Initial Break-in?
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 379
Likes: 35
GT3
Initial Break-in?
Why is there an initial break-in for cars? Especially cars like the GTR? You know, where you gotta keep it under a certain RPM for X number of miles.
Aren't all these engines put through the paces at the factory on an engine dyno before ever being put into a car? Or is more a drivetrain thing with the transmission and diff and all that?
Aren't all these engines put through the paces at the factory on an engine dyno before ever being put into a car? Or is more a drivetrain thing with the transmission and diff and all that?
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 1,075
Likes: 220
2018 Solarbeam Yellow AMG GTS
Pistons move up in down in the cylinders . There’s always some wear on the engine block when first using the engine. If you change oil on a new car after several hundred miles there is lots of metal particles / dust. You don’t want to flog the engine too hard during the initial break in period .
After the parts are appropriately “ worn” , and the oil has been changed, you can go hog wild.
Premature over use may may prevent piston rings from setting up properly and may lead to premature engine wear.
After the parts are appropriately “ worn” , and the oil has been changed, you can go hog wild.
Premature over use may may prevent piston rings from setting up properly and may lead to premature engine wear.
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 379
Likes: 35
GT3
Pistons move up in down in the cylinders . There’s always some wear on the engine block when first using the engine. If you change oil on a new car after several hundred miles there is lots of metal particles / dust. You don’t want to flog the engine too hard during the initial break in period .
After the parts are appropriately “ worn” , and the oil has been changed, you can go hog wild.
Premature over use may may prevent piston rings from setting up properly and may lead to premature engine wear.
After the parts are appropriately “ worn” , and the oil has been changed, you can go hog wild.
Premature over use may may prevent piston rings from setting up properly and may lead to premature engine wear.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 4,005
Likes: 711
From: ATLANTA
R Nine T
Why is there an initial break-in for cars? Especially cars like the GTR? You know, where you gotta keep it under a certain RPM for X number of miles.
Aren't all these engines put through the paces at the factory on an engine dyno before ever being put into a car? Or is more a drivetrain thing with the transmission and diff and all that?
Aren't all these engines put through the paces at the factory on an engine dyno before ever being put into a car? Or is more a drivetrain thing with the transmission and diff and all that?
Member
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 140
Likes: 92
AMG GTR, G63, Mclaren 675 LT S, 991 GT3 RS, 991 GT3, many more
Pistons move up in down in the cylinders . There’s always some wear on the engine block when first using the engine. If you change oil on a new car after several hundred miles there is lots of metal particles / dust. You don’t want to flog the engine too hard during the initial break in period .
After the parts are appropriately “ worn” , and the oil has been changed, you can go hog wild.
Premature over use may may prevent piston rings from setting up properly and may lead to premature engine wear.
After the parts are appropriately “ worn” , and the oil has been changed, you can go hog wild.
Premature over use may may prevent piston rings from setting up properly and may lead to premature engine wear.
Trending Topics
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 485
Likes: 38
2017 AMG GT
Yes, I always warm up properly. First 1000-2000 miles I drive in comfort and vary rpms and never floor it to avoid kick down.
MB World Stories
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
6 Mercedes Models That Did NOT Age Well (But Are Somehow Still Cool)
Verdad Gallardo
Manual Mercedes? 6 Times Sindelfingen Let Drivers Have All The Fun
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes SLR McLaren 722 S Is Extremely Rare Example Modified by McLaren
Verdad Gallardo
8 Classic Boxy Mercedes Designs That Have Aged Like Fine Wine
Verdad Gallardo
Flawlessly Restored Mercedes 190E Evo II Heads to Auction
Verdad Gallardo
Electric Mercedes C-Class Unveiled: 11 Things You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes EQS Gets A Major Update: Everything You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
5 Underrated Mercedes-Benz Models That Don't Get the Love They Deserve
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes 300D Has Pushed Well Past 1 Million Miles and It Ain't Stopping
Verdad Gallardo
Super Member
Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 556
Likes: 80
2018 AMG GTS, 2015 911 GT3, 2017 E300, 2014 X3 35i
I always drive in Comfort mode until the engine oil reaches appropriate temperature usually after several minutes and than switch to my Individual setting which has Race transmission.
My round trip work commute is 12 miles so it takes me too long to reach 2000 miles so I've used 500 miles as a threshold. So far I'm at 450 miles owning the car since September 1st. The engine does seem to perform better at 450 miles compared to delivery with 25 miles on the odometer.
