Reliability of W213?
#26
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 2,581
Received 145 Likes
on
103 Posts
2010 E350 Luxury Sedan, Engine 272 (V6)
The new "C" Class has been rated very low in reliability, as has the new "S" Class.
Consumer Reports automobile issue comes out in April (actually in a couple of weeks), so you might want to see what it says. Just take it with several grains of salt.
As for electronics, such as navigation, audio, etc, the Asians have usually been way ahead of Germans. Germans do better on safety and performance though.
Consumer Reports automobile issue comes out in April (actually in a couple of weeks), so you might want to see what it says. Just take it with several grains of salt.
As for electronics, such as navigation, audio, etc, the Asians have usually been way ahead of Germans. Germans do better on safety and performance though.
#27
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,115
Received 3,323 Likes
on
2,057 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
The new "C" Class has been rated very low in reliability, as has the new "S" Class.
Consumer Reports automobile issue comes out in April (actually in a couple of weeks), so you might want to see what it says. Just take it with several grains of salt.
As for electronics, such as navigation, audio, etc, the Asians have usually been way ahead of Germans. Germans do better on safety and performance though.
Consumer Reports automobile issue comes out in April (actually in a couple of weeks), so you might want to see what it says. Just take it with several grains of salt.
As for electronics, such as navigation, audio, etc, the Asians have usually been way ahead of Germans. Germans do better on safety and performance though.
#28
Newbie
Thread Starter
You're funny.
Thank's for everyone's comments about their experiences. I really like what the W213 has to offer. I'll keep an eye on how the 2017 model performs.
I do realize there is a tradeoff here. I could go with a Lexus LS and get older technology that is very reliable, or go with a W213 that looks great and has cutting edge technology, but I need to make sure the dealership has a comfortable sofa.
#29
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 2,581
Received 145 Likes
on
103 Posts
2010 E350 Luxury Sedan, Engine 272 (V6)
Not wrong.
However, up until a few years ago, they reported reliability on E350 and E550 separately. Now they lump them together under E Class.
Problem with that is the E350 had above average reliability while E550 had below average.
CR has been very, very kind to luxury makes. Infiniti M series for years was rated very highly, as were the Lexus ES and LS. Audi rates very highly. New MB S Class rated very highly on their tests, but OWNERS reported many problems.
Same with Tesla (CR is obsessed with it), but the OWNERS reported significant reliability issues.
Ironically CR gave very high ratings to E Class W211. Then about 10 points lower for 2010 W212 and then rated it highly again a couple of years later when they rated the diesel version. The difference between the three: W211 was comfort suspension, 2010 was sports suspension and diesel was comfort suspension again.
They test cars for days or weeks and then let different staffers drive them for months and report.
Is CR totally objective and perfect? Absolutely not, but their information is at the top for what owners have actually experienced. They also require a minimum number of owner reports on each model for each year before they report the data.
For those interested, pick up a copy of the April issue. They also publish special issues on Used Cars and New Cars that contain reliability information.
I do not work for CR, but the OP wanted to know about reliability. CR is a good source for that.
Last edited by El Cid; 02-22-2016 at 02:32 PM.
#30
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 2,581
Received 145 Likes
on
103 Posts
2010 E350 Luxury Sedan, Engine 272 (V6)
The April (car) issue of CR is out. Once again they have changed the manner in which they rate cars. Also, they previously reported the V6 separately from V8 or just the V6 for reliability.
While there is a lot I disagree with in their information, it does make for interesting reading.
Of course, this only covers the W211 and W212 models. So W213 is an unknown.
For a good expectation, look at ratings for S and C classes as to how well MB does when rolling out a new model.
While there is a lot I disagree with in their information, it does make for interesting reading.
Of course, this only covers the W211 and W212 models. So W213 is an unknown.
For a good expectation, look at ratings for S and C classes as to how well MB does when rolling out a new model.
#31
Super Member
Consumer Reports stinks
Considering CR will show different ratings for the *exact same* appliance, with the only difference being the nameplate stuck on the front of it, their testing methodologies are utterly and completely worthless.
If they're too dumb to realize that two washing machines, refrigerators, or air conditioners are exactly the same design, exact same parts minus decorative trim, why on Earth would anyone trust them with something as complex as a car. Even a 1950s car, for that matter.
