
#10
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2020
Posts: 1,363
Received 1,007 Likes
on
675 Posts
'11 E350, '11 E550, '98 M3, '95 E320
The issue with these "smart" charging systems is diagnosis is not as simple as older voltage regulated systems... now you have computers determining how to charge the battery and to what state. I think without access or diagnosis using MB Star diag, like Xentry... were to go?
To me it sounds like a control issue if indeed the charging voltage is too low...
To me it sounds like a control issue if indeed the charging voltage is too low...
The following 2 users liked this post by bmwpowere36m3:
pierrejoliat (03-07-2021),
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
#11
MBWorld Fanatic!
and regarding the part about the 14v, i could barely get 13v at some times most of the time if I'm lucky with full load its like 12.8 or 12.7, and at the moments of flickering the voltage is around 12.3 or 12.2v with full load. Plus when i say flickering i mean everything is flickering (Blower Motor, Headlights, cabin lights, ambient light, exterior license plate light, door panel lights, drawer lights, instrument cluster backlight literally every electrical thing is flickering).
How do you check the voltage? If you measure from battery cable, like the positive you probably do you could have a simple problem as the loose battery cable. This would give you charging voltage but battery could be lower if connection is bad and only partial current flow to battery takes place.
The following users liked this post:
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
#12
Junior Member
Thread Starter
The issue with these "smart" charging systems is diagnosis is not as simple as older voltage regulated systems... now you have computers determining how to charge the battery and to what state. I think without access or diagnosis using MB Star diag, like Xentry... were to go?
To me it sounds like a control issue...
To me it sounds like a control issue...
#13
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Again, if voltage is above 12 the systems should work.
How do you check the voltage? If you measure from battery cable, like the positive you probably do you could have a simple problem as the loose battery cable. This would give you charging voltage but battery could be lower if connection is bad and only partial current flow to battery takes place.
How do you check the voltage? If you measure from battery cable, like the positive you probably do you could have a simple problem as the loose battery cable. This would give you charging voltage but battery could be lower if connection is bad and only partial current flow to battery takes place.
#14
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2020
Posts: 1,363
Received 1,007 Likes
on
675 Posts
'11 E350, '11 E550, '98 M3, '95 E320
Again, if voltage is above 12 the systems should work.
How do you check the voltage? If you measure from battery cable, like the positive you probably do you could have a simple problem as the loose battery cable. This would give you charging voltage but battery could be lower if connection is bad and only partial current flow to battery takes place.
How do you check the voltage? If you measure from battery cable, like the positive you probably do you could have a simple problem as the loose battery cable. This would give you charging voltage but battery could be lower if connection is bad and only partial current flow to battery takes place.
The following users liked this post:
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
#15
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2020
Posts: 1,363
Received 1,007 Likes
on
675 Posts
'11 E350, '11 E550, '98 M3, '95 E320
already tried that, brought it to a car diagnosis specialist he scanned it with the mb star and found nothing, and to what i assume is that the alternator is controlled via the rear sam, the only fault code found on the rear sam was low battery voltage fault and nothing else.
What did the specialist recommend?
The following users liked this post:
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
#16
Junior Member
Thread Starter
I guess we should define "work"? As one of the strategies MB has is to shutdown convenience features when onboard voltage drops below a certain threshold. I'll have to dig up some material on it, because off hand I can't remember. Another thing to consider is he has a "blue efficiency" model, which I believe has even further measures related to efficiency (thus strategies might be different). So I would just be cautious correlating our experience on US model cars.
As ausmbtech stated a couple of years ago that the battery voltage with full load should be around 14 - 14.6.
#17
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Okay, no faults... but there's more data in there that could help diagnose the issue. For one, I'd be curious to know if one could monitor energy management. Essentially seeing when the car commands the alternator to charge and then measuring the output confirming whether it does.
What did the specialist recommend?
What did the specialist recommend?
#18
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Okay, no faults... but there's more data in there that could help diagnose the issue. For one, I'd be curious to know if one could monitor energy management. Essentially seeing when the car commands the alternator to charge and then measuring the output confirming whether it does.
What did the specialist recommend?
What did the specialist recommend?
#19
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2020
Posts: 1,363
Received 1,007 Likes
on
675 Posts
'11 E350, '11 E550, '98 M3, '95 E320
I really like this stuff... but its an exercise in mental-masturbation at some point. At the end of the day, unless someone has has the EXACT same issue... I don't think you or even many of us, have ALL the tools and INFORMATION (Mercedes technical) to provide exact fix.
Can you post your VIN, maybe I can pull some docs out of WIS.
Can you post your VIN, maybe I can pull some docs out of WIS.
The following users liked this post:
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
#20
MBWorld Fanatic!
The following 2 users liked this post by Arrie:
pierrejoliat (03-07-2021),
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)
#21
Junior Member
Thread Starter
I really like this stuff... but its an exercise in mental-masturbation at some point. At the end of the day, unless someone has has the EXACT same issue... I don't think you or even many of us, have ALL the tools and INFORMATION (Mercedes technical) to provide exact fix.
Can you post your VIN, maybe I can pull some docs out of WIS.
Can you post your VIN, maybe I can pull some docs out of WIS.
#22
Junior Member
Thread Starter
#23
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Pepper Pike Ohio
Posts: 1,948
Received 1,124 Likes
on
750 Posts
12 E350 4Matic 13 E350 4Matic AMG Sport
It seems my "13 Charges at Idle and my '12 does not.
#24
MBWorld Fanatic!
if the voltage isn't at least 0.8 to 1.2V higher than the battery's at rest voltage, which is 12.6V when its fully charged, then your cars electrics will be pulling power from the battery instead of from the alternator. with a fully charged battery, if the charger (alternator) is at about 13.5V, then there's no current going into the battery, all the current would be going into the vehicle electric systems (lights, ignition, fuel injection, etc)
#25
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: May 2018
Location: Jakarta-Indonesia
Posts: 4,344
Received 4,395 Likes
on
2,576 Posts
2014 - W212.065 - E400 ( M276.820, 3 liter Turbo) RWD not Hybrid
Agree with BMW. MB own "smart" charging algorithm is confusion contribution to troubleshoot if based on alternator voltage only.
Mine has the Hyundai Mobius sensor at the battery negative terminal, this is part of the smart charging management. This stuff surely also is a current sensor ( shunt/CT).
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Mercedes-E-...-/143208340324 2nd photo
30 minutes charging profile below. Anything 12.5V and lower = discharge on purpose by MB algorithm. 12.7V above is charging.
Also agree with OP, too much deficit at hot temperature of alternator is sign of a "weakening" alternator.
Try to unplug the Mobius sensor at battery negative terminal, see if that can allow conventional charging "un-smart" of the alternator ?
Mine has the Hyundai Mobius sensor at the battery negative terminal, this is part of the smart charging management. This stuff surely also is a current sensor ( shunt/CT).
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Mercedes-E-...-/143208340324 2nd photo
30 minutes charging profile below. Anything 12.5V and lower = discharge on purpose by MB algorithm. 12.7V above is charging.
Also agree with OP, too much deficit at hot temperature of alternator is sign of a "weakening" alternator.
Try to unplug the Mobius sensor at battery negative terminal, see if that can allow conventional charging "un-smart" of the alternator ?
The following 2 users liked this post by S-Prihadi:
pierrejoliat (03-08-2021),
Wail maghazi (03-30-2021)