OM651 vs OM642 oil jelling




(They also met API SN, which makes them suitable for Gasoline powered engines as well.)




Now those MB engine seizing are just handfull incidents in big thousands of Bluetecs on US roads. I follow the fate of the guy starting the topic and he did not seek lawyer advise, while he screw up service terms. That gave MB USA excuse to close the case.
Till something like that happens to a hot-shot lawyer, the case will not go farther.








I trust MB engineers and rather listen to their recommendations, eventually even going farther with oil quality than min requirements.






When I am not original owner of any of them, I run them on what you call "thinned oils" and I do oil lab test to prove that what I am doing is right.
The years when oil viscosity was giving main protection are long gone. Now it is chem pack, with lubrication improvements what counts. Beside chemical neutralizers who balance emission byproducts.
Pezoil Platinum Euro LX 0w30 229.52 spec is on sale @canadian tire now for $39.99 for 5L.
when you buy 2 jugs, you can apply for cash rebate of $20 from penzoil .
https://www.pennzoil.com/en_ca/promo...jM5MV85My9jYS8
For USA friends, there are rebates too. Visit their site.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG

When I am not original owner of any of them, I run them on what you call "thinned oils" and I do oil lab test to prove that what I am doing is right.
The years when oil viscosity was giving main protection are long gone. Now it is chem pack, with lubrication improvements what counts. Beside chemical neutralizers who balance emission byproducts.
The MB 229.5X oils were designed as light duty diesel engine oils with ash dispersants, They are ACEA C3 class oils that happen to also be suitable in many gasoline engines.
By the "logic" employed by some, many HDEO oils are also gasoline rated, so they must not be good for diesel engines!!! Don't use that Rotella or Delo, it's for gas engines!!!
Dual rated oils are desirable from a logistics and bean counting view. Being a professional logistician for the Navy/Marine Corps for 35 years, I am pretty sure that purchasing, shipping, storing, and handling one product is less expensive and more efficient than having to do the same for multiple consumables. Especially for bulk items.
Hence, "rationalization" by the OEM to dealer network and vehicle fleets to one oil that meets multiple requirements.
MB doesn't spec thin, watery, inadequate oil. The 0/5W-30 229.5x oils are almost as thick as a 40. It's the HTHS >3.5 that is the defining spec that makes many other oils not meet C3, MB, BMW, and VW specs.
Many truck fleets are running SAE 30 oils in their big engines on the highway. It isn't too thin.. They're all >3.5 HTHS oils.
Old ways go with old engines. People still swear by diesel fuel and transmission fluid oil flushes. It's antiquated and should go the way of heating houses with coal.
SAPS content greater than .08 isn't good for DPFs in any DPF equipped Euro diesel car by any OEM. BMW and VW spec the same low SAPS.
Your engine, your money, don't care what you do. But don't tell other people that you know more than the people who designed the engines and oil. Saying MB spec oil is inadequate or bad or only for gasoline engines is false, wrong, and harmful.
Last edited by gone gone gone; Mar 15, 2023 at 11:42 PM.

