Piggyback vs MB warranty question
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Montreal
Posts: 64
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
C43 AMG CAB & VIPER
Piggyback vs MB warranty question
Hi Everyone,
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
#2
Hi Everyone,
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
Whether you lease or own it, I do not think makes much of a difference unless the leasing company gets involved because you have affected the residual value.
#3
Hi Everyone,
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
With that being said, most reputable tuners will stand by their product if something goes wrong. Don't be afraid to get your feet wet if you're looking to open up your car a bit more.
#4
" When you flash the ECU a permanent trace is left behind even if flashed to stock. The internal checksum is changed, the ECU stores the peak target load/torque/boost values in a hidden area of memory, flash counters increment, etc. With a well designed piggyback, the ECU is never aware it's making more than the factory power levels so no trace is left behind when removed. Not all piggybacks are well designed, but the BMS Stage1 is
That said, there are certain risks involved in modifying your car, and if you break something running at higher power levels, wither a flash, or a piggyback, you should pay for the resulting damage."
Basically, if you remove it, MB won't know. However, if you break something (axle, driveshaft, trans, diff, etc...), you should man-up and pay for it yourself.
FTFY
#5
M
My understanding is that is. It true. MB can look at engine parameters that are caotured and recorded and from these they can determined if modifications, including piggyback tunes, were in place at one time.
Again, whether they go to these lengths might be another question, but from what I have read a lot of information is capture which can then be analyzed to determine if the car has undergone a tune.
I have actually asked BMS the same question after I bought my unit used from another forum member, and here is their response,
" When you flash the ECU a permanent trace is left behind even if flashed to stock. The internal checksum is changed, the ECU stores the peak target load/torque/boost values in a hidden area of memory, flash counters increment, etc. With a well designed piggyback, the ECU is never aware it's making more than the factory power levels so no trace is left behind when removed. Not all piggybacks are well designed, but the BMS Stage1 is
That said, there are certain risks involved in modifying your car, and if you break something running at higher power levels, wither a flash, or a piggyback, you should pay for the resulting damage."
Basically, if you remove it, MB won't know. However, if you break something (axle, driveshaft, trans, diff, etc...), you should man-up and pay for it yourself.
FTFY
" When you flash the ECU a permanent trace is left behind even if flashed to stock. The internal checksum is changed, the ECU stores the peak target load/torque/boost values in a hidden area of memory, flash counters increment, etc. With a well designed piggyback, the ECU is never aware it's making more than the factory power levels so no trace is left behind when removed. Not all piggybacks are well designed, but the BMS Stage1 is
That said, there are certain risks involved in modifying your car, and if you break something running at higher power levels, wither a flash, or a piggyback, you should pay for the resulting damage."
Basically, if you remove it, MB won't know. However, if you break something (axle, driveshaft, trans, diff, etc...), you should man-up and pay for it yourself.
FTFY
My understanding is that is. It true. MB can look at engine parameters that are caotured and recorded and from these they can determined if modifications, including piggyback tunes, were in place at one time.
Again, whether they go to these lengths might be another question, but from what I have read a lot of information is capture which can then be analyzed to determine if the car has undergone a tune.
#6
Super Member
Join Date: Feb 2016
Location: Taiwan
Posts: 688
Received 103 Likes
on
78 Posts
GLC43, X P100D, S P100D, CT200H
I dont see how the car can be aware if a piggy back was present, when piggy backs intercept data after the ECU sends them. But then again, I am not the engineer. But...
- AMG Performance Center in town, the sales told me they would not know and they are not able to detect it (a piggy back)
- Dinan told me the same thing
- Racechip told me the same thing
- BMS told me the same thing
However, I put the most stock in the sales at the AMG performance center. He told me this as He was showing me his super super tuned 135i (ecu, headers, intake, meth injection, exhaust, BOV). He and I got into a discussion and I told him I was considering a tune. I asked him the above question and thats what he told me.
- AMG Performance Center in town, the sales told me they would not know and they are not able to detect it (a piggy back)
- Dinan told me the same thing
- Racechip told me the same thing
- BMS told me the same thing
However, I put the most stock in the sales at the AMG performance center. He told me this as He was showing me his super super tuned 135i (ecu, headers, intake, meth injection, exhaust, BOV). He and I got into a discussion and I told him I was considering a tune. I asked him the above question and thats what he told me.
#7
M
My understanding is that is. It true. MB can look at engine parameters that are caotured and recorded and from these they can determined if modifications, including piggyback tunes, were in place at one time.
Again, whether they go to these lengths might be another question, but from what I have read a lot of information is capture which can then be analyzed to determine if the car has undergone a tune.
My understanding is that is. It true. MB can look at engine parameters that are caotured and recorded and from these they can determined if modifications, including piggyback tunes, were in place at one time.
Again, whether they go to these lengths might be another question, but from what I have read a lot of information is capture which can then be analyzed to determine if the car has undergone a tune.
I could be wrong, but I can see MB techs looking into ECU tunes for busted axles, driveshafts, trans, etc.. But, I don't see them looking deeper into it unless you blow the engine.
If you're trying to pass a quick one by MB techs, you have a slim chance with a full ECU tune and a good chance with a piggyback.
