Run flats revisited
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Run flats revisited
When the new s class was first released there was a furor on this board about the lack of a spare tire. Nothing more has been said in months from new or old owners.
Has anyone had a bad experience with their run flats? If you replaced your tires due to wear, at what mileage did you do it and what did you replace them with? I haven't had any problems, but I drive so few miles that I'm not a good person to survey.
Has anyone had a bad experience with their run flats? If you replaced your tires due to wear, at what mileage did you do it and what did you replace them with? I haven't had any problems, but I drive so few miles that I'm not a good person to survey.
#2
My original post was about run flats and how I was pleasantly surprised about ride quality,noise,etc.I have the Michelin MXM4 ZP tires on 19"wheels.Road force balanced and rotated every 5k. Have 12k miles and still showing 7/32 to 8/32 tread depth.I would call this acceptable wear.
#3
Super Member
i've has two "bad experiences" but the runflat tyres saved my **** both times. i've had two "blowouts" (or what would have been "blowouts" if i had conventional rubber) due to massive potholes. the runflats saved me as - whilst they developed these massive bulges - they continued to operate until i could get them changed out. so they operated as designed.
for reference:
i have a 2015 s550 4matic with the sport+1 package that came factory-equipped with goodyear runflats. 6mos ownership; 2,900 miles on the odo now. i think the ride is acceptable though not as soft as my 2013 s5504m that had conventional continentals.
for reference:
i have a 2015 s550 4matic with the sport+1 package that came factory-equipped with goodyear runflats. 6mos ownership; 2,900 miles on the odo now. i think the ride is acceptable though not as soft as my 2013 s5504m that had conventional continentals.
#4
Super Member
The runflats were very nice on my car on 19" and as far as I could tell didn't change anything. Now I use 20" non-runflats as they apparently could crack my alloys. Just need to hope nothing goes wrong.
#6
Junior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Hudson Valley NY
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
4 Posts
'12 S350 ('15 S550 on order)
I have a 2015 S550 4Matic with 18' runflats. My previous vehicle was a 2012 S350 with 18" conventional tires. Ride quality on the 2015 is better than on the 2012. with the 2012 I averaged 8-9 flats per year (very bad pot holes, and I use the car in emergency services as an emergency response vehicle). Pot holes have, if anything gotten worse. I have the 2015 for 11 months now, with almost 14,000 miles on it - No flats or bubbles, and insignificant wear. I am very satisfied with the runflats, and am beginning to have second thoughts about the tire warranty I bought.
#7
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Corona Del Mar, CA
Posts: 7,380
Received 3,665 Likes
on
2,099 Posts
2020 S560 Sedan, 2019 SL450, 2019 E450 Luxury Trim Wagon, '24 BMW I7 on order...
No matter how well a car rides on run flat tires, it will ride better, smoother and MUCH quieter on certain conventional tires. You may feel that your W222 rides just fine on the run flats, but if you could do immediate, side by side tests, over the same roads, I believe that the difference between your run flats and, let's say Michelin Primacy MXM4's or Bridgestone Serenity's (what I have) would be very noticeable, especially on rougher roads, intersection joints, parking lot aprons, etc. and the noise level at highway speeds would truly be a NIGHT and DAY difference. My 2015 S550 sedan was ordered with 18" wheels. I drove the car for about 500 miles with the run flats and then the dealer put the Bridgestone Serenity Plus tires on and I was STUNNED at the improvement. If you guys are happy with your ride & noise quality with RFT's, I'm happy for you. As for me, I've never looked back. To complete the package, I purchased an unused W221 compact spare and a W222 jack, both of which now reside in my trunk, giving me peace of mind on longer trips, albeit with diminished trunk space.
Trending Topics
#8
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: FL & CT
Posts: 2,755
Received 796 Likes
on
752 Posts
2015 S550 Palladium/Deep Sea Blue, 2016 Tesla Model S 70D, 2015 Volvo XC70
Personally, I'm still satisfied with my runflats. However, I've come to realize that may have something to do with the road surfaces in my area...they tend to be asphalt rather than concrete (concrete seems common for Calif freeways). Recently, I drove over a short stretch of highway that was concrete, and it seemed quite loud. Would my W221 with regular tires have been quieter in that instance? Possibly.
