Oil change - every 6 months?
#52
MBWorld Fanatic!
"I do cars" a youtube sight disassembles engines, some of them are Merc's with less than 70K miles on them with nasty cylinder scoring.
A few of these he has accurate mileage data. I don't think he has any OCI data on them.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjUUA6bjgT4
A few of these he has accurate mileage data. I don't think he has any OCI data on them.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjUUA6bjgT4
Again, you would see contamination in UOAs at or before 10,000 miles between changes that would show what causes that cylinder scoring, and out of all of them that have been presented (check out BITOG forums) there are no such results.
#54
SPONSOR
Join Date: Apr 2021
Location: San Jose, CA
Posts: 555
Received 377 Likes
on
227 Posts
11 E550, 16 AMG GTS, 13 S550
i sell oil analysis kits
i also see a TON of UOA for my customer cars since I keep kits at the shop for morbid curiosity if the guest wants it. 10k is fine but the oil starts cooking off, it still lubricates but something has to give first and usually it's the oils volatility resistance even though the TBN and visosity are ok. Now the viscosity over time thickens and whatnot but within 10k thats usually not an issue and if you're not driving city miles you don't have a ton of cook-off anyway.
All of my customers are told to follow the manual and get oil changes between 7500-12k. I have about 50 customers that keep me running, I don't exactly take new business anymore, I'm a small 3-bay shop with 1 partner, no employees. We change a lot of oil, I also sell a lot of oil through the Amsoil program to personal customers who sign up with my link so I have a lot of data. If you want to change your oil because its starting to look gross or it's starting to cook off and its just economical to save the 1-2qts youd' normally just sent into the atmosphere anyway thats actually great thinking. However if you don't experience anything of the sort and lose only a half quart between changes, 10k all day. I've been looking at this for 10 years. I have like 20+ UOA's that say all the various 229.5/229.51 oils work and have reserve protection at 10k in Audi/BMW/Porsche/MB.
A UOA is kinda wasted since it only tells you if you have problems with your engine. It is not the end-all be-all way of determining which oil is better, because on the first change, for example Amsoil shakes out a lot of oil debris from all the detergeants on the Signature series stuff so it looks really bad on the UOA, on the 2nd one its nice. This doesn't apply to Euro spec since we have to use an OE equivalent oil and Amsoil doesn't really mess around with the Euro specs. So UOA's only establish a pattern after a few of them and by then you're spending $180 after 3 of them just to tell you you can keep changing the oil at 10k anyway.
i also see a TON of UOA for my customer cars since I keep kits at the shop for morbid curiosity if the guest wants it. 10k is fine but the oil starts cooking off, it still lubricates but something has to give first and usually it's the oils volatility resistance even though the TBN and visosity are ok. Now the viscosity over time thickens and whatnot but within 10k thats usually not an issue and if you're not driving city miles you don't have a ton of cook-off anyway.
All of my customers are told to follow the manual and get oil changes between 7500-12k. I have about 50 customers that keep me running, I don't exactly take new business anymore, I'm a small 3-bay shop with 1 partner, no employees. We change a lot of oil, I also sell a lot of oil through the Amsoil program to personal customers who sign up with my link so I have a lot of data. If you want to change your oil because its starting to look gross or it's starting to cook off and its just economical to save the 1-2qts youd' normally just sent into the atmosphere anyway thats actually great thinking. However if you don't experience anything of the sort and lose only a half quart between changes, 10k all day. I've been looking at this for 10 years. I have like 20+ UOA's that say all the various 229.5/229.51 oils work and have reserve protection at 10k in Audi/BMW/Porsche/MB.
A UOA is kinda wasted since it only tells you if you have problems with your engine. It is not the end-all be-all way of determining which oil is better, because on the first change, for example Amsoil shakes out a lot of oil debris from all the detergeants on the Signature series stuff so it looks really bad on the UOA, on the 2nd one its nice. This doesn't apply to Euro spec since we have to use an OE equivalent oil and Amsoil doesn't really mess around with the Euro specs. So UOA's only establish a pattern after a few of them and by then you're spending $180 after 3 of them just to tell you you can keep changing the oil at 10k anyway.
