GLE or Cayenne?



I'd been planning to buy the new 2024 Cayenne E-Hybrid (with 26-kWh battery pack) for a long time (it's still not out yet in the US due to chip issues), when I heard last October about the 2024 GLE 450e via a Kyle Conner electric-range-test video. I'd never considered Mercedes before because I just don't like how they look and have heard nothing but bad things about MB reliability. But that video showing 68 miles of all-electric range in city driving (< 40 mph) really caught my eye, along with the DC fast charging (unique to PHEVs on sale today). So that started months of my looking closely at the GLE 450e and doing about eight test drives (so far) at a half-dozen MB dealerships in my area.
Things that I like about the 450e over the E-Hybrid besides the better electric range and DC-fast-charging: (1) it's about $25k USD cheaper as I'd spec them both; (2) I like the track pad a lot; (3) I like the matte-black surfaces in the 450e (vs. fingerprint-prone, glare-prone "piano black" surfaces inside the Cayenne). Those are some very important things for me. Things I like better in the E-Hybrid over the 450e: (1) can option many more things (stuff I'd option are: infrared night-vision camera; all-metal roof; compass/clock on dashboard; heated windshield; can order no chrome on the exterior, including badging); (2) larger gas tank; (3) better appearance (to me, looks less like a minivan); (4) better stability at speed; (5) no fake exhaust tips; (6) drive-mode control dial on steering wheel; (7) much-better gear switcher (on dashboard instead of on a stalk coming out of the steering wheel); (8) can turn all exterior lights off when car is on (can't in the 450e); (9) can charge the traction battery via the ICE (as most PHEVs can do but the 450e cannot do -- great for long roadtrips when you want all-electric driving in stop-and-go traffic and can't charge from an outlet/charger); (10) classier-looking instrument panel and infotainment screen.
If they cost the same money to buy, it'd be a no-brainer for me. But the 450e is still in the running (by a thread) for me because of its being so much cheaper to buy.
Last edited by cometguy; Feb 23, 2024 at 01:00 PM.