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 485
Likes: 38
2017 AMG GT
My neighbor only drove his 458 Italia on the weekend and would warm up the engine while still parked in the garage and then go WOT. He would also rev the engine to redline before turning it off. Obviously doing it wrong.
I always drive in Comfort mode until the engine oil reaches appropriate temperature usually after several minutes and than switch to my Individual setting which has Race transmission.
My round trip work commute is 12 miles so it takes me too long to reach 2000 miles so I've used 500 miles as a threshold. So far I'm at 450 miles owning the car since September 1st. The engine does seem to perform better at 450 miles compared to delivery with 25 miles on the odometer.
I always drive in Comfort mode until the engine oil reaches appropriate temperature usually after several minutes and than switch to my Individual setting which has Race transmission.
My round trip work commute is 12 miles so it takes me too long to reach 2000 miles so I've used 500 miles as a threshold. So far I'm at 450 miles owning the car since September 1st. The engine does seem to perform better at 450 miles compared to delivery with 25 miles on the odometer.
Super Member
Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 556
Likes: 80
2018 AMG GTS, 2015 911 GT3, 2017 E300, 2014 X3 35i
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2015
Posts: 4,037
Likes: 1,012
From: Miami, FL
2003 CL 600
According to the factory reps, when asked this question, they always give the same response. It's not to break-in the engine as in days of old, the production values are much too good for that. It's to allow all the adaptations to build up in the computers, for the specific tolerances to learn to each other. The transmission shift behavior, engine airflow characteristics, voltage variances, etc. They also stress, the break in period should be done in Comfort mode, as the other modes will run off an adjusted value based on what the comfort mode learning has been.
You certainly won't blow up the engine with some full throttle right out of the box, god knows it happens all the time with salesmen/porters driving the newest and fanciest cars on the lot, hard to resist the temptation to give it some throttle. But if it was driven like a race car from day one, it will never learn how to be smooth and relaxed when you want it to be. Teach it to be normal, then use Sport+ or Race to make it run like a race car. That's the engineering intention.
You certainly won't blow up the engine with some full throttle right out of the box, god knows it happens all the time with salesmen/porters driving the newest and fanciest cars on the lot, hard to resist the temptation to give it some throttle. But if it was driven like a race car from day one, it will never learn how to be smooth and relaxed when you want it to be. Teach it to be normal, then use Sport+ or Race to make it run like a race car. That's the engineering intention.
Member
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 140
Likes: 92
AMG GTR, G63, Mclaren 675 LT S, 991 GT3 RS, 991 GT3, many more
According to the factory reps, when asked this question, they always give the same response. It's not to break-in the engine as in days of old, the production values are much too good for that. It's to allow all the adaptations to build up in the computers, for the specific tolerances to learn to each other. The transmission shift behavior, engine airflow characteristics, voltage variances, etc. They also stress, the break in period should be done in Comfort mode, as the other modes will run off an adjusted value based on what the comfort mode learning has been.
You certainly won't blow up the engine with some full throttle right out of the box, god knows it happens all the time with salesmen/porters driving the newest and fanciest cars on the lot, hard to resist the temptation to give it some throttle. But if it was driven like a race car from day one, it will never learn how to be smooth and relaxed when you want it to be. Teach it to be normal, then use Sport+ or Race to make it run like a race car. That's the engineering intention.
You certainly won't blow up the engine with some full throttle right out of the box, god knows it happens all the time with salesmen/porters driving the newest and fanciest cars on the lot, hard to resist the temptation to give it some throttle. But if it was driven like a race car from day one, it will never learn how to be smooth and relaxed when you want it to be. Teach it to be normal, then use Sport+ or Race to make it run like a race car. That's the engineering intention.
At least it's not 2000 mile recommended break in like Porsche.
Junior Member
Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 21
Likes: 6
2017 AMG GTS
I always follow protocol in the owner's manual. Why deviate from that? Maybe some people think that they know more than the manufacturer who built the car.
Last edited by bford100; Oct 19, 2017 at 11:44 PM.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2015
Posts: 4,037
Likes: 1,012
From: Miami, FL
2003 CL 600
The things it's learning are mainly transmission gear change adaptations, times and pressures to get desired shift quality. The "desired" window for a comfort shift is longer than one in a more aggressive mode, but driving harder won't give you harsher shifting all the time, it will just take longer to learn it's points.
