SL/R129: 1999 SL500 Cats
#1
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 2,576
Received 164 Likes
on
132 Posts
From: Bahrain
R129 SL55 AMG & W208 CLK55 AMG
1999 SL500 Cats
So my cats are shot, I can hear rattling noises inside on acceleration.
Easy replacement? universal ones okay?
Any recommendations or ideas?
Will de-catting trigger a fault? What about the sensors?
Thanks in advance.
Easy replacement? universal ones okay?
Any recommendations or ideas?
Will de-catting trigger a fault? What about the sensors?
Thanks in advance.
#2
Super Member
MB might offer rebuilt cats and for a reasonable price.
You can replace with modern cats, not too hard to do (I had someone swap them out). The car will throw a light if you don't have cats. (I assume you have 4 sensors) the front O2 sensors are for tuning the fuel mixture, while the rear ones check the effectiveness of the cats. There used to be sensor substitutes for cat delete off-road usage that provided fake values to the computer, but I don't think they exist any more. V8 and 6 cylinder cars use small cats, so its easier to do, but the V12 cars need big cats because 1 cat serves 6 cylinders instead of 4 or 3. The initial replacement cats for my car were rated for a V8 (2 x 4 cylinder usage) and were too small.
I had mine replaced with modern new cats instead of the old style ceramic design MB originally employed. After the new cats were installed the sound of the exhaust changed slightly, but everything works and there are no CEL events. New style cats should flow better than original and aren't really a hindrance to performance like in the olden days.
The V12 cat swap was about $500, your's should be a little less.
You can replace with modern cats, not too hard to do (I had someone swap them out). The car will throw a light if you don't have cats. (I assume you have 4 sensors) the front O2 sensors are for tuning the fuel mixture, while the rear ones check the effectiveness of the cats. There used to be sensor substitutes for cat delete off-road usage that provided fake values to the computer, but I don't think they exist any more. V8 and 6 cylinder cars use small cats, so its easier to do, but the V12 cars need big cats because 1 cat serves 6 cylinders instead of 4 or 3. The initial replacement cats for my car were rated for a V8 (2 x 4 cylinder usage) and were too small.
I had mine replaced with modern new cats instead of the old style ceramic design MB originally employed. After the new cats were installed the sound of the exhaust changed slightly, but everything works and there are no CEL events. New style cats should flow better than original and aren't really a hindrance to performance like in the olden days.
The V12 cat swap was about $500, your's should be a little less.
The following users liked this post:
FATHERTIME (09-07-2019)
#7
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 2,576
Received 164 Likes
on
132 Posts
From: Bahrain
R129 SL55 AMG & W208 CLK55 AMG
Primary cats were shot and had to be gutted out.
CEL kicked in.
What are my options?
O2 simulators? Available?
ECU Tune? Possible?
Aftermarket Cats? Available?
Thank you in advance guys, much appreciated.
CEL kicked in.
What are my options?
O2 simulators? Available?
ECU Tune? Possible?
Aftermarket Cats? Available?
Thank you in advance guys, much appreciated.
Trending Topics
#8
Super Member
Last year I got fed up with the aftermarket replacement cats and ordered new MB ones. Not terribly expensive, and they wanted my old cats (the whole middle cat pipes). You get a refund of $200 per pipe which helps offset the overall price of the replacements.
2 new (not rebuilt) factory cat pipes for the V12.
The paperwork showing the refund and the prices circa last year.
Who know how much it would cost now with the "for our own green good" inflation.
2 new (not rebuilt) factory cat pipes for the V12.
The paperwork showing the refund and the prices circa last year.
Who know how much it would cost now with the "for our own green good" inflation.
#9
Member
MB might offer rebuilt cats and for a reasonable price.
You can replace with modern cats, not too hard to do (I had someone swap them out). The car will throw a light if you don't have cats. (I assume you have 4 sensors) the front O2 sensors are for tuning the fuel mixture, while the rear ones check the effectiveness of the cats. There used to be sensor substitutes for cat delete off-road usage that provided fake values to the computer, but I don't think they exist any more. V8 and 6 cylinder cars use small cats, so its easier to do, but the V12 cars need big cats because 1 cat serves 6 cylinders instead of 4 or 3. The initial replacement cats for my car were rated for a V8 (2 x 4 cylinder usage) and were too small.
