SBC malfunction = accident
#101
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: FL410
Posts: 4,968
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
'05 E320 CDI, '08 BMW X5 4.8i, '11 Duramax 2500HD
Originally Posted by mleskovar
The SBC 'system' is inferior because it offers questionable improvement over the system it is replacing and the implementation is inferior.
#102
Super Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Mansfield, TX
Posts: 693
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
11 ML350W2 / 17 GLC300
Originally Posted by SAguirre
I have previously stated that the SBC has let me stop very quickly and IN CONTROL on snow and icy roads that are curved. This can be measured in other units instead of milliseconds. I can simply say that the SBC stopped my in time to avoid the animal and kept my car on the road.
Steve
Steve
Your experience with the SBC braking system is more extensive than most other drivers. Your driving in the mountains and snow is something that I don't envy. I used to live in Upstate NY and had similar experiences with snow, curves, hills, and critters. The SBC braking system would have been very welcome.
Jim
#103
Super Member
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: North Scottsdale
Posts: 910
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
06 C 350 2014 GLK350
I'm convinced that the SBC braking system is supereior to standard brakes. My wife and I each had to make an emergency stop with one of our W211's and both times we couldn't believe how smoothly and quickly the brakes stopped the car. In both cases with ordinary brakes the ABS would most likely have come on but with SBC it was able to stop smoothly without needing ABS.
#104
MBWorld Fanatic!
This horse has been beat to death....
Originally Posted by GearHead
Like I said before, I love my W211 and I sincerely believe SBC does work but once I experienced my brake failure, perception changed. For you die hards, I pray you will NEVER have to experience it.
#105
MBWorld Fanatic!
Originally Posted by CE750
The problem is that you're the only one questioning that.. Every other article I've read on it says it safer and better that normal brakes.
#106
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 293
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'13 E550 W4
SBC or Battery Control Module Failure??
I believe that many people experiencing "SBC brake failure" are really experiencing the failure of the Battery Control Module, which when failed shuts down the brakes and transmission. This happended to my '04 E500 in traffic. No accident, but disasterously close.
#107
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Poland
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
[QUOTE=GearHead]You NAILED it.
A braking system should be rated as a complete system (SBC and backup). MB should not have introduced a STATE of the ART primary braking system and provide some 3rd rate back up braking system.
This is the point: You buy MB for amny reasons. On of them is safety.
WHen SBC goes into failure mode by higher speed you are not able to stop it" especially whet the driver is for example woman.
IT is disaster when only on axe is breaking with no assistance. The break accuracy is in the power of your feet...like 30 years before. What is important that when such a situation occurs you are so scared that brake is not working that you panic and distance is longer and longer...
A braking system should be rated as a complete system (SBC and backup). MB should not have introduced a STATE of the ART primary braking system and provide some 3rd rate back up braking system.
This is the point: You buy MB for amny reasons. On of them is safety.
WHen SBC goes into failure mode by higher speed you are not able to stop it" especially whet the driver is for example woman.
IT is disaster when only on axe is breaking with no assistance. The break accuracy is in the power of your feet...like 30 years before. What is important that when such a situation occurs you are so scared that brake is not working that you panic and distance is longer and longer...
#108
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Valley of the Sun, Arizona
Posts: 1,794
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
2 Posts
2011 E550, 2013 GLK
OK, I don't disagree that the back-up system is inadequate but that's water over the dam. What do we expect Mercedes to do about the millions of cars with SBC? Do we expect them to retrofit an entirely new system? That's not going to happen even if it were possible.
So then what should those of us who have cars with SBC do? Is it so dangerous that we must immediately get rid of our W211's and buy something else?
I'll tell you what I'm going to do. I'm going to make sure that I have ever TSB related to my car installed as soon as I know about it. I'm going to use common sense in judging the reliability of the SBC and drive-by-wire systems in my car and if I get to the point where I think a shutdown could be possible, I'll switch cars with my wife and drive it myself. I know what I need to do in that event.
If I did get an SBC system shutdown I would feel better about it if I had a hand brake and a transmission that was easier to downshift. Even so, I'll treat the event like any other problem I might have such as a tire blowout or a skid on bad road surfaces.
I won't be keeping this car for more than a decade the way I have other Mercedes but I'm not going to be panicked into a rash decision.
So then what should those of us who have cars with SBC do? Is it so dangerous that we must immediately get rid of our W211's and buy something else?
I'll tell you what I'm going to do. I'm going to make sure that I have ever TSB related to my car installed as soon as I know about it. I'm going to use common sense in judging the reliability of the SBC and drive-by-wire systems in my car and if I get to the point where I think a shutdown could be possible, I'll switch cars with my wife and drive it myself. I know what I need to do in that event.