As to the W213, there WILL be problems. Guaranteed. The question is how quickly Mercedes comes up with a remedy AND will Mercedes ever bother to properly fix it or will they completely ignore it like the W212's transmission & AC stepper motors.
If they're too dumb to realize that two washing machines, refrigerators, or air conditioners are exactly the same design, exact same parts minus decorative trim, why on Earth would anyone trust them with something as complex as a car. Even a 1950s car, for that matter.
As to the W213, there WILL be problems. Guaranteed. The question is how quickly Mercedes comes up with a remedy AND will Mercedes ever bother to properly fix it or will they completely ignore it like the W212's transmission & AC stepper motors.
#32
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 2,581
Received 145 Likes
on
103 Posts
2010 E350 Luxury Sedan, Engine 272 (V6)
Not the same
Considering CR will show different ratings for the *exact same* appliance, with the only difference being the nameplate stuck on the front of it, their testing methodologies are utterly and completely worthless.
If they're too dumb to realize that two washing machines, refrigerators, or air conditioners are exactly the same design, exact same parts minus decorative trim, why on Earth would anyone trust them with something as complex as a car. Even a 1950s car, for that matter.
If they're too dumb to realize that two washing machines, refrigerators, or air conditioners are exactly the same design, exact same parts minus decorative trim, why on Earth would anyone trust them with something as complex as a car. Even a 1950s car, for that matter.
The difference between CR and other rating sites is that CR purchases the car outright, lets several employees drive is for about 2,000 miles and give their opinions and then they put on the test track and other evaluations.
CR does a more thorough evaluation of the vehicle than any other magazine or site out there. I have subscribed to or used all of them at one time or another.
Are they biased - absolutely, but still the most objective reviews and reports, especially regarding reliability. Their reliability, satisfaction, etc. reports come from actual owners - hundreds of thousands of them. Not from fanboys. Incidentally, I still question their "satisfaction" ratings, but it does come from owners.
You really need to pick up the April issue and read it thoroughly. Might add that the "E" Class is one of most highly spoken of cars in CR's reviews and reports.
If all you are interested in is 0-60, top end speeds, etc., there are plenty of magazines and websites that consider that as the holy grail and ignore the rest.
Happy Motoring (and redaing)!
#33
Super Member
I stand by what I said.
...and I've seen this pattern repeatedly with CR over the past 20 years. Not just once, repeatedly.
Maybe they mention the similarities with cars. I doubt they have ever mentioned that the Mercedes V6 "350" engine is shared w/Chrysler. Or that up until ~2014, the US E350 *was* using Chrysler parts. Since they're using the same part, the reliability should be similar. They're not according to CR.
When CR's ratings repeatedly don't mirror what I'm seeing in insurance claims, repair techs/mechanics' reports, and sales feedback, I question the validity of their methodology.
There are some people who are quite fans of CR. I'm not one of them.
...and I've seen this pattern repeatedly with CR over the past 20 years. Not just once, repeatedly.
Maybe they mention the similarities with cars. I doubt they have ever mentioned that the Mercedes V6 "350" engine is shared w/Chrysler. Or that up until ~2014, the US E350 *was* using Chrysler parts. Since they're using the same part, the reliability should be similar. They're not according to CR.
When CR's ratings repeatedly don't mirror what I'm seeing in insurance claims, repair techs/mechanics' reports, and sales feedback, I question the validity of their methodology.
There are some people who are quite fans of CR. I'm not one of them.
#34
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 2,581
Received 145 Likes
on
103 Posts
2010 E350 Luxury Sedan, Engine 272 (V6)
I am not a fan of CR. In fact, I vehemently disagree with their giving advice on which medications people should and should not take, but that is another issue. Also, disagree with their road test review and rating for Tesla S.
In what capactity do you see insurance claims, repair reports and sales feedback? Also, how much of it?
CR surveys hundreds of thousands of vehicle owners for their actual personal experiences.
While Chrysler and MB V6 may have "shared parts," more likely they were MB parts or manufactured to MB specs under DaimlerChrysler. Also, even if using the same parts, reliability is based on the entire component - not just pieces of it. Assembly would also factor greatly into reliability. Reliability should be the same if the entire component (engine, trans, etc.) and components it linked to were exactly the same. Doubt this is the case between Chrysler and MB products.
