$3,400 repair quote: AC evaporator leak. Keep car??
I have an opinion question. I bought my c55 a year ago from a buyer who did not drive it. He was the original owner since 2005 and I bought it in July of 2011 with 15,500 miles on it. This is something I now regret (the low mileage). Since owning it, I've almost doubled the mileage; it now sits at 27,000-ish.
Shortly after I bought it, the driver heated seat had an issue. It overheats to the point of burning the seat. $900 dealer quote to replace seat bottom. I decided to live without the heat. Second issue: rear door actuator developed issue. Again, I just live with this minor problem.
Third item: passenger headlight goes out. Not the bulb, not the ballast, not the fuses, and not the ignitor. Needed whole modual/unit. Indy shop did this for around $1,200. Three months later, the driver side goes out lol. I've tested the bulb myself and it's fine. I hope it's not in need of the whole modual being replaced. I don't drive too much at night, so I've been putting this matter off.
Lastly, today the AC blowing warm air was diagnosed by dealer as a leak in the evaporator. Seeing as entire dash must be disassembled, 15 hours of labor plus parts leads the dealership to quote me $3,600. I've looked at the DIY videos, but I'm a bit hesitant to tackle something this complex without the experience.
My opinion questions: what should I do? DIY? Get Indy quote? Just deal with AC matter next spring? Sell car? Try to obtain extended warranty? What would you do?
The car is in excellent condition appearance-wise and aside from the seat, light, door, and AC issues. It's a nice car- my first AMG- it's not too common- its got all available options-again, I love it. BUT, I'm afraid more issues might develope down the road. I'm already having thoughts that it's a lemon sadly. I'm not really sure what the best course of action is.
I appreciate in advance any suggestions you might have. Thanks, Chris

Did you have a Pdi by a good tech?
I have an opinion question. I bought my c55 a year ago from a buyer who did not drive it. He was the original owner since 2005 and I bought it in July of 2011 with 15,500 miles on it. This is something I now regret (the low mileage). Since owning it, I've almost doubled the mileage; it now sits at 27,000-ish.
Shortly after I bought it, the driver heated seat had an issue. It overheats to the point of burning the seat. $900 dealer quote to replace seat bottom. I decided to live without the heat. Second issue: rear door actuator developed issue. Again, I just live with this minor problem.
Third item: passenger headlight goes out. Not the bulb, not the ballast, not the fuses, and not the ignitor. Needed whole modual/unit. Indy shop did this for around $1,200. Three months later, the driver side goes out lol. I've tested the bulb myself and it's fine. I hope it's not in need of the whole modual being replaced. I don't drive too much at night, so I've been putting this matter off.
Lastly, today the AC blowing warm air was diagnosed by dealer as a leak in the evaporator. Seeing as entire dash must be disassembled, 15 hours of labor plus parts leads the dealership to quote me $3,600. I've looked at the DIY videos, but I'm a bit hesitant to tackle something this complex without the experience.
My opinion questions: what should I do? DIY? Get Indy quote? Just deal with AC matter next spring? Sell car? Try to obtain extended warranty? What would you do?
The car is in excellent condition appearance-wise and aside from the seat, light, door, and AC issues. It's a nice car- my first AMG- it's not too common- its got all available options-again, I love it. BUT, I'm afraid more issues might develope down the road. I'm already having thoughts that it's a lemon sadly. I'm not really sure what the best course of action is.
I appreciate in advance any suggestions you might have. Thanks, Chris
I did do a PPI when I bought it, everything checked out, but more importantly I bought a 4 year warranty for it last Fall. Just had annual service done at my dealer, they fixed several items I was unaware of under warranty, which has now paid for 50% of it's price in 9 months.
I would absolutely get a warranty if you plan to keep it, it will make your ownership tenure much better.
My suggestion, don't tell new shop about your other quote, they may use that as baseline. If you look young enough throw some old text books in your car (like you're a college student) and wear jeans/tshirt (may not help, but anything to reduce dreaded 'mercedes tax')...perhaps even sing a song about how concerned you are that its going to be too expensive to fix....
Regarding your question, I'd first get a quote from an indy show specializes in MB or European cars. Goodluck!
