Jade2005e500

my girlfriend and I bought a 2005 e500 from a friend about a month ago. Its her car but I have fell in love with driving it. I currently have a 2007 mustang gt. I bought the car with the idea that I would modify it and be able to do it fairly cheap. Well after having the e500 and after looking around at tons of used Mercedes-Benz's I found that a 2005 e55 could be a better option then putting money into modifying the mustang. I could spend 10-15 grand on the mustang to make it still not as quick and reliable as the e55.

I think its also made me kind of bummed out just that her car is quicker then the mustang... kinda sad.


I would really appreciate some feedback if you guys think just going for a e55 would be a better choice then dumping money into the mustang.

And how much of a money pit can the e55 become when it comes to repairs?


Thanks in advance Im new here so id just really like some help.

Russell

outrun

I have a Mustang. I have an E55. There is no comparison. Especially that year. 2011 is the year to get, but after I test drove one, I was not too impressed and it's full of blind spots. And I really wanted the Mustang. So I bought the E55....though it was my 1st choice, I Wanted to give the stang a shot since I have owned one for almost half my life.

Yes the E55 will be more expensive. There is nothing easy about these cars if you're used to working on American cars.

But the E55 is way more fun, has 4 doors, goes like hell, and in the end it's a Mercedes, and a Mustang is well, just a Mustang.

Apples to Oranges.

W211 BEAST

Get the E55 and enjoy your day to day life like you never have before.

And I didn't know an E500 was faster than a Mustang GT. Kinda sad really. Sorry.

Jade2005e500

Hey guys thanks for the feedback. cool to hear from a mustang and e55 owner. We haven't raced the e500 and the mustang yet so Im not 100% sure that its faster but by my feel of the pants they feel way too close.

Its funny you say you'll enjoy day to day driving. that's what my friend said that sold us the e500. He said dynamic seats, satellite radio, massage seats all might seem overkill at first but you will never want to drive a car without them again. and that's kinda where I'm at.

by the way the guy that sold me the e500 got a 2008 s65, that car was honestly amazing even had the night vision in the dash.

GregMB

Russell,

I just traded an '05 E500 for my '06 E55 and couldn't be happier... Lots more power and even more creature comforts than my E500 had.

Some will disagree, but the Mustang is a "young guy" car. It is fast, crude and plentiful.... You won't feel unique driving one, because they're everywhere. As an older guy (44) I could never be seen driving a Mustang.... If I was ever going to own one, it should have been about 20 years ago. To own one now would just smack of "mid-life crisis desperation"...

As I get older, I am more drawn to cars with the "iron fist in a velvet glove" approach.... I don't need big spoilers and windshield stickers to draw attention to myself. It's a lot more satisfying to be in an understated car that can absolutely humiliate 98% of the so-called "fast" cars out on the road.

Something you probably already appreciate since you own both cars..... The Mercedes has a lot more to offer than just pure speed. When you want to just relax and drive comfortably you can do it. You can hold a conversation without shouting over the exhaust.... And when you take your lady out for dinner or a nice weekend getaway the Mercedes is a much more elegant and sophisticated way to get there.

Search the forums here for plenty of details on repair costs. Hint: Get a warranty and you'll love the car a lot more. The E55 was almost $100,000 when it was new.... The repair costs don't depreciate like the car does; keep that in mind.


-G

Richie999

Welcome to the site and welcome to MBZ.

I too ran V8 Mustangs for years. I too had rattles, loud exhaust, jenky plastic interiors, interior coolant leaks, loud power steering pumps, etc. Hahahahahaha

Sell the Musty and grab the E. You'll never go back.

skratch77

The E55 is the best bang for the buck right now.

pulley,tune,heat exchanger is 460whp and will be more than enough for you.

Then you can get stupid and do even more mods but you cant use the power.I havnt used first gear on the street in over a year haha.

DO IT!!!!

Jade2005e500

Guys I just actually ran into a e55 on the road on the way home from work. We just played from 0-60ish he pulled off me with a lot of ease. He was a really cool guy and shot me a thumbs up after we stopped again.

I'm still a "young guy" 24 years old. But I have always loved the devil in a tuxedo cars. Its just being young I never had the means to buy one. But now the e55's are in my price point.

I really appreciate how cool everyone on this forum has already been.

Russell

Zmydust

My 2004 http://www.cars.com/go/search/detail...5&aff=national

AMGfifty5

No offense but a mustang gt is not fast car. I just got a 06 e55 and i used to have a 04 cobra. If you want best bang for buck you would get that car. (03-04 cobra) you'll mid 11s for under $2000. Plus it's a 6 spd, so it'll be more sportier. If you want some luxury and power go for e55. Just depends what you want
In a car now. I actually still miss my 04 cobra.

rondocap

One thing though, you mentioned reliable and E55 in the same sentence. I wouldn't go that far - but with proper maintenance it sure can be a car that lasts long - it just has some issues that have a tendency to appear and be expensive. (Airmatic, stuff like that)

The E55 is a more refined vehicle than the Mustang, and very fast. With some mods it is a great bang for the buck, and more unique than the Mustang.

unagi1

The two cars are so far apart in what they offer -- I've got both for the very same reason; Cobra is for when I want to do track / Auto-x or spirited driving on the weekends. The E55 is basically for me to cruise around or go fast in a straight line

Sounds like you just need to think about what you are looking to get from a car, and then go out and buy it.