SL55/63/65/R230 AMG: which one looks better, f1 nose or the current look
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
which one looks better, f1 nose or the current look
Just want someone's comments on the ever increasing discrepancy between the current sl model and the future model with the f1 nose.
WHich one do u like better?
my thought on this is that the current one looks better because the f1 nose doesn't fit the car's style and copies too much from the great SLR.
another thing i thought of when i looked at the SLR and those self modified or photoshopped pictures of f1 nose SL is that SLR is very very pointy, like those MB logos at the front extends all the way near the front end of teh car thus giving it an eagle look from the side, very unique, but those self modified/photoshopped ones just has the nose sorta to say attached to the front. so from the side, the car does not look as nice or rather even flat when looked at from any angle other than the straightforward front of the car.
i know it sounds confusing but i guess for those who can't put it to words what's wrong with the car, that's as close as i can to describing it. i might be bias because i dun want the old sl to go a generation behind the new sl but even more than that, i dun want sl to copy SLR and have to follow SLK in the F1 nose. if anything, SLK shouldn't get the nose until SL does rite.
WHich one do u like better?
my thought on this is that the current one looks better because the f1 nose doesn't fit the car's style and copies too much from the great SLR.
another thing i thought of when i looked at the SLR and those self modified or photoshopped pictures of f1 nose SL is that SLR is very very pointy, like those MB logos at the front extends all the way near the front end of teh car thus giving it an eagle look from the side, very unique, but those self modified/photoshopped ones just has the nose sorta to say attached to the front. so from the side, the car does not look as nice or rather even flat when looked at from any angle other than the straightforward front of the car.
i know it sounds confusing but i guess for those who can't put it to words what's wrong with the car, that's as close as i can to describing it. i might be bias because i dun want the old sl to go a generation behind the new sl but even more than that, i dun want sl to copy SLR and have to follow SLK in the F1 nose. if anything, SLK shouldn't get the nose until SL does rite.
Member
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 137
Likes: 0
From: France
SL65/ML55/BMW M3 CSL
Front of R230
Hello "bbjay"
Think about the "old" model of the MB roadster (W129) - they never changed the front of this car !
As well I hope, that MB will not change the face of the R230 - because it is unique and fits in the "family" of Mercedes cars. A combination between SL and SLR would not really look good, in my point of view. (but this is maybe only my idea about this...... and I am a little
?? )
kind regards from France
Walter
Think about the "old" model of the MB roadster (W129) - they never changed the front of this car !
As well I hope, that MB will not change the face of the R230 - because it is unique and fits in the "family" of Mercedes cars. A combination between SL and SLR would not really look good, in my point of view. (but this is maybe only my idea about this...... and I am a little
?? ) kind regards from France
Walter
Almost a Member!
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
Its tough to say without first seeing the actual car "in the metal" -- yet, I wish to say that I find the R230 quite attractive and I dislike the F1 style nose on the SLR, yet it looks pretty good on the SLK- so therefore I would not "mess with success" and I would opt to leave the R230 alone.
best regards,
Jerry
best regards,
Jerry
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
it worries me for them to change beacuse i want an sl55 but not one that will change its look in a year, as speculated that if the f1 nose appears, it will be '06 model.
also, about the other rumor on the increased 5.5 liter on standard sl500, do u think that this will also affect the hp of sl55. it would only make sense if it does rite, because since sl500 is faster, sl55 has got to increase its hp too (if it does, sl65 buyers beware of a change as well, haha).
also, about the other rumor on the increased 5.5 liter on standard sl500, do u think that this will also affect the hp of sl55. it would only make sense if it does rite, because since sl500 is faster, sl55 has got to increase its hp too (if it does, sl65 buyers beware of a change as well, haha).
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,488
Likes: 0
A bucket on wheels
to answer your question bbjai IF they do increase the hp on the sl500 they will keep the horespower on the 55. The difference between the 500 and the 55 are so large that there is no need to up it. who knows for sure though?
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 258
Likes: 0
From: Perth,Australia
I too think Mercedes should stick to the current shape, however I think that the SLK looks rather nice. It all depends on how they fit it all together, but from what I have seen, stick to the beautiful style that exists today, then all of this generation SL will look similar, and resales and such will not be ruined. Unfortunately, it's probably too late, I am sure they have already finalised the design for the 06 model.