The MB 229.5X oils were designed as light duty diesel engine oils with ash dispersants, They are ACEA C3 class oils that happen to also be suitable in many gasoline engines.
By the "logic" employed by some, many HDEO oils are also gasoline rated, so they must not be good for diesel engines!!! Don't use that Rotella or Delo, it's for gas engines!!!
Dual rated oils are desirable from a logistics and bean counting view. Being a professional logistician for the Navy/Marine Corps for 35 years, I am pretty sure that purchasing, shipping, storing, and handling one product is less expensive and more efficient than having to do the same for multiple consumables. Especially for bulk items.
Hence, "rationalization" by the OEM to dealer network and vehicle fleets to one oil that meets multiple requirements.
MB doesn't spec thin, watery, inadequate oil. The 0/5W-30 229.5x oils are almost as thick as a 40. It's the HTHS >3.5 that is the defining spec that makes many other oils not meet C3, MB, BMW, and VW specs.
Many truck fleets are running SAE 30 oils in their big engines on the highway. It isn't too thin.. They're all >3.5 HTHS oils.
.........Just for clarifciation I assume all the 15w40 oils are greater than 3.7 Correct me if Im wrong...........
Old ways go with old engines. People still swear by diesel fuel and transmission fluid oil flushes. It's antiquated and should go the way of heating houses with coal.
SAPS content greater than .08 isn't good for DPFs in any DPF equipped Euro diesel car by any OEM. BMW and VW spec the same low SAPS.
.........whats the difference from euro DPFs to US DPFs in diesel applications or italian japanese .... for that matter? Not argueing lower is better but less than 1.0 is the standard for most vehicles over here, and they are usually less then that when tested.........
Your engine, your money, don't care what you do. But don't tell other people that you know more than the people who designed the engines and oil. Saying MB spec oil is inadequate or bad or only for gasoline engines is false, wrong, and harmful.
The MB 229.5X oils were designed as light duty diesel engine oils with ash dispersants, They are ACEA C3 class oils that happen to also be suitable in many gasoline engines.
By the "logic" employed by some, many HDEO oils are also gasoline rated, so they must not be good for diesel engines!!! Don't use that Rotella or Delo, it's for gas engines!!!
Dual rated oils are desirable from a logistics and bean counting view. Being a professional logistician for the Navy/Marine Corps for 35 years, I am pretty sure that purchasing, shipping, storing, and handling one product is less expensive and more efficient than having to do the same for multiple consumables. Especially for bulk items.
Hence, "rationalization" by the OEM to dealer network and vehicle fleets to one oil that meets multiple requirements.
MB doesn't spec thin, watery, inadequate oil. The 0/5W-30 229.5x oils are almost as thick as a 40. It's the HTHS >3.5 that is the defining spec that makes many other oils not meet C3, MB, BMW, and VW specs.
Many truck fleets are running SAE 30 oils in their big engines on the highway. It isn't too thin.. They're all >3.5 HTHS oils.
Old ways go with old engines. People still swear by diesel fuel and transmission fluid oil flushes. It's antiquated and should go the way of heating houses with coal.
SAPS content greater than .08 isn't good for DPFs in any DPF equipped Euro diesel car by any OEM. BMW and VW spec the same low SAPS.
Your engine, your money, don't care what you do. But don't tell other people that you know more than the people who designed the engines and oil. Saying MB spec oil is inadequate or bad or only for gasoline engines is false, wrong, and harmful.
Pezoil Platinum Euro LX 0w30 229.52 spec is on sale @canadian tire now for $39.99 for 5L.
when you buy 2 jugs, you can apply for cash rebate of $20 from penzoil .
https://www.pennzoil.com/en_ca/promo...jM5MV85My9jYS8
For USA friends, there are rebates too. Visit their site.
Last edited by Mawk1; Mar 16, 2023 at 11:35 PM.




Read them and see that Diabolis and Johnny CC are correct, and some others just don't do their homework.
MB 229.51 Official @MB
MB 229.52 Official @MB
Been driving a 2008 E320 w/DPF (no ADBlue) since 2008 and the worst I've ever had is replacing the Batwing for bad MAFs after 14 years!
Nothing internal to the Engine nor DPF. Why? Following the BEVO!!! I do not follow internet hearsay, the old ways gramps did, or use HDEO with too much ash.
By the way, Gramps died in the 1960s and so did his ways of doing things. I'm Gramps now, so do it my way!

