Burning MP3 DVDs
What is the trick? DVD+R or -R discs? I've used Roxio V.6 software set to "make a disc for an MP3 player". The resulting DVD+R disc can be played with Windows Media Player on my PC, but the car returns "CD Error" when I insert the disc in the single-disc slot. I've also tried seting the Roxio software to produce data discs with .mp3 files and to produce a conventional music disc, with similar results.
Has anyone successfully burned MP3 files to a DVD? Suggestions/detailed instructions will be welcomed. Thanks.
What is the trick? DVD+R or -R discs? I've used Roxio V.6 software set to "make a disc for an MP3 player". The resulting DVD+R disc can be played with Windows Media Player on my PC, but the car returns "CD Error" when I insert the disc in the single-disc slot. I've also tried seting the Roxio software to produce data discs with .mp3 files and to produce a conventional music disc, with similar results.
Has anyone successfully burned MP3 files to a DVD? Suggestions/detailed instructions will be welcomed. Thanks.
There are lots of replies on this interesting topic, most of which will confirm that you can indeed burn Mp3's.
I personally threw away countless disc's that would play on anything other than my COMAND. I eventually used 'Nero' and it has never failed.
If you carry out a search on this subject you should be inundated with information.
Good luck,
John
A sunny cool morning in Torquay
What is the trick? DVD+R or -R discs? I've used Roxio V.6 software set to "make a disc for an MP3 player". The resulting DVD+R disc can be played with Windows Media Player on my PC, but the car returns "CD Error" when I insert the disc in the single-disc slot. I've also tried seting the Roxio software to produce data discs with .mp3 files and to produce a conventional music disc, with similar results.
Has anyone successfully burned MP3 files to a DVD? Suggestions/detailed instructions will be welcomed. Thanks.
Good luck
ps: Use DVD-RW or +RW. That will save you a lot of discs while trying....
Last edited by Oslo; Nov 14, 2004 at 05:01 AM.
Last edited by Oslo; Nov 14, 2004 at 12:01 PM.
I have no tried as of yet to burn a dvd with this, but its worth a shot.
it is absolutely true that the COMAND unit will play MP3 DVD's and it does it brilliantly however: -
1. the manual states that DVD should be burnt using the UDF format and as correctly idenitified by other people the unit will not read them at all
2. if a DVD is burnt using ISO (i use Nero 6) then it will read, however, you CANNOT see all of the folders, it states in the manual that you can see a maximum of 255 folders and in each, 255 files. this is the question i am still waiting to get answered (i have a dvd with a 141 folders and it only sees the first 60-80 folders, it also does not support multiple folder layers. for example, you cant create a folder music, put a folder labelled phil collins, and then within that, all of his albums. the car will see it, but it just lists one level of folders, this is easier to explain than to type!
i have a theory however, it states that the ISO format only supports files up to 2Gb in size, a blank DVD can be 4.7Gb or the new dual layer are 8.5Gb. i think the folder limitation is because it is only reading the first 2gb.... UDF supports more but as you know, this cannot be read by the COMAND unit!
this is going to be a problem for MB because people are going to cotton onto the fact that you can stick a lot of music on one disk and the manual is basically wrong!
i have contacted MB and i hope that all of you will do the same, that way we may be able to get this sorted, i know it is a feature i want!
i hope that helps, if only to outline where i have got to
Kerry
John: I did, indeed, do a search on "DVD", but, alas, found no useful information. If you can point me at a specific post you're familiar with, I'll be most appreciative.
Oslo: The vehicle is an '05, built in 8/04. I was told at MB's kundencenter that it would play DVDs. However, it will play MP3s I've burned onto CDRs, so you may be correct. Interestingly, our home DVD player, which will play MP3 CDs and should play MP3 DVDs will not play the MP3 DVD+Rs I've burned so far, leading me to hope the problem lies somewhere with my technique or software.
Kerryburn: I'll try burning a DVD using the ISO format and Nero (I have an older version of Nero) and see what happens. I'll post back when I've had success (or more failures!).
Trending Topics
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
The only problem that I have had that the head unit could not read them was that I did not finalise the disk.
I use Nero 6 just as a DATA disk.
Make the folders on the hard drive (no sub foders thats a folder in a folder) import the mp3 files into the required folder then make sure you have no multi session and nero is set finalise so no more data can be added to the disk then burn.
Good luck.
Leslie Chesterfield England.
E320 CDI 16,000 miles 5,000 to go before service B used 1 litre of oil so far.
I have just carried out a search for 'Mp3' just in the E211 forum and it has come up with four pages of seperate threads. Some of these thread have over 150 messages, so it is quite a 'long' job to read through them all.
I have highlighted one thread that might be of use.
https://mbworld.org/forums/showthrea...&highlight=Mp3
Good luck,
John
A cool overcast morning in Torquay
I guess like everything else worthwhile, there is a learning curve.
I don't have a computer that can record to DVD yet. The next one will have that feature.
I guess like everything else worthwhile, there is a learning curve.
I don't have a computer that can record to DVD yet. The next one will have that feature.
If you deleted the file extension, COMAND had no way knowing what kind of file it is. If you compress them too much, then all you hear are clicks.