Trending Topics
#8
With a full tune, they can tell immediately even if it was flashed back to stock, since the ECU has to be physically opened (broken seal), flash counter, actual boost logs, etc... But with a piggyback, the ECU will see/log factory settings since the piggyback is fooling the sensor to only see factory boost settings. Basically, the ECU sees/logs factory settings. Maybe If they dig-in a little deeper into fuel trims and see how the ECU is adding fuel (AFR correction) to compensate for the extra "Unseen" boost... maybe.... but even then, it could be blamed on a faulty O2 sensor!
I could be wrong, but I can see MB techs looking into ECU tunes for busted axles, driveshafts, trans, etc.. But, I don't see them looking deeper into it unless you blow the engine.
If you're trying to pass a quick one by MB techs, you have a slim chance with a full ECU tune and a good chance with a piggyback.
I could be wrong, but I can see MB techs looking into ECU tunes for busted axles, driveshafts, trans, etc.. But, I don't see them looking deeper into it unless you blow the engine.
If you're trying to pass a quick one by MB techs, you have a slim chance with a full ECU tune and a good chance with a piggyback.
#9
Again I am not a technical expert on the subject, but I have read several articles that have claimed that based on the data captured on boost and such that if a dealer ( or in one case AMG ) can detect a tune. I would suggest that if this is a big concern, do some additional research as there is a lot of information available on this by just doing a google.
See the below data from BMS logs:
ECU PSI : is what the ECU sees and records with a piggyback
Target : is what's being requested by BMS and unlike a full tune, the ECU does not see that
Boost : is what you're actually getting, and again..... unlike a full tune, the ECU does not see that either.
Chances of a piggyback car being flagged is very slim, if any vs. a full tune.
#10
Hi Everyone,
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
I've been wanting to tune my 2018 C43 cab however it's a lease and I am concerned with the factory MB warranty being affected.
I've been seing some nice posts on the BMS JB1 piggyback which seems to be exactly what I'm in the market for (price and results and easy reversibility), however,
I wonder if it truly is undetectable if I remove the piggyback when I return to the dealer for regular maintenance or warranty service.
If the engine ever had a major problem, would MB be able to know that the car had a piggyback on it even though I would have removed it prior
to taking the car to them with the engine trouble ?
Thanks for your comments
#11
Super Member
Some people are giving false information if you are leading people to believe they are 100% safe for warranty repairs with a piggy back. It's misleading and just wrong - because the place you bought it said so is a BS reason to share this. I would say - if you want to mod or tune, you have to pay to play, do not expect MB to take the fault for your hobby. There's a reason people end up back at Dinan for warranty repairs, and there is an increased price with the product. If you buy a JB1, proceed at your own risk. The ECU and modules record and store more than PSI - what about the adjusting fuel/air to compensate for the piggyback's increased boost? MB can see that an ECU has been disconnected. This is not black and white.
Last edited by threefirs; 01-17-2018 at 10:31 AM.
#12
MBWorld Fanatic!
Some people are giving false information if you are leading people to believe they are 100% safe for warranty repairs with a piggy back. It's misleading and just wrong - because the place you bought it said so is a BS reason to share this. I would say - if you want to mod or tune, you have to pay to play, do not expect MB to take the fault for your hobby. There's a reason people end up back at Dinan for warranty repairs, and there is an increased price with the product. If you buy a JB1, proceed at your own risk. The ECU and modules record and store more than PSI - what about the adjusting fuel/air to compensate for the piggyback's increased boost? MB can see that an ECU has been disconnected. This is not black and white.
The only way they'd detect my piggy-back would be if I were stupid enough to leave it connected when I took the car to the dealership. At most, the only case they would have is a malfunctioning inlet pressure sensor.
#13
Super Member
There's no way in Hell a dealership would be able to prove I'm running my wimpy Dinantronics Sport...which only connects to the inlet pressure senor and only boosts pressure by 4.0 psi max. I would not feel guilty in the least if something were to blow at only this small increase in pressure.
The only way they'd detect my piggy-back would be if I were stupid enough to leave it connected when I took the car to the dealership. At most, the only case they would have is a malfunctioning inlet pressure sensor.
The only way they'd detect my piggy-back would be if I were stupid enough to leave it connected when I took the car to the dealership. At most, the only case they would have is a malfunctioning inlet pressure sensor.
#14
MBWorld Fanatic!
#15
#17
MBWorld Fanatic!
One could counter the issue could have been a malfunctioning sensor or sporadic electrical issue...something ALL make of vehicles are prone to.
#18
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Montreal
Posts: 64
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
C43 AMG CAB & VIPER
Thanks for your input everyone. Very helpful.
It seems rather clear that the likelihood of them knowing is within an acceptable margin.
I will check out the "warranty friendly mods" section, I did not know it existed.
It seems rather clear that the likelihood of them knowing is within an acceptable margin.
I will check out the "warranty friendly mods" section, I did not know it existed.
#20
Former Vendor of MBWorld
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: hongkong Shenzhen
Posts: 152
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
C260
Generally speaking with a flash there is always a trace left behind, and with a properly designed piggyback like the JB1 there is virtually no way to detect it after the fact. That said you should pay for any damages you cause with tuning.
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)