cross shopping E550 coupe and audi S5




Get the S5 and chip it and you will have a car that is more pleasing to look at from the interior and exterior and it will be faster once you chip it. And you don't have to have an italian car to have curves on your car. I really don't get it when someone says the awkward early adoption period of a new model introduction. Do you say the same about a Ferrari or a pretty women. NO you just love the shape, you don't have to look at it a million times before you appreciate the figure.
Get the S5 and chip it and you will have a car that is more pleasing to look at from the interior and exterior and it will be faster once you chip it. And you don't have to have an italian car to have curves on your car. I really don't get it when someone says the awkward early adoption period of a new model introduction. Do you say the same about a Ferrari or a pretty women. NO you just love the shape, you don't have to look at it a million times before you appreciate the figure.
Yeah, okay let's just tune everything out there. That solves it. Duh.
On the other hand, I don't know what you're talking about in the last four sentences of your post, so let's just call the whole thing a failure to communicate.
Yeah, okay let's just tune everything out there. That solves it. Duh.
On the other hand, I don't know what you're talking about in the last four sentences of your post, so let's just call the whole thing a failure to communicate.
And what problems do you have with tuning? What do you think Brabus and Carlson etc. do for MB. Dinan does it for BMW and Porsche. Like another poster already said turbo charging and supercharging will be the future and if you are not taking advantage of respected aftermarket tuners than you are stupid. Most of these tuners have been in business for a long long time without any problems like blowing up engines etc. and some like Dinan are even manufacturer approved so that warranty is not affected or is provided through Dinan.
And what problems do you have with tuning? What do you think Brabus and Carlson etc. do for MB. Dinan does it for BMW and Porsche. Like another poster already said turbo charging and supercharging will be the future and if you are not taking advantage of respected aftermarket tuners than you are stupid. Most of these tuners have been in business for a long long time without any problems like blowing up engines etc. and some like Dinan are even manufacturer approved so that warranty is not affected or is provided through Dinan.
I should take advantage of these "tuners" you mention. Yes, very good idea. I never thought of that. Thanks. I'll will tune my AMG and my Porsche.
I can't remember if I was positioning the 4.2 against the 5.5 MB V8. Hmm? I thought I just said Audi in general. Oh well, I also have dementia and my memory is slipping. Thanks for pointing that out!
This forum needs more informative members like you. Thanks for the tips




And what problems do you have with tuning? What do you think Brabus and Carlson etc. do for MB. Dinan does it for BMW and Porsche. Like another poster already said turbo charging and supercharging will be the future and if you are not taking advantage of respected aftermarket tuners than you are stupid. Most of these tuners have been in business for a long long time without any problems like blowing up engines etc. and some like Dinan are even manufacturer approved so that warranty is not affected or is provided through Dinan.
MB and BMW has always dominated the engines. MB with the bigger litre sized engines and awesome torque, BMW with their smaller litre sized engines and impressive power outputs.
The 63 engine is a beast. You take off the resonator on those pipes and man is that thing sweet. The 55 kompressor engines didn't sound anywhere near the way the 63's do.
And for everyone's info out there, MB was pumping out more forced induced cars (supercharged and turbos: I4SS, V6SS, V8SS, V12TT) while BMW was jerking it and Audi was pumping out 1 POS 1.8L I4 turbo. MB saw all the problems that came with those supercharged engines and decided to go back to the N/A route. And you know what, their engines get decent gas mileage for their large sizes. Wait till those 335i and 535i started getting a couple of more years old, we'll see the gremlins that pop up.
Last edited by gaazmon; Jul 31, 2009 at 02:06 PM.
I should take advantage of these "tuners" you mention. Yes, very good idea. I never thought of that. Thanks. I'll will tune my AMG and my Porsche.
I can't remember if I was positioning the 4.2 against the 5.5 MB V8. Hmm? I thought I just said Audi in general. Oh well, I also have dementia and my memory is slipping. Thanks for pointing that out!
This forum needs more informative members like you. Thanks for the tips
We are talking about the E550 so it makes sense to compare the equivalent V8 no? What you want to compare a 2.0T to this engine? If you say Audi engines in general than why don't you specify which one and lets compare that engine to MB engines than smarty pants?
Man you are stupid if you didn't understand that what I am saying is that engines with turbo and supercharging get a lot more than what is on paper with chipping hence Audi engines may seem under powered on paper but once chipped they are comparable to engines with huge displacements from MB. Unless you have a Porsche turbo or an AMG 55 supercharged engine than it would be pointless to chip your cars. So if you thought about it than you are stupid since you have a E63.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG




We are talking about the E550 so it makes sense to compare the equivalent V8 no? What you want to compare a 2.0T to this engine? If you say Audi engines in general than why don't you specify which one and lets compare that engine to MB engines than smarty pants?
Man you are stupid if you didn't understand that what I am saying is that engines with turbo and supercharging get a lot more than what is on paper with chipping hence Audi engines may seem under powered on paper but once chipped they are comparable to engines with huge displacements from MB. Unless you have a Porsche turbo or an AMG 55 supercharged engine than it would be pointless to chip your cars. So if you thought about it than you are stupid since you have a E63.
So I guess everyone that has a 63 engine MB is stupid? I don't mean to be an a*s like this, but this convo is getting quite insulting towards one of my fellow forum members.
MB and BMW has always dominated the engines. MB with the bigger litre sized engines and awesome torque, BMW with their smaller litre sized engines and impressive power outputs.
The 63 engine is a beast. You take off the resonator on those pipes and man is that thing sweet. The 55 kompressor engines didn't sound anywhere near the way the 63's do.
I mean anyone can really shoehorn a big *** engine in a car just like the american muscle cars but look at the trend and how gas prices are going up and the way to go is with forced induction and hp/l of displacement and not just putting huge engines into big and bigger cars.
Audi does have some engines that definitely have to be revised such as the the 3.2 V6 which is now discontinued but I think the 4.2 V8 is not one of them as the hp/l of displacement is great just if you want more hp on it then they will be turbocharging it rather than just upping the displacement I think. This will allow for more torque and bigger gears which will allow it to be more fuel efficient at the same time more hp.
No one wants to argue with you. It's all good. Believe what you want.
Clearly VAG can produce good engines, I'm sure we all agree that's possible given their resources.
In the future audi could very well be ahead of the curve in regards to smaller forced induction motors. Look at the VW line up.
Both the K1 and K2 tunes are pretty nice for the M156. The K1 is a no-brainer. Talk to Cory (Kleemann USA) about it, if you're considering it.
I think I might bite the bullet this winter (and when the weather is better for noticing the best performance) ECU, pulley, intake, headers. And mix in some some stuff from Renntech (another straight up vendor) Maybe a LSD, too. Also check the W211 AMG forums for Fedor Dezyn's goodies.
It's a better choice than Evosport (which is a Powerchip ECU) or MHP, imho. Carlsson (the correct spelling, btw
) and Brabus have way less US support.Again, that's just my opinion.
There's nothing like a large displacement, high spinning NA
And hey, we don't have to think about heat soak and over sized intercoolers. A bit less foot lbs than the 55's FI, but the torque sure is buttery smooth with the M156.




Also, in regards, to hp/L displacement, MB has always had bigger displacement engines... but that is why they last so long. BMWs and Audis always squeeze out more power from their engines without increasing the displacement and therefore the quality and reliability of their engines are not as good as MBs, therefore they don't last as long. Ya, MBs have electric and other problems, but so does BMW and Audi.
honestly I would love to go to town on stuff with this car, but I need to feel out the local MB place for what would and would not be cool about warranty.
I also promised I would not dump a bunch of money on parts. We'll see how that goes.
I'm trying to get away from tinkering with cars too much. Depends though really. I can see getting into the exhaust and an LSD. next year sometime.
I'm already scheming, we'll see
will the vin show build month?
Last edited by jbrinkley; Jul 31, 2009 at 05:19 PM.
Also, in regards, to hp/L displacement, MB has always had bigger displacement engines... but that is why they last so long. BMWs and Audis always squeeze out more power from their engines without increasing the displacement and therefore the quality and reliability of their engines are not as good as MBs, therefore they don't last as long. Ya, MBs have electric and other problems, but so does BMW and Audi.
That said I would rather have the w211 E63 than the BMW M5 and Audi S6 just because the fact the E63 W211 looks nicer in my books and the S6 rides a little harsh. But what I am arguing about is that someone said Audi engines are inferior or obsolete, but in reality they are not. With the new w212 I will probably look at the new BMW 5 series to arrive soon or even wait a year or two for audi to release the new A6. Or like this poster consider the S4/S5.
Last edited by rieger; Jul 31, 2009 at 06:16 PM.

