Dealer vs Indy shop's Service B pricing...
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 308
Likes: 22
From: Houston TX
2015 E400
Dealer vs Indy shop's Service B pricing...
Just received a coupon special for the local MB dealership service dept for $399 MB Service B.
Looking at our upcoming 40k Service B needed services, I called my local Indy shop, who has been doing great services for most of our family vehicles over the years. He quoted the fol prices:
$20 Oil & filter change service, I bring in Mobil 1 & MB filter (approx $50)
$35 Cabin dust filter change
$80 Brake Fluid change, DOT 4 synthetic
$20 Wiper Blades change
So for approx $200, I can have my Indy shop do all the work for half the price of the Dealer's, probably more, since Dealer always tack on lots of BS services, taxes & fees to the bottom line on top the "Starting at $399" coupon price & "since yours is an E400...".
Indy shop is a block away from my office, so I can walk to drop off & pick up, but don't get MB Dealership's fancy coffee....
Thoughts...?
Looking at our upcoming 40k Service B needed services, I called my local Indy shop, who has been doing great services for most of our family vehicles over the years. He quoted the fol prices:
$20 Oil & filter change service, I bring in Mobil 1 & MB filter (approx $50)
$35 Cabin dust filter change
$80 Brake Fluid change, DOT 4 synthetic
$20 Wiper Blades change
So for approx $200, I can have my Indy shop do all the work for half the price of the Dealer's, probably more, since Dealer always tack on lots of BS services, taxes & fees to the bottom line on top the "Starting at $399" coupon price & "since yours is an E400...".
Indy shop is a block away from my office, so I can walk to drop off & pick up, but don't get MB Dealership's fancy coffee....
Thoughts...?
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 1,190
Likes: 68
From: Charlotte, NC
2014 E350 4M Diamond Silver
Just received a coupon special for the local MB dealership service dept for $399 MB Service B.
Looking at our upcoming 40k Service B needed services, I called my local Indy shop, who has been doing great services for most of our family vehicles over the years. He quoted the fol prices:
$20 Oil & filter change service, I bring in Mobil 1 & MB filter (approx $50)
$35 Cabin dust filter change
$80 Brake Fluid change, DOT 4 synthetic
$20 Wiper Blades change
So for approx $200, I can have my Indy shop do all the work for half the price of the Dealer's, probably more, since Dealer always tack on lots of BS services, taxes & fees to the bottom line on top the "Starting at $399" coupon price & "since yours is an E400...".
Indy shop is a block away from my office, so I can walk to drop off & pick up, but don't get MB Dealership's fancy coffee....
Thoughts...?
Looking at our upcoming 40k Service B needed services, I called my local Indy shop, who has been doing great services for most of our family vehicles over the years. He quoted the fol prices:
$20 Oil & filter change service, I bring in Mobil 1 & MB filter (approx $50)
$35 Cabin dust filter change
$80 Brake Fluid change, DOT 4 synthetic
$20 Wiper Blades change
So for approx $200, I can have my Indy shop do all the work for half the price of the Dealer's, probably more, since Dealer always tack on lots of BS services, taxes & fees to the bottom line on top the "Starting at $399" coupon price & "since yours is an E400...".
Indy shop is a block away from my office, so I can walk to drop off & pick up, but don't get MB Dealership's fancy coffee....
Thoughts...?
The 399$ package might not have brake fluid change - please check with the SA once before scheduling - if you pick that route.
Dealer will give you a loaner vehicle if needed, however, if it is a discounted service, they might not honor loaner. YMMV.
I bought the 3-pack PPM for 1750, which is around 300$ cheaper if I price their Services separately (at the dealer). (One-A and One-B services left on this pack) Which usually covers few more additional to the Service packages the dealership put out.
You mentioned 40k service - meaning at 60k you may need to change sparkplugs and get transmission fluid changed (check your manual). Which will be extra cost than the B-service offered. So, does the 3-pack PPM purchase favors your situation which definitely comes with a loaner?
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 9,224
Likes: 1,798
From: V E G A S
1922 Ford Model T / no OBD
My local dealer also serves donuts and bananas.
I think Service B covers with dealer more than you listed, but is your indy capable to check for software updates?
How about SCN coding if hidden code (no CEL) will require module replacement?
Than money spend at dealer gives you free roadside assistance.
How about carwash?
Lastly in case you run into a friend during visit, which place will make you look better?
Not saying it has to make sense to pay more at dealer, but there is more than meets the eye.
Consider that last time I was at dealer's for service was about year 1999, when I had new car and I DIY everything I can. MB Service was $78 at the time...
I think Service B covers with dealer more than you listed, but is your indy capable to check for software updates?
How about SCN coding if hidden code (no CEL) will require module replacement?
Than money spend at dealer gives you free roadside assistance.
How about carwash?
Lastly in case you run into a friend during visit, which place will make you look better?
Not saying it has to make sense to pay more at dealer, but there is more than meets the eye.
Consider that last time I was at dealer's for service was about year 1999, when I had new car and I DIY everything I can. MB Service was $78 at the time...
Last edited by kajtek1; Feb 27, 2020 at 02:42 PM.
