Wheel size V.S Performance
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Wheel size V.S Performance
I am considering +2 from 17 inch factory wheel. Is there any down side in terms of performance after the upgraded ?
A friend of mine suggest me to upgrade a lighter forged wheel(17inch) and forget about +2, this in terms will improve performance and handling.
I thought as long as the overall circumference of the tyre stay the same, the performance should not be affected ?
Any thought on this ?
Hard to find a super light(18" ; less than 16lbs) and good looking wheels for the W204 ...... any suggestion ?
A friend of mine suggest me to upgrade a lighter forged wheel(17inch) and forget about +2, this in terms will improve performance and handling.
I thought as long as the overall circumference of the tyre stay the same, the performance should not be affected ?
Any thought on this ?
Hard to find a super light(18" ; less than 16lbs) and good looking wheels for the W204 ...... any suggestion ?
#4
The less sidewall the rougher the ride and the better the lateral handling. Typically larger wheels add more weight but not always. More weight would result in slower acceleration and breaking.
I think most people get larger wheels for appearance purposes and sacrifice the ride quality. Unless you are running on a track or racing often on the streets I dont see how the handling inmprovements could be significant.
I think most people get larger wheels for appearance purposes and sacrifice the ride quality. Unless you are running on a track or racing often on the streets I dont see how the handling inmprovements could be significant.
Last edited by nil8r; 01-24-2008 at 10:51 AM.
#5
Senior Member
when people moves up to 19"s, it's mainly for looks.
if you want better handling, put new sway bars.
moving from 17"s to 19"s, performance wouldn't change much.
if you want better handling, put new sway bars.
moving from 17"s to 19"s, performance wouldn't change much.
#6
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: N. California
Posts: 1,007
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 Arctic White C300 Sport 6M
#7
Super Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Kirkland, WA
Posts: 616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
c300
Best performance upgrade for the money is new tires.
Besides that, shorter sidewalls are stiffer and flex less which provies better feedback ... completely useless in this car, the steering is too light to benefit from this much. That stiffness also results in quicker break away at the limit.
Besides that it'll ride a bit harsher, more so if you get heavier wheels than the stock 17s. Which isn't hard to do if you go cheap. Lightweight forged 19's cost some dollars. The suspension has to work harder to keep up with the increase in unsprung weight also, so you can get some funkiness going on in the ride. Not a lot if the wheels are light, a lot if they're heavy.
Even if the 19s are lighter, keep in mind that you're still pushing more weight out further from the hub of the wheel which creates rotational inertia. Which is bad for acceleration and braking. How much you'll actually notice this from the seat of your pants? Probably not much. Unless, again, you cheap out and get really heavy wheels. Then it'll feel like you've got two really heavy people sitting in your car with you.
But they look great. I've always ended up with 19s on my previous cars (I've run the whole spectrum of cheap and heavy to expensive and light). Probably won't with this one though; the amg 18s do it enough for me and I'm just not in the mood to drop the cash on this car like I did my others.
Besides that, shorter sidewalls are stiffer and flex less which provies better feedback ... completely useless in this car, the steering is too light to benefit from this much. That stiffness also results in quicker break away at the limit.
Besides that it'll ride a bit harsher, more so if you get heavier wheels than the stock 17s. Which isn't hard to do if you go cheap. Lightweight forged 19's cost some dollars. The suspension has to work harder to keep up with the increase in unsprung weight also, so you can get some funkiness going on in the ride. Not a lot if the wheels are light, a lot if they're heavy.
Even if the 19s are lighter, keep in mind that you're still pushing more weight out further from the hub of the wheel which creates rotational inertia. Which is bad for acceleration and braking. How much you'll actually notice this from the seat of your pants? Probably not much. Unless, again, you cheap out and get really heavy wheels. Then it'll feel like you've got two really heavy people sitting in your car with you.
But they look great. I've always ended up with 19s on my previous cars (I've run the whole spectrum of cheap and heavy to expensive and light). Probably won't with this one though; the amg 18s do it enough for me and I'm just not in the mood to drop the cash on this car like I did my others.