I'd been planning to buy the new 2024 Cayenne E-Hybrid (with 26-kWh battery pack) for a long time (it's still not out yet in the US due to chip issues), when I heard last October about the 2024 GLE 450e via a Kyle Conner electric-range-test video. I'd never considered Mercedes before because I just don't like how they look and have heard nothing but bad things about MB reliability. But that video showing 68 miles of all-electric range in city driving (< 40 mph) really caught my eye, along with the DC fast charging (unique to PHEVs on sale today). So that started months of my looking closely at the GLE 450e and doing about eight test drives (so far) at a half-dozen MB dealerships in my area.
Things that I like about the 450e over the E-Hybrid besides the better electric range and DC-fast-charging: (1) it's about $25k USD cheaper as I'd spec them both; (2) I like the track pad a lot; (3) I like the matte-black surfaces in the 450e (vs. fingerprint-prone, glare-prone "piano black" surfaces inside the Cayenne). Those are some very important things for me. Things I like better in the E-Hybrid over the 450e: (1) can option many more things (stuff I'd option are: infrared night-vision camera; all-metal roof; compass/clock on dashboard; heated windshield; can order no chrome on the exterior, including badging); (2) larger gas tank; (3) better appearance (to me, looks less like a minivan); (4) better stability at speed; (5) no fake exhaust tips; (6) drive-mode control dial on steering wheel; (7) much-better gear switcher (on dashboard instead of on a stalk coming out of the steering wheel); (8) can turn all exterior lights off when car is on (can't in the 450e); (9) can charge the traction battery via the ICE (as most PHEVs can do but the 450e cannot do -- great for long roadtrips when you want all-electric driving in stop-and-go traffic and can't charge from an outlet/charger); (10) classier-looking instrument panel and infotainment screen.
If they cost the same money to buy, it'd be a no-brainer for me. But the 450e is still in the running (by a thread) for me because of its being so much cheaper to buy.
Don't buy a car you dislike.
You'll kick yourself every time you see the Mercedes in your garage. 😡
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
I'd been planning to buy the new 2024 Cayenne E-Hybrid (with 26-kWh battery pack) for a long time (it's still not out yet in the US due to chip issues), when I heard last October about the 2024 GLE 450e via a Kyle Conner electric-range-test video. I'd never considered Mercedes before because I just don't like how they look and have heard nothing but bad things about MB reliability. But that video showing 68 miles of all-electric range in city driving (< 40 mph) really caught my eye, along with the DC fast charging (unique to PHEVs on sale today). So that started months of my looking closely at the GLE 450e and doing about eight test drives (so far) at a half-dozen MB dealerships in my area.
Things that I like about the 450e over the E-Hybrid besides the better electric range and DC-fast-charging: (1) it's about $25k USD cheaper as I'd spec them both; (2) I like the track pad a lot; (3) I like the matte-black surfaces in the 450e (vs. fingerprint-prone, glare-prone "piano black" surfaces inside the Cayenne). Those are some very important things for me. Things I like better in the E-Hybrid over the 450e: (1) can option many more things (stuff I'd option are: infrared night-vision camera; all-metal roof; compass/clock on dashboard; heated windshield; can order no chrome on the exterior, including badging); (2) larger gas tank; (3) better appearance (to me, looks less like a minivan); (4) better stability at speed; (5) no fake exhaust tips; (6) drive-mode control dial on steering wheel; (7) much-better gear switcher (on dashboard instead of on a stalk coming out of the steering wheel); (8) can turn all exterior lights off when car is on (can't in the 450e); (9) can charge the traction battery via the ICE (as most PHEVs can do but the 450e cannot do -- great for long roadtrips when you want all-electric driving in stop-and-go traffic and can't charge from an outlet/charger); (10) classier-looking instrument panel and infotainment screen.
If they cost the same money to buy, it'd be a no-brainer for me. But the 450e is still in the running (by a thread) for me because of its being so much cheaper to buy.
From my side, I was looking at X5, GLE and Cayenne, money did matter but wasn't a deciding factor. I'll spare this thread from X5 talk and focus on 2024 Cayenne...
1. The gear shifter, it's usable but Mercedes style was just better for me. After a decade of shifting at the center console, MB style shifter grew on me after just a few days of driving, it's intuitive and just works IMHO.
2. Interior buttons that weren't real buttons or even normal sensor panels. For whatever reason, somebody decided that making the whole blocks (areas with multiple buttons) move up and down was a good idea. It felt incredibly weird and cheap.
3. Infotainment system felt dated and reminded me some cheaper vanilla Android tablets, the one that used native design with no skins.
4. I learned from Rennlist users that they moved garage opener control to the infotainment system when it's more tricky to operate, it doesn't always automatically pop up, can't access it in reverse etc. It may seem like a small thing but my wife's approval factor would be affected severely by it. It's annoying for me too.
5. Comparable specs would end up about 15-20k more expensive than Mercedes vehicles.
6. Somewhat common complaint about water ingress into vehicle from clogged drains.
None of the items above are critical by any means but it just didn't feel like "my next car".
Last edited by stktyz33; Feb 23, 2024 at 03:33 PM.


2) I don’t understand the aversion to “fake exhaust tips? It’s not like it’s an exotic sports car. I’m just happy not to have to clean exhaust residue off exposed pipes.
3) I don’t drive enough to worry about mileage; I don’t want a car that has a complicated power train (e.g., PHEV, EV, E-Hybrid...) -- My 450 with Mild-Hybrid is complicated enough and my other ride is a Hemi with no turbos or superchargers -- simple.
I don't recall seeing this on Rennlist. Are you referring to 955/957 or 958?