If I did get an SBC system shutdown I would feel better about it if I had a hand brake and a transmission that was easier to downshift. Even so, I'll treat the event like any other problem I might have such as a tire blowout or a skid on bad road surfaces.
I won't be keeping this car for more than a decade the way I have other Mercedes but I'm not going to be panicked into a rash decision.
#109
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: FL410
Posts: 4,968
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
'05 E320 CDI, '08 BMW X5 4.8i, '11 Duramax 2500HD
This is all really a bunch of over reacting.. I am as into my safety as anyone else, and my 76 year old mother drives an SBC car now.. surely I care about her safety. The newer SBC's that have had bugs worked out are safe, period.
#110
Almost a Member!
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Texas
Posts: 47
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'06 E350, appearance/entertainment/ sunroof/DVD NAV/brilliant silver (C744)/Ash leather
E-class safest car in the US !!!
Have a read of this. Agree, have not seen the detailed report on this but it includes the 2003 E-class (i.e. the W211 first model year with the early SBC). MB must be doing something right, as data like this from the US market tends to be representative due to the high number of vehicles sold over here.
http://www.germancarfans.com/news.cf...ercedes/1.html
http://www.germancarfans.com/news.cf...ercedes/1.html
#111
MBWorld Fanatic!
Curious what response (if any)......
Dr. Dieter Zetsche
DaimlerChrysler AG
70546 Stuttgart
Germany
Dr. Zetsche - I have a safety concern with Mercedes Benz vehicles equipped with the Sensotronic Braking System (SBC) that I hope you can help me alleviate. I do not own one of these vehicles but share the road with them on a daily basis . I have read numerous horrific accounts from drivers that experienced SBC system failure and gone into backup mode that is inadequate to stop the car in a timely manner. I realize Daimler Chrysler (DC)
has produced engineering changes to help eliminate the sources of the initial failures but surely no one plans for 100% reliability of a primary brake system. Parts wear or are defective, assemblers and mechanics make mistakes, system errors occur, or the unknown happens to force the vehicle into backup brake mode. As SBC cars age this problem will be more pronounced. What is DC doing to increase the backup brake system capability for SBC equipped vehicles?
DaimlerChrysler AG
70546 Stuttgart
Germany
Dr. Zetsche - I have a safety concern with Mercedes Benz vehicles equipped with the Sensotronic Braking System (SBC) that I hope you can help me alleviate. I do not own one of these vehicles but share the road with them on a daily basis . I have read numerous horrific accounts from drivers that experienced SBC system failure and gone into backup mode that is inadequate to stop the car in a timely manner. I realize Daimler Chrysler (DC)
has produced engineering changes to help eliminate the sources of the initial failures but surely no one plans for 100% reliability of a primary brake system. Parts wear or are defective, assemblers and mechanics make mistakes, system errors occur, or the unknown happens to force the vehicle into backup brake mode. As SBC cars age this problem will be more pronounced. What is DC doing to increase the backup brake system capability for SBC equipped vehicles?
#112
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Valley of the Sun, Arizona
Posts: 1,794
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
2 Posts
2011 E550, 2013 GLK
Originally Posted by mleskovar
Dr. Dieter Zetsche
DaimlerChrysler AG
70546 Stuttgart
Germany
Dr. Zetsche - I have a safety concern with Mercedes Benz vehicles equipped with the Sensotronic Braking System (SBC) that I hope you can help me alleviate. I do not own one of these vehicles but share the road with them on a daily basis . I have read numerous horrific accounts from drivers that experienced SBC system failure and gone into backup mode that is inadequate to stop the car in a timely manner. I realize Daimler Chrysler (DC)
has produced engineering changes to help eliminate the sources of the initial failures but surely no one plans for 100% reliability of a primary brake system. Parts wear or are defective, assemblers and mechanics make mistakes, system errors occur, or the unknown happens to force the vehicle into backup brake mode. As SBC cars age this problem will be more pronounced. What is DC doing to increase the backup brake system capability for SBC equipped vehicles?
DaimlerChrysler AG
70546 Stuttgart
Germany
Dr. Zetsche - I have a safety concern with Mercedes Benz vehicles equipped with the Sensotronic Braking System (SBC) that I hope you can help me alleviate. I do not own one of these vehicles but share the road with them on a daily basis . I have read numerous horrific accounts from drivers that experienced SBC system failure and gone into backup mode that is inadequate to stop the car in a timely manner. I realize Daimler Chrysler (DC)
has produced engineering changes to help eliminate the sources of the initial failures but surely no one plans for 100% reliability of a primary brake system. Parts wear or are defective, assemblers and mechanics make mistakes, system errors occur, or the unknown happens to force the vehicle into backup brake mode. As SBC cars age this problem will be more pronounced. What is DC doing to increase the backup brake system capability for SBC equipped vehicles?
