Highly Disappointed in the new C300
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 47
Likes: 4
From: McKinney, Texas
08 C300 4matic Sport
Highly Disappointed in the new C300
Hello guys,
this thread is for discussion and information exchanges purposes.
Anyways I will start with my first touch to the new c300, I currently have a 2008 c300 4matic sport and what I love about it is the grip, it feels like my car is holding and hugging the road for me. since I love my car I started thinking about the new c300 2015 to now. I don't like the exterior but the interior is terrific. I brought one home for extended test drive and drove about 120 miles in 24 hours the car feels nice from inside but leather and most of the stuff in the car feels cheap. the grip I was talking about it's gone. the new c300 has lot of wind noise, road noise coming from tires and it's bumpy. feel like a Toyota. it doesn't have a Mercedes taste anymore. the reason I will buy another Mercedes is because of the grip and feel behind the wheel. The new models has more like ford fusion or a Toyota Camry feel. I think a Subaru WRX feels better than the new c300. I'm totally disappointed and will think about a 2014 or older c-class or might end up with a Subaru WRX. what do you guys think about the new c-class?
this thread is for discussion and information exchanges purposes.
Anyways I will start with my first touch to the new c300, I currently have a 2008 c300 4matic sport and what I love about it is the grip, it feels like my car is holding and hugging the road for me. since I love my car I started thinking about the new c300 2015 to now. I don't like the exterior but the interior is terrific. I brought one home for extended test drive and drove about 120 miles in 24 hours the car feels nice from inside but leather and most of the stuff in the car feels cheap. the grip I was talking about it's gone. the new c300 has lot of wind noise, road noise coming from tires and it's bumpy. feel like a Toyota. it doesn't have a Mercedes taste anymore. the reason I will buy another Mercedes is because of the grip and feel behind the wheel. The new models has more like ford fusion or a Toyota Camry feel. I think a Subaru WRX feels better than the new c300. I'm totally disappointed and will think about a 2014 or older c-class or might end up with a Subaru WRX. what do you guys think about the new c-class?
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 1,739
Likes: 120
From: London ON Canada
2012 C300 4Matic Sport Sedan
did you drive it in all driving modes? I hear its not to bad but like all new models some people take longer for it to grow on them. Your right i hear there are tons of rattles that get annoying but i wouldn't know first hand.
Every time I see the new C it looks a little better to me. Personally I haven't drove one but I will soon. I just want to test out sports+ mode and see how it is.
Don't get me wrong i still absolutely love my W204, I don't think il ever stop loving it unless i have a major problem with it. the quality of the build, it sticks to the road like you mentioned it still looks great compared to other new cars. I just wish it wasn't so expensive to add features hahaha thats my only gripe about it, i still can't get over not having navi. my goal is to retrofit it eventually.
but if your considering an upgrade to the facelift w204 I'm sure you'll be happy about the updated interior. I still don't mind the 2008-2011 interior even though its a lot of plastic. but the exterior still looks awesome on them, with a few mods it makes that look super aggressive.
Every time I see the new C it looks a little better to me. Personally I haven't drove one but I will soon. I just want to test out sports+ mode and see how it is.
Don't get me wrong i still absolutely love my W204, I don't think il ever stop loving it unless i have a major problem with it. the quality of the build, it sticks to the road like you mentioned it still looks great compared to other new cars. I just wish it wasn't so expensive to add features hahaha thats my only gripe about it, i still can't get over not having navi. my goal is to retrofit it eventually.
but if your considering an upgrade to the facelift w204 I'm sure you'll be happy about the updated interior. I still don't mind the 2008-2011 interior even though its a lot of plastic. but the exterior still looks awesome on them, with a few mods it makes that look super aggressive.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 47
Likes: 4
From: McKinney, Texas
08 C300 4matic Sport
Yes I tried all modes. For someone like me I will never get into the ne C-Class again, everything feels so cheap and the car doesn't stick to the road like the old ones and the noise is not a Mercedes thing, we Americans messed it up I will say R.I.P. C-class. I will just upgrade mine to a 2014 C300. I love how mine hugs the road for me and it's so quite. I will recommend you to test drive it just so you stop thinking about one lol
did you drive it in all driving modes? I hear its not to bad but like all new models some people take longer for it to grow on them. Your right i hear there are tons of rattles that get annoying but i wouldn't know first hand.