__________________
Alpha European Autotech
Purchase Amsoil at 25% off from me
Chris Tran, Service Manager/Owner
Amsoil Independent Dealer #7236674
Alpha European Autotech
Purchase Amsoil at 25% off from me
Chris Tran, Service Manager/Owner
Amsoil Independent Dealer #7236674
#55
MBWorld Fanatic!
#57
MBWorld Fanatic!
What OCI would someone recommend if you wanted the engine to last 1,000,000 miles ?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubMyWT49IWs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubMyWT49IWs
His car is still in service, so it may be that factory recommendations CAN get you to 1m miles.
#58
MBWorld Fanatic!
I would never expect an engine to last 1M miles...nor would I ever own a vehicle that got to 1M miles.
I will also say this about mechanic recommendations...bear in mind that telling you to change your oil every 5k miles vs 10k doubles the number of times he gets your car in his shop. You can't assign all kinds of nefarious intent to the engineers who set the 10K OCI and ignore the very reasonable potential of nefarious intent by the mechanic for saying it needs to be serviced at his profit twice as often...
I will also say this about mechanic recommendations...bear in mind that telling you to change your oil every 5k miles vs 10k doubles the number of times he gets your car in his shop. You can't assign all kinds of nefarious intent to the engineers who set the 10K OCI and ignore the very reasonable potential of nefarious intent by the mechanic for saying it needs to be serviced at his profit twice as often...
Last edited by SW20S; 12-03-2023 at 10:41 AM.
#59
Super Member
- 1966 Volvo P1800. Irv Gordon is a legend in the long-distance driving club after taking his 1966 Volvo P1800 to 3.25 million miles. ...
- 2006 Chevrolet Silverado 3500 HD. ...
- 1990 Honda Accord. ...
- 1989 Saab 900 SPG. ...
- 1963 Volkswagen Beetle.
#60
Senior Member
I would never expect an engine to last 1M miles...nor would I ever own a vehicle that got to 1M miles.
I will also say this about mechanic recommendations...bear in mind that telling you to change your oil every 5k miles vs 10k doubles the number of times he gets your car in his shop. You can't assign all kinds of nefarious intent to the engineers who set the 10K OCI and ignore the very reasonable potential of nefarious intent by the mechanic for saying it needs to be serviced at his profit twice as often...
I will also say this about mechanic recommendations...bear in mind that telling you to change your oil every 5k miles vs 10k doubles the number of times he gets your car in his shop. You can't assign all kinds of nefarious intent to the engineers who set the 10K OCI and ignore the very reasonable potential of nefarious intent by the mechanic for saying it needs to be serviced at his profit twice as often...
#61
MBWorld Fanatic!
If you get the time I would recommend watching this video: https://youtu.be/TJhFAwFv-O0?si=L6Ff8J3XqSwZ00rL
The mechanic actually did the math on the extra oil changes vs the new engine block price and it was not even close. Prevention is better than the 10k gimmick that even Toyota is pushing now.
The mechanic actually did the math on the extra oil changes vs the new engine block price and it was not even close. Prevention is better than the 10k gimmick that even Toyota is pushing now.
I do not believe Toyota engineers and oil formulators are suggesting 10k OCIs as a "gimmick". It just doesn't make any sense. Show me some UOAs that back up that the oil before 10k is tired and full of contaminants and show me some vehicles that require new engine blocks when they have religiously changed their oil every 10k like I do and I will reevaluate that position. Hard to do that though because none of that evidence exists.
Why would Toyota, Mercedes, etc knowingly put an OCI in their maintenance schedule when they know it causes engine damage? Why would every respected oil formulator guarantee their oil well past even that OCI when they know it won't protect an engine? Thats bad business and they aren't doing that.
Last edited by SW20S; 12-03-2023 at 11:50 PM.
