Air Filters??
#1
Super Member
Thread Starter
Air Filters??
Im sure this topic has been covered before but I have searched and really haven't found what is the best aftermarket Air Filter for C63 if any.
Is it actually worth doing. Any gains? K & N or BMC?
From what I have read seems the oil on the filters can cause problems. In Australia we don't have charcoal filters. Would I be best just leaving factory filters in?
If there is already a thread on this topic can someone point me in the right direction.
Thanks
Is it actually worth doing. Any gains? K & N or BMC?
From what I have read seems the oil on the filters can cause problems. In Australia we don't have charcoal filters. Would I be best just leaving factory filters in?
If there is already a thread on this topic can someone point me in the right direction.
Thanks
#2
Super Member
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Mel/Syd/Tpe
Posts: 517
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
GF
Im sure this topic has been covered before but I have searched and really haven't found what is the best aftermarket Air Filter for C63 if any.
Is it actually worth doing. Any gains? K & N or BMC?
From what I have read seems the oil on the filters can cause problems. In Australia we don't have charcoal filters. Would I be best just leaving factory filters in?
If there is already a thread on this topic can someone point me in the right direction.
Thanks
Is it actually worth doing. Any gains? K & N or BMC?
From what I have read seems the oil on the filters can cause problems. In Australia we don't have charcoal filters. Would I be best just leaving factory filters in?
If there is already a thread on this topic can someone point me in the right direction.
Thanks
#5
As strange as it sounds, BMC's feel very different from stock paper filters, even when you have the carbon filters removed.
The engine revs faster with BMC's in. The torque hit comes harder and is more available with the BMC's.
Like others have said, I have experienced no CEL's or engine codes with BMC's, or carbon delete, but and this is a big, "but," the BMC's cause the car to have a chugging problem and some surging.
I don't know what this is caused by. It's not the oil, because there is no oil residue on my MAF or the inside of my air boxes after several thousand hard driven miles.
I believe it has to do with the extra air coming in through the BMC's and how that interrelates with the eletronic throttle control that is set to function with the stock paper filters. So, it seems like the chugging problems with the BMC's really only happen at very low speeds when light throttle is engaged.
If you engage the throttle too fast with the BMC's, sometimes, the car will literally skip a beat before it wakes itself up and leaps forward (and with the BMC's it will leap forward more so than it will with stock paper filters, which do make the engine feel a little more starved for air than the BMC's do.
My experiences.
That said, I really liked the BMC's. And I will most likely re-install them soon. But, overall, the car drives smoother with the paper filters. Plus, the BMC's make the car a bit louder, which is nice.
The engine revs faster with BMC's in. The torque hit comes harder and is more available with the BMC's.
Like others have said, I have experienced no CEL's or engine codes with BMC's, or carbon delete, but and this is a big, "but," the BMC's cause the car to have a chugging problem and some surging.
I don't know what this is caused by. It's not the oil, because there is no oil residue on my MAF or the inside of my air boxes after several thousand hard driven miles.
I believe it has to do with the extra air coming in through the BMC's and how that interrelates with the eletronic throttle control that is set to function with the stock paper filters. So, it seems like the chugging problems with the BMC's really only happen at very low speeds when light throttle is engaged.
If you engage the throttle too fast with the BMC's, sometimes, the car will literally skip a beat before it wakes itself up and leaps forward (and with the BMC's it will leap forward more so than it will with stock paper filters, which do make the engine feel a little more starved for air than the BMC's do.
My experiences.
That said, I really liked the BMC's. And I will most likely re-install them soon. But, overall, the car drives smoother with the paper filters. Plus, the BMC's make the car a bit louder, which is nice.
Last edited by SonnyakaPig; 11-24-2010 at 02:26 PM.
#6
Super Member
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Mel/Syd/Tpe
Posts: 517
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
GF
As strange as it sounds, BMC's feel very different from stock paper filters, even when you have the carbon filters removed.
The engine revs faster with BMC's in. The torque hit comes harder and is more available with the BMC's.
Like others have said, I have experienced no CEL's or engine codes with BMC's, or carbon delete, but and this is a big, "but," the BMC's cause the car to have a chugging problem and some surging.
I don't know what this is caused by. It's not the oil, because there is no oil residue on my MAF or the inside of my air boxes after several thousand hard driven miles.
I believe it has to do with the extra air coming in through the BMC's and how that interrelates with the eletronic throttle control that is set to function with the stock paper filters. So, it seems like the chugging problems with the BMC's really only happen at very low speeds when light throttle is engaged.
If you engage the throttle too fast with the BMC's, sometimes, the car will literally skip a beat before it wakes itself up and leaps forward (and with the BMC's it will leap forward more so than it will with stock paper filters, which do make the engine feel a little more starved for air than the BMC's do.
My experiences.
That said, I really liked the BMC's. And I will most likely re-install them soon. But, overall, the car drives smoother with the paper filters. Plus, the BMC's make the car a bit louder, which is nice.
The engine revs faster with BMC's in. The torque hit comes harder and is more available with the BMC's.
Like others have said, I have experienced no CEL's or engine codes with BMC's, or carbon delete, but and this is a big, "but," the BMC's cause the car to have a chugging problem and some surging.
I don't know what this is caused by. It's not the oil, because there is no oil residue on my MAF or the inside of my air boxes after several thousand hard driven miles.
I believe it has to do with the extra air coming in through the BMC's and how that interrelates with the eletronic throttle control that is set to function with the stock paper filters. So, it seems like the chugging problems with the BMC's really only happen at very low speeds when light throttle is engaged.
If you engage the throttle too fast with the BMC's, sometimes, the car will literally skip a beat before it wakes itself up and leaps forward (and with the BMC's it will leap forward more so than it will with stock paper filters, which do make the engine feel a little more starved for air than the BMC's do.
My experiences.
That said, I really liked the BMC's. And I will most likely re-install them soon. But, overall, the car drives smoother with the paper filters. Plus, the BMC's make the car a bit louder, which is nice.
Last edited by DTMCLK; 11-25-2010 at 08:13 AM.
#7
Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Northern Virginia
Posts: 200
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2010 C63 AMG
I've noticed this also when I want to do a quick acceleration in the middle of traffic, the car does not respond immediately, there is a bit of delay which i thought because im in the wrong gear, but the transmission should lower the gear immediately without any delay.... so will ECU performance upgrade eliminate this issue? so the BMC should work in parallel with upgraded ECU flash ? that would be my guess
Last edited by Baby Gorilla; 11-25-2010 at 10:47 AM.
Trending Topics
#9
I've noticed this also when I want to do a quick acceleration in the middle of traffic, the car does not respond immediately, there is a bit of delay which i thought because im in the wrong gear, but the transmission should lower the gear immediately without any delay.... so will ECU performance upgrade eliminate this issue? so the BMC should work in parallel with upgraded ECU flash ? that would be my guess
#10
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Northern NJ
Posts: 1,035
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2009 C63