A little help and ubias suggestion
#26
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: NorCal
Posts: 297
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2006 C230
Originally Posted by NY C32
If the theory that the cost is built onto the price, then you people that buy a 2005+ Mercedes Benz just got raped for a few thousand dollars because they certainly didn't lower the price. Had you bought a 2004, you got your maintanance included plus, paid less than anyone who bought a 2005.
If you don't like mercedes then don't buy another one, i could care less but get your info correct first before saying you know it all. At least I've been down to my local bmw dealer and have talked to them about the FREE service before saying what I know.
#27
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: NYC / Miami
Posts: 3,616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2020 BMW X3M Comp
Originally Posted by 06C230
I have a C230 and I don't know what the msrp was in 2004. However prices do change on cars year after year. It's also not my theory, if you really believe your bmw service is 100% free and you don't pay anything for it than more power to you. Then go to the bmw dealer and talk to them about it, they will admit you pay for it up front. I like bmw however in my opinion I like the C230 over the 325.
I'm currently consulting for a major medical device manufacturer who's price point is between $50k-$450k. They have a minimum net selling price which factors in every cost associated with manufacturing, warehousing, transportation and selling these products. Only one year warranties (repairs and service) are built into the selling price. The sales reps can give away extended warranties as part of a value added program which is part of the negotiating process which costs less than the dollar value given. Again, these extended service/warranties are not built into the selling price. Those costs come out of a repair arm of the business and are actually given and come out of the repair business budget.
#28
Out Of Control!!
Originally Posted by 06C230
It's kind of like the whole gas issue that's going on. Once companies see the customer is willing to pay a certian price they aren't going to lower it. Would it make sence that as each year goes on that the price of a new car keeps going down? That's not how the world works.
You and TN are doing the "how many angels can fit on the head of a pin" argument here. Why, I don't know.
![crazy](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/crazy.gif)
BMW's "free" service should definitely be figured into the C vs. 3 series argument, as far as valuing them against each other. But to me, the quality of the handling, manual transmission, and aftermarket make picking the 3 a no brainer, even without the freebies.
#29
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: NYC / Miami
Posts: 3,616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2020 BMW X3M Comp
Originally Posted by 06C230
If you don't like mercedes then don't buy another one, i could care less but get your info correct first before saying you know it all. At least I've been down to my local bmw dealer and have talked to them about the FREE service before saying what I know.
I'll buy whatever I feel like buying and as of right now, I won't buy another Benz because the quality doesn't deserve the price. The free service is a secondary thought. Oh BTW, I do know what I'm talking about through real experience, not "talking" to the dealer
![crazy](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/crazy.gif)
I bought an Audi Coupe the first year they offered free maintanance. There was a measely $500 increase in MSRP from the previous year. I highly doubt that money went to offset the costs associated with the value added benefit of free maintanance.
I bought an BMW E30 M3 that included free service. When I brought in my car. Rather than giving me a stripped down loaner or rented Kia, they'd ask "3,5 or7?"
I bought a Jaguar S-Type 4.0 that came with service. Contrary to what most say, the car was never in the shop
If you want, I can also list my families cars too. Both before and after car manufacturers began giving away maintanance.
#30
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Pasadena, CA
Posts: 3,206
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
5 Posts
2002 C230K, 2013 BMW 328, 2015 BMW X5
Geez, this seems unfair to the poor guy. His thread gets jacked into a free and unfree type discussion. Geez.
I drove the new 325 and the 330. Slow as dogs. Last years cars felt so much better. If you want performance, Get the sport package on you MB.
Me personally, I like to buy a car right when the model gets revamped so I have what appears to be a newer car. But, I don't car for the BMW's lack of performance in comparison to previous models.
Ed
![Gfight](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/gfight.gif)
I drove the new 325 and the 330. Slow as dogs. Last years cars felt so much better. If you want performance, Get the sport package on you MB.
Me personally, I like to buy a car right when the model gets revamped so I have what appears to be a newer car. But, I don't car for the BMW's lack of performance in comparison to previous models.
Ed
#32
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: asdfasdf
Posts: 2,158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One with 4 wheels
Originally Posted by NY C32
All scheduled service and maintanance. I don't know how much that equates to over the warranty period but I imagine its a good amount of money.
All 2004 and earlier MB's have it too so the only thing I pay for on my car are the windshield wiper blades.