When we do an adaptation drive after a repair or reset, it requires 5 repeated gear changes, for each shift, at a specified low torque and engine speed. It's trying to learn how to shift in normal driving, not *****-out. From there, when you put your foot in it, it knows to go faster and harder. If it never learns what it takes for a nice smooth shift, it just goes off the factory default, instead of adjusting to the specific characteristics of your actual powertrain.
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 389
Likes: 33
From: A Beach in the Med
G63 & 991.2 GT3 & AMG GT
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 2,527
Likes: 1,009
From: Overland Park, KS
‘24 BMW iX M60
Not exactly.
The things it's learning are mainly transmission gear change adaptations, times and pressures to get desired shift quality. The "desired" window for a comfort shift is longer than one in a more aggressive mode, but driving harder won't give you harsher shifting all the time, it will just take longer to learn it's points.
When we do an adaptation drive after a repair or reset, it requires 5 repeated gear changes, for each shift, at a specified low torque and engine speed. It's trying to learn how to shift in normal driving, not *****-out. From there, when you put your foot in it, it knows to go faster and harder. If it never learns what it takes for a nice smooth shift, it just goes off the factory default, instead of adjusting to the specific characteristics of your actual powertrain.
The things it's learning are mainly transmission gear change adaptations, times and pressures to get desired shift quality. The "desired" window for a comfort shift is longer than one in a more aggressive mode, but driving harder won't give you harsher shifting all the time, it will just take longer to learn it's points.
When we do an adaptation drive after a repair or reset, it requires 5 repeated gear changes, for each shift, at a specified low torque and engine speed. It's trying to learn how to shift in normal driving, not *****-out. From there, when you put your foot in it, it knows to go faster and harder. If it never learns what it takes for a nice smooth shift, it just goes off the factory default, instead of adjusting to the specific characteristics of your actual powertrain.
I ask because I’ve been led to believe, as well as read, that ECU’s/TCU’s are constantly adaptive in modern high performance vehicles. Meaning that the drivetrain characteristics will ‘change’ relatively rapidly; (within 10-20 miles?), depending on how the driver is actually driving in real time. Hence, you could be in ‘Comfort’ mode because the road is crappy, but actually driving the car briskly; hence the engine and transmission will respond more quickly than if you’re just tooling around. Conversely you could be in Sport/Sport + type modes but driving ‘sedately’; hence the gear changes, etc. are less brisk than if you were driving in ‘earnest’.
There are no doubt baseline maps, but the adaptive maps will ‘over-write’ those given the way in which the car is actually driven by the owner.
Bish
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 1,171
Likes: 415
From: Irvine, California
2022 AMG SL63
Are you 100% certain of what you speak, both above and your previous post?
I ask because I’ve been led to believe, as well as read, that ECU’s/TCU’s are constantly adaptive in modern high performance vehicles. Meaning that the drivetrain characteristics will ‘change’ relatively rapidly; (within 10-20 miles?), depending on how the driver is actually driving in real time. Hence, you could be in ‘Comfort’ mode because the road is crappy, but actually driving the car briskly; hence the engine and transmission will respond more quickly than if you’re just tooling around. Conversely you could be in Sport/Sport + type modes but driving ‘sedately’; hence the gear changes, etc. are less brisk than if you were driving in ‘earnest’.
There are no doubt baseline maps, but the adaptive maps will ‘over-write’ those given the way in which the car is actually driven by the owner.
Bish
I ask because I’ve been led to believe, as well as read, that ECU’s/TCU’s are constantly adaptive in modern high performance vehicles. Meaning that the drivetrain characteristics will ‘change’ relatively rapidly; (within 10-20 miles?), depending on how the driver is actually driving in real time. Hence, you could be in ‘Comfort’ mode because the road is crappy, but actually driving the car briskly; hence the engine and transmission will respond more quickly than if you’re just tooling around. Conversely you could be in Sport/Sport + type modes but driving ‘sedately’; hence the gear changes, etc. are less brisk than if you were driving in ‘earnest’.
There are no doubt baseline maps, but the adaptive maps will ‘over-write’ those given the way in which the car is actually driven by the owner.
