14 E350 coolant In transmission 2nd time this happened only 77k
The cars can completely cook off an entire fill of ATF within 30k miles and render it smelly and black if you're hard on the car or run it for extended hours. I have learned not to trust dealer recommendations and more how the car is used when it comes to ATF.
If you JUST got a transmission service, I don't know how good the shop is when you say its trusted, but can you verify what exact fluid they used on it? 2014 uses A89 transmission with special blue ATF which is low viscosity which is more fuel efficient. It has the disadvantage of aging like milk and cooking off prematurely for my taste. There is a possible simple problem where they used the red ATF and you would have sluggish, yet functional transmission. The point of ATF is to pressurize the clutch plates and lubricate the pump/gears/etc. When you get that famous 722.9 shuddering, it's actually the transmission not having enough pressure to pack the clutches together so you get some chatter and pulsation.
Incorrect fluid example
https://www.autohausaz.com/pn/FB-001989680313
This is the correct fluid.
https://www.autohausaz.com/pn/FB-001989770309
It's simple to mix these up if you don't know Mercedes very well.
I'm saying the next thing assuming I'm VERY WRONG. I want to actually be wrong about the next thing I'm saying as I'm still new when it comes to Mercedes service relatively speaking. I don't think your first one was bad so much as they didn't want to do a transmission service on your car. The sludge is quite normal at 80k, and I'd say you should replace the trans fluids on these every 40k. Mercedes even backpedalled their original 80k interval down to 60 or 40 I forgot the actual number. Now I wasn't there, I didn't see what they were looking at, but I'm all too familiar with dealer tactics as I used to be at a local VW dealership who would do the exact same thing to sell things like steering racks, transmissions, and engines under false pretenses and I've been told "this is the dealer life bro". My radiator which isn't too different from yours is the original one at 143k, I have a G550 with around 110k as well original radiator and both cars have been flogged around town and run on 100F days doing ubereats for fun with friends to pay for gas. Their transmissions need servicing almost every 20-30k or else they develop that exact same shudder were talking about. I service quite a few MB's who've received a "needs transmission" diagnosis only for like 5 liters of fresh ATF FE to solve the problem for a couple years. I have a Denso manufactured radiator and Graf water pump waiting for either car when the radiator end tanks start to let go, but surprisingly the thermostats let go first due to electrical shorts.
Intermix is possible and it has absolutely happened before. I've seen it on ancient 20-year old C230/E320 who have been running the original radiators to this day.
This is my E550's transmission fluid after 20k miles in a year. No metal in the pan, the fluid was burnt, didn't have a ton of suspended material. Also I swear the pans are slightly porous as they age, I replaced the pan and it stopped collecting moisture at the bottom. I have receipts and pictures of when I did the job last which is hilarious since it was like a year until I experienced the issues again
April of 2021, 119k, Vaico's kit with bolts, gasket, 6L of ATF134 FE which is more than enough
December 2022, 141k, went for Vaico's filter kit with bolts for the A89 transmission, filter was clean, fluid was burnt and smelled that way, not a lot of suspended clutch material, magnets were clean, pan didn't have excessive sludge. This time Amsoil Signature FE as an experiment. This fluid is not approved by MB, I would not recommend anybody use this for liability reasons, but Amsoil does say it is compatible with MB 236.15 and my cars are working way better than they ever have. The G550's transmission works a lot harder, was looking about the same that day.
Before resorting to transmission #3, you really should just make sure all the proper homework was done, and go for a trans service again.