#9
Member
While I have no problems with the 18" run flats on my 2015 I still worry. I drive from Phoenix to Yuma AZ about once or twice a month. There are long stretches (40 to 60 miles) with nothing. If I had a blowout that could not be fixed with a can and compressor I will really be up the creek.
Michael in Arizona
Michael in Arizona
#11
MBWorld Fanatic!
I don't love, to any extent, my run flats. I am also not too keen on taking up my trunk space with a spare if I changed to conventional tires, so for now, I live with the 20 inch run flats.
My wife just got a new 7 series with 19 inch run flats and we took her car this weekend for a 3 1/2 hour road trip each way. I had forgotten how great the 7 series car is. I had a 2010 7 series Individual, and I really didn't care for the run flats anymore than I do on my 2015 MB.
On the other hand, the 2015 7 series, with the 19 inch run flats, drove incredibly. The ride was quiet, and the car is really smooth, much more so than my MB.
I had forgotten how nice the ride was with the 7 series. I think Streamliner will be a happy camper.
My wife just got a new 7 series with 19 inch run flats and we took her car this weekend for a 3 1/2 hour road trip each way. I had forgotten how great the 7 series car is. I had a 2010 7 series Individual, and I really didn't care for the run flats anymore than I do on my 2015 MB.
On the other hand, the 2015 7 series, with the 19 inch run flats, drove incredibly. The ride was quiet, and the car is really smooth, much more so than my MB.
I had forgotten how nice the ride was with the 7 series. I think Streamliner will be a happy camper.
#12
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Corona Del Mar, CA
Posts: 7,380
Received 3,665 Likes
on
2,099 Posts
2020 S560 Sedan, 2019 SL450, 2019 E450 Luxury Trim Wagon, '24 BMW I7 on order...
I don't love, to any extent, my run flats. I am also not too keen on taking up my trunk space with a spare if I changed to conventional tires, so for now, I live with the 20 inch run flats.
My wife just got a new 7 series with 19 inch run flats and we took her car this weekend for a 3 1/2 hour road trip each way. I had forgotten how great the 7 series car is. I had a 2010 7 series Individual, and I really didn't care for the run flats anymore than I do on my 2015 MB.
On the other hand, the 2015 7 series, with the 19 inch run flats, drove incredibly. The ride was quiet, and the car is really smooth, much more so than my MB.
I had forgotten how nice the ride was with the 7 series. I think Streamliner will be a happy camper.
My wife just got a new 7 series with 19 inch run flats and we took her car this weekend for a 3 1/2 hour road trip each way. I had forgotten how great the 7 series car is. I had a 2010 7 series Individual, and I really didn't care for the run flats anymore than I do on my 2015 MB.
On the other hand, the 2015 7 series, with the 19 inch run flats, drove incredibly. The ride was quiet, and the car is really smooth, much more so than my MB.
I had forgotten how nice the ride was with the 7 series. I think Streamliner will be a happy camper.
#13
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,091
Received 3,282 Likes
on
2,040 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
They realized that you can a blowout even with a runflat that you can't continue driving on (cut in the sidewall) and that no shop carries run flats, so all have to be ordered.
#14
MBWorld Fanatic!
For me, an equal competitor to my S class with a spare tire, will most likely get my order. That being said, on the next body change, my bet is MB S class has a spare. Don't look for it on the re-fresh.
#15
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,091
Received 3,282 Likes
on
2,040 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
I just think this whole run flat idea is a disaster waiting to happen.
For me, an equal competitor to my S class with a spare tire, will most likely get my order. That being said, on the next body change, my bet is MB S class has a spare. Don't look for it on the re-fresh.
For me, an equal competitor to my S class with a spare tire, will most likely get my order. That being said, on the next body change, my bet is MB S class has a spare. Don't look for it on the re-fresh.
One of the original reasons for not carrying a spare was the weight savings but it turned out that the extra weight of the runflat tires (they are heavy!) offset the savings completely...
I will change from the 20" Pirelli run flats to all season tires in the next couple of weeks and provide feedback.
#16
Member
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Eastern NC
Posts: 176
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'15 S550 4Matic, '15 GL550, 360 Spider, Escalade ESV
Interesting to run across this topic...
I was en route to an important function thus weekend when my tire monitor flashed and pressure fairly quickly went to zero. I have MY2015 S550 with 20" OEM goodyears, 18k miles.
