C Class not the worst in consumer reports reliability
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 4,524
Likes: 1,181
From: WI
17 E43; 21 GLS580
C Class not the worst in consumer reports reliability
"Only" third worst in its Class! Woohoo!
"Only" 82% below the average!
Really not a surprise for most of us that bought the first production.
Not surprisingly the most common defects reported were all the ones I suffered. Suspension, Infotainment, Electronic controls (Door sensors). They also mentioned the 4matic which has not been a problem for me. Lets hope that these are only first year "teething" issues.
At least it did better than the ATS and the Acura TLX. The TLX was surprisingly bad primarily because of a bum 9 speed transmission.
For non USA residents, the TLX is a North American "luxury" version of the Honda Accord, usually very reliable.
"Only" 82% below the average!
Really not a surprise for most of us that bought the first production.
Not surprisingly the most common defects reported were all the ones I suffered. Suspension, Infotainment, Electronic controls (Door sensors). They also mentioned the 4matic which has not been a problem for me. Lets hope that these are only first year "teething" issues.
At least it did better than the ATS and the Acura TLX. The TLX was surprisingly bad primarily because of a bum 9 speed transmission.
For non USA residents, the TLX is a North American "luxury" version of the Honda Accord, usually very reliable.
Member
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 171
Likes: 1
Ferrari, Lexus, Toyota
I saw that, amazingly embarrassing.
Unfortunately the 2015 C300 I have is the worst car I've ever had. Having MB buy my lease out early based on they've had it more than I have. Terrible build quality IMO. Aside from nice interior appointments and nice handling, nothing luxury about it. It seems beyond teething problems of how adamantly MB is at calling defects normal.
Going to probably buy a Lexus. Not as engaging to drive, but blows MB away in any other luxury metric IMO. Will see what kinks the Germans can work out on next generation or so. If they could only get their QA together, they really would have something.
Unfortunately the 2015 C300 I have is the worst car I've ever had. Having MB buy my lease out early based on they've had it more than I have. Terrible build quality IMO. Aside from nice interior appointments and nice handling, nothing luxury about it. It seems beyond teething problems of how adamantly MB is at calling defects normal.
Going to probably buy a Lexus. Not as engaging to drive, but blows MB away in any other luxury metric IMO. Will see what kinks the Germans can work out on next generation or so. If they could only get their QA together, they really would have something.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,822
Likes: 33
From: Whitefield, NH
2015 C300 Sport: Palladium, Premium, Multimedia, Leather, BLIS
CR mentions drive system, which is not necessarily the 4Matic. I believe that covers several areas, including the transmission, which has garnered its share of complaints. In-car electronics mainly concerns the user interface, which many owners find too complex. The steering/suspension is an area I hadn't heard many complaints about. Nothing listed covers the problems with MB-Tex, wind noise issues, or fit and finish defects. I don't think the CR ratings surprise any of us. I wonder how the European and SA builds would do in a similar survey.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 1,581
Likes: 114
From: Mass
2026 GLE 53 Coupe
I'll tell you though, I'll be looking real hard at the 2017 BMW 328i xDrive with the new 4 cylinder engine, and a 2017 Lexus IS350 AWD if it comes with that new 8 sp transmission.
Last edited by MASSC450; Nov 4, 2015 at 10:26 AM.
Member
Joined: Feb 2015
Posts: 159
Likes: 5
C300
CR mentions drive system, which is not necessarily the 4Matic. I believe that covers several areas, including the transmission, which has garnered its share of complaints. In-car electronics mainly concerns the user interface, which many owners find too complex. The steering/suspension is an area I hadn't heard many complaints about. Nothing listed covers the problems with MB-Tex, wind noise issues, or fit and finish defects. I don't think the CR ratings surprise any of us. I wonder how the European and SA builds would do in a similar survey.
Mine hasn't left me at the side of the road, but has had many visits to the dealer for annoyances, firmware, steering, noise, gas door, touch pad, brake adjustment, the list goes on.
Outstanding designs, poorly executed. I don't think Mercedes will take that as their marketing slogan, but it wound unfortunately fit. Frustrating. I'd sell, but check the postings, these cars are being sold a dime a dozen used. Found one near me, C400 with 8200 miles, pretty loaded, $31k asking.
Last edited by kellens; Nov 4, 2015 at 10:46 AM.