I had mine replaced with modern new cats instead of the old style ceramic design MB originally employed. After the new cats were installed the sound of the exhaust changed slightly, but everything works and there are no CEL events. New style cats should flow better than original and aren't really a hindrance to performance like in the olden days.
The V12 cat swap was about $500, your's should be a little less.
You can replace with modern cats, not too hard to do (I had someone swap them out). The car will throw a light if you don't have cats. (I assume you have 4 sensors) the front O2 sensors are for tuning the fuel mixture, while the rear ones check the effectiveness of the cats. There used to be sensor substitutes for cat delete off-road usage that provided fake values to the computer, but I don't think they exist any more. V8 and 6 cylinder cars use small cats, so its easier to do, but the V12 cars need big cats because 1 cat serves 6 cylinders instead of 4 or 3. The initial replacement cats for my car were rated for a V8 (2 x 4 cylinder usage) and were too small.
I had mine replaced with modern new cats instead of the old style ceramic design MB originally employed. After the new cats were installed the sound of the exhaust changed slightly, but everything works and there are no CEL events. New style cats should flow better than original and aren't really a hindrance to performance like in the olden days.
The V12 cat swap was about $500, your's should be a little less.
#10
Member
You need to have primary cats to avoid check engine light. Secondaries can stay gone but you can smell their non existence lol especially with top down. Buy magnaflows they come from ca in the us. They work great
#11
Member
The state of Colorado applied a law that requires CARB compliant cats. Twice the price of a free flow aftermarket cat and if they do a mirror test at emissions center it better have the CARB numbers. With all the cat thefts its costing a fortune for victims to replace cats.
#13
Super Member
I don't actually know which brand of cat the exhaust guy used, but I did look down into the cat's inlets before they were welded. They weren't the brick style, but a grid.
Ultimately, the fit and sound got on my nerves and after about 8 years, I reverted to OEM MB replacements that looked absolutely brand new.
Ultimately, the fit and sound got on my nerves and after about 8 years, I reverted to OEM MB replacements that looked absolutely brand new.
#15
Super Member
Yep, that's true.
The AMG cars used the V12's resonator and muffler which is larger at the resonator's outlet and muffler's inlet.
If someone is interested in the AMG exhaust setup, I have a V8 (or can be used on the 6 cylinder cars) resonator eliminator and AMG twin tip muffler..
The AMG cars used the V12's resonator and muffler which is larger at the resonator's outlet and muffler's inlet.
If someone is interested in the AMG exhaust setup, I have a V8 (or can be used on the 6 cylinder cars) resonator eliminator and AMG twin tip muffler..
The following users liked this post:
Phillip Berk (01-16-2023)
#17
Member
You wanted to build you a SL55 ;-)
And if you contact Drexler in Germany they can build you the diff with 2.82 ratio. (As it is for the SL55) but then you need new software on the EGS too.
…its a long way to…
And if you contact Drexler in Germany they can build you the diff with 2.82 ratio. (As it is for the SL55) but then you need new software on the EGS too.
…its a long way to…
The following 2 users liked this post by Ahmed:
drewjackowski (11-21-2022),
rickt49 (12-13-2022)
#19
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 2,576
Received 164 Likes
on
132 Posts
From: Bahrain
R129 SL55 AMG & W208 CLK55 AMG
Hey guys,
Still running her with gutted primaries and secondaries and check engine light on.
Exhaust fumes and sound are terrible.
Still looking for replacement primary cats. Any universal ones?
Still running her with gutted primaries and secondaries and check engine light on.
Exhaust fumes and sound are terrible.
Still looking for replacement primary cats. Any universal ones?
#20
Super Member
Ahmed, I know it sounds odd, but have you tried the dealership?
I changed out my original cats for aftermarket ones 8 years ago and they never fit or worked right. They hung too low and occasionally threw CELs.
Last year I went to the dealership and was surprised to find out that brand new (but priced as reconditioned) cats were available. The two cat pipes are new right down to the shielding. The OEM cats are triangular on the V12 out of necessity and sound better than the aftermarket Magnaflows.
They weren't that costly and the fit and performance is OEM.
After I got the cats, I found part numbers for V12 AMG cats. I don't know what the difference was, but there might be factory AMG cats available for you. After getting a core of $200 for each old cat (even though mine were modded), the new cats came out to $260 and $334. I know they will last 200K miles.