All 2004 and earlier MB's have it too so the only thing I pay for on my car are the windshield wiper blades.
Also, if BMW is offering Free Main. currently, why isn't MB doing it as well on all their cars to keep up with competition?? Or does MB already have their hands full trying to work on their quality issues and needs the money?
On another note, I have a friend who has an E46 3 Series, brought it in for service, and was given an E90 for a loaner. She agrees with me that the E90 is slow as *****, and generally not nearly as good as her E46. IMHO, the E90 drives like a cow. And looks like it to boot.
Get a C dude. It has its quirks, but then again every car does. If you wanna get a new 3-Series, wait another 7-8 years for the NEXT iteration to come out.
Last edited by TA-9FF; 05-11-2006 at 06:05 PM.
#33
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: NorCal
Posts: 297
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2006 C230
Well I didn't get hosed on my mercedes. I do find it pretty sad that on a mercedes forum that you have so many people that would rather own a BMW. Why didn't you just buy the bmw to begin with. If you weren't sure at the time you purchased it but now know you dont like it, instead of *****ing about it why not go buy another car. Maybe the few of you i'm talking about are the kind of people that feel the need to complain about everything. If you own a car you don't like then get rid of it. Do you keep old girlfriends around that you don't like cause you don't have the ***** to get rid of them also? All i've heard is a bunch of complainers. All the cars mentioned are great cars and it just comes down to personal choice. All companies have thier problems and if you think going to a different car company is going to make your life that much better then more power to you. Mercedes is a great car, so is bmw, audi, and so on. Drive the cars and figure out which one you like best. Who cares if bmw offers FREE service when it's not really free in the end. It's sad that this guy comes to a mercedes forum asking how the benz is and all there seems to be is complaints. If the cars are that bad then do me a favor and get your car up to speed and drive into a brick wall.
Now to the guy that started the thread, my opinion is just go out and drive each car and don't listen to anyone. Buy the one you like the best and that drives the best to you, cause in the end that's all that really matters. Every car out there has it's problems and you can always find people that think a car sucks when another person just told you it's the best thing out there.
Now to the guy that started the thread, my opinion is just go out and drive each car and don't listen to anyone. Buy the one you like the best and that drives the best to you, cause in the end that's all that really matters. Every car out there has it's problems and you can always find people that think a car sucks when another person just told you it's the best thing out there.
#34
MBWorld Fanatic!
Okay, this is going to be a slightly longer but more detailed post.
Personally, at this time, I would seriously consider the BMW.
But let's take a look at the BMW's scheduled maintenance.
BMW's scheduled maintenance will cover EVERYTHING, you just pay tires and gasoline.
For the 2004 Mercedes-Benz vehicles, they did not cover brakes and brake pads, they did not cover wear and tear items, only scheduled service such as Service A and Service B.
So, these are the things you should consider when you're looking at these two cars.
1. Price. The BMW will cost more, because you are paying a bit of the service upfront like what 06C230 said. HOWEVER, should you ever decide to get rid of the car, this money does come back because BMWs do have higher resale value because on average they're maintained better. A C230, you should be getting about $4k-5k off MSRP. A BMW 325i should be around $2-3k. BMWs are discounted less.
2. Cost of INSURANCE. The BMW is more expensive to insure. This is particularly noticeable when you are a younger driver (such as myself). However, if you are a more mature driver, there will be much less of a difference. If the difference is substantial (for me the difference was over $1000 a year, you can imagine how expensive my insurance is and I don't have any points on my record) then go for the Mercedes. Keep in mind, you need to do everything you can to stay ahead of the game here.
3. Accessibility. Do you have a BMW dealership nearby? Do you have a Mercedes Dealership nearby? I love Maserati, but even if I had the money, I might think twice because the closest dealership is over an hour away. Also, these cars sometimes have little electronic problems. You will have to go into the dealership sometimes.
4. Which transmission are you getting? My personal recommendation, if you're going to get manual, go for the BMW, if you're going for the automatic, then it doesn't matter UNLESS you like to shift manually while in Automatic, if you like to shift manually in automatic, the Mercedes Touch Shift transmission is very good.
5. Which car do you like better? Notice, the BMW's radio is very difficult to use. Notice the BMW's suspension (sport model) is in my opinion more comfortable than the C230's. Both handle pretty well, the BMW's rear tires seem to have even more grip. Which styling do you like better (I like the Mercedes styling WAY more here)?