#62
Senior Member
Planned obsolescence is of course not bad business, it’s just business at this point. These cars are being designed not to last anymore and the companies know the end is near for combustion engines, but they need to be able to sell them as being less onerous with these extended service intervals which in theory sound great but in practice are not a great practice at all (there were no coolant leaks or overheating on that doctor owned Camry with a full service history if you watch the video all the way through). They are banking on the fact that people are lazy and will want the next shiny new object in 2-3 years without regard to the immense waste producing an entirely new vehicle produces, which pales in comparison to the waste of a simple oil change. As noted in the later part of the video, oil changes don’t change all the oil in the motor, there is some left inside it which can do damage, hence why a shorter interval is recommended to dilute it earlier. This will be a thing of the past soon though as they discontinue this propulsion technology entirely and convince you to spend even more of your money on battery driven cars once your combustion car has engine damage that could have been prevented…to each their own though, you have to be comfortable with the risks of believing manufacturer’s marketing, which is kind of like believing big agriculture is producing highly processed food that is good for your body with their marketing claims. There is the marketing and there is the reality…this is sales 101.
.
.
#63
MBWorld Fanatic!
Planned obsolescence is of course not bad business, it’s just business at this point. These cars are being designed not to last anymore and the companies know the end is near for combustion engines, but they need to be able to sell them as being less onerous with these extended service intervals which in theory sound great but in practice are not a great practice at all (there were no coolant leaks or overheating on that doctor owned Camry with a full service history if you watch the video all the way through). They are banking on the fact that people are lazy and will want the next shiny new object in 2-3 years without regard to the immense waste producing an entirely new vehicle produces, which pales in comparison to the waste of a simple oil change. As noted in the later part of the video, oil changes don’t change all the oil in the motor, there is some left inside it which can do damage, hence why a shorter interval is recommended to dilute it earlier. This will be a thing of the past soon though as they discontinue this propulsion technology entirely and convince you to spend even more of your money on battery driven cars once your combustion car has engine damage that could have been prevented…to each their own though, you have to be comfortable with the risks of believing manufacturer’s marketing, which is kind of like believing big agriculture is producing highly processed food that is good for your body with their marketing claims. There is the marketing and there is the reality…this is sales 101.
.
.
Again...show me the evidence? All I am hearing is opinion and conjecture. On that Toyota...there are MILLIONS of those 4 cyl engines on the road and thats not a particularly good engine...where are all the failed engines? You also don't know if that Toyota had oil changes every 5k miles that it still wouldn't start using oil at 130k miles. Oil use at high mileage is not an uncommon issue with modern Toyota engines. In any event, the car had 130,000 miles on it which is well outside of any life it would have with me. Nothing lasts forever, and sometimes with an old high mileage car you gotta add some oil.
I again am very confident that changing the oil according to the manufacturers recommendation will be fine, until I am shown some evidence that it isn't...which I still havent been shown. Conspiracy theories about OCIs being set high to drive sales of EVs are not evidence.
#65
MBWorld Fanatic!
#66
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Cincinnati
Posts: 4,323
Received 1,025 Likes
on
743 Posts
2010 E350 4Matic
You don't think throwing away 10 quarts of oil twice as often as is necessary is wasteful? MB and others have been doing 10k OCIs since long before EVs were ever in the immediate picture.
Again...show me the evidence? All I am hearing is opinion and conjecture. On that Toyota...there are MILLIONS of those 4 cyl engines on the road and thats not a particularly good engine...where are all the failed engines? You also don't know if that Toyota had oil changes every 5k miles that it still wouldn't start using oil at 130k miles. Oil use at high mileage is not an uncommon issue with modern Toyota engines. In any event, the car had 130,000 miles on it which is well outside of any life it would have with me. Nothing lasts forever, and sometimes with an old high mileage car you gotta add some oil.
I again am very confident that changing the oil according to the manufacturers recommendation will be fine, until I am shown some evidence that it isn't...which I still havent been shown. Conspiracy theories about OCIs being set high to drive sales of EVs are not evidence.
Again...show me the evidence? All I am hearing is opinion and conjecture. On that Toyota...there are MILLIONS of those 4 cyl engines on the road and thats not a particularly good engine...where are all the failed engines? You also don't know if that Toyota had oil changes every 5k miles that it still wouldn't start using oil at 130k miles. Oil use at high mileage is not an uncommon issue with modern Toyota engines. In any event, the car had 130,000 miles on it which is well outside of any life it would have with me. Nothing lasts forever, and sometimes with an old high mileage car you gotta add some oil.