I changed out my original cats for aftermarket ones 8 years ago and they never fit or worked right. They hung too low and occasionally threw CELs.
Last year I went to the dealership and was surprised to find out that brand new (but priced as reconditioned) cats were available. The two cat pipes are new right down to the shielding. The OEM cats are triangular on the V12 out of necessity and sound better than the aftermarket Magnaflows.
They weren't that costly and the fit and performance is OEM.
After I got the cats, I found part numbers for V12 AMG cats. I don't know what the difference was, but there might be factory AMG cats available for you. After getting a core of $200 for each old cat (even though mine were modded), the new cats came out to $260 and $334. I know they will last 200K miles.
#21
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 2,576
Received 164 Likes
on
132 Posts
From: Bahrain
R129 SL55 AMG & W208 CLK55 AMG
Hello everyone, just an update.
The dealer no longer carries these parts unfortunately, so I went ahead and did 2 things:
1. Ordered universal cats from Magnaflow ( which should easily replace the undercarriage secondary ones )
2. I also took the plunge and went ahead with ordering the BM Catalysts complete system which includes primary and secondary cats. As per the item specifications and description, they should fit the 1998 to 2001 R129 V6's and V8's M113 setup.
The only observation I may have is that these "might be" made for RHD drive cars ( no mention of this, so I might be making a big deal of it ), but I will go ahead and assume no difference. Even if there are, my exhaust shop will make them fit. The price was too good to pass on honestly. The BM part numbers are 90834 and 90835.
Fingers crossed.
The dealer no longer carries these parts unfortunately, so I went ahead and did 2 things:
1. Ordered universal cats from Magnaflow ( which should easily replace the undercarriage secondary ones )
2. I also took the plunge and went ahead with ordering the BM Catalysts complete system which includes primary and secondary cats. As per the item specifications and description, they should fit the 1998 to 2001 R129 V6's and V8's M113 setup.
The only observation I may have is that these "might be" made for RHD drive cars ( no mention of this, so I might be making a big deal of it ), but I will go ahead and assume no difference. Even if there are, my exhaust shop will make them fit. The price was too good to pass on honestly. The BM part numbers are 90834 and 90835.
Fingers crossed.
Last edited by Ahmed; 11-22-2022 at 12:51 AM.
The following users liked this post:
drewjackowski (11-21-2022)
#22
Newbie
Hello everyone, just an updated.
The dealer no longer carries these parts unfortunately, so I went ahead and did 2 things:
1. Ordered universal cats from Magnaflow ( which should easily replace the undercarriage secondary ones )
2. I also took the plunge and went ahead with ordering the BM Catalysts complete system which includes primary and secondary cats. As per the item specifications and description, they should fit the 1998 to 2001 R129 V6's and V8's M113 setup.
The only observation I may have is that these "might be" made for RHD drive cars ( no mention of this, so I might be making a big deal of it ), but I will go ahead and assume no difference. Even if there are, my exhaust shop will make them fit. The price was too good to pass on honestly. The BM part numbers are 90834 and 90835.
Fingers crossed.
The dealer no longer carries these parts unfortunately, so I went ahead and did 2 things:
1. Ordered universal cats from Magnaflow ( which should easily replace the undercarriage secondary ones )
2. I also took the plunge and went ahead with ordering the BM Catalysts complete system which includes primary and secondary cats. As per the item specifications and description, they should fit the 1998 to 2001 R129 V6's and V8's M113 setup.
The only observation I may have is that these "might be" made for RHD drive cars ( no mention of this, so I might be making a big deal of it ), but I will go ahead and assume no difference. Even if there are, my exhaust shop will make them fit. The price was too good to pass on honestly. The BM part numbers are 90834 and 90835.
Fingers crossed.
after reading your whole 3 year long thread it’s great to see you got something for your baby. Let us know how it goes. I’m currently looking for a new exhaust on my 94 sl500, if u have any info I’d be more than appreciative.
-drew
The following users liked this post:
Ahmed (11-22-2022)
#24
Super Member
Nothing like a new looking exhaust when taking a peek at the underside.
Mine came with all new shielding, which degrades faster than the pipes. Does the factory SL500 exhaust come with shielding ahead of the primary cat?
Did you get your CEL to go out?
Mine came with all new shielding, which degrades faster than the pipes. Does the factory SL500 exhaust come with shielding ahead of the primary cat?
Did you get your CEL to go out?