E class vs. 5 series
#27
MBWorld Fanatic!
It looks like not anymore at least for Benz. New C had almost zero bugs at 1st year production. S class looked also very strong. I can't tell that for BMW, since 1st year 3 series had tons of problems.
#28
Getting the little one in and out of the back seat is starting to get annoying in the CLK, so I am looking (gulp) to upgrade to four doors.
Did any of you do any serious evals of the 5 series before getting your E class? If so, I am interested in hearing your thoughts.
I'm most interested in the E550 vs. the 550i in particular.
thanks in advance....
Did any of you do any serious evals of the 5 series before getting your E class? If so, I am interested in hearing your thoughts.
I'm most interested in the E550 vs. the 550i in particular.
thanks in advance....
BTW = the leather in 5 series is much softer than the E.
cars that I tried when it comes to leather:
C>5 series>E
Last edited by lapok25; 09-15-2008 at 07:52 PM.
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Maryland
Posts: 308
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
03 Eclass, 03 BMW 06 Porsche Cayman S, 03 Harley Davidson "bored & stroked"
They both are nice cars, i've owned 4 of each and currently own a Benz and a Bimmer. The 5 series is a true sports sedan and it translates to the interior with a taunt and teutonic (german hard) feel to everything. The E is a luxury sports sedan capable of doing pretty-much the same things as a 5 series, but it drives so nice and smooth that you sort of slow down and enjoy the ride and feel of the car. Depending on the type of driving you do, each has its strengths and weaknesses. On isolated twisty backroads (if you can find many of them these days) the 5 series feels perfect! On city streets and long highway drives the E class is on another level than the 5. Also, 5 series demographics tend to be a little younger than Eclass owners....
![nix](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/nixweiss.gif)
#30
MBWorld Fanatic!
What I immediately noticed after switching from BMW to Mercedes that I need to stop at gas stations less often. It isn’t because Benz has better MPG (I think Bimmer has it better). It is because E class has a big fuel tank.
#32
MBWorld Fanatic!
And my two cents....
E over 5 any day...quality, design, functionality/comfort
I used to sell both and would sell people away from the 5 - it just isn't the same caliber of car...
anyone agree?
E over 5 any day...quality, design, functionality/comfort
I used to sell both and would sell people away from the 5 - it just isn't the same caliber of car...
anyone agree?
#33
Super Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Essex County, NJ
Posts: 978
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
2011 E350 Sport 4Matic - P2 & Drivers Assist / 2010 C300 Sport 4Matic - P2 / 2013 Porsche Cayenne S
Having never owned a 5 but having my 2nd E I would agree. I was recently looking at the 5 but hated being inside it. It's just too "plasticey" for me. And I'm not fan of the Bangled up design of the current gen either. I really liked the previous gen. 5 series from the outside but the inside was still a bit of a bummer. I also think the E's ride quality is better; granted the 5 has a sportier feel. I commute everyday and sit in traffic about 80% of the time. I'm very happy sitting in my E with the tranny switched to Comfort mode.
#34
Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: newport beach
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 m5
fwiw they say the current 5s had some improvements in interior quality.
The 550s lease really well right now due to a good money factor and a navigation credit. You get a lot of car for a very reasonable lease payment. ...I would venture to say you can't get an e550 for the same kind of payment, all other things being equal
The buy rate is also 0.9%. But i would never buy a 550i or an e550. These things drop like rocks in value. (There is a beautiful loaded e550 in the classified btw.)
The 550s lease really well right now due to a good money factor and a navigation credit. You get a lot of car for a very reasonable lease payment. ...I would venture to say you can't get an e550 for the same kind of payment, all other things being equal
The buy rate is also 0.9%. But i would never buy a 550i or an e550. These things drop like rocks in value. (There is a beautiful loaded e550 in the classified btw.)
#35
Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 232
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
02 ML320 Sport, 04 350z,06 E350 4matic
I recently did the same comparisons- but I was looking at 06 E350 vs 530.
Thing I did like about the 5 - sporty ride , front seats.
I didn't like crash rating, especially rear. Now this part tugged on the heart strings since the wife and I are trying to have kids. So I thought "The E has been rock solid in all impact ratings for years. The 5 just got better. Which do I really want my babies to be in in the case of an accident?... I've got the 350z for sporty. I want my family to be safe"
http://www.iihs.org/ratings/head_res....aspx?mercedes
http://www.iihs.org/ratings/head_res...aints.aspx?bmw
Just my $.02
Thing I did like about the 5 - sporty ride , front seats.