"Since they're using the same part, the reliability should be similar. They're not according to CR." Are you referring to overall reliability of the brand, a particular model or a specific component/system?
How many parts does MB "share" with Audi, BMW, VW, etc.? I had a Saab once and the dealership also sold BMW's. Service tech told me that many of the parts were exactly the same and had the same problems.
Considering your other posts re: your vehicle, seems you might have concerns about reliability of MB. Do you think it is rated too highly by CR?
As I implied in the beginning, CR is a source that is out there for anyone with questions about reliability.
In what capactity do you see insurance claims, repair reports and sales feedback? Also, how much of it?
CR surveys hundreds of thousands of vehicle owners for their actual personal experiences.
While Chrysler and MB V6 may have "shared parts," more likely they were MB parts or manufactured to MB specs under DaimlerChrysler. Also, even if using the same parts, reliability is based on the entire component - not just pieces of it. Assembly would also factor greatly into reliability. Reliability should be the same if the entire component (engine, trans, etc.) and components it linked to were exactly the same. Doubt this is the case between Chrysler and MB products.
"Since they're using the same part, the reliability should be similar. They're not according to CR." Are you referring to overall reliability of the brand, a particular model or a specific component/system?
How many parts does MB "share" with Audi, BMW, VW, etc.? I had a Saab once and the dealership also sold BMW's. Service tech told me that many of the parts were exactly the same and had the same problems.
Considering your other posts re: your vehicle, seems you might have concerns about reliability of MB. Do you think it is rated too highly by CR?
As I implied in the beginning, CR is a source that is out there for anyone with questions about reliability.
#35
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southeastern USA
Posts: 2,581
Received 145 Likes
on
103 Posts
2010 E350 Luxury Sedan, Engine 272 (V6)
Just for reference, I checked my work orders since I got my W212 in Nov. 2009. There have been 13 repairs, updates, etc. Most were done during routine servicing, but two took three days and one took two days. All done as part of warranty.
There are six electronic gremlins that have never been resolved, but they went away-so far. The familiar No Problem Found or Unable to Duplicate.
There are six electronic gremlins that have never been resolved, but they went away-so far. The familiar No Problem Found or Unable to Duplicate.
#36
Newbie
Join Date: Apr 2017
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
MY2017 16 Mercedes Benz E Class
Ownership experience
In 2011 we bought the 2011 Mercedes Benz e class cabriolet and absolutely no problems. Perfect car all round except we've got 5 in a family, the cab only has 4 seats. As Mercedes had just launched the facelift of te e class saloon, I thought why not upgrade. Turned out to be horrible. Within the first 6 months it had been in for repairs about 3-4 times with the same problem. The engine wouldn't change gear. The car would just keep revving even if you only had the accelerate slightly pressed. In any circumstance the engine would just rev and rev and even red line and bounce of the red line for about a minute before changing gears. Only way to solve it was to drive in manual mode, losing the comfort we wanted of an auto box. First time it went it. They said it was a small part needed changing. Next time was engine was rebuilt. Next time was engine and transmission was rebuil and the next time was the engine changed. The time after was the engine and transmission was changed. When it goes in for about 2 weeks and they give u cars that are a hassle to get and a hassle to give back and they give a c class instead an e class. I'm not too bothered but mum n dad weren't happy. They're the main drivers and I just take it every now and then. After that we just left it as well as still having the problem but not as bad and not as regular. After the 3 years mark we decided to upgrade and dad, against what I recommended, bought another e class. Had no problems with it until the other day where it just wouldn't start. You'd press the on button and it would switch the accessories on and that was it. Only until we all got out of the car, locked it and then started again. Then on the way home Id press the accelerator and the engine would just rev and the car wouldn't move. Almost as if the clutch was slipping. So time to call MB up to see what they say. I just realised that this is a lot longer than I expected. Sorry about that
#38
Newbie
Join Date: Apr 2017
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
MY2017 16 Mercedes Benz E Class
#39
In contrast my wife has a 2015 C300 that has had 2 breakdowns and multiple repairs during routine maintenance.