I was able to safely drive a couple miles to the first tire shop (closed) and another mile to one that was open where I was able to drop the car off for a new tire (not exact replacement but will get me by for a couple weeks).
I've never had a strong opinion (or experience) with run flats in the past but on this occasion I was very grateful to have them!
As for the tire...it was completely separated around the inside edge, approx half of the way around. No puncture. I'm not sure if it separated from the 3 miles of driving or if it was the original cause. It would NOT have made it for 50 miles at 50mph (or whatever it is).
I was en route to an important function thus weekend when my tire monitor flashed and pressure fairly quickly went to zero. I have MY2015 S550 with 20" OEM goodyears, 18k miles.
I was able to safely drive a couple miles to the first tire shop (closed) and another mile to one that was open where I was able to drop the car off for a new tire (not exact replacement but will get me by for a couple weeks).
I've never had a strong opinion (or experience) with run flats in the past but on this occasion I was very grateful to have them!
As for the tire...it was completely separated around the inside edge, approx half of the way around. No puncture. I'm not sure if it separated from the 3 miles of driving or if it was the original cause. It would NOT have made it for 50 miles at 50mph (or whatever it is).
#18
My wife was had a flat in our 2014 w/20" run flats a couple weeks ago. I was out of town and she was able to experience the benefit of the run flats. Tire went to 0 psi over a couple miles, puncture in the tread. She drove about 5 miles home then made an apt with the dealer the next day and drove 20+ miles to the dealer on the flat. Worked out great for her and she is now more comfortable with the idea of the run flats now.
#19
MBWorld Fanatic!
Want maximal braking vs any emergent maneuver....thus would only drive w/best factory-spec summ (or winter) perf tires...not runflats/not all-season
Reality is if have (arguably rare) flat, would call roadside assist to flat bed car to competent MB dealer; wouldn't ever risk trying to repair any tire on roadside nor driving a car w/compact spare/"repaired" tire: cars are all cheap/disposable; one's health isn't
And having replaced rears of several new 65s after ?6-8K mis at first (and only) annual oil change before trade-in, would observe big MB dealers in SF/LA sometimes lack factory-spec tires in stock&need 1-2d to obtain: tires/tire replacements are a primitive industry and most customers don't understand how critical are competent tires vs safety, yet how cheap are any tires vs critical role they provide in any car's perf/safety (and given bulk of tires (and specificity of high-perf tires), suspect many dealers avoid inventory costs)
So notion of spares, etc is an irrelev Luddite phenom; simply, having a flat in Podunk (or anywhere on rd) is a miserable/dangerous expce on many levels.....but much of advantage of life in places like SF/LA is no need/desire to traverse Podunk (and if need to, know these unsolvable risks one has assumed)
Reality is if have (arguably rare) flat, would call roadside assist to flat bed car to competent MB dealer; wouldn't ever risk trying to repair any tire on roadside nor driving a car w/compact spare/"repaired" tire: cars are all cheap/disposable; one's health isn't
And having replaced rears of several new 65s after ?6-8K mis at first (and only) annual oil change before trade-in, would observe big MB dealers in SF/LA sometimes lack factory-spec tires in stock&need 1-2d to obtain: tires/tire replacements are a primitive industry and most customers don't understand how critical are competent tires vs safety, yet how cheap are any tires vs critical role they provide in any car's perf/safety (and given bulk of tires (and specificity of high-perf tires), suspect many dealers avoid inventory costs)
So notion of spares, etc is an irrelev Luddite phenom; simply, having a flat in Podunk (or anywhere on rd) is a miserable/dangerous expce on many levels.....but much of advantage of life in places like SF/LA is no need/desire to traverse Podunk (and if need to, know these unsolvable risks one has assumed)
#20
Member
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: FL & MA
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'14 SL550
I recently changed from run-flats to conventional, and yes the ride is much better over bumpy surfaces, don't really notice any noise difference.
My car is a 2014 with the optional 20" wheels. The OEM tire was a Goodyear Eagle F1 performance tire run flat. Great ride and handling on smooth surfaces, but a bit harsh on bad bumpy roads. My car reached 20K miles and I may use it during the winter (which was not the plan when I bought it) so I changed to Conti All Season non runflats.