I didn't like crash rating, especially rear. Now this part tugged on the heart strings since the wife and I are trying to have kids. So I thought "The E has been rock solid in all impact ratings for years. The 5 just got better. Which do I really want my babies to be in in the case of an accident?... I've got the 350z for sporty. I want my family to be safe"
http://www.iihs.org/ratings/head_res....aspx?mercedes
http://www.iihs.org/ratings/head_res...aints.aspx?bmw
Just my $.02
#37
Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: newport beach
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 m5
#39
Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: newport beach
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 m5
550i - titanium silver
sport package
sport trans
cold package
ipod/usb
shades
nav
MSRP 71,150
INVOICE 65,410
there is a navigation package credit of the wholesale price (about $1700) that effectively lowers the dealer's invoice price by that much. if you strike a tough deal, you might get invoice-$1700. i have never been offered anything worse than $500 under invoice.
so let's assume worst case $500 under invoice. 15k/a year. 3 years. 2 year leases on these suck, so don't bother.
money factor is .00155 if you aren't a bmw owner.
1 refundable security deposit of 1 month's payment brings it to .00140.
7 more of those brings the money factor to .00091
residual is 55% (for 15k miles per year)
at the full money factor, with a marked up bank fee ($825 from $625 cost) and NO capital cost reduction down (you will still have to pay first month + license fees):
you end up with $901 plus tax.
now if you do all 8 multiple security deposits to reduce the money factor, it goes to $834 plus tax.
now if you grind the dealer to the full 1700 under invoice (i have had one dealer offer me that straight off the top), your payment is $799 and change PLUS TAX.
that's a lot of car for 800 bucks.
of course all these go down if you need less than 15k/year miles.
and obviously if you are willing to have a car with fewer options (except you have to have nav to get the credit), it gets that much better.
and finally if you put 2 or 3 grand down as cap cost reduction, the payment comes down quite a bit...low 7's easily. MB has no problem asking for $5k drive offs for these impressive sounding $600ish e350 deals, so 2 or 3 grand shouldn't seem excessive.
so my analysis is give or take you can get an 550i for basically the same as an e350 with comand, no leather and p1 (no xenon). the 550i comes with park distance, leather, and some other nice stuff, and this deal presumes getting nav.
hope that helps.
#40
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: USA
Posts: 326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Multiple
OK..I'll way-in with a minority opinion. First of all, if you would ask this question on a BMW forum you would get a whole bunch of different answers. I moved from a Mercedes E-Class to a 5-Series BMW because of reliability problems with the Mercedes. My Mercedes spent more time in the service department than on the street. Since then, I'm on my 4th BMW. This year I drove the the new E-Class again (I go through this every year) and was disappointed in the engine, the "fun-factor" in driveability, and the interior (what's an analog clock doing in the instrument panel?). Though cost was not a factor, a comparably equipped 5-Series was about 5K less and drove and handled so much better. I've never had a problem with any BMW I have owned, other than changing the oil and normal service. And as usual, I was turned off by the arrogance of the sales-staff at Mercedes. They have always acted like they are doing you a favor to sell you a car. I know my opinion will be attacked, but you asked for it, and since I have owned both cars, I gave you my honest one. For those of you who love your Mercedes, I'm sorry if I offended you. I've been very happy with my choice.
![](http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y46/w5lx/528ifrontcloudy.jpg)
#41
I've rode in a 5 series and I would have bought a one if chris bangle didn't design it. I have an '03 e320. I still like the E class more because of the design and amenities. If I want a driver's car then I'd get either a 335i or e92 m3.
Last edited by doriftomodachi; 09-18-2008 at 06:53 PM.
#42
Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: newport beach
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 m5
my opinion:
the latest e class refreshes are beautiful cars. there is an openness to the cabin and sense of graceful design that the bmw doesn't have, although i don't know how they can get away with so many mb-tex equipped mid 50k cars. i do find the bmw seems to squeak less when you push on things. on top of the lack of sporting appeal (great ride though), i find the e's way overpriced for what you get as a driver's car. but then there are people who like a really smooth ride and have no concept of sport. it's why bmw's are 'the ultimate driving machine' and mb's are not.
of course, these cars are all pretty good and it's a very personal decision.
the latest e class refreshes are beautiful cars. there is an openness to the cabin and sense of graceful design that the bmw doesn't have, although i don't know how they can get away with so many mb-tex equipped mid 50k cars. i do find the bmw seems to squeak less when you push on things. on top of the lack of sporting appeal (great ride though), i find the e's way overpriced for what you get as a driver's car. but then there are people who like a really smooth ride and have no concept of sport. it's why bmw's are 'the ultimate driving machine' and mb's are not.
of course, these cars are all pretty good and it's a very personal decision.
#43
MBWorld Fanatic!