Ya, we old folks need our stoplight sprinters.
Of course, all us gray haired E63 owners have multiple cars and maybe just have the AMG as our comfort cruiser with some bite to it. Naw, we just wanted a big a$$ motor, that's all. I admit it.
Hey, driving a sports sedan or sports car gets our old bones all banged up on those long trips to the casino.
And you're right, the E63 AMG is just like an American muscle car. Same comfort, technology, build quality, innovations. Damn, I knew I shoulda bought a Mustang. Coulda saved a lot of bucks, too. Oh well, back to the casino.

Ya, we old folks need our stoplight sprinters.
Of course, all us gray haired E63 owners have multiple cars and maybe just have the AMG as our comfort cruiser with some bite to it. Naw, we just wanted a big a$$ motor, that's all. I admit it.
Hey, driving a sports sedan or sports car gets our old bones all banged up on those long trips to the casino.
And you're right, the E63 AMG is just like an American muscle car. Same comfort, technology, build quality, innovations. Damn, I knew I shoulda bought a Mustang. Coulda saved a lot of bucks, too. Oh well, back to the casino.

Nice to see that we finally can agree about the AMG cars.
Thank you so much for your insight.
The AMG is up for sale now.
And my Porsche, too. Can't tune it like those little 3.0T buggers. Damn.
I've seen the light.
Thank you, again.




That said I would rather have the w211 E63 than the BMW M5 and Audi S6 just because the fact the E63 W211 looks nicer in my books and the S6 rides a little harsh. But what I am arguing about is that someone said Audi engines are inferior or obsolete, but in reality they are not. With the new w212 I will probably look at the new BMW 5 series to arrive soon or even wait a year or two for audi to release the new A6. Or like this poster consider the S4/S5.
). Those are amazing. The RS4 is really pricey though, that's the thing. The C63 is a big a$$ engine and I would never buy one probably (I have a thing about interiors, kind of a pet peeve).Man... the M5 is such a nice car though I must say
But I'd still take a 63 as well.MB has always been the "muscle car" of German cars. Always with their bigger displacement engines and monster torque, I love that. I love those engines. One of my favorite aspects of MB are their engines.
). Those are amazing. The RS4 is really pricey though, that's the thing. The C63 is a big a$$ engine and I would never buy one probably (I have a thing about interiors, kind of a pet peeve).Man... the M5 is such a nice car though I must say
But I'd still take a 63 as well.MB has always been the "muscle car" of German cars. Always with their bigger displacement engines and monster torque, I love that. I love those engines. One of my favorite aspects of MB are their engines.
Maybe next we can have a different drink

The only thing about the B5 S4 is that if you buy an used one take car who you buy from because with Turbo cars they have to be warmed up and cooled down properly otherwise the Turbo could be in rough shape. But that could just mean a Turbo upgrade.
Last edited by rieger; Aug 1, 2009 at 12:40 AM.
). Those are amazing. The RS4 is really pricey though, that's the thing. The C63 is a big a$$ engine and I would never buy one probably (I have a thing about interiors, kind of a pet peeve).Man... the M5 is such a nice car though I must say
But I'd still take a 63 as well.MB has always been the "muscle car" of German cars. Always with their bigger displacement engines and monster torque, I love that. I love those engines. One of my favorite aspects of MB are their engines.
I think the F10 will be a winner, btw.
Do you live in Glendale? I'm going to leave in about 45 min to a party in Silverlake (I used to live in Los Felix) I think we're going to hit that bar in Atwater later, Bigfoot or something? I'm not driving

btw, I was just playing with Nanook here. I didn't want to get into a shout fest with him, I hear he can get sorta cranky with people.
https://mbworld.org/forums/2392762-post442.html
But hey, he had some really bad luck with his MB ownership and so I can understand his frustration. But not sure why he got so pissy at me