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 4,524
Likes: 1,181
From: WI
17 E43; 21 GLS580
I bought the car with my eyes wide open. I knew that Mercedes has always had spotty reliability at best. However the mix of beautiful design and performance of the C400 was impossible to resist. As long as the car doesn't leave me stranded (which is my never buy again criteria) I will take the otherwise minor glitches in stride. After my initial rash of issues the car has been essentially perfect (a little distortion from the radio here and there). Its superbly comfortable, handles with alacrity (after replacing the all seasons) and is very, very fast (after the Renntech tune which added the second "very").
As to going the Lexus path, I test drove an AWD GS back to back with the C Class, a totally disappointing experience. The "luxury" was subpar, the engine was basically "adequate", the handling was poor and the electronic interface was just as bad or worse than MB. In fact it was worse than a C300 in basically every respect. It felt no better than a glorified Toyota with better leather. I guess if you never go faster than the speed limit and feel over the hill an LS might be a good option, otherwise, I would avoid Lexus entirely. I'll take some little frustrations over being bored to death all the time.
As to going the Lexus path, I test drove an AWD GS back to back with the C Class, a totally disappointing experience. The "luxury" was subpar, the engine was basically "adequate", the handling was poor and the electronic interface was just as bad or worse than MB. In fact it was worse than a C300 in basically every respect. It felt no better than a glorified Toyota with better leather. I guess if you never go faster than the speed limit and feel over the hill an LS might be a good option, otherwise, I would avoid Lexus entirely. I'll take some little frustrations over being bored to death all the time.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 3,447
Likes: 333
From: Tampa, FL
2019 E450 4Matic & 2018 E400 4Matic
I bought the car with my eyes wide open. I knew that Mercedes has always had spotty reliability at best. However the mix of beautiful design and performance of the C400 was impossible to resist. As long as the car doesn't leave me stranded (which is my never buy again criteria) I will take the otherwise minor glitches in stride. After my initial rash of issues the car has been essentially perfect (a little distortion from the radio here and there). Its superbly comfortable, handles with alacrity (after replacing the all seasons) and is very, very fast (after the Renntech tune which added the second "very").
As to going the Lexus path, I test drove an AWD GS back to back with the C Class, a totally disappointing experience. The "luxury" was subpar, the engine was basically "adequate", the handling was poor and the electronic interface was just as bad or worse than MB. In fact it was worse than a C300 in basically every respect. It felt no better than a glorified Toyota with better leather. I guess if you never go faster than the speed limit and feel over the hill an LS might be a good option, otherwise, I would avoid Lexus entirely. I'll take some little frustrations over being bored to death all the time.
As to going the Lexus path, I test drove an AWD GS back to back with the C Class, a totally disappointing experience. The "luxury" was subpar, the engine was basically "adequate", the handling was poor and the electronic interface was just as bad or worse than MB. In fact it was worse than a C300 in basically every respect. It felt no better than a glorified Toyota with better leather. I guess if you never go faster than the speed limit and feel over the hill an LS might be a good option, otherwise, I would avoid Lexus entirely. I'll take some little frustrations over being bored to death all the time.
Trending Topics
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,822
Likes: 33
From: Whitefield, NH
2015 C300 Sport: Palladium, Premium, Multimedia, Leather, BLIS
I bought the car with my eyes wide open. I knew that Mercedes has always had spotty reliability at best. However the mix of beautiful design and performance of the C400 was impossible to resist. As long as the car doesn't leave me stranded (which is my never buy again criteria) I will take the otherwise minor glitches in stride. After my initial rash of issues the car has been essentially perfect (a little distortion from the radio here and there). Its superbly comfortable, handles with alacrity (after replacing the all seasons) and is very, very fast (after the Renntech tune which added the second "very").
I have no idea why there is such a huge contrast between that early car's horrible build quality and the virtually trouble free experience I am having with my current C300. The VIN jumped from the 27xx range into the 61xxx range, but that alone doesn't explain the differences since the components are essentially the same. At best, perhaps, it means that someone may be finally getting a handle on the Alabama assembly process and the previous lack of any apparent QC. At worst, it may be nothing but luck in randomly getting a well built car. In any case, it seems to be a learning process that the consumer should never have been exposed to. For everyone's sake, I can only hope that the 2016 production run has finally progressed beyond the beta testing stage.
Last edited by StanNH; Nov 4, 2015 at 11:36 AM.