Every time I see the new C it looks a little better to me. Personally I haven't drove one but I will soon. I just want to test out sports+ mode and see how it is.
Don't get me wrong i still absolutely love my W204, I don't think il ever stop loving it unless i have a major problem with it. the quality of the build, it sticks to the road like you mentioned it still looks great compared to other new cars. I just wish it wasn't so expensive to add features hahaha thats my only gripe about it, i still can't get over not having navi. my goal is to retrofit it eventually.
but if your considering an upgrade to the facelift w204 I'm sure you'll be happy about the updated interior. I still don't mind the 2008-2011 interior even though its a lot of plastic. but the exterior still looks awesome on them, with a few mods it makes that look super aggressive.
Every time I see the new C it looks a little better to me. Personally I haven't drove one but I will soon. I just want to test out sports+ mode and see how it is.
Don't get me wrong i still absolutely love my W204, I don't think il ever stop loving it unless i have a major problem with it. the quality of the build, it sticks to the road like you mentioned it still looks great compared to other new cars. I just wish it wasn't so expensive to add features hahaha thats my only gripe about it, i still can't get over not having navi. my goal is to retrofit it eventually.
but if your considering an upgrade to the facelift w204 I'm sure you'll be happy about the updated interior. I still don't mind the 2008-2011 interior even though its a lot of plastic. but the exterior still looks awesome on them, with a few mods it makes that look super aggressive.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 57
2013 C250 Sport
I had so many services this year I managed to drive some new C300s for a couple months.
The "cheap" part for me is basically the dashboard and center console area. Otherwise the seats, doors and headliner are all fantastic. The dash and instrument cluster is a rather uninspired step backwards. I hate the AC controls too. They remind me of something from the 1970s. Put the dashboard from the facelift W204 in a W205 and then we'd have a beautiful interior.
I never did hear a W205 with rattles but I had one CLA that sounded like loads of squeaky Styrofoam. There was less than 500 miles on that one too.
There is something light about the handling feeling of the new model. I frequently had slight loss of traction. It handles really well but also feels overly electronic. I couldn't tell if the car did have less "grip" or if I was just feeling a bit more overconfident or disconnected and overdriving.
While Audi and BMW have now messed up their cars throttle responses the W205 seems to have redeemed what they did to our W204s. The agility modes are fantastic and C mode is great for every day driving. S+ is for some really spirited track driving.
Still something about the W205 is so electronic that you almost feel like you're driving in a video game at times. I guess that is the future until cars are all self driving anyway.
The "cheap" part for me is basically the dashboard and center console area. Otherwise the seats, doors and headliner are all fantastic. The dash and instrument cluster is a rather uninspired step backwards. I hate the AC controls too. They remind me of something from the 1970s. Put the dashboard from the facelift W204 in a W205 and then we'd have a beautiful interior.
I never did hear a W205 with rattles but I had one CLA that sounded like loads of squeaky Styrofoam. There was less than 500 miles on that one too.
There is something light about the handling feeling of the new model. I frequently had slight loss of traction. It handles really well but also feels overly electronic. I couldn't tell if the car did have less "grip" or if I was just feeling a bit more overconfident or disconnected and overdriving.
While Audi and BMW have now messed up their cars throttle responses the W205 seems to have redeemed what they did to our W204s. The agility modes are fantastic and C mode is great for every day driving. S+ is for some really spirited track driving.