Sure it helps. I still have a credit for my previously owned BMW, so it will also reduce my price a bit. I guess I need to visit a dealer as only 09 models will be coming up; in this case I can negotiate $2K or more below invoice. BTW I configured a car like you + comfort access and got lower MSRP, $69,450.
#44
Newbie
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Somewhere on the European mainland, preferably on the Autobahn.
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2009 E CDI
Having never owned a 5 but having my 2nd E I would agree. I was recently looking at the 5 but hated being inside it. It's just too "plasticey" for me. And I'm not fan of the Bangled up design of the current gen either. I really liked the previous gen. 5 series from the outside but the inside was still a bit of a bummer. I also think the E's ride quality is better; granted the 5 has a sportier feel. I commute everyday and sit in traffic about 80% of the time. I'm very happy sitting in my E with the tranny switched to Comfort mode.
I considered a 5 series as well. You know... the whole sporty feeling and handling thing... every guy (even those who never drove an E / 5) will say "E is comfort, 5 is handling"... so I should try a 5 series as well no?
I ended up at a large BMW dealership this year... after spending quite a lot of time with MB dealers. Looked at one of the 5 series there... right... the exterior... never been a Bangle fan (he removed the "class" piece from BMW)... I like modern style though in every other aspect of life (you should see my house)... so I said to myself I could accept the outside - especially considering I was going to take the M body on it. Right... that was until I opened the door, sat inside, and was stunned by the absolute lack of cohesion (for lack of better word) in the interior!!! Where in MB everything just flows and comes perfectly together in an overly studied interior design, the BMW just felt like different pieces glued together. The front seats are not part of the interior. They simply have been fixed onto the chassis. The dashboard instruments were screaming... the plastic looked cheap... I can't remember ever having seen such cheap interior on a German car (my 1999 Audi was WAY above that). All this within seconds. In the meanwhile my wife had joined me on the passengers seat. I saw her disappointment (before that point she may have preferred a sporty BMW over a MB), she looked at me and we both stepped out of the car. This was ridiculous. Went to MB and never looked back.
If you think about it, this is one single area where MB considers things: how does everything "flow" together. You will not find that with BMW. Not even a little bit. Sitting in a nicely finished (with real leather) E is a beautiful thing. I can't help but thinking of cognac and big cigars! The curved leather, how the dash flows into the panels and how the seats are an integral part of the design. I love it. This is a classy lounge club! BMW has nothing there. Absolutely nothing. And that's a pitty. Otherwise I may have considered them.
The future? It almost sounds like MB is giving up this edge. With the 2010 around the corner and the spy pics so far, I would say MB is copying BMW both for the bad bangled exterior as the cheap interior. What's next to buy? An uncomfortable and overpriced Audi? A cheap looking 5? The ugliest E class in history? Let's hope I'm wrong.
Go for E - especially since you can still get the 2009 model. Hell, I would even pay full price for it. Could very well be the last truly beautiful out there.
#46
Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: newport beach
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2008 m5
Sure it helps. I still have a credit for my previously owned BMW, so it will also reduce my price a bit. I guess I need to visit a dealer as only 09 models will be coming up; in this case I can negotiate $2K or more below invoice. BTW I configured a car like you + comfort access and got lower MSRP, $69,450.
yeah i may have left off some items from the list, but this was a real car at a local dealer and edmunds and the dealer's price lined up.... unfortunately it was sold
![Smilie](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#47
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 3,003
Received 48 Likes
on
42 Posts
2009 SL550 Roadster Diamond White, 2008 CLK550 Coupe Obsidian Black
But I love my E320, just have a little bit of money I want to drop into it, but not at this time (especially cause I have warranty till April 30, 2009. I'm really **** about risking to void warranty stuff). The only thing I can complain about on this car is the drive by wire and throttle learning. Reset my throttle computer the other day, the car woke up, literally. It's kind of like a nice suprise she gives me when I do this.
#49
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 3,003
Received 48 Likes
on
42 Posts
2009 SL550 Roadster Diamond White, 2008 CLK550 Coupe Obsidian Black
I'm sure the 550i gets better mileage. 5.5L V8 v. 4.8L V8, big difference. But hey, I will pay for that extra gas cost just so I get that Mercedes V8 torque. Btw, I hear reliability wise, BMW V8s are horrible compared to Benzes and their V12s are nightmares. We are on our 3rd V8 from Mercedes (420SEL, S420, CL500), the engines have been pretty bulletproof, it's the other sh** that goes wrong.
#50
Junior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Illinois
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2010 E63
My brother in law just bought a BMW 550i. I can provide more feedback on this when I get a chance to drive it.
BTW I used to drive a BMW 540i and there are differences but each holds their own.
BTW I used to drive a BMW 540i and there are differences but each holds their own.