MB World Stories
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
6 Mercedes Models That Did NOT Age Well (But Are Somehow Still Cool)
Verdad Gallardo
Manual Mercedes? 6 Times Sindelfingen Let Drivers Have All The Fun
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes SLR McLaren 722 S Is Extremely Rare Example Modified by McLaren
Verdad Gallardo
8 Classic Boxy Mercedes Designs That Have Aged Like Fine Wine
Verdad Gallardo
Flawlessly Restored Mercedes 190E Evo II Heads to Auction
Verdad Gallardo
Electric Mercedes C-Class Unveiled: 11 Things You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes EQS Gets A Major Update: Everything You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
5 Underrated Mercedes-Benz Models That Don't Get the Love They Deserve
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes 300D Has Pushed Well Past 1 Million Miles and It Ain't Stopping
Verdad Gallardo
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 4,524
Likes: 1,181
From: WI
17 E43; 21 GLS580
I too went into this well aware of the spotty MB reliability record with its cars. Unfortunately, my first C300 was a nightmare as far as defects and mandatory trips to the dealer. It never left me stranded ... although there were times I thought it would due to its refusal to let me into the car ... but the majority of the first 3,000 miles were put on going back and forth to the dealer. If it weren't for my dealer's intervention in getting me a new C300, that car would have been the first and last MB I ever owned. As good as the car's design was, I became thoroughly disgusted with it and would have absorbed any financial hit to get rid of it.
I have no idea why there is such a huge contrast between that early car's horrible build quality and the virtually trouble free experience I am having with my current C300. The VIN jumped from the 27xx range into the 61xxx range, but that alone doesn't explain the differences since the components are essentially the same. At best, perhaps, it means that someone may be finally getting a handle on the Alabama assembly process and the previous lack of any apparent QC. At worst, it may be nothing but luck in randomly getting a well built car. In any case, it seems to be a learning process that the consumer should never have been exposed to. For everyone's sake, I can only hope that the 2016 production run has finally progressed beyond the beta testing stage.
I have no idea why there is such a huge contrast between that early car's horrible build quality and the virtually trouble free experience I am having with my current C300. The VIN jumped from the 27xx range into the 61xxx range, but that alone doesn't explain the differences since the components are essentially the same. At best, perhaps, it means that someone may be finally getting a handle on the Alabama assembly process and the previous lack of any apparent QC. At worst, it may be nothing but luck in randomly getting a well built car. In any case, it seems to be a learning process that the consumer should never have been exposed to. For everyone's sake, I can only hope that the 2016 production run has finally progressed beyond the beta testing stage.
Member
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 171
Likes: 1
Ferrari, Lexus, Toyota
That's why it's great there's so many choices of cars for those that can afford it. The MB when you drive it very engaging, the comparable Lexus' (or is it Lexi) I have test driven beat it in every other metric. While I agree, the LS wouldn't be my first choice, it's as reliable as can be, and so precisely put together, it makes my C look like a high school science project.
I bring this up as they're on the polar opposite of MB on reliability. I didn't think the MB would be completely ironed out, or even to Hyundai level, but didn't think it would be this bad.
While my C is a wonderful design and engaging car to drive when it works if you can ignore the bugs, replace run flats, windows, etc.... NOTHING is more boring and aggravating at the same time than the MB ownership experience where defects are all either normal, or part of the design according to their manufacturer.
Still waiting to hear that they'll take it back on lease and sell it to some other sucker.
I bring this up as they're on the polar opposite of MB on reliability. I didn't think the MB would be completely ironed out, or even to Hyundai level, but didn't think it would be this bad.
While my C is a wonderful design and engaging car to drive when it works if you can ignore the bugs, replace run flats, windows, etc.... NOTHING is more boring and aggravating at the same time than the MB ownership experience where defects are all either normal, or part of the design according to their manufacturer.
Still waiting to hear that they'll take it back on lease and sell it to some other sucker.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,822
Likes: 33
From: Whitefield, NH
2015 C300 Sport: Palladium, Premium, Multimedia, Leather, BLIS
While my C is a wonderful design and engaging car to drive when it works if you can ignore the bugs, replace run flats, windows, etc.... NOTHING is more boring and aggravating at the same time than the MB ownership experience where defects are all either normal, or part of the design according to their manufacturer.
Still waiting to hear that they'll take it back on lease and sell it to some other sucker.
Still waiting to hear that they'll take it back on lease and sell it to some other sucker.
Thread Starter
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 4,524
Likes: 1,181
From: WI
17 E43; 21 GLS580
That's why it's great there's so many choices of cars for those that can afford it. The MB when you drive it very engaging, the comparable Lexus' (or is it Lexi) I have test driven beat it in every other metric. While I agree, the LS wouldn't be my first choice, it's as reliable as can be, and so precisely put together, it makes my C look like a high school science project.
I bring this up as they're on the polar opposite of MB on reliability. I didn't think the MB would be completely ironed out, or even to Hyundai level, but didn't think it would be this bad.