Bish
My experience has been as you describe. In my GTS it changes depending on the kind of driving I do. For instance if I am in the hills on windy roads in Sport+ and I'm working the car, it quickly adapts and holds shifts much longer - becomes a beast. When I get back to town, let's say the next day I am in Comfort but then select Sport+ but I'm not flogging it, it will upshift much sooner - it'll still hold a gear longer than in Comfort, but not like it did when being flogged in the hills. Seems quickly rapidly adaptive to me.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2015
Posts: 4,037
Likes: 1,012
From: Miami, FL
2003 CL 600
Are you 100% certain of what you speak, both above and your previous post?
I ask because I’ve been led to believe, as well as read, that ECU’s/TCU’s are constantly adaptive in modern high performance vehicles. Meaning that the drivetrain characteristics will ‘change’ relatively rapidly; (within 10-20 miles?), depending on how the driver is actually driving in real time. Hence, you could be in ‘Comfort’ mode because the road is crappy, but actually driving the car briskly; hence the engine and transmission will respond more quickly than if you’re just tooling around. Conversely you could be in Sport/Sport + type modes but driving ‘sedately’; hence the gear changes, etc. are less brisk than if you were driving in ‘earnest’.
There are no doubt baseline maps, but the adaptive maps will ‘over-write’ those given the way in which the car is actually driven by the owner.
Bish
I ask because I’ve been led to believe, as well as read, that ECU’s/TCU’s are constantly adaptive in modern high performance vehicles. Meaning that the drivetrain characteristics will ‘change’ relatively rapidly; (within 10-20 miles?), depending on how the driver is actually driving in real time. Hence, you could be in ‘Comfort’ mode because the road is crappy, but actually driving the car briskly; hence the engine and transmission will respond more quickly than if you’re just tooling around. Conversely you could be in Sport/Sport + type modes but driving ‘sedately’; hence the gear changes, etc. are less brisk than if you were driving in ‘earnest’.
There are no doubt baseline maps, but the adaptive maps will ‘over-write’ those given the way in which the car is actually driven by the owner.
Bish
Hey Bish,
My experience has been as you describe. In my GTS it changes depending on the kind of driving I do. For instance if I am in the hills on windy roads in Sport+ and I'm working the car, it quickly adapts and holds shifts much longer - becomes a beast. When I get back to town, let's say the next day I am in Comfort but then select Sport+ but I'm not flogging it, it will upshift much sooner - it'll still hold a gear longer than in Comfort, but not like it did when being flogged in the hills. Seems quickly rapidly adaptive to me.
My experience has been as you describe. In my GTS it changes depending on the kind of driving I do. For instance if I am in the hills on windy roads in Sport+ and I'm working the car, it quickly adapts and holds shifts much longer - becomes a beast. When I get back to town, let's say the next day I am in Comfort but then select Sport+ but I'm not flogging it, it will upshift much sooner - it'll still hold a gear longer than in Comfort, but not like it did when being flogged in the hills. Seems quickly rapidly adaptive to me.
What I'm talking about is the software learning the hardware. The exact shift times and such will vary from one transmission to the next, the software compensates to make, in theory, every car drive the same, once the adaptations are set. This is different than the car reacting to how you're driving and holding gears longer, that's not adaptation, but a response to your aggressive inputs. This behavior happens quickly but also goes away quickly. If you stop for coffee and then drive normally home, the car won't be holding shifts and preparing for aggressive driving.
We were discussing break-in, which absolutely is designed to give the car time to learn everything, mate that engine and transmission together with any production variations and make it all play nice. I'm an MB tech, this is what I do.
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 379
Likes: 35
GT3
Different types of adaptations.
What I'm talking about is the software learning the hardware. The exact shift times and such will vary from one transmission to the next, the software compensates to make, in theory, every car drive the same, once the adaptations are set. This is different than the car reacting to how you're driving and holding gears longer, that's not adaptation, but a response to your aggressive inputs. This behavior happens quickly but also goes away quickly. If you stop for coffee and then drive normally home, the car won't be holding shifts and preparing for aggressive driving.
We were discussing break-in, which absolutely is designed to give the car time to learn everything, mate that engine and transmission together with any production variations and make it all play nice. I'm an MB tech, this is what I do.
What I'm talking about is the software learning the hardware. The exact shift times and such will vary from one transmission to the next, the software compensates to make, in theory, every car drive the same, once the adaptations are set. This is different than the car reacting to how you're driving and holding gears longer, that's not adaptation, but a response to your aggressive inputs. This behavior happens quickly but also goes away quickly. If you stop for coffee and then drive normally home, the car won't be holding shifts and preparing for aggressive driving.