Last edited by Chedeng88; Jul 26, 2012 at 09:39 PM.
A lot of people think they need someone MB specific to do work on this...and it may be the case/ideal for some repairs...but this is a standard function with nothing special about it over any other vehicles. If any concerns when you go ask them if they think this vehicle will be any more diffucult than any other...these guys will know what to do with you car, they've probably cracked open hundreds of dashboards including MBs.
Trending Topics
I am leaning toward an extended warranty. Did you obtain a third-party aftermarket one or one thru MB?
I love the low mileage on my car as well; I've just been a bit discouraged by the items that have occured in such a short period of time. An extended warranty will make me feel better about the risk of anything happening further down the road.
Nice E63 btw.
testknight:
Thanks for your suggestions! I'm 26, so I think I could pull off the whole "poor college kid" thing if need be lol. The indy quote will help. The MB labor rate is something like $155/hr. Their quote included 15 hours of labor-- so in labor alone the cost is $2,325. I would love to find an indy shop that would let me learn/help/assist in the repair so as to both learn and reduce the cost.
Chedeng88:
Agreed. According to dealer's inspection and my experience there are no leaky seals believe it or not. Well, none currently I should say...
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
As for your headlights, try replacing the $100 module on the bottom of the headlight. You can get at it if you remove the fender well plastic cover.
good luck!
As for your headlights, try replacing the $100 module on the bottom of the headlight. You can get at it if you remove the fender well plastic cover.
good luck!
The carfax is flawless as well. I certainly hope it was not involved in a flood. There's absoutely no rust or replaced parts or anything. I agree though-- the problems all being electrical do make me wonder...
The dealer repairs are very expensive.
My CLK55 is a garage queen. I took it in for service A at the Benz dealer, and the inspection came up with some issues that needed to be addressed. Lower Thrust Bearings were worn, valve covers were leaking, lower oil pan leak, and the Rear main seal was seeping.
Dealer quote you ask? Over 4,000 dollars to fix.
By buying the parts myself and having an indy do the labor part, I did all mentioned above plus both the upper and lower thrust bushings for less than 1500. Most of the cost was for the Rear Main Seal labor, without that repair the cost would have been under $500.
The leak was not that bad, but I have to have it perfect. Haha.
Do not sell the car for bad air, try to obtain the parts yourself and have an actual A/C shop do the work.
Last edited by Nachtsturm; Jul 26, 2012 at 06:03 PM.
I have an opinion question. I bought my c55 a year ago from a buyer who did not drive it. He was the original owner since 2005 and I bought it in July of 2011 with 15,500 miles on it. This is something I now regret (the low mileage). Since owning it, I've almost doubled the mileage; it now sits at 27,000-ish.
Shortly after I bought it, the driver heated seat had an issue. It overheats to the point of burning the seat. $900 dealer quote to replace seat bottom. I decided to live without the heat. Second issue: rear door actuator developed issue. Again, I just live with this minor problem.
Third item: passenger headlight goes out Mobile Truck Repair Services in Parkland. Not the bulb, not the ballast, not the fuses, and not the ignitor. Needed whole modual/unit. Indy shop did this for around $1,200. Three months later, the driver side goes out lol. I've tested the bulb myself and it's fine. I hope it's not in need of the whole modual being replaced. I don't drive too much at night, so I've been putting this matter off.
Lastly, today the AC blowing warm air was diagnosed by dealer as a leak in the evaporator. Seeing as entire dash must be disassembled, 15 hours of labor plus parts leads the dealership to quote me $3,600. I've looked at the DIY videos, but I'm a bit hesitant to tackle something this complex without the experience.
My opinion questions: what should I do? DIY? Get Indy quote? Just deal with AC matter next spring? Sell car? Try to obtain extended warranty? What would you do?
The car is in excellent condition appearance-wise and aside from the seat, light, door, and AC issues. It's a nice car- my first AMG- it's not too common- its got all available options-again, I love it. BUT, I'm afraid more issues might develope down the road. I'm already having thoughts that it's a lemon sadly. I'm not really sure what the best course of action is.
I appreciate in advance any suggestions you might have. Thanks, Chris