While my C is a wonderful design and engaging car to drive when it works if you can ignore the bugs, replace run flats, windows, etc.... NOTHING is more boring and aggravating at the same time than the MB ownership experience where defects are all either normal, or part of the design according to their manufacturer.
Still waiting to hear that they'll take it back on lease and sell it to some other sucker.
I bring this up as they're on the polar opposite of MB on reliability. I didn't think the MB would be completely ironed out, or even to Hyundai level, but didn't think it would be this bad.
While my C is a wonderful design and engaging car to drive when it works if you can ignore the bugs, replace run flats, windows, etc.... NOTHING is more boring and aggravating at the same time than the MB ownership experience where defects are all either normal, or part of the design according to their manufacturer.
Still waiting to hear that they'll take it back on lease and sell it to some other sucker.
Member
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 171
Likes: 1
Ferrari, Lexus, Toyota
The steering has a bug in it that they can't find, it gives the warning, will reset if left alone for 15-20 minutes, and yet to be fixed by firmware. Fuel door was ok new, but after closing door after fill up, it's crooked. I'm not that strong. I just pushed in about half an inch. Required rework, and they said I had damaged it...wasn't covered. They contacted MBUSA who said "No fuel doors on a 2015 c class have had any alighment issues to date'. My command volumes are erratic, and they changed the unit, and tried several firmwares, no luck. They say it's hopefully going to be addressed in a future patch. There's a buzzing sound, from the drive line or rear end differential when vehicle isn't accelerating that is new, they say it's normal. That's all I can think of now.
Great group of folks here! i just feel badly they didn't get the kinks worked out. Cool looking and driving car, when it works.
Member
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 171
Likes: 1
Ferrari, Lexus, Toyota
Agree completely. I switched dealers for that reason. The new dealer is most definitely better than the old one. My only chagrin is the new one is 40 miles farther than the previous one (which was already 80 miles away) though its now in a place I go often since my daughter is in college there.
My issues were more with once hitting an issue, MBUSA acting like I'm the first one to express the concern.
I understand refresh year cars have bugs. They just don't get fixed or keep customers with the MBUSA mentality. I don't mean to be negative either. I had high hopes, and relatively low expectations for this car. I went through 2 of them.
Hopefully my C will be gone soon enough. Great handling concept car. A finished refined product, even if boring to drive, sounds most luxurious and appealing to me about now
Last edited by HelenR; Nov 4, 2015 at 04:55 PM.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,822
Likes: 33
From: Whitefield, NH
2015 C300 Sport: Palladium, Premium, Multimedia, Leather, BLIS
Helen, just so you know, fuel door alignment problems were common. My first C300 had a terribly aligned fuel door and the entire assembly had to be replaced. The door and assembly are plastic, and the door is glued on to the arm. There is no adjustment in this, so a new unit is the only way to get it set properly. Your dealer should have simply replaced the assembly for you.
Member
Joined: Oct 2015
Posts: 118
Likes: 1
2016 C450 AMG; 2015 Infiniti QX60
I too went into this well aware of the spotty MB reliability record with its cars. Unfortunately, my first C300 was a nightmare as far as defects and mandatory trips to the dealer. It never left me stranded ... although there were times I thought it would due to its refusal to let me into the car ... but the majority of the first 3,000 miles were put on going back and forth to the dealer. If it weren't for my dealer's intervention in getting me a new C300, that car would have been the first and last MB I ever owned. As good as the car's design was, I became thoroughly disgusted with it and would have absorbed any financial hit to get rid of it.
I have no idea why there is such a huge contrast between that early car's horrible build quality and the virtually trouble free experience I am having with my current C300. The VIN jumped from the 27xx range into the 61xxx range, but that alone doesn't explain the differences since the components are essentially the same. At best, perhaps, it means that someone may be finally getting a handle on the Alabama assembly process and the previous lack of any apparent QC. At worst, it may be nothing but luck in randomly getting a well built car. In any case, it seems to be a learning process that the consumer should never have been exposed to. For everyone's sake, I can only hope that the 2016 production run has finally progressed beyond the beta testing stage.
I have no idea why there is such a huge contrast between that early car's horrible build quality and the virtually trouble free experience I am having with my current C300. The VIN jumped from the 27xx range into the 61xxx range, but that alone doesn't explain the differences since the components are essentially the same. At best, perhaps, it means that someone may be finally getting a handle on the Alabama assembly process and the previous lack of any apparent QC. At worst, it may be nothing but luck in randomly getting a well built car. In any case, it seems to be a learning process that the consumer should never have been exposed to. For everyone's sake, I can only hope that the 2016 production run has finally progressed beyond the beta testing stage.