It's literally a joke to say the Lexus is a less reliable car, especially the front wheel drive ES. No credibility whatsoever. MB can't touch Lexus in reliability. Fun to drive and prestige may be a different thing, but a Lexus with a 2GR-FE V6 is a tank that will run reliably for decades.
Last edited by Guineas; 05-24-2017 at 07:40 PM.
#40
Just to chime in - I had a 2008 Lexus ES300 for 12 years, and it had given me zero problems. My next car, a 2010 Lexus GX460, was a different story. Just after the warranty period ended (4 years), a power lock motor had failed. Like, those things are not supposed to fail after 4 years! A few months later, an engine part had failed and got the car into limp mode. The part cost $2000CAD to fix!! Just 2 months ago, the suspension system had failed, and would cost over $3000CAD to have it replaced. I got so freaked that didn't even think about getting another Lexus! So are all Lexus vehicles reliable? I would say not; it depends on the model of the vehicle. Are all German cars not as reliable as Japanese cars? No - again, it depends on the model of the car.
#41
MBWorld Fanatic!
I've been driving a 2004 Lexus ES330 since I bought it new 12 years ago. I'm considering handing it over to my 16yr old daughter next summer. I really like the new W213.
Given that I've lived with a hassle free car for a dozen years, I'm a little worried, and I'm interested in your opinions as experienced MB owners, what the reliability of the 2017 W213 E-class might be.
Opinions?
I was previously interested in the new C-class, W205, but there are way too many horror stories over on the W205 forum about that car.
Given that I've lived with a hassle free car for a dozen years, I'm a little worried, and I'm interested in your opinions as experienced MB owners, what the reliability of the 2017 W213 E-class might be.
Opinions?
I was previously interested in the new C-class, W205, but there are way too many horror stories over on the W205 forum about that car.
#42
I currently drive a 2014 Lexus GS350 F-Sport. The 2GR-FSE is a fabulous motor, good low-end torque for a NA V6 and it is silent and vibration free. With that being said, the 2GR-FSE is a 12 year old design. However, the ride and handling compromise is excellent, I chose it over the BMW F10 on this reason alone.
However, the electronics are antiquated. The haptic mouse input system is terrible. My wife's Audi with Google maps and a Nvidia GPU is 10 years ahead of the Lexus.
Sure, the Lexus will most likely be more reliable, but it is using antiquated technology to do so.
However, the electronics are antiquated. The haptic mouse input system is terrible. My wife's Audi with Google maps and a Nvidia GPU is 10 years ahead of the Lexus.
Sure, the Lexus will most likely be more reliable, but it is using antiquated technology to do so.
#43
W213 made on late 2016
The W213 made on late 2016 are very unreliable.
Maybe models made on late 2017 will be better, but on the moment they are really buggy.
My W213 220d AMG kit.
Motor problems.. consumes oil.. 1 liter avery 10K miles
Suspensions problems... makes noise and vibrarios on the wheels.. this is a chronic problema for 19" Wheels
Internal noises on dashbooard.. rantles and squeachs on hot weather
The trunk is missalined and is dificult to close.
MB solved the trunk problem, and tried to skip repairs on motor and suspension problems.
Recomendation.. skip the AMG styling versions.
Skip new OM654 motor
Skip 19" and 20" wheels
Maybe models made on late 2017 will be better, but on the moment they are really buggy.
My W213 220d AMG kit.
Motor problems.. consumes oil.. 1 liter avery 10K miles
Suspensions problems... makes noise and vibrarios on the wheels.. this is a chronic problema for 19" Wheels
Internal noises on dashbooard.. rantles and squeachs on hot weather
The trunk is missalined and is dificult to close.
MB solved the trunk problem, and tried to skip repairs on motor and suspension problems.
Recomendation.. skip the AMG styling versions.
Skip new OM654 motor
Skip 19" and 20" wheels
#44
MBWorld Fanatic!
The W213 made on late 2016 are very unreliable.
Maybe models made on late 2017 will be better, but on the moment they are really buggy.
My W213 220d AMG kit.
Motor problems.. consumes oil.. 1 liter avery 10K miles
Suspensions problems... makes noise and vibrarios on the wheels.. this is a chronic problema for 19" Wheels
Internal noises on dashbooard.. rantles and squeachs on hot weather
The trunk is missalined and is dificult to close.