Trending Topics
#8
Super Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Kirkland, WA
Posts: 616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
c300
if you want better handling, put new sway bars.
A well tuned shock/spring combo first is a better choice in my opinion. And then adjustable bars afterward to dial in balance.
#9
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Ohio
Posts: 2,424
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
X3 and 2012 C coming soon
19" wheels will have a negative impact acceleration and braking due to increased rotational mass. They will also increase unsprung weight. You will get improved turn-in with good 19" tires. However, it seems when people switch to 19" wheels they slap some Nankang tires on 'em totally defeating the purpose of a wheel upgrade; unless you're motivation is to just get big chrome wheels stuffed under your fenders for as little money as possible.
As long as the overall diameter of your combo is very near stock, your speedometer will remain accurate.
I have to agree with another member who indicated springs and struts are a better upgrade option than installing anti-sway bars. I have always believed that as well. A while ago I read that German car makers believe in making cars handle better with proper springs, struts and geometry and do not rely heavily on anti-sway bars. I can't remember the source. Sorry.
Finally: It doesn't matter how much horsepower your car has. Any car is more satisfying to drive when the handling is dialed in properly. Years ago I had 1995 Jetta with about 135hp. With suspension upgrades, it was a blast to drive. Taking curves faster doesn't reqire more horsepower.
As long as the overall diameter of your combo is very near stock, your speedometer will remain accurate.
I have to agree with another member who indicated springs and struts are a better upgrade option than installing anti-sway bars. I have always believed that as well. A while ago I read that German car makers believe in making cars handle better with proper springs, struts and geometry and do not rely heavily on anti-sway bars. I can't remember the source. Sorry.
Finally: It doesn't matter how much horsepower your car has. Any car is more satisfying to drive when the handling is dialed in properly. Years ago I had 1995 Jetta with about 135hp. With suspension upgrades, it was a blast to drive. Taking curves faster doesn't reqire more horsepower.
Last edited by Derspeed; 01-24-2008 at 03:20 PM.
#10
Member
Thread Starter
thanks everyone for you kind words
I guess i won't do much with the new ride till more tested suspension kits available on the market.
e.g. BILSTEIN - B16 PSS10
I guess i won't do much with the new ride till more tested suspension kits available on the market.
e.g. BILSTEIN - B16 PSS10
#11
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: SEATTLE WASHINGTON USA
Posts: 3,986
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
'08 C300 Lux Barolo Red Beige Leather P2 MM 18" wheels '84 944
BIG wheels
<<I am considering +2 from 17 inch factory wheel. Is there any down side in terms of performance after the upgraded ? Hard to find a super light (18" ; less than 16lbs) and good looking wheels for the W204...>>
Less than 16lbs?
The 18" AMG factory wheels and tires on my car (C300 Luxury) weigh 54 lbs. Each. That is damned heavy and certainly contributes to the not-so-hot ride. They do look "sick" though, whatever that means. Right now I'm running my winter tires (Nokians) on the OE 17s and the ride is marginally more civilized.
Keep in mind that a really big wheel (with low aspect ratio tires) is going to have less resistance to chuckhole damage if it's lightweight than the overweight OE wheels. M3 owners know all about this.
When I switched to the 18s, I purchased Bridgestone RE050A tires which are great tires, wet or dry, but are a bit noisier than I expected. I see that these tires are factory stock on the '08 Infiniti G35 and the new M3.
Less than 16lbs?
The 18" AMG factory wheels and tires on my car (C300 Luxury) weigh 54 lbs. Each. That is damned heavy and certainly contributes to the not-so-hot ride. They do look "sick" though, whatever that means. Right now I'm running my winter tires (Nokians) on the OE 17s and the ride is marginally more civilized.
Keep in mind that a really big wheel (with low aspect ratio tires) is going to have less resistance to chuckhole damage if it's lightweight than the overweight OE wheels. M3 owners know all about this.
When I switched to the 18s, I purchased Bridgestone RE050A tires which are great tires, wet or dry, but are a bit noisier than I expected. I see that these tires are factory stock on the '08 Infiniti G35 and the new M3.