BTW, your exageration of SBC problems simply gets worse every time you post. You don't know didly squat about it. Since people took you to task about not even owning a W211, you have now taken the approach SBC is dangerous to you. That's pure, unadulterated B.S.
#113
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: THE NAPA VALLEY, CA
Posts: 1,439
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Build date 2-04 E500
Originally Posted by mleskovar
Dr. Dieter Zetsche
DaimlerChrysler AG
70546 Stuttgart
Germany
Dr. Zetsche - I have a safety concern with Mercedes Benz vehicles equipped with the Sensotronic Braking System (SBC) that I hope you can help me alleviate. I do not own one of these vehicles but share the road with them on a daily basis . I have read numerous horrific accounts from drivers that experienced SBC system failure and gone into backup mode that is inadequate to stop the car in a timely manner. I realize Daimler Chrysler (DC)
has produced engineering changes to help eliminate the sources of the initial failures but surely no one plans for 100% reliability of a primary brake system. Parts wear or are defective, assemblers and mechanics make mistakes, system errors occur, or the unknown happens to force the vehicle into backup brake mode. As SBC cars age this problem will be more pronounced. What is DC doing to increase the backup brake system capability for SBC equipped vehicles?
DaimlerChrysler AG
70546 Stuttgart
Germany
Dr. Zetsche - I have a safety concern with Mercedes Benz vehicles equipped with the Sensotronic Braking System (SBC) that I hope you can help me alleviate. I do not own one of these vehicles but share the road with them on a daily basis . I have read numerous horrific accounts from drivers that experienced SBC system failure and gone into backup mode that is inadequate to stop the car in a timely manner. I realize Daimler Chrysler (DC)
has produced engineering changes to help eliminate the sources of the initial failures but surely no one plans for 100% reliability of a primary brake system. Parts wear or are defective, assemblers and mechanics make mistakes, system errors occur, or the unknown happens to force the vehicle into backup brake mode. As SBC cars age this problem will be more pronounced. What is DC doing to increase the backup brake system capability for SBC equipped vehicles?
L.O.L....Nice letter and well written.
I'd give them a week to responed and if you don't hear from them, I'd be selling all my cars never to drive again. Imagine sharing the road with all them "dangerous" E's... I quiver just thinking about it.....
#114
MBWorld Fanatic!
Originally Posted by BudC
And what did you say to the Ford Motor Company who have been responsible for 45 deaths and terrible injuries just this year alone for their failure to fix the fuel tank and door jamming on Crown Victorias? What did you say to them about the incidents of vehicle fires in Fords dating all the way back to the Pinto. What did you say to them about the Explorers which had crappy tires that had to be under inflated by 9 pounds to keep the thing from rolling over?
BTW, your exageration of SBC problems simply gets worse every time you post. You don't know didly squat about it. Since people took you to task about not even owning a W211, you have now taken the approach SBC is dangerous to you. That's pure, unadulterated B.S.
BTW, your exageration of SBC problems simply gets worse every time you post. You don't know didly squat about it. Since people took you to task about not even owning a W211, you have now taken the approach SBC is dangerous to you. That's pure, unadulterated B.S.
#115
MBWorld Fanatic!
Originally Posted by HELL ONA HARLEY
L.O.L....Nice letter and well written.
I'd give them a week to responed and if you don't hear from them, I'd be selling all my cars never to drive again. Imagine sharing the road with all them "dangerous" E's... I quiver just thinking about it.....
I'd give them a week to responed and if you don't hear from them, I'd be selling all my cars never to drive again. Imagine sharing the road with all them "dangerous" E's... I quiver just thinking about it.....
#116
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: THE NAPA VALLEY, CA
Posts: 1,439
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Build date 2-04 E500
Originally Posted by mleskovar
I must admit that if I owned an SBC car today I would not abandon it because of this problem...
It seems even the people who have had "reported" brake failure think as you also.... Everyone who reported a failure on this forum either still drives their car with SBC or opted for a new one with SBC.
Makes you think how serious it really was... Don't it????
#117
MBWorld Fanatic!
Originally Posted by HELL ONA HARLEY
It seems even the people who have had "reported" brake failure think as you also.... Everyone who reported a failure on this forum either still drives their car with SBC or opted for a new one with SBC.
Makes you think how serious it really was... Don't it????
Makes you think how serious it really was... Don't it????
#118
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Longmont, CO
Posts: 1,281
Likes: 0
Received 8 Likes
on
7 Posts
04 E320 4 Matic, 95 Audi S6, 99 Carrera 4 Cabrio, 12 Fiat 500 Sport, 00 BMW R1200C 10, BMW R1200R
Originally Posted by mleskovar
No, the reason could be because they are on a lease and have time to go, or purchsed it outright and can't afford to lose it, or whatever fnancial reason. Do you know?