We were discussing break-in, which absolutely is designed to give the car time to learn everything, mate that engine and transmission together with any production variations and make it all play nice. I'm an MB tech, this is what I do.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2015
Posts: 4,037
Likes: 1,012
From: Miami, FL
2003 CL 600
On my last car—a Lexus IS300—whenever you disconnected the battery, you'd have to help the ECU re-learn the fuel maps. No sure how many miles it took. But if you drove like a grandma, the car would perform like one. But if you drove it like you stole it, the car would respond in kind. It was a manual, so it's not like it was learning the transmission or anything. It was strictly air/fuel.
A/F targets are always stoich out of power enrichment, and a set power enrich setting at enough throttle. Changes screw with emissions so adaptations don't adjust that.
The timing, most Japanese manufacturers have 3 maps, a middle "stock" map, and aggressive, and a retarded map. You can manually set + or - 2 degrees of timing using the factory scan tools on nissan stuff. If you drive like a putz all the time, it will end up on the softest map by default. If you are always playing Ricky Bobby, it will end up on the advanced map.
Member
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 162
Likes: 26
2016 AMG GTS Edition 1, 2007 Alpina B7, 1987 560SL, 2011 E350 Wagon, Ural Patrol
Different types of adaptations.
What I'm talking about is the software learning the hardware. The exact shift times and such will vary from one transmission to the next, the software compensates to make, in theory, every car drive the same, once the adaptations are set. This is different than the car reacting to how you're driving and holding gears longer, that's not adaptation, but a response to your aggressive inputs. This behavior happens quickly but also goes away quickly. If you stop for coffee and then drive normally home, the car won't be holding shifts and preparing for aggressive driving.
We were discussing break-in, which absolutely is designed to give the car time to learn everything, mate that engine and transmission together with any production variations and make it all play nice. I'm an MB tech, this is what I do.
What I'm talking about is the software learning the hardware. The exact shift times and such will vary from one transmission to the next, the software compensates to make, in theory, every car drive the same, once the adaptations are set. This is different than the car reacting to how you're driving and holding gears longer, that's not adaptation, but a response to your aggressive inputs. This behavior happens quickly but also goes away quickly. If you stop for coffee and then drive normally home, the car won't be holding shifts and preparing for aggressive driving.
We were discussing break-in, which absolutely is designed to give the car time to learn everything, mate that engine and transmission together with any production variations and make it all play nice. I'm an MB tech, this is what I do.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2015
Posts: 4,037
Likes: 1,012
From: Miami, FL
2003 CL 600
ItalianJoe1, as a tech, Have you ever had a situation with a tuned 2k mile GTS where after driving long enough in town to warm up, the 'engine warning' light lit up, the car felt like it was leaving a stop light in third gear and running on three cylinders? Stop the car, let it rest and it resets....5o miles later it does it again? Could this be a turbo boost issue and unrelated to the tune?
On tuned cars, I've seen plenty of instances of codes setting related to parameters changed by the tune, unfortunately the first step to making sure the parts are working properly is to put a factory calibration back in it and see if it returns. On my tuned CL, there's very little in the way of airflow diag. On these new 177/178 engines, they check everything, and there's stuff the tuners can't see or don't know needs to be addressed. The increased airflow from the tune can cause strange issues.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 4,005
Likes: 711
From: ATLANTA
R Nine T
Not specifically, but if the light is on, there's a code. Have it scanned and see what it is.
On tuned cars, I've seen plenty of instances of codes setting related to parameters changed by the tune, unfortunately the first step to making sure the parts are working properly is to put a factory calibration back in it and see if it returns. On my tuned CL, there's very little in the way of airflow diag. On these new 177/178 engines, they check everything, and there's stuff the tuners can't see or don't know needs to be addressed. The increased airflow from the tune can cause strange issues.
On tuned cars, I've seen plenty of instances of codes setting related to parameters changed by the tune, unfortunately the first step to making sure the parts are working properly is to put a factory calibration back in it and see if it returns. On my tuned CL, there's very little in the way of airflow diag. On these new 177/178 engines, they check everything, and there's stuff the tuners can't see or don't know needs to be addressed. The increased airflow from the tune can cause strange issues.
My understanding is that guys who get second ECUs on tuned cars, don’t understand that this information is stored in those buses and therefore the second ECU is useless.