I have my Gramps' old Ford wrench from the 1920s if you want to try changing your O2 sensor with it. He also put sand in his tires during WWII because they wouldn't go flat during the rubber shortage. Want to try that?
MB 229.51 Official @MB
MB 229.52 Official @MB
A: It varies by manufacturer and specific product, but mostly yes, in that neighborhood, 3.7 to about 4.
Q: "whats the difference from euro DPFs to US DPFs in diesel applications or Italian Japanese .... for that matter? Not arguing lower is better but less than 1.0 is the standard for most vehicles over here, and they are usually less then that when tested.........
A: Eurocar DPFs are small, very small. US DPFs are huge in comparison. Pickup trucks have DPFs larger than the mufflers on Eurocars.. Big trucks, like semi's and dump trucks, etc., have huge DPFS that are designed to be dismantled and cleaned commercially. Low ash HDEOs are designed around an ash content of 1. I have never seen a manufacturer's (Shell, Castrol, Mobil, etc) spec sheet that shows less than 1. Could be some, but the standard is 1.
Size matters.. You can see the DPF on an OM642 car on the right/passenger side of the engine. It has an O2 sensor in the middle and a temp sensor facing towards the turbo, It's tiny relative to a truck.
Sorry, for the Japanese diesel cars, I have no experience as they are few and far between here.




I have MaxiEcu scanner, made for European cars and too often my US modules are "unknow" to it.
Part of the differences is different fuels, but also US drivers tend to abuse vehicles more than European drivers, what leads to US engines being derated for their protection.
Sprinters have DPFs about 4 times bigger than the same engines in sedans.
Read and learn :"Bro":
Oilspecifications.org
Reading is comprehensive. Comprehension is beyond some individual's ability.
Last edited by gone gone gone; Mar 17, 2023 at 12:31 PM.

A: It varies by manufacturer and specific product, but mostly yes, in that neighborhood, 3.7 to about 4.
Q: "whats the difference from euro DPFs to US DPFs in diesel applications or Italian Japanese .... for that matter? Not arguing lower is better but less than 1.0 is the standard for most vehicles over here, and they are usually less then that when tested.........
A: Eurocar DPFs are small, very small. US DPFs are huge in comparison. Pickup trucks have DPFs larger than the mufflers on Eurocars.. Big trucks, like semi's and dump trucks, etc., have huge DPFS that are designed to be dismantled and cleaned commercially. Low ash HDEOs are designed around an ash content of 1. I have never seen a manufacturer's (Shell, Castrol, Mobil, etc) spec sheet that shows less than 1. Could be some, but the standard is 1.
Size matters.. You can see the DPF on an OM642 car on the right/passenger side of the engine. It has an O2 sensor in the middle and a temp sensor facing towards the turbo, It's tiny relative to a truck.
Sorry, for the Japanese diesel cars, I have no experience as they are few and far between here.
DPF is sized according to the expected load on the engine, not where the vehicle came from. When engineers size the DPF they look at miles between Regen cycles and size accordingly. 6.0+ diesel truck is expected to spend much of its life towing heavy loads therefore the DPF is sized accordingly. Even through a sprinter uses the same long block as an E class, It punches a huge hole through the air and can be loaded well over 8000lbs.
There are some important differences between diesel CK-4 oil and gasoline 229.51 oil. Can you spot the differences?
CK-4 diesel oil
229.51 gasoline oil
Keep pouring gasoline oil into your diesel engine and watch your timing chain stretch while the crankcase fills with jello. Somebody's got to put the MB tech's kids through college.
👍
Last edited by tjts1; Mar 18, 2023 at 10:56 AM.
DPF is sized according to the expected load on the engine, not where the vehicle came from. When engineers size the DPF they look at miles between Regen cycles and size accordingly. 6.0+ diesel truck is expected to spend much of its life towing heavy loads therefore the DPF is sized accordingly. Even through a sprinter uses the same long block as an E class, It punches a huge hole through the air and can be loaded well over 8000lbs.
There are some important differences between diesel CK-4 oil and gasoline 229.51 oil. Can you spot the differences?
CK-4 diesel oil
229.51 gasoline oil
Keep pouring gasoline oil into your diesel engine and watch your timing chain stretch while the crankcase fills with jello. Somebody's got to put the MB tech's kids through college.
👍