I don't know what the future will be for run flats, I'm sure that the R&D departments of every tire manufacturer are working to improve them. I think the car companies jumped on the bandwagon too soon. I had a 2007 BMW with run flats and it was awful. I actually have a 2009 Ferrari with Bridgestone high performance run flats that came as OEM tires and it is not so bad, but that car is not built for a comfy ride.
My car is a 2014 with the optional 20" wheels. The OEM tire was a Goodyear Eagle F1 performance tire run flat. Great ride and handling on smooth surfaces, but a bit harsh on bad bumpy roads. My car reached 20K miles and I may use it during the winter (which was not the plan when I bought it) so I changed to Conti All Season non runflats.
I don't know what the future will be for run flats, I'm sure that the R&D departments of every tire manufacturer are working to improve them. I think the car companies jumped on the bandwagon too soon. I had a 2007 BMW with run flats and it was awful. I actually have a 2009 Ferrari with Bridgestone high performance run flats that came as OEM tires and it is not so bad, but that car is not built for a comfy ride.
#22
This thread persuaded me to switch to conventionals (Bridgestone Turanza ER30). Here's my impressions on my petrol S400 with ABC (no MBC) and 18" rims:
+ Overall ride improved significantly (yes, day and night difference);
+ Better turns;
+ Better handling with potholes and bumps;
+ I feel as though suspension was tuned for conventional tires;
- Michelin run-flats had slightly less surface noise (surprisingly).
I wish I made the switch to conventional 25,000 km sooner !!
+ Overall ride improved significantly (yes, day and night difference);
+ Better turns;
+ Better handling with potholes and bumps;
+ I feel as though suspension was tuned for conventional tires;
- Michelin run-flats had slightly less surface noise (surprisingly).
I wish I made the switch to conventional 25,000 km sooner !!
#23
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Corona Del Mar, CA
Posts: 7,380
Received 3,665 Likes
on
2,099 Posts
2020 S560 Sedan, 2019 SL450, 2019 E450 Luxury Trim Wagon, '24 BMW I7 on order...
This thread persuaded me to switch to conventionals (Bridgestone Turanza ER30). Here's my impressions on my petrol S400 with ABC (no MBC) and 18" rims:
+ Overall ride improved significantly (yes, day and night difference);
+ Better turns;
+ Better handling with potholes and bumps;
+ I feel as though suspension was tuned for conventional tires;
- Michelin run-flats had slightly less surface noise (surprisingly).
I wish I made the switch to conventional 25,000 km sooner !!
+ Overall ride improved significantly (yes, day and night difference);
+ Better turns;
+ Better handling with potholes and bumps;
+ I feel as though suspension was tuned for conventional tires;
- Michelin run-flats had slightly less surface noise (surprisingly).
I wish I made the switch to conventional 25,000 km sooner !!
#24
Although I went straight to the Bridgestone importer (freshness) they didn't have the Serenity Plus.
Importer gave me a reasonable deal on (4) ER30 wheels: USD 205 per wheel including installation and 1 additional free balance within 12 months. So I said to myself: "replace wheels first; think later". I'm glad I did
#25
Super Moderator
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Land of 10,000 lakes
Posts: 10,091
Received 3,282 Likes
on
2,040 Posts
AMG GTC Roadster, E63s Ed.1, M8 Comp. Coupe
My fault for being lazy :(
I was dropping off our SL for service and my wife picked me up with our S-Class so I don't have to enjoy the loaner for the day. Turned out to be wishful thinking.
5 miles from the dealer we hit a reasonably small pothole which immediately killed the front-right tire. Pirelli 20" run-flats.
I had planned to switch to non-runflats a while back but have been too busy/lazy. So now we are back to the dealer to get a loaner and now have two cars sitting there and have to wait to get the tires delivered which will take a couple of days.
Such a bummer, we barely have a 1000 miles on the car...
On the positive side, I was able to drive back to the dealer. On the other side, no way the non-runflats would have blown...
5 miles from the dealer we hit a reasonably small pothole which immediately killed the front-right tire. Pirelli 20" run-flats.
I had planned to switch to non-runflats a while back but have been too busy/lazy. So now we are back to the dealer to get a loaner and now have two cars sitting there and have to wait to get the tires delivered which will take a couple of days.
Such a bummer, we barely have a 1000 miles on the car...
On the positive side, I was able to drive back to the dealer. On the other side, no way the non-runflats would have blown...