6. Assign each one of these aspects, from bullets 1 to 5 a specific point value. Draw a Venn Diagram and count which one has more points. Then, that will tell you which one you're leaning towards.
Lastly, if you can't make up your mind, or you really don't care, and the money is about the same either way, go for the BMW.
Whichever decision you make, simply never look back.
Personally, at this time, I would seriously consider the BMW.
But let's take a look at the BMW's scheduled maintenance.
BMW's scheduled maintenance will cover EVERYTHING, you just pay tires and gasoline.
For the 2004 Mercedes-Benz vehicles, they did not cover brakes and brake pads, they did not cover wear and tear items, only scheduled service such as Service A and Service B.
So, these are the things you should consider when you're looking at these two cars.
1. Price. The BMW will cost more, because you are paying a bit of the service upfront like what 06C230 said. HOWEVER, should you ever decide to get rid of the car, this money does come back because BMWs do have higher resale value because on average they're maintained better. A C230, you should be getting about $4k-5k off MSRP. A BMW 325i should be around $2-3k. BMWs are discounted less.
2. Cost of INSURANCE. The BMW is more expensive to insure. This is particularly noticeable when you are a younger driver (such as myself). However, if you are a more mature driver, there will be much less of a difference. If the difference is substantial (for me the difference was over $1000 a year, you can imagine how expensive my insurance is and I don't have any points on my record) then go for the Mercedes. Keep in mind, you need to do everything you can to stay ahead of the game here.
3. Accessibility. Do you have a BMW dealership nearby? Do you have a Mercedes Dealership nearby? I love Maserati, but even if I had the money, I might think twice because the closest dealership is over an hour away. Also, these cars sometimes have little electronic problems. You will have to go into the dealership sometimes.
4. Which transmission are you getting? My personal recommendation, if you're going to get manual, go for the BMW, if you're going for the automatic, then it doesn't matter UNLESS you like to shift manually while in Automatic, if you like to shift manually in automatic, the Mercedes Touch Shift transmission is very good.
5. Which car do you like better? Notice, the BMW's radio is very difficult to use. Notice the BMW's suspension (sport model) is in my opinion more comfortable than the C230's. Both handle pretty well, the BMW's rear tires seem to have even more grip. Which styling do you like better (I like the Mercedes styling WAY more here)?
6. Assign each one of these aspects, from bullets 1 to 5 a specific point value. Draw a Venn Diagram and count which one has more points. Then, that will tell you which one you're leaning towards.
Lastly, if you can't make up your mind, or you really don't care, and the money is about the same either way, go for the BMW.
Whichever decision you make, simply never look back.
#35
Super Member
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: san francisco
Posts: 999
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
C32
Originally Posted by NY C32
Good comeback... "Don't buy another Mercedes if you don't like it"
I'll buy whatever I feel like buying and as of right now, I won't buy another Benz because the quality doesn't deserve the price. The free service is a secondary thought. Oh BTW, I do know what I'm talking about through real experience, not "talking" to the dealer
I bought an Audi Coupe the first year they offered free maintanance. There was a measely $500 increase in MSRP from the previous year. I highly doubt that money went to offset the costs associated with the value added benefit of free maintanance.
I bought an BMW E30 M3 that included free service. When I brought in my car. Rather than giving me a stripped down loaner or rented Kia, they'd ask "3,5 or7?"
I bought a Jaguar S-Type 4.0 that came with service. Contrary to what most say, the car was never in the shop
If you want, I can also list my families cars too. Both before and after car manufacturers began giving away maintanance.
I'll buy whatever I feel like buying and as of right now, I won't buy another Benz because the quality doesn't deserve the price. The free service is a secondary thought. Oh BTW, I do know what I'm talking about through real experience, not "talking" to the dealer
![crazy](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/crazy.gif)
I bought an Audi Coupe the first year they offered free maintanance. There was a measely $500 increase in MSRP from the previous year. I highly doubt that money went to offset the costs associated with the value added benefit of free maintanance.
I bought an BMW E30 M3 that included free service. When I brought in my car. Rather than giving me a stripped down loaner or rented Kia, they'd ask "3,5 or7?"
I bought a Jaguar S-Type 4.0 that came with service. Contrary to what most say, the car was never in the shop
If you want, I can also list my families cars too. Both before and after car manufacturers began giving away maintanance.