My car has about 230 hours of driving on it and I have enjoyed about 150 hours of DVD-audio from it.
Last edited by Baby Jocko; Nov 15, 2004 at 12:06 PM.
My car is a MY2005, 07/04 Build.
The 357 code has nothing to do with DVD MP3.
There is (currently) no DVD logo on the 2005 US E-class models.
Which all means nothing as to whether your car is equipped with a DVD player or not. I'm thinking that MB had no real intention of offering a DVD player. But, who makes a CD only player anymore? The market is filled with DVD players that also play CD. The manufacturing cost of a DVD player is so cheap that it's probably not worth making a CD only player because there is no longer a market for it. So, when MB's optical disk vendor filled their order for a zillion CD players, they just as well provided DVD players. And, MB, not being electronically astute, didn't promote this as an advantage for their consumers. So, they didn't update their manuals or logo in the software. That's my speculation.
That would also explain why the DVD player is as inferior as it is. It was probably never meant to be a DVD. But, since it was wiser for the vendor to make DVD players instead of CD-only players, they added only minimum DVD specs while CD specs are hard to screw up these days. So, MB got what they wanted, a good CD player, but they also got a DVD player, albiet a rather lousy DVD player.
I guess I'll have to buy the new Nero 6 since that's what seems to be working.
-Nero 6 set to burn an ISO Data DVD
-Generic DVD+R disc
-VBR (Variable Bit Rate) MP3 files at the "higest" quality setting, converted from .WAV files by using CoolEdit software.
So far, I've only tried a test disc with three folders with 12-13 files each, but the system reads them just fine and they sound great.
FWIW, I couldn't get my Roxio 6 software to produce a playable DVD, no matter how I set it. And trying to use Nero to produce a normal MP3 disc didn't work either. Also, FWIW, our home DVD player will not play the successful test disc, although it will play MP3 files I've burned onto a CD!
Many thanks to all who contributed to my success, particularly John, Oslo and Kerryburn. Couldn't have done it without ya!
My nightmare with all these electronics is that one day we will all start to experience electrical problems. It doesn't take anything more then an errant spark or a short to cofuse the management system and then all kinds of stupid things can happen.
Ok, buddy. If that is true, you have a lemon and should get it replaced. NO FAILURE ON THE COMMAND UNIT WILL SHUT THE CAR OFF! Not even safe mode. The worst that can happen is to have the electricals redirected to vital organs only (i.e. car runs). LOL!!!
Anyhow,
DVDs work for sure in the single slot. DO NOT USE THE DOUBLE DENSITY AS THEY ARE TOO THICK!
I use Microsoft Windows XP, and simply copy the .mp3 files to the DVD, and tell it to "burn" as a data disk. All works well. It does not like folders inside of folders, but it does pull the inside folders out. Let me explain that. I placed 2 folders (each an album) inside of a single folder (artist's name). I also happenned to place some random .mp3s from that artist into the top layer folder. The car showed it as three folders. Kinda odd, but now I've learned.
As far as how many it can read and compression rates, I am still investigating. I am having no issues w/ bit rates over 300, but I do notice a little delay in response at times (from the unit). Guess it has something to do with buffering, dunno.
I wish someone would do a nice writeup of this feature and the full facts behind it. It really is awesome to have so many hours of music on one disk. I am only at about 50 folders, but man it is awesome!
I've been reading many posts on this topic and they (for the most part) have been quite helpful.
Just a data point, I have a 2005 E500 (build date 5/04) and have found out the following after playing around quite a bit...
1) CD player in HU plays MP3 CDs AND DVDs.
2) I can play MP3 CDs in the 6-disk changer.
3) I can do the 5-3-7 trick, and see the menus.
3a) Using the above trick, I was not able to get the CD/DVD player in the HU to recognize a DVD movie like some have.
As a side note, for music I experimented with burning MP3 files to +RW DVD media (Verbatim) and it works everytime for me. Not only did/does this save a lot of money (coasters), I can change the songs after a while and not have to keep burning new DVDs.
Oh, one last thing... My documentation for Command nor the owners manual does not say anything about MP3 playback. I can't believe this, as this is a tremendous feature. If anyone has a link to the latest COMMAND documentation, I'd greatly appreciate it.
GL all,
Tom
To get the Brit chick to talk to you there is another "secret" menu that I got into once but can't remember the keystokes. If there is any ambitious people out there that want to try it I do remember getting into it while first attempting to get into the 3-5-7 menu and hit that menu by accident. I think I was pressing the NAV and MAP buttons as well. This menu gave me the option to choose the language (English - UK) or something to that effect which gave me a nice British-accented navigator. I didn't let the COMAND reboot so the changes didn't stick but I definitely heard her speak after I made the changes.
1) I have no idea what you are doing wrong. Spaces should not be a problem.
2) The manual says that the CDC will only list and play the first 99 tracks/folders.
3) The 357 trick on the '05 does not have W211-ECE for a model, only for the keyboard, which means nothing will change. This has been discussed in this forum a million times.
3a) The '05 does not come with the necessary hardware (most notably, a video decoder chip). There is no way you will be able to view DVD's unless you replace the entire head unit. This has been discussed more than anything else in this forum.