a hot one, albeit by logic the section for tranny cooler pipes would be at the bottom side of the radiator or the already cooled section AFTER or OUTPUT, but don't expect it to be NOT HOT.
Below is from M276 3.0 TT, radiator input and output when thermostat fully open and engine REAL* coolant temp is at 99C and 100C.
*MB instrument cluster coolant temp loves to under report by 5 to 10C cooler...ON PURPOSE. https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w...inda-liar.html
Full test story is here : https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w...mperature.html
NOTE : Value of maximum cooling by the radiator is dictated a great deal too by the speed of the fan, thermostat fully opening itself is not enough. Test car is stationary.
How the hell tranny oil can get its stable 80C temp if the coolant itself is at 72C to 83C ?
M276 3.0TT and M278 too is luckier, we get stand alone air cooled tranny cooler with built in thermostat.
M276 M002 means M276 3.0 Turbo
I think if OP wants to keep the car for a long time after the repair, considering the option to install a stand alone air cooled tranny oil cooler can make good sense.
The cars can completely cook off an entire fill of ATF within 30k miles and render it smelly and black if you're hard on the car or run it for extended hours. I have learned not to trust dealer recommendations and more how the car is used when it comes to ATF.
If you JUST got a transmission service, I don't know how good the shop is when you say its trusted, but can you verify what exact fluid they used on it? 2014 uses A89 transmission with special blue ATF which is low viscosity which is more fuel efficient. It has the disadvantage of aging like milk and cooking off prematurely for my taste. There is a possible simple problem where they used the red ATF and you would have sluggish, yet functional transmission. The point of ATF is to pressurize the clutch plates and lubricate the pump/gears/etc. When you get that famous 722.9 shuddering, it's actually the transmission not having enough pressure to pack the clutches together so you get some chatter and pulsation.
Incorrect fluid example
https://www.autohausaz.com/pn/FB-001989680313
This is the correct fluid.
https://www.autohausaz.com/pn/FB-001989770309
It's simple to mix these up if you don't know Mercedes very well.
I'm saying the next thing assuming I'm VERY WRONG. I want to actually be wrong about the next thing I'm saying as I'm still new when it comes to Mercedes service relatively speaking. I don't think your first one was bad so much as they didn't want to do a transmission service on your car. The sludge is quite normal at 80k, and I'd say you should replace the trans fluids on these every 40k. Mercedes even backpedalled their original 80k interval down to 60 or 40 I forgot the actual number. Now I wasn't there, I didn't see what they were looking at, but I'm all too familiar with dealer tactics as I used to be at a local VW dealership who would do the exact same thing to sell things like steering racks, transmissions, and engines under false pretenses and I've been told "this is the dealer life bro". My radiator which isn't too different from yours is the original one at 143k, I have a G550 with around 110k as well original radiator and both cars have been flogged around town and run on 100F days doing ubereats for fun with friends to pay for gas. Their transmissions need servicing almost every 20-30k or else they develop that exact same shudder were talking about. I service quite a few MB's who've received a "needs transmission" diagnosis only for like 5 liters of fresh ATF FE to solve the problem for a couple years. I have a Denso manufactured radiator and Graf water pump waiting for either car when the radiator end tanks start to let go, but surprisingly the thermostats let go first due to electrical shorts.
Intermix is possible and it has absolutely happened before. I've seen it on ancient 20-year old C230/E320 who have been running the original radiators to this day.
This is my E550's transmission fluid after 20k miles in a year. No metal in the pan, the fluid was burnt, didn't have a ton of suspended material. Also I swear the pans are slightly porous as they age, I replaced the pan and it stopped collecting moisture at the bottom. I have receipts and pictures of when I did the job last which is hilarious since it was like a year until I experienced the issues again
April of 2021, 119k, Vaico's kit with bolts, gasket, 6L of ATF134 FE which is more than enough
December 2022, 141k, went for Vaico's filter kit with bolts for the A89 transmission, filter was clean, fluid was burnt and smelled that way, not a lot of suspended clutch material, magnets were clean, pan didn't have excessive sludge. This time Amsoil Signature FE as an experiment. This fluid is not approved by MB, I would not recommend anybody use this for liability reasons, but Amsoil does say it is compatible with MB 236.15 and my cars are working way better than they ever have. The G550's transmission works a lot harder, was looking about the same that day.
Before resorting to transmission #3, you really should just make sure all the proper homework was done, and go for a trans service again.
Thank you for your input sir.
The shop used the Pentosin blue ATF fluid not the OEM MB fluid.
There was definitely a sludge mix of the trans fluid and coolant in the reservoir. The oily smell of trans fluid was very noticeable when I opened the cap.
I am very sure the dealer replaced the transmission, the first time. They mentioned to me that they did not want any future issues so the protocol was to replace everything. The paper work had all of the parts listed including a reman transmission.
The independent repair shop only replaced the fluid that was in the pan, including the filter and gasket.
Do you recommend the Pentosin fluid?
Trending Topics
First MB indy mechanic, flushed replaced coolant lines, and trany filters and fluid, same thing happen less than 200 miles later.
Trany was removed, rebuilt. Now all is well.
Culprit was the trany oil cooler in the radiator. Its seals failed allowing high pressure engine coolant into the trany, ruining the clutch faces.
Here is the photo of the problem. Note the red dye where the seals failed.
red dye at the end show failure.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
The shop used the Pentosin blue ATF fluid not the OEM MB fluid.
There was definitely a sludge mix of the trans fluid and coolant in the reservoir. The oily smell of trans fluid was very noticeable when I opened the cap.
I am very sure the dealer replaced the transmission, the first time. They mentioned to me that they did not want any future issues so the protocol was to replace everything. The paper work had all of the parts listed including a reman transmission.
The independent repair shop only replaced the fluid that was in the pan, including the filter and gasket.
Do you recommend the Pentosin fluid?
Sorry I wish I could help more. I had no idea this was possible on younger cars.