#14
Super Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Kirkland, WA
Posts: 616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
c300
That's pretty normal for a cast aluminum wheel.
According to tirerack.com, the 225/40-18 Contisport3 is 21lbs by itself; the rear tire size as 255/35-18 are 24lbs.
So the wheel itself isn't terrible. But it's not light either. OEM cast wheels never are.
According to tirerack.com, the 225/40-18 Contisport3 is 21lbs by itself; the rear tire size as 255/35-18 are 24lbs.
So the wheel itself isn't terrible. But it's not light either. OEM cast wheels never are.
Last edited by oblu; 01-28-2008 at 06:31 PM.
#15
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: N. California
Posts: 1,007
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 Arctic White C300 Sport 6M
18" at less than 16 lbs?
Wow.
I don't think a wheel like that would be very practical in a daily application. Could a wheel this light be strong enough to withstand the potholed streets?
Wow.
I don't think a wheel like that would be very practical in a daily application. Could a wheel this light be strong enough to withstand the potholed streets?
#17
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: N. California
Posts: 1,007
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 Arctic White C300 Sport 6M
Well, of course, if you wanna spend the loot, I guess. I think I'm gonna wait until I get sick and tired of the AMG 18" to get new rims. I like the AMGs a lot, as of yet. We'll see how long it takes me to tire of them.
#18
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: SFV CA
Posts: 4,433
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
2008 Black Out C350 Saks Edition / 87 VW GTI
I am considering +2 from 17 inch factory wheel. Is there any down side in terms of performance after the upgraded ?
A friend of mine suggest me to upgrade a lighter forged wheel(17inch) and forget about +2, this in terms will improve performance and handling.
I thought as long as the overall circumference of the tyre stay the same, the performance should not be affected ?
Any thought on this ?
Hard to find a super light(18" ; less than 16lbs) and good looking wheels for the W204 ...... any suggestion ?
A friend of mine suggest me to upgrade a lighter forged wheel(17inch) and forget about +2, this in terms will improve performance and handling.
I thought as long as the overall circumference of the tyre stay the same, the performance should not be affected ?
Any thought on this ?
Hard to find a super light(18" ; less than 16lbs) and good looking wheels for the W204 ...... any suggestion ?
#19
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Albuquerque, NM
Posts: 479
Received 34 Likes
on
27 Posts
2018 C300 4 Matic
Plus sizes are for looks and rougher ride. Stock 17s will give better performance than most (heavier) plus sizes, lighter than stock 17s will be even better. When was the last time you saw a race car running on tires with a skimpy sidewall?
#20
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: N. California
Posts: 1,007
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 Arctic White C300 Sport 6M
One possible performance benefit of larger wheels would be in the larger tire contact with the road. More rubber on the road equates to better handling performance.
But then, as many have already said, that increase in handling is probably negated/offset by the decrease in acceleration/deceleration/riding comfort/etc. Everything is a give-n-take!
In the end, do what makes you happy -- it's YOUR ride.
For the longest while, I've been adamant about not adding anything that does not add to the pure performance potential of any of my vehicles (2- or 4-wheeled). But now, I'm beginning to change a bit... I'll probably add a spoiler to my C300 even if it's just for show, because I think it just looks better. And it'll make me a little happier. In fact, with this car, just about everything I do to it will most likely be purely for cosmetic reasons. I have become that guy (All show, no go) that I used to laugh at...
But then, as many have already said, that increase in handling is probably negated/offset by the decrease in acceleration/deceleration/riding comfort/etc. Everything is a give-n-take!
In the end, do what makes you happy -- it's YOUR ride.
For the longest while, I've been adamant about not adding anything that does not add to the pure performance potential of any of my vehicles (2- or 4-wheeled). But now, I'm beginning to change a bit... I'll probably add a spoiler to my C300 even if it's just for show, because I think it just looks better. And it'll make me a little happier. In fact, with this car, just about everything I do to it will most likely be purely for cosmetic reasons. I have become that guy (All show, no go) that I used to laugh at...
Last edited by narky; 01-31-2008 at 01:37 AM.
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)