Still something about the W205 is so electronic that you almost feel like you're driving in a video game at times. I guess that is the future until cars are all self driving anyway.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 47
Likes: 4
From: McKinney, Texas
08 C300 4matic Sport
Michael,
I will have to agree with you on S+, the interior looks nice even though it feels cheap. The downside for me was harsh driving and not having the same grip that we have in the W204. also road noise is really annoying that it feels just like any Japanese or American daily commute cars, I can literately hear every bump my tires hit. I will just stick with my w204 and keep looking for a 2014 c300 with AMG Package if I could find one.
I appreciate your guys sharing your experience here with me
I will have to agree with you on S+, the interior looks nice even though it feels cheap. The downside for me was harsh driving and not having the same grip that we have in the W204. also road noise is really annoying that it feels just like any Japanese or American daily commute cars, I can literately hear every bump my tires hit. I will just stick with my w204 and keep looking for a 2014 c300 with AMG Package if I could find one.
I appreciate your guys sharing your experience here with me
I had so many services this year I managed to drive some new C300s for a couple months.
The "cheap" part for me is basically the dashboard and center console area. Otherwise the seats, doors and headliner are all fantastic. The dash and instrument cluster is a rather uninspired step backwards. I hate the AC controls too. They remind me of something from the 1970s. Put the dashboard from the facelift W204 in a W205 and then we'd have a beautiful interior.
I never did hear a W205 with rattles but I had one CLA that sounded like loads of squeaky Styrofoam. There was less than 500 miles on that one too.
There is something light about the handling feeling of the new model. I frequently had slight loss of traction. It handles really well but also feels overly electronic. I couldn't tell if the car did have less "grip" or if I was just feeling a bit more overconfident or disconnected and overdriving.
While Audi and BMW have now messed up their cars throttle responses the W205 seems to have redeemed what they did to our W204s. The agility modes are fantastic and C mode is great for every day driving. S+ is for some really spirited track driving.
Still something about the W205 is so electronic that you almost feel like you're driving in a video game at times. I guess that is the future until cars are all self driving anyway.
The "cheap" part for me is basically the dashboard and center console area. Otherwise the seats, doors and headliner are all fantastic. The dash and instrument cluster is a rather uninspired step backwards. I hate the AC controls too. They remind me of something from the 1970s. Put the dashboard from the facelift W204 in a W205 and then we'd have a beautiful interior.
I never did hear a W205 with rattles but I had one CLA that sounded like loads of squeaky Styrofoam. There was less than 500 miles on that one too.
There is something light about the handling feeling of the new model. I frequently had slight loss of traction. It handles really well but also feels overly electronic. I couldn't tell if the car did have less "grip" or if I was just feeling a bit more overconfident or disconnected and overdriving.
While Audi and BMW have now messed up their cars throttle responses the W205 seems to have redeemed what they did to our W204s. The agility modes are fantastic and C mode is great for every day driving. S+ is for some really spirited track driving.
Still something about the W205 is so electronic that you almost feel like you're driving in a video game at times. I guess that is the future until cars are all self driving anyway.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jul 2015
Posts: 1,071
Likes: 349
From: Fredonia, WI
2012 E550 v8-Biturbo
You'll find lots of comments from W205 owners about the electric steering feeling "unnatural."
There was also a recall dealing with the steering software IIRC.
I don't know, it's probably just me, but I'm not a fan of all this "fly by wire" stuff ...
There was also a recall dealing with the steering software IIRC.
I don't know, it's probably just me, but I'm not a fan of all this "fly by wire" stuff ...
Last edited by ghlkal; May 26, 2016 at 10:53 PM.
