WTB: Weistec Oil/Water Seperator/Catch Can

The PCV valve part # is A156-010-03-70 (MB refers to it as a breather pipe). See somewhat relevant and interesting writeup at https://mbworld.org/forums/w211-amg/...-m156-e63.html, which is where Jasonoff got that second pic.
A decent catch can (one that I like for a number of reasons for THIS PARTICULAR APPLICATION is the ADD W1 - the closed loop one without the breather) is $100. Another $50 would easily get you 12' of 3/8" hose (I am talking proper gas/oil grade stuff), two flat or barbed couplers (straight or angled TBD), six pressure release or worm-gear hose clamps, one small L-bracket and one Scotchbrite pad if you want to collect even more oil. You could even buy another MB PCV valve (breather hose) for another $100 so you don't have to mess with the one on your engine nor worry about cutting the hose on it - you could separate the "hose" portion from the PCV and crankcase fittings and directly connect the new hoses from the catch can to those, in which case you won't need the couplers and you'll need only four clamps ($10 savings). In other words, for $250 you can PROPERLY put together and build the whole thing without going anywhere near your car, and then put it all in in an hour or two if you do it the proper way (i.e. by removing the intake manifold and replacing the intake gaskets and bolts, which will add another $50 in parts - so that's $300 for a solution that is at least as good as the Weistec, and you've also got a clean manifold with a new gasket). And, the PCV is an item that needs to be replaced at the 120,000 km service, so by replacing it you'll also be doing some preventative / scheduled maintenance!
Last edited by Diabolis; Feb 27, 2016 at 03:53 PM.





The PCV valve part # is A156-010-03-70 (MB refers to it as a breather pipe). See somewhat relevant and interesting writeup at https://mbworld.org/forums/w211-amg/...-m156-e63.html, which is where Jasonoff got that second pic.
A decent catch can (one that I like for a number of reasons for THIS PARTICULAR APPLICATION is the ADD W1 - the closed loop one without the breather) is $100. Another $50 would easily get you 12' of 3/8" hose (I am talking proper gas/oil grade stuff), two flat or barbed couplers (straight or angled TBD), six pressure release or worm-gear hose clamps, one small L-bracket and one Scotchbrite pad if you want to collect even more oil. You could even buy another MB PCV valve (breather hose) for another $100 so you don't have to mess with the one on your engine nor worry about cutting the hose on it - you could separate the "hose" portion from the PCV and crankcase fittings and directly connect the new hoses from the catch can to those, in which case you won't need the couplers and you'll need only four clamps ($10 savings). In other words, for $250 you can PROPERLY put together and build the whole thing without going anywhere near your car, and then put it all in in an hour or two if you do it the proper way (i.e. by removing the intake manifold and replacing the intake gaskets and bolts, which will add another $50 in parts - so that's $300 for a solution that is at least as good as the Weistec, and you've also got a clean manifold with a new gasket). And, the PCV is an item that needs to be replaced at the 120,000 km service, so by replacing it you'll also be doing some preventative / scheduled maintenance!
There are catch cans and crap cans. Buy a decent can to start with. Beware the nice can that does not separate so you have to remove the complete can to empty/check for oil.
Could you go with a Crawford, Mishimoto, Moroso, Radium or a similar higher-end can? Sure - except that even them you'd want one without a quick drain valve which always leaks or a glass tube which always breaks (both of which are BTW useless unless you have an old Impala and there's enough room under the hood to stuff a human body in addtion to the engine), so even a decent sub-$100 design like the ADD-W1 will work at least as good as the $600 Weistec. So will a $140 Moroso or Mishimoto. You certainly don't need to drop $500 on a catch can - there's abolsutely no reason to unless you do want a CF covered canister or other engine bling.
Could you go with a Crawford, Mishimoto, Moroso, Radium or a similar higher-end can? Sure - except that even them you'd want one without a quick drain valve which always leaks or a glass tube which always breaks (both of which are BTW useless unless you have an old Impala and there's enough room under the hood to stuff a human body in addtion to the engine), so even a decent sub-$100 design like the ADD-W1 will work at least as good as the $600 Weistec. So will a $140 Moroso or Mishimoto. You certainly don't need to drop $500 on a catch can - there's abolsutely no reason to unless you do want a CF covered canister or other engine bling.
See, this guy gets it. I hope you build something for the platform and dont price gauge people like others have done. No offense to Weistec as I know you guys build quality parts, but it is a catch can. You sell full pulley replacements with hardware for less. i think your can should be between $300 and $400 and you would likely sell 35-50% more so in truth you would be making more money.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Another heads up, the PVC hold down, the "C" shaped piece is tricky to hold in place while your tightening down the fitting to the intake. It slipped off and fell once and I was sweating bullets since i couldn't see where it went. I had the intake taped off, so i wasn't worried about that -it had only fallen a very, very short distance. Luckily my magnetic grabber snapped it up right away. That was an uncomfortable 30 seconds though.

I should have taken pictures while I had the boxes and Y inlet off, but you can get a sense from the photo below. Anyway, a project for revisiting for another day.
Diabolis - If you're going to consider developing a piece, bear in mind that hose fitment and travel to the catch can. I think that is something that can be improved upon.
Last edited by pbaylog; Mar 4, 2016 at 04:49 PM.
Another heads up, the PVC hold down, the "C" shaped piece is tricky to hold in place while your tightening down the fitting to the intake. It slipped off and fell once and I was sweating bullets since i couldn't see where it went. I had the intake taped off, so i wasn't worried about that -it had only fallen a very, very short distance. Luckily my magnetic grabber snapped it up right away. That was an uncomfortable 30 seconds though.

I should have taken pictures while I had the boxes and Y inlet off, but you can get a sense from the photo below. Anyway, a project for revisiting for another day.
Diabolis - If you're going to consider developing a piece, bear in mind that hose fitment and travel to the catch can. I think that is something that can be improved upon.
Thanks Again
Last edited by Wobble64; Mar 9, 2016 at 09:28 PM.






