Bad battery or alternator ?
Last edited by Mmr1; Today at 10:46 AM.
Apparently you do so let’s take a look behind the curtain and welcome to OZ.
Mercedes has picked a state of charge that they believe is the best for us and it isn’t necessarily 100%.
I can see that the voltage output of the Alternator is switching between charging and off. If the START/STOP is enabled then it will do this. Also the Alternator may be turning on and off so that it is running when decelerating or going down hill and then turning off when accelerating or climbing a hill.
To know what is really happening you need disable START/STOP and run a test with the cruise control on a flat section of highway.
The VOLTAGE DIP when starting looks good
The voltage at idle is slightly higher than the range that your app is looking for. The actual target voltage will vary depending on the temperature of the battery.
Based on your data I wouldn’t be concerned about the battery or the Alternator.
One test that I typically do beyond what you have already done is to load test the Alternator at idle.
Get a volt meter and measure the voltage at the battery and then start turning on loads: high beams, HVAC fan to high, heated seats. Rear defroster. The voltage will likely drop but it should get most of the way through the loads without dropping too much
good luck
Paul
PS thanks for sharing your data and let us know what you find out.
This data is from a post I made on a different forum 5 years ago
A4 2.0T_____10.64 Volts MFG --> April 2019
328i________10.20 Volts Original battery from 2015
Jetta 1.8T____10.53 Volts Original battery from 2015
S80_________10.52 Volts MFG --> May 2017
The 328i needed a replacement battery and the S80 also. I can’t remember if I changed the battery in the Jetta.
The LR2 is now in need of a new battery and I will replace it when I go to see my daughter in California in a few weeks.
take care
Paul
PS if you want to read that post here it is
VOLTAGE DIP
Last edited by p_gill; Today at 02:02 PM.