Trending Topics
MB World Stories
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
New Electric Mercedes-AMG GT 4-Door Coupe Unveiled: 10 Things You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
6 Mercedes Models That Did NOT Age Well (But Are Somehow Still Cool)
Verdad Gallardo
Manual Mercedes? 6 Times Sindelfingen Let Drivers Have All The Fun
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes SLR McLaren 722 S Is Extremely Rare Example Modified by McLaren
Verdad Gallardo
8 Classic Boxy Mercedes Designs That Have Aged Like Fine Wine
Verdad Gallardo
Flawlessly Restored Mercedes 190E Evo II Heads to Auction
Verdad Gallardo
Electric Mercedes C-Class Unveiled: 11 Things You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes EQS Gets A Major Update: Everything You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
5 Underrated Mercedes-Benz Models That Don't Get the Love They Deserve
Verdad Gallardo
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 57
2013 C250 Sport
Michael,
I will have to agree with you on S+, the interior looks nice even though it feels cheap. The downside for me was harsh driving and not having the same grip that we have in the W204. also road noise is really annoying that it feels just like any Japanese or American daily commute cars, I can literately hear every bump my tires hit. I will just stick with my w204 and keep looking for a 2014 c300 with AMG Package if I could find one.
I appreciate your guys sharing your experience here with me
I will have to agree with you on S+, the interior looks nice even though it feels cheap. The downside for me was harsh driving and not having the same grip that we have in the W204. also road noise is really annoying that it feels just like any Japanese or American daily commute cars, I can literately hear every bump my tires hit. I will just stick with my w204 and keep looking for a 2014 c300 with AMG Package if I could find one.
I appreciate your guys sharing your experience here with me
Perhaps it could be rougher roads where you are with the run flats? The CLA is definitely stiffer. But I have found the new C300s I've driven to be on the cushy side.
Super Moderator
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 19,942
Likes: 192
From: Llandudno, Cape Town, South Africa
late 2009 CLK 350 Coupe Elegance, '65 Jaguar S Type wires
Drive a W205 with decent Michelin Tyres & not run flats & you will be surprised! You soon get used to the steering. The cabin is subjective. Early pre facelift W204 cabins came in for plenty of criticism.
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 350
Likes: 22
From: Edmonton
14' E63S
What you should be driving is a C400/450 and not a C300 if you are looking at the W205 models.
Comparing the W204 C300 to the W205 C300 is like comparing a C300 to a C250 to be honest.
The C300 you drove is for sure a 4 banger which no matter what you do will not feel as nice as our model. That could be due to the weight of the car as well/or weight of the engine on the front.
Go and drive the C400/450 which has a V6 and you will feel and hear the difference big time. In regards to the interior, it also might depend if you get the new MBTex or the Actual leather option.
Comparing the W204 C300 to the W205 C300 is like comparing a C300 to a C250 to be honest.
The C300 you drove is for sure a 4 banger which no matter what you do will not feel as nice as our model. That could be due to the weight of the car as well/or weight of the engine on the front.
Go and drive the C400/450 which has a V6 and you will feel and hear the difference big time. In regards to the interior, it also might depend if you get the new MBTex or the Actual leather option.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 47
Likes: 4
From: McKinney, Texas
08 C300 4matic Sport
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 47
Likes: 4
From: McKinney, Texas
08 C300 4matic Sport
Odd thing is I would say the new C300 is much quieter than my car and a bit on the softer side. Although I have a cupped tire and something whiney in the serpentine belt system. Those two things are driving me a bit bonkers.
Perhaps it could be rougher roads where you are with the run flats? The CLA is definitely stiffer. But I have found the new C300s I've driven to be on the cushy side.
Perhaps it could be rougher roads where you are with the run flats? The CLA is definitely stiffer. But I have found the new C300s I've driven to be on the cushy side.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 47
Likes: 4
From: McKinney, Texas
08 C300 4matic Sport
What you should be driving is a C400/450 and not a C300 if you are looking at the W205 models.
Comparing the W204 C300 to the W205 C300 is like comparing a C300 to a C250 to be honest.
The C300 you drove is for sure a 4 banger which no matter what you do will not feel as nice as our model. That could be due to the weight of the car as well/or weight of the engine on the front.
