Safety record for the 97' E320?
06-17-2002, 09:20 PM
#2
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Philadelphia area
Posts: 4,260
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
2010 ML550, 2010 E350 4M, 1966 Corvette Convt C2
Have never heard anything bad at all with regard to E Class safety. In fact have heard just the opposite. I believe my 01 E Class is extremely safe
06-18-2002, 02:20 AM
#3
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Vancouver Island, B.C. Canada
Posts: 1,377
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
2005 smart cabrio; 2008 Mercedes-Benz B 200
From EuroNCAP.com:
"Mercedes-Benz E Class (1998)
Test Scores: Front 10(63%) Side 15(83%) Overall 26(76%) Pedestrian 17(47%)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Impact Protection
Frontal Impact
Side Impact
Child Restraints
Pedestrian Protection
Model history and details
Mercedes decided to retest a modified car after the left front wheel was forced back in an initial test, rupturing the driver's footwell. The modified car was awarded three stars but, with just a little improvement, it would have earned a fourth. Mercedes tell us that cars ordered now will be modified. Despite there being no hard impact areas for the knees, the risk to the driver's legs and feet is still high because of the extent of brake pedal movement. Finally, the car meets side-impact legislation taking effect from October.
The Mercedes E-class just missed gaining a four-star Euro NCAP rating when the car was first tested in 1998. With the inclusion of the pole test into the Euro NCAP protocols, Mercedes commissioned a pole test to prove that the head-protecting airbag that is fitted as standard to the car from the 1999 model year has improved the protection offered. The requirements of the pole test, though demanding, were met without difficulty. The improvement in protection now earns the E-class a four-star Euro NCAP rating. The head-protecting device is a drop-down airbag curtain and was introduced across the range from VIN 210065 WDB JF65G9Y A 962233.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Impact Protection
Driver Front Impact Passenger Front Impact Driver Side Impact
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Frontal Impact
After the impact, the door aperture was little deformed and the body structure was stable. The left front wheel crushed the driver's footwell, causing a body seam to burst and expose the wheel arch liner. The driver and passenger airbags worked well and the load limiting belts reduced chest injury risks from those seen in the first test. The knee impact areas included hard contact points which could injure the driver's knees, upper legs and pelvis.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Side Impact
The E-class has door-mounted side-impact chest airbags fitted as standard. The driver's airbag cushioned his arm, chest, and abdomen, but did not improve protection as much as those in some other cars in this group.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Child Restraint
An European manufacturer's association (ACEA) pictogram was fixed to the passenger's end of the facia and was a single-language text label on the windscreen which could be peeled off or lost if the screen had to be replaced. The text did not explain the risk of serious injury or death if a child seat was fitted in the front passenger seat. Both dummies were in Mercedes forward-facing child seats. Belt guides on the seats were colour coded in accordance with regulation R44.03, but the stick-on dots used to indicate the route could be removed too easily.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pedestrian Protection
The bonnet top gave reasonable protection for pedestrian head impacts. The child protection zone had half the test points meeting proposed legislation and three other sites were not far away from passing. Tests for adult head contact revealed two bad points although the rest came close to compliance. However, the front end of the car was found to be aggressive and each test point rated as 'poor'.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Model history and safety equipment
The latest E-class was launched in Sept '95. Twin front and side airbags, belt pre-tensioners and load limiters, traction control, anti-lock brakes, Brake Assist and power steering are fitted to all cars sold in the EU. Make, model and hand of drive Mercedes-Benz E200 Classic LHD
Body type 4-door saloon
Model year 1998
Kerb weight 1440 kg
VIN and date when rating applies 210065 WDB JF65G9Y A 962233"
......Conclusion: It's quite a safe car. A new C Class is safer though. EuroNCAP is the best crash test standard around - IIHS and NHTSA do not compare from a technical standpoint.
"Mercedes-Benz E Class (1998)
Test Scores: Front 10(63%) Side 15(83%) Overall 26(76%) Pedestrian 17(47%)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Impact Protection
Frontal Impact
Side Impact
Child Restraints
Pedestrian Protection
Model history and details
Mercedes decided to retest a modified car after the left front wheel was forced back in an initial test, rupturing the driver's footwell. The modified car was awarded three stars but, with just a little improvement, it would have earned a fourth. Mercedes tell us that cars ordered now will be modified. Despite there being no hard impact areas for the knees, the risk to the driver's legs and feet is still high because of the extent of brake pedal movement. Finally, the car meets side-impact legislation taking effect from October.
The Mercedes E-class just missed gaining a four-star Euro NCAP rating when the car was first tested in 1998. With the inclusion of the pole test into the Euro NCAP protocols, Mercedes commissioned a pole test to prove that the head-protecting airbag that is fitted as standard to the car from the 1999 model year has improved the protection offered. The requirements of the pole test, though demanding, were met without difficulty. The improvement in protection now earns the E-class a four-star Euro NCAP rating. The head-protecting device is a drop-down airbag curtain and was introduced across the range from VIN 210065 WDB JF65G9Y A 962233.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Impact Protection
Driver Front Impact Passenger Front Impact Driver Side Impact
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Frontal Impact
After the impact, the door aperture was little deformed and the body structure was stable. The left front wheel crushed the driver's footwell, causing a body seam to burst and expose the wheel arch liner. The driver and passenger airbags worked well and the load limiting belts reduced chest injury risks from those seen in the first test. The knee impact areas included hard contact points which could injure the driver's knees, upper legs and pelvis.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Side Impact
The E-class has door-mounted side-impact chest airbags fitted as standard. The driver's airbag cushioned his arm, chest, and abdomen, but did not improve protection as much as those in some other cars in this group.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Child Restraint
An European manufacturer's association (ACEA) pictogram was fixed to the passenger's end of the facia and was a single-language text label on the windscreen which could be peeled off or lost if the screen had to be replaced. The text did not explain the risk of serious injury or death if a child seat was fitted in the front passenger seat. Both dummies were in Mercedes forward-facing child seats. Belt guides on the seats were colour coded in accordance with regulation R44.03, but the stick-on dots used to indicate the route could be removed too easily.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pedestrian Protection
The bonnet top gave reasonable protection for pedestrian head impacts. The child protection zone had half the test points meeting proposed legislation and three other sites were not far away from passing. Tests for adult head contact revealed two bad points although the rest came close to compliance. However, the front end of the car was found to be aggressive and each test point rated as 'poor'.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Model history and safety equipment
The latest E-class was launched in Sept '95. Twin front and side airbags, belt pre-tensioners and load limiters, traction control, anti-lock brakes, Brake Assist and power steering are fitted to all cars sold in the EU. Make, model and hand of drive Mercedes-Benz E200 Classic LHD
Body type 4-door saloon
Model year 1998
Kerb weight 1440 kg
VIN and date when rating applies 210065 WDB JF65G9Y A 962233"
......Conclusion: It's quite a safe car. A new C Class is safer though. EuroNCAP is the best crash test standard around - IIHS and NHTSA do not compare from a technical standpoint.