I again am very confident that changing the oil according to the manufacturers recommendation will be fine, until I am shown some evidence that it isn't...which I still havent been shown. Conspiracy theories about OCIs being set high to drive sales of EVs are not evidence.
#67
MBWorld Fanatic!
Tons of people on the Lexus forums as an example with 200k+ miles who follow the factory maintenance schedule, etc. Multiple people here too with cars over 150k following the schedule...some have posted in this thread. If nobody has, then all the older model forums on every site would be full of engine failures.
The following 2 users liked this post by Sean._.S:
aypues (12-04-2023),
blackbullit (03-19-2024)
#69
MBWorld Fanatic!
You bought the car used though right? What about before that? How have you examined your cylinder walls?
#70
Senior Member
I did indeed buy it used. From 1500 miles to the 28k I bought it with, it had oil changes every 5-7k miles verified by receipts. To answer your last question, a borescope.
#71
MBWorld Fanatic!
I would bet money if you used a borescope on another S550 that had verified oil changes every 10k you would find the cylinder walls equally smooth.
#72
Super Member
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: PA
Posts: 762
Received 99 Likes
on
91 Posts
E Coupe C207, ML W166, ML W164, Sprinter 1500/144, W111 SB220 Fintail(s), A5 chassis Beetle 5+5
"Extreme Service" conditions, learn what that is and why 6 month change intervals are perfect (over 8000 miles a year) 10k or a full year are under optimal conditions.
Remember Pennzoil Euro L is an inexpensive way to get 229.51 reduced ash.
https://www.walmart.com/ip/Pennzoil-...5-qt/495194903
For God's sake get an oil extractor.
Remember Pennzoil Euro L is an inexpensive way to get 229.51 reduced ash.
https://www.walmart.com/ip/Pennzoil-...5-qt/495194903
For God's sake get an oil extractor.
#73
Super Member
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: PA
Posts: 762
Received 99 Likes
on
91 Posts
E Coupe C207, ML W166, ML W164, Sprinter 1500/144, W111 SB220 Fintail(s), A5 chassis Beetle 5+5
What OCI would someone recommend if you wanted the engine to last 1,000,000 miles ?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubMyWT49IWs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubMyWT49IWs
#74
For what it’s worth, in my personal experience, I did maintenance by the book (10K OCI) on my last two cars that were my daily driver/commuter.
My first was the w204 2011 C300 that had about 39K miles when I bought it, still under factory warranty. It had a slight hesitation at idle—dealer replaced the head of passenger side under warranty to fix the issue. Since then, I drove it trouble free until 217k miles, I tracked every fuel up and service I did. Not a single oil related issue, bone dry engine bay with no leaks. Car was
totaled in 2018.
I then purchased a w212 2014 E350, high mileage 95k or so, out of warranty but had good service history and engine bay was immaculate. I personally serviced and drove that car to about 201k before it was also totaled. The car never had any oil related issues, no leaks or burning of oil.
I then bought a w222 in 2023. We will see how this one does, but this engine has turbos which will be different from the two NA engines I has no issues with. I’ve changed the oil twice already, practicing 5-6k change intervals. My concern is the turbos and how they will probably affect the oil differently than the two previous cars I had.
My first was the w204 2011 C300 that had about 39K miles when I bought it, still under factory warranty. It had a slight hesitation at idle—dealer replaced the head of passenger side under warranty to fix the issue. Since then, I drove it trouble free until 217k miles, I tracked every fuel up and service I did. Not a single oil related issue, bone dry engine bay with no leaks. Car was
totaled in 2018.
I then purchased a w212 2014 E350, high mileage 95k or so, out of warranty but had good service history and engine bay was immaculate. I personally serviced and drove that car to about 201k before it was also totaled. The car never had any oil related issues, no leaks or burning of oil.
I then bought a w222 in 2023. We will see how this one does, but this engine has turbos which will be different from the two NA engines I has no issues with. I’ve changed the oil twice already, practicing 5-6k change intervals. My concern is the turbos and how they will probably affect the oil differently than the two previous cars I had.
#75
Super Member
That display looks very interesting. Is it from an app, or is it a homemade concoction?