Member
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 82
Likes: 0
From: SF Bay Area
Mercedes C300, BMW X5
"Only" third worst in its Class! Woohoo!
"Only" 82% below the average!
Really not a surprise for most of us that bought the first production.
Not surprisingly the most common defects reported were all the ones I suffered. Suspension, Infotainment, Electronic controls (Door sensors). They also mentioned the 4matic which has not been a problem for me. Lets hope that these are only first year "teething" issues.
At least it did better than the ATS and the Acura TLX. The TLX was surprisingly bad primarily because of a bum 9 speed transmission.
For non USA residents, the TLX is a North American "luxury" version of the Honda Accord, usually very reliable.
"Only" 82% below the average!
Really not a surprise for most of us that bought the first production.
Not surprisingly the most common defects reported were all the ones I suffered. Suspension, Infotainment, Electronic controls (Door sensors). They also mentioned the 4matic which has not been a problem for me. Lets hope that these are only first year "teething" issues.
At least it did better than the ATS and the Acura TLX. The TLX was surprisingly bad primarily because of a bum 9 speed transmission.
For non USA residents, the TLX is a North American "luxury" version of the Honda Accord, usually very reliable.
Newbie
Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 6
Likes: 0
04 Yukon XL 8.1 09 WRX
I really wanted to risk it....really
The CR and JD power reliability data for the 14 C series was what finally killed it for me. I don't live anywhere near a dealer, and even if an hour away I would have taken the risk after my c450 test drive. Almost resentful of MB actually. Love that interior and I think they have hit the sweet spot for performance, handling and $$ with the 450. Let's see if they can get reliability mostly sorted as they did at the end of the 204 production run. Then I can get one after this lease.
With 4 kids, the c was a bit of a down stretch but I would have done it. Getting a GS Fsport. Handling beat the A6, E 400 (it's size equivalent) IMHO when I drove them and turns out many road test articles agree. Not near the straight line punch, but more than I will get to use often. I had the same "it's a fancy Toyota appliance" mentality and only drove it to kill 2 hours in between other appointments. Put it in Sport + and left it there. I was shocked that I enjoyed it.
With 4 kids, the c was a bit of a down stretch but I would have done it. Getting a GS Fsport. Handling beat the A6, E 400 (it's size equivalent) IMHO when I drove them and turns out many road test articles agree. Not near the straight line punch, but more than I will get to use often. I had the same "it's a fancy Toyota appliance" mentality and only drove it to kill 2 hours in between other appointments. Put it in Sport + and left it there. I was shocked that I enjoyed it.
Member
Joined: Feb 2015
Posts: 159
Likes: 5
C300
The CR and JD power reliability data for the 14 C series was what finally killed it for me. I don't live anywhere near a dealer, and even if an hour away I would have taken the risk after my c450 test drive. Almost resentful of MB actually. Love that interior and I think they have hit the sweet spot for performance, handling and $$ with the 450. Let's see if they can get reliability mostly sorted as they did at the end of the 204 production run. Then I can get one after this lease.
With 4 kids, the c was a bit of a down stretch but I would have done it. Getting a GS Fsport. Handling beat the A6, E 400 (it's size equivalent) IMHO when I drove them and turns out many road test articles agree. Not near the straight line punch, but more than I will get to use often. I had the same "it's a fancy Toyota appliance" mentality and only drove it to kill 2 hours in between other appointments. Put it in Sport + and left it there. I was shocked that I enjoyed it.
With 4 kids, the c was a bit of a down stretch but I would have done it. Getting a GS Fsport. Handling beat the A6, E 400 (it's size equivalent) IMHO when I drove them and turns out many road test articles agree. Not near the straight line punch, but more than I will get to use often. I had the same "it's a fancy Toyota appliance" mentality and only drove it to kill 2 hours in between other appointments. Put it in Sport + and left it there. I was shocked that I enjoyed it.
The older brand snobs, or many on this board likely to scoff at Lexus as it's a newer brand, or think less of Toyota making it, but anyone in the know realizes Toyota's build process puts MB to shame on every model, every year, every car. Not luck of the draw like with this car. I'll say it shouldn't be that way, but it is. MB has gizmos and driving engagement, but that's where it stops. They kinda returned to the early 2000s. Poor builds, and MB, especially MBUSA not standing behind the products. I'm disheartened. The reliability numbers don't lie. And I think they're actually being kind to the German auto makers.
All that said, I realize we're on an MB forum, and many will disagree with me. CR, JD Power, and owners of the cars won't though.
Last edited by kellens; Nov 5, 2015 at 08:35 PM.