Go and drive the C400/450 which has a V6 and you will feel and hear the difference big time. In regards to the interior, it also might depend if you get the new MBTex or the Actual leather option.
Comparing the W204 C300 to the W205 C300 is like comparing a C300 to a C250 to be honest.
The C300 you drove is for sure a 4 banger which no matter what you do will not feel as nice as our model. That could be due to the weight of the car as well/or weight of the engine on the front.
Go and drive the C400/450 which has a V6 and you will feel and hear the difference big time. In regards to the interior, it also might depend if you get the new MBTex or the Actual leather option.
Super Moderator
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 19,942
Likes: 192
From: Llandudno, Cape Town, South Africa
late 2009 CLK 350 Coupe Elegance, '65 Jaguar S Type wires
What you should be driving is a C400/450 and not a C300 if you are looking at the W205 models.
Comparing the W204 C300 to the W205 C300 is like comparing a C300 to a C250 to be honest.
The C300 you drove is for sure a 4 banger which no matter what you do will not feel as nice as our model. That could be due to the weight of the car as well/or weight of the engine on the front.
Go and drive the C400/450 which has a V6 and you will feel and hear the difference big time. In regards to the interior, it also might depend if you get the new MBTex or the Actual leather option.
Comparing the W204 C300 to the W205 C300 is like comparing a C300 to a C250 to be honest.
The C300 you drove is for sure a 4 banger which no matter what you do will not feel as nice as our model. That could be due to the weight of the car as well/or weight of the engine on the front.
Go and drive the C400/450 which has a V6 and you will feel and hear the difference big time. In regards to the interior, it also might depend if you get the new MBTex or the Actual leather option.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 47
Likes: 4
From: McKinney, Texas
08 C300 4matic Sport
What kind of tires do you recommend for my w204. I like a good grip and quite ride. I have continentals on mine now
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 57
2013 C250 Sport
For some reason I can't feel that much of a significant difference between the C250 and C300 and I tend to be sensitive to those things. I test drove both extensively and opted for RWD in the end. Although my car has occasional rough warm starts.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 57
2013 C250 Sport
Super Member
Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 885
Likes: 57
From: PA
2019 E63s AMG
You guys are nuts, I currently have a base W205 and it feels SOO much better than my 2012, so much that after a year with the 12 I already want the 16. The car feels SO MUCH quicker in Sport+ than S on the W204 that it is ridiculous. Lets not talk about its looks, the only downside it has is the rear end, everything else looks better and more modern.
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 350
Likes: 22
From: Edmonton
14' E63S
I don't know but there is a big feel difference for me between the 4 and the 6. For me the main thing is that raspy noise out of the 4 banger, and the power line is just not as refined as it is in the 6.
The other thing and maybe its just me, but isn't the c450 like 300 pounds heavier as well. That would make it feel different that's for sure. Everything else is going to be pretty much the same but the C450 for me feels much more refined than the C300.
The other thing and maybe its just me, but isn't the c450 like 300 pounds heavier as well. That would make it feel different that's for sure. Everything else is going to be pretty much the same but the C450 for me feels much more refined than the C300.
Super Moderator
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 19,942
Likes: 192
From: Llandudno, Cape Town, South Africa
late 2009 CLK 350 Coupe Elegance, '65 Jaguar S Type wires
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 8,384
Likes: 800
2019 G70 6MT & 2022 Ford Maverick XL
The W205 interior doesn't do it for me. I don't seem to like the interiors until facelifts for some reason. Am I the only one who looks at the gauges in the new C and sees GM? Reminds me of Pontiac. Can't help it, thought it from the first time I saw it.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 1,282
Likes: 57
2013 C250 Sport
Mercedes is woefully behind Audi, BMW, Ford, etc. when it comes to some of the interior tech. That is unless you have an S class.
I think we'll see a facelift soon. Some things are nice about the W205. But the designers left me scratching my head on a few things.