I understand the typical drain and fill tranny procedure still leaves oil in the torque converter. Was the torque converter drained separately? I understand the drain/fill procedure leaving old fluid in the torque converter is used on the assumption of dilution, and servicing more often will save the step of draining the torque converter.
Perhaps another drain/fill oil transmission service will help, or a thorough drain (everything as much as possible),

I understand the typical drain and fill tranny procedure still leaves oil in the torque converter. Was the torque converter drained separately? I understand the drain/fill procedure leaving old fluid in the torque converter is used on the assumption of dilution, and servicing more often will save the step of draining the torque converter.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6QQ6El-G1k&t=40s
Perhaps another drain/fill oil transmission service will help, or a thorough drain (everything as much as possible),

I hope this does not happen to you. You really have to keep an eye on the coolant and constantly smell it for trans fluid or just get rid of the Valeo radiator from Mercedes.
The torque converter was not drained, only what was in the pan and filter.
The video was really helpful and the drilling process to get the drain plug seems like it might do the trick of getting most of the fluid out. I hope the shop is willing to drill the hole. From what he said there was not much coolant in the trans. It did not look like a milk shake.
Interesting fact. The shuttering starts occurring only after driven for 20 minutes on a cold start. If only driven for 5-10 minutes on a cold start you will never know there is a problem.
First MB indy mechanic, flushed replaced coolant lines, and trany filters and fluid, same thing happen less than 200 miles later.
Trany was removed, rebuilt. Now all is well.
Culprit was the trany oil cooler in the radiator. Its seals failed allowing high pressure engine coolant into the trany, ruining the clutch faces.
Here is the photo of the problem. Note the red dye where the seals failed.
red dye at the end show failure.
Sorry that you had to go through that process.
question- Did your trans fluid look like a milk shake or was it just slight bit of coolant in the transmission?
I understand the typical drain and fill tranny procedure still leaves oil in the torque converter. Was the torque converter drained separately? I understand the drain/fill procedure leaving old fluid in the torque converter is used on the assumption of dilution, and servicing more often will save the step of draining the torque converter.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6QQ6El-G1k&t=40s
Perhaps another drain/fill oil transmission service will help, or a thorough drain (everything as much as possible),

I'm really sorry you're going through this I wish I could help
I'm really sorry you're going through this I wish I could help




If you have coolant in the transmission, it is not the transission's fault. There is a leak in the transmission cooling circuit that flows within 1mm of coolant in the same unit. I think MB stopped doing this mid-cycle for W212s. Pretty sure my 2014 has a separate tranny cooler so this shouldn't be a problem for me.
Obviously, if people keep rebuilding the transmission, but don't fix the crossover between coolant and transmission fluid elsewhere in the system, transmissions will keep tanking. They aren't designed to circulate water.
If you have coolant in the transmission, it is not the transission's fault. There is a leak in the transmission cooling circuit that flows within 1mm of coolant in the same unit. I think MB stopped doing this mid-cycle for W212s. Pretty sure my 2014 has a separate tranny cooler so this shouldn't be a problem for me.
Obviously, if people keep rebuilding the transmission, but don't fix the crossover between coolant and transmission fluid elsewhere in the system, transmissions will keep tanking. They aren't designed to circulate water.




While those lines are disconnected, I imagine that pressurizing the coolant circuit should not hold pressure for long, and coolant should show up on the transmission side connections. Just an idea.




If you have a clean transmission with only transmission fluid inside of it and you do not have a leak between your engine cooling and transmission cooling systems, the fluid will never become milky. If they did not fix the source of the contamination when this was first discovered, it will keep coming back regardless of how many times the transmission is rebuilt.
I don't know what kind of test kits they are using, but the transmission fluid is very deeply colored and it's cloudy. The test kits might be designed to detect mostly pure water/coolant. You might have only 3% water in your transmission fluid turning it into a milkshake. I don't know if they work like that unless they're designed for this situation.
ALSO if you have not done a radiator on one of these cars, it has transmission lines that go in. If you do not respect this you end up with all your ATF on the floor... so youll have to re-fill the trans afterwards. This is also just a great chance to do a trans service of which I have done like 50 of.
Don't put this off, if your end-tanks are already kind of leaking, you're only a specific kind of radiator failure away from destroying your transmission. The coolant's glycol soaks in the friction discs and debonds the glue which is an irreparable situation in the worst case scenario.
Alpha European Autotech
Purchase Amsoil at 25% off from me
Chris Tran, Retired Alpha European Autotech Owner
Amsoil Independent Dealer #7236674
Last edited by T2IV; May 2, 2025 at 12:32 AM. Reason: Add Photo




If you have a clean transmission with only transmission fluid inside of it and you do not have a leak between your engine cooling and transmission cooling systems, the fluid will never become milky. If they did not fix the source of the contamination when this was first discovered, it will keep coming back regardless of how many times the transmission is rebuilt..