On a side note, when I dropped my Christmas gifts off at my dealer yesterday I spoke with the head "Master Mechanic" of Glauser Mercedes Benz in Westminster Colorado. Glauser is the largest volume dealer in Colorado btw. He is the only one who works on my car and I have complete trust is what he says. I "point blank" asked him how many SBC failures they have had at this dealer. He said ZERO. He also added that the system is a great one but he knew that it was going to be discontinued the day he got training on it. He said that the system tends to be a bit too noisy and expensive.
He also added that he personally drives a W211 and has complete trust in it. He also says that he still thinks that it is a incredibly great performing braking system. This is coming from a master mechanic, not some internet article or the rumor mill.
Just remember, you can't believe everything you read on the internet. Even what I say (which I am now saying is 1st hand information and true) could be a total fake. I think that you are being a bit too paranoid about the system that you are not even using. Also, I would not bee too concerned about the other W211's on the roads. Like Bud and H on a H said, how about all the other real problems on the road? GM's side mounted fuel tanks, Ford cars that have always had a propensity to BURN (even when parked like the F 150 cruise control problem), flip or stall in the middle of intersections (Ford Econoline ignition modules). You are really fighting a very illusive problem that is very rare and after these TSBs will not be happening at all. If you worry this much about the SBC, how can you sleep with all the greater problems happening?
BTW, I had friend who had a 1992 Ford Aerostar that had complete brake failure when the front flex line ruptured and the backup system did not work. I was in the car when this happened and if I had not pulled the emergency brake (which was next to the driver’s seat but on the passenger’s side) and yelled at him to downshift we would have rear ended the car in front of us. I will not own a Ford nor have I ever owned one. However, I find it surprising that I personally experienced a brake failure in a Ford when I was a passenger in one. I should also mention that when my friend bought the replacement flex lines at a local NAPA store, the employee said that they stock tons of them since they fail all the time! Also, what would you say about a car whose braking distance is around 145 feet (60-0 MPH) when a W211's is around 120 feet. There are many cases here in the mountains where Suburbans and Dodge RAMs rear end other cars because they can not stop in time. A SBC system will stop and avoid the accident since 25 feet is a very large number. Yet it will never get credit for its good performance.
Anyway, I don't mean to rant on and on, but I don't think that anyone is "stuck" with their W211s. The people who have had documented failures have either had everything repaired or they got a new car. Either way, they are OK with their cars now. There have been failures, no fatalities and tons of bad press. However, this seems to be resolved. I plan to get the ground wire retrofit done at my convenience. In the mean time I am still driving my E with full confidence. At the same time, there are some people who tend to overextend their financial picture by buying things they can not afford. I imagine that it that case this could happen, but then again this is a W211 not a Hyundai Sonata. The average owner of a W211 tends to be in a bit better financial situation than the average Joe.
Steve
#119
Super Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 819
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
06 320E CDI, Porsche 911 C2, Pontiac Montana
Originally Posted by mleskovar
No, the reason could be because they are on a lease and have time to go, or purchsed it outright and can't afford to lose it, or whatever fnancial reason. Do you know?
The other thing is that some of you had problems with Mercedes management. I did NOT. They GAVE me a new car even though my old car was a year old. How can I curse and slam them for that? How can I abandon them when they treated me like that? How many car companies do that? Could it possibly be that some of you are taking the wrong course of action? I tell you one thing, my approach was simple and honest, "I love the E but I can not drive THIS ONE anymore because my family and I don't trust it". With that approach, how can they argue? No legal threats, no lawyers, no swearing, no fits of anger. They saw the problem, they accepted my concerns and they did the right thing. It was gentleman's agreements and handshakes. Case closed.
Anyway.........
Isn't this thread going to die? It doesn't appear to be a discussion as much as it appears to be a spaghetti tossing. :p
#120
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: FL410
Posts: 4,968
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
'05 E320 CDI, '08 BMW X5 4.8i, '11 Duramax 2500HD
I am much happier with the fact that I have SBC, than had I not... just yesterday, no BS, I had a car try to merge into my lane while on the 51 freeway doing 80+ and in a shallow curve... I panic slammed on the brakes, during the banking turn (as I also had to turn aggressively to avoid him as he came into my lane), and the car reacted amazingly stable, and maintained perfect directional control. I've drive cars in the past that would have been swerving all over the place after such a dynamic situation.. that instance there as far as I'm concerned has earned this system it's "keeper status".
Oddly, after exiting the freeway, a older man and woman in an ML pulled up next to me and asked my how I like the CDI.. to which I said.. "Great milage, power, and brakes!"
NO BS...
And Merry Christmas eve!
Oddly, after exiting the freeway, a older man and woman in an ML pulled up next to me and asked my how I like the CDI.. to which I said.. "Great milage, power, and brakes!"
NO BS...
And Merry Christmas eve!