Touareg story: I’m standing in the Service Line at the VW dealership in Alexandria, VA and this “government” guy behind me says, “You know the name Touareg comes from a nomadic tribe in the Sahara Desert; I spent time with them.” So I asked, “Did you work for some NGO?” With a slight grin he said, “Something like that.” Ten years later I’m sitting in a meeting at Bagram AB, Afghanistan. There’s a female in civilian clothes sitting next to me. I ask her, “Are you with an NGO?” She replies, “No, OGO” (Other Governmental Organization). And I thought, I’m so naive; I bet she works for the same organization as the "Touareg guy."
Last edited by HDLBRG; Feb 23, 2024 at 10:38 PM.

In a Consumer Reports review (link below) the GLE was ranked the lowest in reliability for all luxury SUVs; however, that has not been my experience, either.
Likewise, According to repairpal.com (link below) Cayenne owners had to visit their dealership 1.1 times per year for problems compared to a .6 times per year average for all luxury SUVs they reviewed. Of the 14 SUVs reviewed, the Cayenne ranked last; Lexus was ranked #1. Would that alone convince me to buy a Lexus? No.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2021/11/18/consumer-reports-most-reliable-cars-trucks-suvs/6385214001/?gps-source=AFPTNRIDN121977&utm_source=impact&utm_mediu m=affiliate&utm_campaign=121977&utm_content=116426 3&irclickid=y8ZRjsVQkxyPT0szCtwHszDtUkH16P3hp3iyXc 0&irgwc=1
https://repairpal.com/reliability/porsche/cayenne
Last edited by HDLBRG; Feb 24, 2024 at 07:51 AM.
In a Consumer Reports review (link below) the GLE was ranked the lowest in reliability for all luxury SUVs; however, that has not been my experience, either.
Likewise, According to repairpal.com (link below) Cayenne owners had to visit their dealership 1.1 times per year for problems compared to a .6 times per year average for all luxury SUVs they reviewed. Of the 14 SUVs reviewed, the Cayenne ranked last; Lexus was ranked #1. Would that alone convince me to buy a Lexus? No.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2021/11/18/consumer-reports-most-reliable-cars-trucks-suvs/6385214001/?gps-source=AFPTNRIDN121977&utm_source=impact&utm_mediu m=affiliate&utm_campaign=121977&utm_content=116426 3&irclickid=y8ZRjsVQkxyPT0szCtwHszDtUkH16P3hp3iyXc 0&irgwc=1
https://repairpal.com/reliability/porsche/cayenne
https://www.jdpower.com/business/pre...lity-study-vds
Why not 15 test drives? I drive a car a lot before I buy it, not a small decision for me.




They are "satisfaction surveys," wondering if the shift stalk is In a good place, or if the radio sounds good.
The reliability part comes after three years, and nobody pays attention.
The "Satisfaction Surveys" are click bait.
In a Consumer Reports review (link below) the GLE was ranked the lowest in reliability for all luxury SUVs; however, that has not been my experience, either.
Likewise, According to repairpal.com (link below) Cayenne owners had to visit their dealership 1.1 times per year for problems compared to a .6 times per year average for all luxury SUVs they reviewed. Of the 14 SUVs reviewed, the Cayenne ranked last; Lexus was ranked #1. Would that alone convince me to buy a Lexus? No.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2021/11/18/consumer-reports-most-reliable-cars-trucks-suvs/6385214001/?gps-source=AFPTNRIDN121977&utm_source=impact&utm_mediu m=affiliate&utm_campaign=121977&utm_content=116426 3&irclickid=y8ZRjsVQkxyPT0szCtwHszDtUkH16P3hp3iyXc 0&irgwc=1
https://repairpal.com/reliability/porsche/cayenne
How much time have you spent on rennlist reading owners’ experiences and posting questions of your own?




You have to subscribe to see the disclaimer that their "reliability" ratings are just guesses, not based on actual data. You actually have to pay!
Rennlist is a much less useful forum than this one.
Mostly complaints about not being able to get green piping on orange seats or similar sources of anger.




Actually, pretty much all Porsche models have lots of complaints on Rennlist.
Kind of like any Auto Forum. People with problems, posting.