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 308
Likes: 22
From: Houston TX
2015 E400
I'm out of orig factory warranty, but still under extended warranty for another 2 yrs.
However, how does overpaying at the dealer affects the warranty, if we follow the exact same services schedule?
However, how does overpaying at the dealer affects the warranty, if we follow the exact same services schedule?
Super Member
Joined: Nov 2014
Posts: 545
Likes: 230
From: Toronto & California
2015 ML400 4MATIC, 2016 C300 4MATIC, 2014 E350 4MATIC (Totaled), 2006 E350 (Sold)
Servicing at the dealer can give you some goodwill in the future, if something were to go wrong. such as maybe your seat ripping. But in general, i’d just service else where unless you plan to sell you car soon, it just looks good in the records to have it serviced by mercedes. As long as you trust your indy mechanic, then i’d just go there. done. case closed lol
Trending Topics
Super Member
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 737
Likes: 60
From: HESPERIA CA
2011 E550
Originally Posted by NickTH
I'm out of orig factory warranty, but still under extended warranty for another 2 yrs.
However, how does overpaying at the dealer affects the warranty, if we follow the exact same services schedule?
However, how does overpaying at the dealer affects the warranty, if we follow the exact same services schedule?
Well incase anything happens to the engine down the line, there's a paper trail at the dealer. They can't blame it on anyone else but the service techs they trained.
If you get your oil changed at the Indy, and anything goes wrong, they can absolutely point the finger and say the Indy didn't do something right, despite you having evidence. At that point it would be between you and your Indy.
Think of it this way, it's 200 dollars more, but they give you a rental, which easily is a 60-80 dollar a day car/value. And it usually takes two days to service your car, so you're gonna be paying only an extra 40-80 dollars for the piece of mind and complete and utter immunity from Mercedes denying you coverage if anything goes wrong in the future.
Unless you tuned your car or something, then you might as well go to the Indy lol.
I'm just giving you a heads up, don't think im discouraging you from getting it done by your Indy. If you trust them, and they know what they are doing, you'll be just fine.
MB World Stories
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Manual Mercedes? 6 Times Sindelfingen Let Drivers Have All The Fun
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes SLR McLaren 722 S Is Extremely Rare Example Modified by McLaren
Verdad Gallardo
8 Classic Boxy Mercedes Designs That Have Aged Like Fine Wine
Verdad Gallardo
Flawlessly Restored Mercedes 190E Evo II Heads to Auction
Verdad Gallardo
Electric Mercedes C-Class Unveiled: 11 Things You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes EQS Gets A Major Update: Everything You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
5 Underrated Mercedes-Benz Models That Don't Get the Love They Deserve
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes 300D Has Pushed Well Past 1 Million Miles and It Ain't Stopping
Verdad Gallardo
10 Most Reliable Mercedes-Benz Models You Can Buy Used
Verdad Gallardo
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 6,190
Likes: 1,549
From: MA
2008 E350 4Matic, 2011 E350 4matic
If you trust and know this Indy shop, I don't see why not.
The 399$ package might not have brake fluid change - please check with the SA once before scheduling - if you pick that route.
Dealer will give you a loaner vehicle if needed, however, if it is a discounted service, they might not honor loaner. YMMV.
I bought the 3-pack PPM for 1750, which is around 300$ cheaper if I price their Services separately (at the dealer). (One-A and One-B services left on this pack) Which usually covers few more additional to the Service packages the dealership put out.
You mentioned 40k service - meaning at 60k you may need to change sparkplugs and get transmission fluid changed (check your manual). Which will be extra cost than the B-service offered. So, does the 3-pack PPM purchase favors your situation which definitely comes with a loaner?
The 399$ package might not have brake fluid change - please check with the SA once before scheduling - if you pick that route.
Dealer will give you a loaner vehicle if needed, however, if it is a discounted service, they might not honor loaner. YMMV.
I bought the 3-pack PPM for 1750, which is around 300$ cheaper if I price their Services separately (at the dealer). (One-A and One-B services left on this pack) Which usually covers few more additional to the Service packages the dealership put out.
You mentioned 40k service - meaning at 60k you may need to change sparkplugs and get transmission fluid changed (check your manual). Which will be extra cost than the B-service offered. So, does the 3-pack PPM purchase favors your situation which definitely comes with a loaner?
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 1,190
Likes: 68
From: Charlotte, NC
2014 E350 4M Diamond Silver
I kinda agree that the 3 pack is probably a good deal for the OP at this stage. The spark plugs and transmission fluid would be coming up. I think spark plugs at 60 and fluid at 70 and those two probably means you break even on going to the dealer vs the indy. Plus you get a loaner and the car wash. The dealer I go to also has a free breakfast/sandwich bar so way more amenities than the indy. Plus for entertainment, you can wander around the lot at the dealer looking at new models...
and adding to kajtek1,
if there are any recalls or something is not right, dealer might change it for free. You know, like faded wood trim pieces (they honored the ones on the dashboard in 2020. Yeah, its a 2014 vehicle.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 9,224
Likes: 1,798
From: V E G A S
1922 Ford Model T / no OBD