I also believe that even pre-2004 models so called "free maintenance" also only covered service A and B's, not wipers, brakes, or rotors. If you rack up the service bills, they should come up to about 1200 - 1500 dollars. This number was based on 2005 service records, and can vary from one dealership to another.
As for the thread starter, I would prefer the 3 based on the fact that it just went through a model change recently. The 2007 C class will be the final year for this generation.
#37
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: NYC / Miami
Posts: 3,616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2020 BMW X3M Comp
I just realized that I accidently deleted my orginal response while addressing the maintainance issue.
I think the current W203 is better looking than the previous 3 series it competed against however I like what BMW did with the new 3 series. I think its the only good looking BMW on the road and with the sport package, I'd take it over a C-class.
I think the current W203 is better looking than the previous 3 series it competed against however I like what BMW did with the new 3 series. I think its the only good looking BMW on the road and with the sport package, I'd take it over a C-class.
#38
MBWorld Fanatic!
from rlee02135:
It depends on the amount of money you have to spend.
if you go with bmw you should get the new twin turbo 3-series.
if you go with benz, go with a c55.
It depends on the amount of money you have to spend.
if you go with bmw you should get the new twin turbo 3-series.
if you go with benz, go with a c55.
And then most people buy the C55 because it is overkill and they like overkill (that's what I'd buy it for).
The C230 and the 325i are a good match. They're both great cars for the money. I'm surprised that nobody's considering the IS250 from Lexus here. I think that car's wonderful (except the rear seats are a little more snug than the C or the 3).
Last edited by patrick_y; 05-11-2006 at 09:38 PM.
#39
MBWorld Fanatic!
Originally Posted by NY C32
I just realized that I accidently deleted my orginal response while addressing the maintainance issue.
I think the current W203 is better looking than the previous 3 series it competed against however I like what BMW did with the new 3 series. I think its the only good looking BMW on the road and with the sport package, I'd take it over a C-class.
I think the current W203 is better looking than the previous 3 series it competed against however I like what BMW did with the new 3 series. I think its the only good looking BMW on the road and with the sport package, I'd take it over a C-class.
#40
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: NYC / Miami
Posts: 3,616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2020 BMW X3M Comp
Originally Posted by patrick_y
Hmm, that's a tough one, you see, some people find the new 3 series to be a bit too chisled. Personally, I don't find any faults with the new 3 series EXCEPT for the rear taillights, they could've come up with something better for the rear taillights.
#41
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: NorCal
Posts: 297
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2006 C230
Originally Posted by patrick_y
I don't think he's looking for something in that HP range. And some people think the C55 is a tad bit overkill (I don't, but I know people who do).
And then most people buy the C55 because it is overkill and they like overkill (that's what I'd buy it for).
The C230 and the 325i are a good match. They're both great cars for the money. I'm surprised that nobody's considering the IS250 from Lexus here. I think that car's wonderful (except the rear seats are a little more snug than the C or the 3).
And then most people buy the C55 because it is overkill and they like overkill (that's what I'd buy it for).
The C230 and the 325i are a good match. They're both great cars for the money. I'm surprised that nobody's considering the IS250 from Lexus here. I think that car's wonderful (except the rear seats are a little more snug than the C or the 3).
#42
MBWorld Fanatic!
Originally Posted by NY C32
That weird, I think the tail lights are what I like most on the 3 compared to the 5 and 7.
#43
MBWorld Fanatic!
Originally Posted by 06C230
I like the new IS250 however i'm 6'4 and just like the old IS300 it's not set up for tall people. I have to have the seat all the way back to fit in it and then I have to really stretch for the wheel.
The IS250 really doesn't work for anybody higher than 5'10. I have a friend with the porcupine hair who's 6', just got his IS in April, and he has to put the seat all the way down in order to prevent his hair from hitting the roof.
#44
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: NorCal
Posts: 297
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2006 C230
Originally Posted by patrick_y
Totally, agree, i'm 5'6", and another family member is 5', and a friend of mine is 6' something. The seating position for people of all these heights is acceptable.
The IS250 really doesn't work for anybody higher than 5'10. I have a friend with the porcupine hair who's 6', just got his IS in April, and he has to put the seat all the way down in order to prevent his hair from hitting the roof.
The IS250 really doesn't work for anybody higher than 5'10. I have a friend with the porcupine hair who's 6', just got his IS in April, and he has to put the seat all the way down in order to prevent his hair from hitting the roof.