New Tire with 3 "OK" Tires, shop told me I need to buy 3 new tires
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Feb 2024
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
From: DFW Texas
2022 E450 Wagon
New Tire with 3 "OK" Tires, shop told me I need to buy 3 new tires
I got a flat recently by blowing out the sidewall on my RF in a pothole. When I got the new tire on my front driver side i took it into a local shop to have it realigned bc it was pulling slight right. The shop owner informed me that since I have an ALL WHEEL Drive that the other 3 tires need to be replaced or else I'll damage my drive train.The 3 other tires still have plenty of life left in them to get another 10K miles or so. I've heard of mechanics saying this before but have found it to be some BS. I've owned many other all wheel drive vehicles and have replaced 1 tire due to damage and never had a problem with the drive train getting damaged. They did realign my car since it was off.
All 4 of my tires are the same brand and tread pattern . Is this some BS or is this some concern?
My plan was to buy some aftermarket rims and switch to non rf's and go for a square setup. Currently my E450 wagon has a staggered set up right now.
All 4 of my tires are the same brand and tread pattern . Is this some BS or is this some concern?
My plan was to buy some aftermarket rims and switch to non rf's and go for a square setup. Currently my E450 wagon has a staggered set up right now.
Last edited by DadWagon450; Feb 26, 2024 at 03:29 PM.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 3,048
Likes: 905
From: Long Island, NY
2019 E 450, 2016 E350 4matic (retired), 2018 Ford Edge Sport, 2008 Porsche Boxster
I got a flat recently by blowing out the sidewall on my RF in a pothole. When I got the new tire on my front driver side i took it into a local shop to have it realigned bc it was pulling slight right. The shop owner informed me that since I have an ALL WHEEL Drive that the other 3 tires need to be replaced or else I'll damage my drive train.The 3 other tires still have plenty of life left in them to get another 10K miles or so. I've heard of mechanics saying this before but have found it to be some BS. I've owned many other all wheel drive vehicles and have replaced 1 tire due to damage and never had a problem with the drive train getting damaged. They did realign my car since it was off.
All 4 of my tires are the same brand and tread pattern . Is this some BS or is this some concern?
My plan was to buy some aftermarket rims and switch to non rf's and go for a square setup. Currently my E450 wagon has a staggered set up right now.
All 4 of my tires are the same brand and tread pattern . Is this some BS or is this some concern?
My plan was to buy some aftermarket rims and switch to non rf's and go for a square setup. Currently my E450 wagon has a staggered set up right now.
But here is the reality: a new tire will have between 9/32 and 10/32 of tread life. A tire with 10,000 miles left probably about 6/32 of tread life left. That difference, 3/32 is miniscule. It is less than than the difference between 30 psi vs. 35 psi.
Just my $.02. Hope it helps.
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Feb 2024
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
From: DFW Texas
2022 E450 Wagon
That was my same exact thoughts, just needed some backup. In practice in the real world, I’ve never heard of someone damaging their drivetrain on a new tire where the other 3 tires are used and all are the same tire. I haven’t seen this in forums as well
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Oct 2018
Posts: 1,430
Likes: 820
From: Florida
2018 AMG E43
Agreed, you are both thinking correctly. Modern AWD systems are not that sensitive and fragile even though many keep repeating these old wives tales.
It's absolute BS and perpetuated to sell more tires, it's an AWD gravy train of tire sales.
If you think about it, if what they are saying is true, most automotive forums and most garages would be full of broken AWD cars and trucks because of mismatched tires, but it just flat-out doesn't happen.
It's absolute BS and perpetuated to sell more tires, it's an AWD gravy train of tire sales.
If you think about it, if what they are saying is true, most automotive forums and most garages would be full of broken AWD cars and trucks because of mismatched tires, but it just flat-out doesn't happen.
Senior Member
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 383
Likes: 89
From: SW Desert USA
2014 Jag F-Type vert, 2004 Volvo V70R
Remember, it is an industry based on larceny, and the larceny starts with the dealers. I had one suggest I replace all the tires because they were over seven years old. Michelin pilot sports with maybe 25,000 miles on them. The car is only used seasonally. When the dealer wants your money, it is better to always say no and then work from there.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 3,048
Likes: 905
From: Long Island, NY
2019 E 450, 2016 E350 4matic (retired), 2018 Ford Edge Sport, 2008 Porsche Boxster
Remember, it is an industry based on larceny, and the larceny starts with the dealers. I had one suggest I replace all the tires because they were over seven years old. Michelin pilot sports with maybe 25,000 miles on them. The car is only used seasonally. When the dealer wants your money, it is better to always say no and then work from there.
Never ask a barber if you need a haircut
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Nov 2014
Posts: 5,376
Likes: 1,104
.
Remember, it is an industry based on larceny, and the larceny starts with the dealers. I had one suggest I replace all the tires because they were over seven years old. Michelin pilot sports with maybe 25,000 miles on them. The car is only used seasonally. When the dealer wants your money, it is better to always say no and then work from there.
Last edited by ua549; Feb 27, 2024 at 09:20 AM.