MB solved the trunk problem, and tried to skip repairs on motor and suspension problems.
Recomendation.. skip the AMG styling versions.
Skip new OM654 motor
Skip 19" and 20" wheels
Maybe models made on late 2017 will be better, but on the moment they are really buggy.
My W213 220d AMG kit.
Motor problems.. consumes oil.. 1 liter avery 10K miles
Suspensions problems... makes noise and vibrarios on the wheels.. this is a chronic problema for 19" Wheels
Internal noises on dashbooard.. rantles and squeachs on hot weather
The trunk is missalined and is dificult to close.
MB solved the trunk problem, and tried to skip repairs on motor and suspension problems.
Recomendation.. skip the AMG styling versions.
Skip new OM654 motor
Skip 19" and 20" wheels
#45
Well when you get stuck on the side of the road, on a new car with just 4 months and 10K miles.. they don't think is funny. I didn't either.
On the previous model W212 the oil consuption was someting like an liter every 16K miles.. so I didn't have to refill between maintance services.
Now I travelled back in time to my old beatle with the traditional oil bottle in the trunk.
#46
MBWorld Fanatic!
Unlike my C400 my E43 arrived in flawless condition and has been flawless for its initial 4000 miles. My C had minor issues such as a partially non functional radio almost right out of the gate. My car is a 17. Knock on wood it will continue so. The E class has traditionally been the most reliable Benz but given that its a new model, all bets are off. It seems they have polished their act since its the last major model to get the "new" makeover.
#47
MBWorld Fanatic!
The W213 made on late 2016 are very unreliable.
Maybe models made on late 2017 will be better, but on the moment they are really buggy.
My W213 220d AMG kit.
Motor problems.. consumes oil.. 1 liter avery 10K miles
Suspensions problems... makes noise and vibrarios on the wheels.. this is a chronic problema for 19" Wheels
Internal noises on dashbooard.. rantles and squeachs on hot weather
The trunk is missalined and is dificult to close.
MB solved the trunk problem, and tried to skip repairs on motor and suspension problems.
Recomendation.. skip the AMG styling versions.
Skip new OM654 motor
Skip 19" and 20" wheels
Maybe models made on late 2017 will be better, but on the moment they are really buggy.
My W213 220d AMG kit.
Motor problems.. consumes oil.. 1 liter avery 10K miles
Suspensions problems... makes noise and vibrarios on the wheels.. this is a chronic problema for 19" Wheels
Internal noises on dashbooard.. rantles and squeachs on hot weather
The trunk is missalined and is dificult to close.
MB solved the trunk problem, and tried to skip repairs on motor and suspension problems.
Recomendation.. skip the AMG styling versions.
Skip new OM654 motor
Skip 19" and 20" wheels
So let me get this straight, based on the opinions and experiences with the one (1) vehicle you own you feel that it is correct to call the 2016 W213 unreliable?
Let me tell you this, we have sold hundreds of W213 since launch, some very early cars had their share of issues, all adressed with SB.s from Daimler,
since then the model has been truly solid and is very similar in reliability to the now well proven 205 series.
No vehicle is perfect, and remember to not use a brand forum to get an opinion on how good a car is by reading the comments alone, it is much easier to complain than to praise and it will not give a true picture of the vehicles quality.
#48
Super Member
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Boston 'burbs
Posts: 667
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
7 Posts
2018 E300 Lux, 2006 Corvette Z51, 2015 Mercedes ML350 (wife's)
Well when you get stuck on the side of the road, on a new car with just 4 months and 10K miles.. they don't think is funny. I didn't either.
On the previous model W212 the oil consuption was someting like an liter every 16K miles.. so I didn't have to refill between maintance services.
Now I travelled back in time to my old beatle with the traditional oil bottle in the trunk.
On the previous model W212 the oil consuption was someting like an liter every 16K miles.. so I didn't have to refill between maintance services.
Now I travelled back in time to my old beatle with the traditional oil bottle in the trunk.
#49
MBWorld Fanatic!
If you have 10,000 miles on the vehicle, oil level should be perfect because 10,000 miles is when the A Service is due. It sounds like the vehicle is not being maintained according to the required maintenance schedule.