Renntech ECU
Trending Topics
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Cheers
Last edited by Intercooled; Jun 11, 2016 at 04:47 PM.
Cheers
I understand the reasoning for purchasing an extra ECU, but the headache of swapping them out between dealer visits kind of defeats the purpose -- the amount of labor required to access the ECU for a swap or re-flash is ridiculous.
I do agree that an ECU flash is a much better solution to a piggyback, but until a tuner comes out with a handheld OBD-II flasher, I'm not interested because of the above reasons.
I understand the reasoning for purchasing an extra ECU, but the headache of swapping them out between dealer visits kind of defeats the purpose -- the amount of labor required to access the ECU for a swap or re-flash is ridiculous.
I do agree that an ECU flash is a much better solution to a piggyback, but until a tuner comes out with a handheld OBD-II flasher, I'm not interested because of the above reasons.
Understood. The second ECU is so that I'd also have one if I have to send one back to Rentech etc. or run into issues. I'd only swap it in extreme circumstances. But if dealer were to wipe it with a re-flash I'd have to send it back anyway so that's a pain as Id want both the FW and the Renntech so even with me having a second ECU is not full proof but still lesser of the evils of sorts? Especially if I were to need to do a recall or major warranty claim. It also helps that I have a lift in my garage. Its like $200 labor I believe to swap out an ECU according to my sources anyway. Once they program new ECU to my car VIN I'd likely perform my own future swaps. We'll see I guess? Trust me I'm fine if second ECU ends up being redundant insurance : )
In regards to to the piggy back systems I'm not knocking them and looked into them with all my cars at one time or another. Having weighed all the pros and cons for this particular car I decided to go the route I did. It was a hard trigger to pull I assure you given the price of new ECU on top of Renntech price. Figured car costing what it did helped in my decision making. Still in the end is crazy added power for the $$$$ and now just need to get that power to the ground and not just sit and roast tires.
Lets start off with the labor.. If you have a mechanic who will drop the entire front end or transmission and put it all back together for $200 then you have the deal of the century.
The biggest issue for me is that once you take the entire car apart I feel it never goes back together the same way they did it at the factory. Maybe I am being paranoid and silly, but there are so many little sensors and connectors and if even one breaks then the parts costs go up. Then the cost and risk to do it again to swap out the ECU back to factory.. not for me.
The gains you achieve compared to the piggyback are negligible in my opinion. Some people will argue that even a 1hp gain is worth it but, in my opinion the piggyback offers 95% of the bang for 1/4 the buck and ease of install and removal.
If I was going to change downpipes I would agree that the ECU is mandatory to eliminate the CE light.
If they could do the ECU flash with a handheld and not have to disassemble the car I would also consider it. But, for what you need to do in order to flash the ECU and the risks associated versus a piggyback, I wouldn't even consider it.
My 2 cents.
Cheers
Lets start off with the labor.. If you have a mechanic who will drop the entire front end or transmission and put it all back together for $200 then you have the deal of the century.
The biggest issue for me is that once you take the entire car apart I feel it never goes back together the same way they did it at the factory. Maybe I am being paranoid and silly, but there are so many little sensors and connectors and if even one breaks then the parts costs go up. Then the cost and risk to do it again to swap out the ECU back to factory.. not for me.
The gains you achieve compared to the piggyback are negligible in my opinion. Some people will argue that even a 1hp gain is worth it but, in my opinion the piggyback offers 95% of the bang for 1/4 the buck and ease of install and removal.
If I was going to change downpipes I would agree that the ECU is mandatory to eliminate the CE light.
If they could do the ECU flash with a handheld and not have to disassemble the car I would also consider it. But, for what you need to do in order to flash the ECU and the risks associated versus a piggyback, I wouldn't even consider it.
My 2 cents.
I'm new to AMG c63s W205, which why I'm letting the professionals handle it. Guess I'm stressing over car having 87K sticker felt better going with RennTech and working with Mercedes specialist on the install. Just like I tend to go with AMS for my GT-R. Its just a piece of mind comfort thing?
In the world of car mods we all struggle with making what we think and hope is the right decision and likely even lose sleep over it
Perhaps I posted here prematurely due to excitement and will gladly post updates of my experiences good and bad. I'm seriously considering down pipes and may as well have it all done same time and out of the way.
As for labor, I paid $700 to have original ECU removed and new one paired up to VIN etc. (Ideally updated FW if not already done by Factory)? Remove from pairing install and send out to RennTech overnight to be programmed and overnight-ed back and installed. I'm not exactly sure of any real significance of me wanting to keep my original as OEM untouched as they could of just as well send out my OEM one and just keep the second as insurance only if needed have it paired do at time of need? Probably could of save $1500. Also not sure if Renntech can program new ECU having not been paired to VIN yet? That just might be policy to tie to VIN? I'll have to call them myself with some of these questions. maybe change up my execution route as long as there are not repercussions. At my age the weighted value leans heavy toward piece of mind and back out plan and or redundancy. Just how I'm wired.
That being said aside from all these initial efforts I ask for future (what if needed) swap pricing and was quoted $200-ish. I'll see first hands whats involved but as of right now this is uncharted territory.
Hopefully in future some tuners will have developed a hand held OBD port upload option









